Total: 930 Guests
| Name: Megan Riggs Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-21 15:18:04 Comments: Nothing would make me happier than to see Michael Crawford perform the role of the Phantom in the movie of the best musical ever. |
| Name: matt Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-21 08:21:27 Comments: Antonio is very talented. he was great in Evita. But Crawford is the Phantom. Cast Banderas in another role like Roul. |
| Name: Jeffrey D.
Purvis Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Cincinnatti, Oh Time: 1998-09-21 07:23:58 Comments: Despite how much I respect Antonio as an actor, this just isn't in his field of specialty. I have been a fan of Phantom and particularly Michael Crawford ever since I heard the first notes from the "Phantom" cd. I never got the chance to see him perform the part live, so I am hoping that Warner Bros. will awaken and realize that Michael is the only logical choice for the movie production. |
| Name: Wayne K.
Sorlie Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: South San Francisco Time: 1998-09-20 18:16:01 Comments: Marvelous idea! Maybe somebody could help me. I have been unable to download the Warner Brothers' site and find out the E-mail address. If somebody could let me know their E-mail address, I would love to E-mail them my feelings. Keep up the good work. Wayne K. Sorlie viking10@jps.net |
| Name: Linda
Huber Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: California Time: 1998-09-20 17:29:17 Comments: Michael is the only Phantom |
| Name: Kath Duxbury Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Stockport, UK Time: 1998-09-20 15:09:55 Comments: Warner Bros must not consider ANY star other than MICHAEL CRAWFORD for the movie of Phantom of the Opera! |
| Name: Dorothy
Haring Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: CA Time: 1998-09-20 13:39:12 Comments: i can't imagine anyone else playing the phantom in a movie. i hope your campaign works. |
| Name: Alison Lehto Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Oakland, Maine Time: 1998-09-20 12:21:12 Comments: I'm not sure this went throught the first time; so, here again is my 2 cents worth: no one, but no one, can portray Erik, the character created by Gaston Leroux in The Phantom of the Opera, with such depth and emotion as Michael Crawford can. He is Erik, the Phantom. Warners' Brothers would, indeed, be making a mistake beyound their wildest imagination is they do not properly cast Michael as the Phantom!!! |
| Name: Jenni Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: U.K. Time: 1998-09-19 13:44:54 Comments: I absolutely HAVE to respond NOW to what I have read so far,although I'd like to go away and compose something marginally more eyecatching and in tune with my heartfelt opinions on this matter! IT HAS TO BE MICHAEL! I have performed in (amateur) musical theatre for the last 35 years so I believe I know something about MISCASTING. It must be obvious to any intelligent casting agency that certain people are RIGHT for parts whatever the other considerations might be. Have the courage of your convictions...money isn't everything. Jenni Lomax, 18, Linden Avenue, Little Lever, Bolton, BL3 1QA, Gtr. Manchester, England. |
| Name: Yee-Kyoung Ku Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Korea Time: 1998-09-19 13:39:53 Comments: Hi. I'm a musicals fan from Korea. I've never imagined that any people act the phantom except michael crawford. I hope this campaign would have successful effect and I can see michael in the movie soon. Go Go Go Michael!!! |
| Name: Jenni Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Finland Time: 1998-09-19 10:08:28 Comments: Michael Crawford has to be chosen to play the role of the Phantom in the film!! |
| Name: Adam Pietz Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Army Brat Time: 1998-09-18 20:22:07 Comments: Micheal Crawford would be the obvious choice. Who else would they get? No one in Hollywood could do nearly as good of a job. |
| Name: Kandy Pansire Website: Referred by: AOL From: Cincinnati, OH Time: 1998-09-18 11:47:22 Comments: Congrats on all your great work! I have been a fan of Michael Crawford's for several years now. I've seen others try and play the role, but they don't do it justice. Any other actor as the Phantom would be ludicrous, esp. if they go with some Hollywood name just to make more money! Keep up the good work, and e-mail me if thee's any way I can help! |
| Name: Tom Duggan Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Time: 1998-09-18 10:40:07 Comments: If the rumors I've been hearing about John Travolta as the Phantom are true, all I can say is "puhleeeaaassse?!?!" This kind of miscasting of big name actors is the reason so many movies suck these days!>> >> **Thank you for your comments. We here at the Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign feel the way you do. John Travolta's not going for the role now however, Antonio Banderas is. We're trying to get WB and ALW to realize that we the public will accept no "substitute." We want the original Phantom as promised by Warner Bros. years ago and that's what our goal here is: to promote the casting of Michael Crawford in this movie.** |
| Name: ALLAn Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Aurora Time: 1998-09-18 09:11:55 Comments: Being an owner of many different Phantom versions;Michael Crawford is definitely the best Phantom ever. To have Antonio Banderas play the role is a joke and an insult to Phantom phans all across the world. I can definetly say I would not waste a dime or my time seeing the film with Antonio disgracefullly playing the Phantom role. Michael Crawford is most deserving of the role, WAKE UP WARNER BROS. |
| Name: Linda Levitt Website: Referred by: AOL From: Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania Time: 1998-09-17 14:22:39 Comments: Please - I would very much like to be part of the Michael Crawford guest list and be privy to any info pertaining to him! Linda Levitt |
| Name: Carol Roddy Website: Referred by: Tripod From: Southern California Time: 1998-09-17 01:09:26 Comments: There is ONE & only ONE Phantom of the Opera - Michael Crawford. I have seem 5 different performers in the role of the Phanton. NONE of the others can match the sensitivity, depth & passion that Michael gives the character. This is not to degrade anyone else. It's just to state that: if you're going to make a movie, it can be 'first rate' ONLY IF the 'first rate' actor is cast in the lead role |
| Name: Nate Schultz Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-15 18:03:57 Comments: i am with you all the way. I think Michael should be in the movie. He was awesome in the musical and he would be good in the movie Nate |
| Name: M. Fallon Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-15 17:55:28 Comments: |
| Name: Mary Kobus Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-15 11:38:25 Comments: Claude Raines (sp?) was my idol in the 30s, but today, it has to be Michael Crawford. Please. We love P of the O. Give us the Master. Please. |
| Name: Anne Sokol Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Portland, Oregon Time: 1998-09-14 21:51:40 Comments: Antonio Banderas?!!! I've only just heard - what an outrage! I haven't quite calmed down yet. If they don't cast Michael as the Phantom, they shouldn't even consider the project. What a travesty! I'll start sending some e-mails right away. Hope it helps. Good Grief!!!! |
| Name: Diane
Ahrens Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Illinois- USA Time: 1998-09-14 17:55:18 Comments: I just attended my 3rd "Phantom of the Opera" (Really Useful Theatre Co) here in St. Louis on Sunday. While Brad Little presented a credible "Phantom," he still cannot sing as well as Michael Crawford. I, too, was devasted to learn of the choice of Banderas as the Phantom! :-( Michael made that role, and is the standard that others try to imitate (bravo, Brad! wonderful performance!) But please let us have Michael Crawford on the big screen! |
| Name: Jennifer
Williams Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-13 19:54:07 Comments: I would fully support a movie with Michael Crawford |
| Name: Rachel Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Pennsylvania Time: 1998-09-13 16:06:59 Comments: When I heard about the possibility of a Phantom movie, my First response was I hope they get Michael Crawford to be Phantom. When I heard they were considering Travolta and now Banderas, i was very disappointed. I am so glad i found this web page. Keep up the good work. |
| Name: M.E.S. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Illinois (U.S.A) Time: 1998-09-13 15:02:21 Comments: I would love to say that Michael is one of the most talented singers, but I have only heard him in The Phantom Of The Opera soundtrack. Based on that soundtrack, I would have to say Michael is a very good singer. I have seen him sing on PBS, and he sings with a lot of emotion. I have no doubt that he is a very good actor. He's also kind for starting all those charities.Michael Crawford is my role model sort of, and becaue of him, I'm more interested in singing (I've always been interested in acting).I'm going to try to hear more of him. Thank you Michael Crawford! |
| Name: Katya Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Illinois Time: 1998-09-13 07:24:56 Comments: Hallo! I think, that it is a great idea of making movie "tha Phantom of the Opera" with Michael Crawford! Now I have only the possibility of hearing his voice. And of course, it will be wonderful to see the greatest Phantom. Best wishes, Katya. |
| Name: Debra Hertel Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Palmdale, CA Time: 1998-09-12 08:53:47 Comments: I am praying that your hardworking efforts in this campaign are fruitful. This was the movie I was waiting for, for many years. I have been distributing your flyers from my place of business. The looks on the faces of my customers always register the same, first shock and then dismay. Some believe it is a joke, but I am not laughing. I still cannot believe it, and it may be the death knoll for the movie musical. Diane, let me know if there is more I can do. -Deb- |
| Name: D. Earle Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-12 08:39:08 Comments: I"m just writing to express my support for Mr. Crawfors'd recreation of his signature role on the big screen. |
| Name: Ann
Raymond Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-12 08:04:52 Comments: Michael Crawford has captured the essence of the phantom so brilliantly. To cast anyone else would be cruel, always subjecting the artist to unfavorable conmparison. |
| Name: Rick Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: USA Time: 1998-09-12 07:06:09 Comments: Hello. My name is Rick and I am a loyal fan of The Phantom of the Opera. I have seen the show over 10 times, and I love it. I have heard of the rumors that Antonio Banderas will be the Phantom, yet I greatly disapprove of that. Yeah, he did good in Evita, but the only real Phantom is Micheal Crawford. I greatly support this cause, and I hope my entry will make a difference. I will never see another Warner Brother's movie, and I will never see the movie if Antonio Banderas, or any other person is cast as the Phantom besides Micheal. Thank You. |
| Name: Jackie
Monticup Website: MagicTricks.Com Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: USA Time: 1998-09-11 13:22:08 Comments: Casting anyone else in the role of the Phantom other than Michael Crawford would be a travesty. Why settle for anything less than the genuine article? Michael Crawford IS the Phantom. |
| Name: Tom Gross Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Time: 1998-09-11 06:53:23 Comments: We, too, are Phantom fans, and we would hate to see the role of the Phantom go to any one else but Michael Crawford. Yes, Antonio Banderas was good in Evita, but where was that set? Argentina! A Spanish-speaking country! The accent fit. Phantom is set in Paris, not Madrid. They need Michael Crawford. --A Family of Fans |
| Name: Maggie Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Owensboro, KY Time: 1998-09-10 19:19:53 Comments: In reference to an earlier message, I also have considered the possibility that Warner Bros. is using all this fuss about Phantom casting to their advantage in a publicity buildup for the movie. You know what? I don't care. Just cast Michael Crawford in the lead and get the darn movie made! I'm tired of all these years of anticipation and can hardly wait to rush to the theater and start spending my money to see the film multiple times. BUT...WB and ALW have to do it right. That means Michael Crawford and NO ONE ELSE!!! |
| Name: Willette Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Boston Time: 1998-09-10 17:33:44 Comments: I would enjoy Michael Crawford in the movie version of Phantom of the Opera. I enjoy going to see it a the Wang Center in Boston everytime it is there ! |
| Name: Ali Paskun Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-10 17:26:57 Comments: I agree wholeheartedly with you that Michael Crawford is the only choice to play the Phantom in any proposed film version of the Broadway play. And perhaps I am simply a cynical individual, but has anyone considered this possible scenario (remember we are dealing with Hollywood-types here)? Could this whole situation be a huge publicity ploy on the part of Warner Brothers? They announce someone obviously unsuitable for the role. Everyone gets upset and protests quite loudly that doing so is unreasonable and unthinkable. Warner Brothers now has unlimited free publicity for their upcoming movie at a time when most of their recent films have not exactly been blockbusters. They ride the tide, don't make any public comment, and let the outrage feed on itself. Then, when all seems hopeless, they announce, "Gee, in response to public demand, we have decided to cast the part with the one person everyone wants to see." Every news story done while the film is being shot will, of course, make mention of the fact that the film began shrouded with controversy; a controvery that was finally resolved to everyone's satisfaction. Every film review will, of course, rave about Warner Brothers brilliance in coming to its senses and making a film destined to become a Hollywood classic. I cannot imagine a film critic who could pan a film starring Crawford, especially when they take into consideration what the alternative almost was. This entire situation is beginning to sound more and more like a PR executive's dream. After all, how many people who may otherwise not be interested in seeing another film version of "Phantom" will suddenly rush to buy a ticket simply to see what all the fuss was about? I sincerely hope with all my heart that Crawford is cast in the film. However, a part of me also sincerely hopes that we are not being used. Ali Paskun |
| Name: Robert
Abdich Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-10 17:01:35 Comments: I wholeheartedly support the casting of the one and only actor who can do justice to the part of the Phantom. Performance quality should be the overriding factor versus "$$$$$ BOX OFFICE $$$$$". In fact, the movie version should make every attempt to cast the original London Cast. This means casting Sarah Brightman as "Christine". |
| Name: Eleanor Website: The Phantom's Lair Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: NY Time: 1998-09-10 14:38:58 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the phantom and if antonio banderas or travolta or anybody else should play title role (with little *singing*/acting experience), it would be a great shame to the history of theater. eleanor |
| Name: Charles
Preston Dietrich Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mechanicsburg, Pa Time: 1998-09-10 12:02:37 Comments: Michael Crawford is the phantom. You could never see anyone else in the role. As titled in the PBS telecast, His music is the Music of the night. I hope you are successfull in your campaign. Best of Luck. |
| Name: Nora
Mosqueda Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-10 11:48:06 Comments: Cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom. There can be no other. Nora |
| Name: Joeseph Resivo Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-10 10:10:47 Comments: To Whom It May Concern.......... MICHAEL CRAWFORD IS THE ONLY ONE WHO CAN DO THE PHAMTOM MOVIE THE JUSTICE IT DESERVES!!!!!!!!!!! Keep on Smiling................... |
| Name: Clare Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Texas Time: 1998-09-09 14:09:38 Comments: If Michael Crawford is not given the part of the Phantom in the movie, I will actively boycott it. I speak for many of my friends as well. Warner Brothers cannot realize the magnitude of the mistake they will commit if they cast Antonio Banderas. Just the idea is laughable and ridiculous. Michael Crawford was the ultimate Phantom of the Opera, and a movie without his beautiful, sensuous voice is too horrible to be contemplated. |
| Name: Patricia J
Stinson Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Colorado Springs, Colorado Time: 1998-09-09 08:44:17 Comments: There is no other person to play the Phantom than Michael Crawford. I never had the opportunity to see him in the play and would never pay to see anyone else play the Phantom in the movie. My family all feels the same way. We were so excited when we heard they were going to make the movie, then when we heard he would not be in the role of the Phantom, well, we just couldn't see it. Michael Crawford is the Phantom. I and my family would have no problem boycotting any movie that Warner Brothers puts out. |
| Name: Dalw
Bernard Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Australia Time: 1998-09-08 23:07:39 Comments: Hello, My name is Dale Barnard and I live in Western Australia. Currently, the Phantom is in Perth (starring Rob Guest) and I loved it. At home I have the CD with Michael Crawford as the Phantom. I have listened to it heaps of times (My mother has too) and after looking at your site, I think Michael Crawford definitely deserves a movie role as the Phantom. I have only seen one Phantom movie, (starred Robert Englund) and that scared me to death. It was real nice to see Carlotta become vegetable soup and a couple of people losing their skin. Yuck! Anyway, I will never watch it again. About this 1990 movie, was it going to star Crawford? Do you have any other information about it? Let me know. Thanks Dale Barnard P.S- I don't think Warner Bros. know the real music of the night |
| Name: Mrs.
Roberta I. Montville Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Time: 1998-09-08 23:01:49 Comments: You really really must cast Michael Crawford in the roll of Phantom, in the Phantom of the Oprah. He would be the best for the part and bring it to life like no other can. Mrs. Roberta I. Montville |
| Name: Cindy Lou
Burroughs Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-08 22:58:44 Comments: Michael Crawford is the Phantom!!!! Listen to his voice and you will know |
| Name: Julie M
Tilley Website: Referred by: Clicked on our Banner Advertisement From: Time: 1998-09-08 22:54:45 Comments: I just wanted to write and support this web page. I feel Michael Crawford is the only one to play phantom. I will not go see this movie if he not in it. |
| Name: Virginia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Hong Kong Time: 1998-09-08 20:49:40 Comments: I am a fan of Phantom and of coz I will support the campaign. However I am not Living in CA and USA, so I can only show my support through e-mail. Hope you will gain success!! Best wishes, Virginia, |
| Name: A fan of
Phantom Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-08 20:45:14 Comments: I would very much like to see Michael Crawford perform the role of The Phantom in Andrew Lloyd Webber's blockbuster movie-musical... Crawford is the reason for the Tony awards that the show won in 1988 and he should be given the chance to act the part again on the silver screen.Joel Grey was not a famous film actor but his role in the movie of Cabaret gave him an Academy Award and the same challenge should be given to Mr.Crawford. he may not be a big selling star like the people that are up for the role but I would not want to see an untalented person take on my favorite Broadway role. If Banderas gets the part, he would be giving ALW a bad casting reputation. First off, Phantom is not spanish (not racist- its truth) and second, he was already in Evita- its time for Michael to come on back. GIve him a shot. Thank you. |
| Name: June Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-08 20:40:29 Comments: It will be a terrible tradegy in the history of movies, if Mr. Michael Crawford is not allowed to star as Erik. Blunders have been done many times, in casting "correct" people in roles. The mask belongs to the original musician and actor who will do credit to the movie. Do the "right" thing, people will flock to see a good production. Enjoy each moment of the day!!! June |
| Name: Sheroiz
Hakimudin Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Malaysia Time: 1998-09-08 20:36:30 Comments: I fully support Michael Crawford to play the Phantom in the movie. BTW, when is the movie due to be released? |
| Name: Kate Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-08 20:33:24 Comments: I think that Michael Crawford is the only person who is meant for the role of the phantom and Warner Brothers Studio would be really stupid to cast anyone else in the title. The man made the role and should be able to have the chance to play it on the big screen. Otherwise we will boycott the movie. Please send me any information concerning this at Fantom8@aol.com Sincerely, Kate |
| Name: Rosanna Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-08 20:29:44 Comments: Hi! My name is Rosanna. I just wanted to join in the campain, to have Micheal Craford play the Phantom in the Movie. If you even think of casting someone else your nuts!! Look what happened to the movie "Les Mis". It came out, it's gone. I say, why fool with perfection. You've got the perfect person, why take chances. You're making a big mistake, not going with Micheal. The first one is, all his fans, me included, will not go see the movie. Let's face it, why bother. No-one could ever, replace him. Please, please, DON'T DO IT!!!! YOU'LL BE SORRY!!!!!! |
| Name: Shelly
Mitchell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Decatur, IL Time: 1998-09-08 20:26:03 Comments: Please, let me know how I can help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Have seen Michael in London shortly after opening! Have seen POTO "on the road" ... the "Phantom" is Michael's role!!! no one else can compare!!! |
| Name: Lisa Marie
Marusiak Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Phoenix, AZ Time: 1998-09-08 15:30:07 Comments: The very fisrt musical I ever saw was "Phantom," and let me tell you it had a major impact on me. It is the reason I'm working towards my B.F.A. But back to my encounter with the Phantom. From the moment I heard Michael Crawford's voice on the CD, I knew he was the only one who could ever fill the role. To give "Phantom" to any other actor, such as Antonio Banderas, would be a great big stake in the heart to Mr. Crawford and to all of us Phantom fans. CAST MICHAEL!!!! |
| Name: Roberta
Ward Website: Jadell's Lagoon Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Hawaii, Time: 1998-09-08 10:23:48 Comments: Aloha I would Love to See only Michael as the Phantom, I saw it -4- times & twice with the Master Michael, No one could ever do justice to the part but Michael, No one else has that voice or those hands, that can seduce you without touching you. Oh Please no one else but Michael. Aloha Jadell |
| Name: C.J.
Pankey Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Bethany, OK Time: 1998-09-08 06:55:03 Comments: I really enjoyed your page. It's awesome! |
| Name: Magdalena
Johansson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Sweden Time: 1998-09-07 11:36:39 Comments: Michael Crawford is the best, and this place is just great!!!!!!!! |
| Name: A. Alcantar Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 1998-09-06 22:59:16 Comments: There is no way on earth I would watch the Phantom of the Opera movie, if Micheal Crawford is not the lead!!!! |
| Name: mark zewe Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: california Time: 1998-09-06 22:50:21 Comments: Please let Mr. Crawford play the Phantom in the movie version. Rumor has Antonio Banderas or John Travolta playing him. Please don't do this . Don't cater to the youth of today with a pretty face. Both actors i'm sure would do a great job but, Michael Crawford IS THE PHANTOM. He is perfect that as the OLDER PATRON. Please don't dishonor this wonderful man. LET HIM PLAY THE PHANTOM. In Christ, Mark Zewe |
| Name: Ethan
Tarris Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-06 21:19:19 Comments: Dear Sir, September 06, 1998 We understand that there is a movie of the Phantom of the Opera in the making, and it has come to our attention that Michael Crawford is not the starring role. This is so sad as Michael Crawford is the person who has made the stage production what it is today. If Mr Crawford is not chosen to play his role that he has made so famous worldwide, I fear the movie will not succeed at the movie theaters and what an injustice to the citizens who have supported the productions. If Antonio Banderas must be in the film, why not have him play Raoul as he is much more suited for the character. Thank You for Your Time, Ethan Tarris |
| Name: Claudia
Richards Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: S.D. Time: 1998-09-06 18:17:24 Comments: Okay here it is and this is my humble opinion. This is a sad commentary on the way that films are made today. No longer can we expect the timeless tributes to the lost art of the musical. No, now we can expect nothing from the major Hollywood studios but their continuing race to make money, money, money, and it will all be at the sake of musical movies. It is enough to make anyone lose their temper and all we can now hope for is that "the powers that be" will lose some sleep. Hah! Who heard of anyone in modern day Hollywood with a conscience? If they had one they would be using the man best suited for the Phantom in the movie. No mystery there. Michael Crawford the Phantom of the Opera for all time. Thank you, Claudia |
| Name: Sarah
Kathleen Weber Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Lansing, Michigan Time: 1998-09-06 07:36:05 Comments: Dear Sarah, We at the campaign fully support the theatre and the artists who continue to bring the experience to all people of the beauty and wonder of a live performance. However, if this movie is to be made, we are campaigning to ensure that it is treated with the love and respect that this cherished masterpiece, Phantom of the Opera, deserves. If Hollywood continues to advocate the casting of a box office draw to line its pockets with money from the unknowing masses then, we are with you! However, we would love to have Andrew Lloyd Webber release for public viewing the video he is said to have squirreled away of the Original Phantom of the Opera cast, taped in London. Now, let me state here for the record that this guestbook was not started as a forum for debate, and we are not seeking entries to discuss the merits of the film translation of the play. This guestbook was started solely as a support for Michael Crawford, and for the fans who wish to see him star in the movie as was promised to him and all of us in 1991. We thank you for your entry and for your sincere support and dedication to the live Performing Arts. Sincerely, Diane Flogerzi ********************************* PLEASE!!!! Don't let the media do to theatre what they want to. Theatre is one of the only forms of live entertainment left where the performer isn't screaming his head off at the audience. Do you really want what happened to Vaudville to happen to the theatre? Pretty soon no one will go to the theatre any more. Why should they when they can see it on video? :-( |
| Name: acc Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-06 02:15:28 Comments: MICHAEL CRAWFORD IS THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA. IF WARNER BROTHERS CAST BANDERAS OR ANYBODY OTHER THAN MICHAEL, THEN ALL TRUE CRAWFORD AND PHANTOM FANS SHOULD VOTE WITH THEIR FEET AND STAY AWAY FROM ANY SHOWINGS OF THE MOVIE OR ANY ATTEMPTS TO SELL THE VIDEOS AFTERWARDS. MICHAEL CRAWFORD DESERVES TO BE THE PHANTOM IN A MOVIE VERSION OF THE SHOW. HE HAS CERTAINLY GOT MY VOTE. |
| Name: Jeanette Malinowski Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 19:08:52 Comments: Make Michael the phantom. |
| Name: Sandra Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: England UK Time: 1998-09-05 15:53:43 Comments: Micheal Crawford is undoubtedley the only reasonable chioce for this role ... wake up and smell the coffee !!! |
| Name: Koulla
Manousou Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: SCOTLAND UK Time: 1998-09-05 15:50:33 Comments: Well ... What can I say that hasn't been said already ... ??? ... I feel strongly that Micheal Crawford should take the part of Phantom in the movie ... It would be a crime not to ... He is made for the role ... what is more he worked hard to reach the standard required for going on stage with the show ... At the end of the day he would be the only rational choice ... and looking at this guestbook I see that I am not one of a select few with this opinion !!! |
| Name: W. Reader Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 13:25:59 Comments: HAS WARNER BROTHERS GONE BRAIN DEAD. NO ONE CAN FILL THE SHOES OF THE PHANTOM EXCEPT MICHAEL CRAWFORD. NO ONE CAN SING IT OR PERFORM IT LIKE HIM. I CATCH EVERY PERFORMANCE I CAN OF MICHAEL'S INCLUDING EFX AND HIS LATEST CONCERT..TRAVELING TO DO IT! NEVER HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE HIS ENTIRE PERFORMSANCE OF PHANTOM , BUT HAVE SEEN PHANTOM 4 TIMES AND NO ONE HAS COME CLOSE TO MICHAEL'S FEELINGS HE GIVES THE PHANTOM....PLEASE RECONSIDER!!!!BANDARAS IS A FINE ACTOR AND DID A SURPRISING JOB IN EVITA...BUT HE'S NO PHANTOM...BESIDES HE'S TOO YOUNG..THE ROLE CALLS FOR MATURITY! |
| Name: Jayne
Brown Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Canada Time: 1998-09-05 13:19:15 Comments: how could anyone possible see the Phantom as someone other than Michael Crawford. This is yet one of the stupid things that movie people do. Why bother bringing a stranger to the silver screen to play phantom, when Michael Crawford is "THE PHANTOM" Antonio Banderas....I don't think so. I know I won't be one of those Phantom Phans standing in line to watch my Phantom with a spanish accent. Antonio, stick to Melanie, leave the music to the real Phantom of the Opera-That would be Michael Crawford. Jaye Brown Canada |
| Name: Alan
Bruce Drake Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 13:14:50 Comments: As a music instructor and lover of musicals, I agree with your quest! Look at history... Audrey Hepburn who couldn't sing takes Julie Andrews' role in My Fair Lady and what happened to Julie later? Do you remember Paint your Wagon? Clint Eastwood and Lee Marvin singing? I still cringe! You mentioned many successful transfers from stage to screen. Weren't Shirley Jones and Gordon McCray on Broadway before doing the screen versions? And of course Fred Astair, et al started on stage. I'm sure the studios worry about name recognition and box office draw. I would be interested to see how many "common folks" know the name Michael Crawford and associate him with the Phantom. I never got to see him perform the Phantom, but love the sountrack. Let's face it, there's no one in Hollywood who can sing the role and it would be a cheap shot to dub Michael Crawford over someone else. Good Luck, Bruce Drake |
| Name: Adela
Buffa Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 13:09:59 Comments: How could you even consider anyone else but Michael Crawford to play the Phantom in the movie version? Michael's singing is fantastic and boy could he hold those notes, he's sexy and embodies exactly what you would want to see in the movie version of the play. I have seen the play many times, own the original soundtrack of the POTO and just seen Michael recently (June 30) in New York. His voice sounded so good. You will be making a big mistake by someone other than Michael Crawford as the Phantom of the Opera. Very truly yours, Adela Buffa |
| Name: Stephanie
Stinchcomb Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Pasadena, MD Time: 1998-09-05 13:05:59 Comments: It would be a crime to not have Michael Crawford as the Phantom. His talent and presence is the epitome of drama. You cannot cast anyone else because Michael Crawford IS THE PHANTOM!!!!! |
| Name: P. Brady Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: U.S.A Time: 1998-09-05 13:02:18 Comments: HEY YOU PRODUCERS OF PHANTOM - I THINK YOU NEED TO SEE "EVITA" AGAIN AND TELL US WHAT ANTONIO BANDERAS IS SINGING? WE CAN'T UNDERSTAND THE LYRICS AND HE IS supposed TO BE TELLING THE STORY! QUITE A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE DISTINCT SINGING VOICE OF MICHAEL CRAWFORD AND "HARD TO UNDERSTAND" ANTONIO BANDERAS. |
| Name: Gertrude
Rapp Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Time: 1998-09-05 12:56:49 Comments: Greetings, It should be noted (as many times as is necessary) that MC has already done a full production video of "Music of the Night". It, I think, puts to rest any notion that the Phantom cannot survive the translation into a medium other than "the theatre". That being said, I doubt any other actor could breath more life into the role of the Phantom on film. The video is only a taste of how magnificent the film could be with MC in the title role. |
| Name: J.H. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Clearwater FL Time: 1998-09-05 12:50:43 Comments: After seeing Michael Crawford in Concert in Tampa, FL, I cannot imagine anyone else in the role. Michael's voice is so extraordinary, anything else would be insulting. Antonio Banderas would only look silly lip synching his words and I don't think his voice is powerful enough to do the role justice. The Phantom is not only about the songs, but the pathos of the man. Banderas is TOO ypung and good looking. Michael Crawford is still very good looking and still a good age to play the part. Please reconsider. I would suggest Mask only ,no clown make up as I saw in the program--Yuck! |
| Name: Ingrid
Kennedy Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: UK Time: 1998-09-05 12:45:35 Comments: I am a fellow fan of the phantom of the opera, and most of all Michael Crawford. I must say that casting Michael as the lead in the movie would be the best thing Hollywood could do, when people think of the phantom, they always think of Michael Creawford, and since the phantom has always been see as HIS musical, the same as Aspects of love is Michael Balls musical then it would only be right to cast him as the man part once again, this show is big in the theatre, it could also be big in the movie views,as long as the parts were played right. you alone can make this song take flight. Miss H Kennedy |
| Name: John Gentile Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 12:40:31 Comments: I really think Michael Crawford is the only one that can do the role justice. He is a fantastic performer and one fabulous singer. He deserves to be the one for the role of Phantom, because he is the only actor in the world who can make "The Phantom of the Opera" live and breath and he alone should recreate his role for the future film. |
| Name: Lauren A. Zaccarelli Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Harrisburg, Pa Time: 1998-09-05 12:34:53 Comments: I agree that Michael Crawford is truly the only star that should be cast in this role. Neither Antonio Banderas nor John Travalota have the vocal depth nor the acting depth to carry off this role. Thank you. Lauren A. Zaccarelli |
| Name: Judy Denny Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 12:31:10 Comments: Your Web Page says it much better than I - Michael Crawford, and no one else, should be the one to portray the Phantom in the movie. I'm sure Warner Bros. feels they need top dollar, younger actors in order to make this movie a success. They are so wrong. Look at "Titanic" and it's success. The story, presentation and proper casting are what make great movies - not necessarily "big" names. Cast Michael in the lead and, if Warners feels it is necessary to grab the younger set, select the Travolta's and Banderas' for supporting roles. Those are important parts to the story, too! Good luck in this quest. Judy Denny |
| Name: Bob Glazier Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Bakersfield, CA Time: 1998-09-05 12:24:54 Comments: I for one would not set foot in the theater if Michael Crawford does not play the Phantom... I would not buy the sound track recording or the video or DVD... How in the world can the people at Warner Brothers and A.L. Webber even consider anyone but Michael ??? I hope that this campaign is sucessful cause I sure do want to see the movie... Good Luck... Bob Glazier - Bakersfield, Ca. |
| Name: Dr. Richie
Schwartz Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Time: 1998-09-05 12:19:51 Comments: He is the logical choice. I've seen many Phantoms in my day and he is the best of them all. Richie Schwartz |
| Name: Susan Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Texas Time: 1998-09-05 12:13:31 Comments: I saw Phantom twice in LA, the first time with Michael Crawford, the second time with Robert Guillome. There was no comparison. With Michael Crawford I was totally oblivious to time and the present; I only felt moved by his voice, his songs, his emotions, his expressions of unrequited love. I did not feel any of that with Robert. I also so Phantom in Houston several years later, and again was somewhat disappointed . I have since purchased numerous CD's and tapes of Mr. Crawford's. I must admit I have seen Antonio Banderas in several movies and find him lacking as an actor, over-rated musically and somewhat cartoonish. I don't consider those the qualities needed to portray the Phantom, but I know Michael Crawford has those qualities. I feel it would be a shame to deny him this opportunity and a mistake to deny fans everywhere to experience his talents on the big screen. Thank you! Susan |
| Name: Tom Ernst Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Time: 1998-09-05 12:08:51 Comments: There is only one Phantom and that is Michael Crawford. Please do not allow the role to be changed for the years as a result of someone else being the Phantom in the movie. There is only one Babe Ruth; one Ben Hogan; one FDR; and one Phantom! |
| Name: Bruna
Cristielle De Carvalho Porto Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Brazil Time: 1998-09-05 12:05:16 Comments: PLEASE PUT MICHAEL CRAWFORD AND SARAH BRIGHTMAN IN THAT MOVIE!!!!! Nothing would be better! I'm fourteen, I live in Brazil, Sarah's my favorite singer , I love Michael's voice!!! It would be a real GIFT to those who, like me, couldn't watch them on New York neither Broadway! They're the best!!!! Why would ALW choose other???? He did the christine's role after miss Brightman and discovered in Crawford the perfect phantom!!! You can't turn this great play in a joke using anybody else! yours truly, Bruna |
| Name: Sheila Hakun Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Washington, DC Time: 1998-09-05 11:59:44 Comments: Michael Crawford is the one and only Phantom around. I just saw him perform in DC and he's still got it. There is no other Phantom!! Please use Michael in the movie, he is still GREAT!! Sheila Hakun |
| Name: Elynor Vine Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: New York Time: 1998-09-05 11:43:06 Comments: Does anyone remember what a bomb "Mame" was when it became "Lucy Does Mame"? It should have starred Angela Lansbury, who can actually sing, dance and act without Fred and Ethel. With all due respect, the big name and money politics of not having Michael Crawford doing a role he brilliantly crafted, performed and made famous will be an enormous creative and economic disaster. And will alienate zillions of people who pay lots of money at the box office. Banderas hasn't the voice or the talent, nor is he anywhere believable as a middle-aged, disfigured and tortured man desperately in love with a woman he can't have. No matter what he says. No matter what his agent tells you. Transient heart throbs look pretty with Madonna, but that's about all. Get the bankers out of the Business or you'll soon have Donald Trump and Bill Gates doing the remake of "It's a Wonderful World" on ice and Christmas will have to be cancelled. What are you thinking of anyway? Wake up moguls. Cheers, Elynor Vine |
| Name: A.
Jones Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: U.S.A Time: 1998-09-05 11:38:18 Comments: Only Michael Crawford can do justice to the role of the Phantom in planned movie adaptation of The Phantom of the Opera.....He just absolutely can present the Phantom with a passion no other can muster!!!! Please.........Please........Please........give serious consideration to looking no farther for yours and everyone else's Phantom..... Michael Crawford!!!!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Margaret
J. Hutchinson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 11:33:58 Comments: Michael Crawford is the diamond of all the phantoms. To me it is inconceivable that either Andrew Lloyd Webber or Warner Bros. would want to use a cubit zirconium in place of the real gem. Because of the diamond that Michael is, the value of the POTO movie and subsequent videos would only increase with time if Michael Crawford immortalized Erik. Margaret Hutchison |
| Name: Mollie
Baldwin Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Florida Time: 1998-09-05 11:28:12 Comments: No contest! Michael Crawford IS the Phantom of the Opera!! We saw it several times with different artists, in several different countries, but none of them captured the role the way that Michael did. He BECOMES the Phantom, and if anyone decides to cast another star in the movie role, you can count us out! We wouldn't even bother to go and see it. Good luck with your campaign. |
| Name: Ali Paskin Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1998-09-05 11:24:52 Comments: Michael Crawford is the only actor/singer qualified to bring the Phantom to the screen. Casting anyone else is that role would be a disgrace. I have loved Lloyd Webber's musical version of this story for years, and have seen the stage show several times. However, I would NEVER consider supporting (with my time and money) a film version in which Crawford was not the Phantom. And I am not alone. I personally know many people who enjoyed "Phantom" because of Crawford's electrifying performance in the lead role. I know the would not be enticed to see a film version without Crawford. I think it would be in WB's best interest to reconsider this casting decision. |
| Name: Christine
Alongi Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: N.Y. Time: 1998-09-05 11:18:00 Comments: I wasn't as fortunate as many, to have seen Phantom with Michael Crawford, but once I did see the play, I raced out to buy the CD which is all of Michael. I can still remember listening to him and closing my eyes so I could picture him on stage putting his heart and soul into "The Music of the Night". I saw that he was going to be in New York on June 30 and July 1. I went to Manhattan to meet him at his record signing on June 29th. On June 30th I was sitting in the audience at Radio City Music Hall listening to Michael, my breath was taking away, his voice was so strong and full of emotion as he sang the tunes from Phantom that you believe that he really is the Phantom. I am a fan of Antonio Banderas, but not as the Phantom......only as Antonio Banderas. |
| Name: Josh
Albers Website: The Way Referred by: Yahoo! From: St. Louis, MO, USA Time: 1998-09-05 11:16:10 Comments: Great site featuring my favorite musical of all time. I just went to the Fox Theatre's, St. Louis, production with Michael Crawford, and I loved it. I have never seen anything like it. |
| Name: Phantom Fan Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: New York Time: 1998-09-05 11:13:04 Comments: i had the pleasure of seeing michael crawford on stage in new york when he was the phantom and can't imagine anyone else in this role. not only did he have the ability to handle a physically demanding role, but his vocal range and ability was captivating. despite the fact that michael is older now, he still maintains a strong stage presence and certainly maintains the vocal ability of past years. to take antonio banderas and place him in this role is to appease fans who appreciate lesser talent. it seems that mr. banderas has had few roles recently which have been critically acclaimed or have been box office successes. where is the logic in placing him in the role of phantom... |
| Name: Ann Henry Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Ohio Time: 1998-09-05 11:03:22 Comments: Hi, I want you to know that we support the idea of Michael Crawford playing the Phantom in the movie version.There is no other choice,he is superb at his craft! I just saw him in Cleveland with Dale Kristen and they were wonderful. He makes you feel every breath he takes and every move that he makes as he glides across the stage. He is enchanting!!!! Michael Crawford excels in his art! Thanks from Ohio |
| Name: Valerie
Banta Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Sandy, Utah Time: 1998-09-04 19:47:27 Comments: I would be very disappointed if Michael wasn't given the part in the movie. I have read so much on this subject that it makes me wonder if Warner Bros. will ever make this movie. When and if they do and if Michael plays the Phantom once again, I will be first in line to see it. |
| Name: Erikka Nilsen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Swansea, Massachusetts Time: 1998-09-04 17:44:13 Comments: I just have to say that I have seen Phantom on several occasions and was fortunate to see Michael perform. Although all the performers who played the Phantom did an outstanding job, I must say that when Michael sings you not only hear the words..you FEEL them, you feel the emotion. I do not believe any other actor/singer can capture what Michael does. Michael absorbs himself in the role completely...a sign of a true talanted artist. Any important production such as a movie..to be authentic and worthwhile should include Michael Crawford. Only he alone can do it justice. |
| Name: Deborah Earle Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: U.S.A. Time: 1998-09-03 16:27:57 Comments: I see no sense in bucking popular sentiment on the issue of casting for the film version of "Phantom". Most of us out here prefer to see Michael recreate his signature role on film and a lesser formula isn't likely to work on screen if fans won't accept it.--D. Earle |
| Name: Sandra
Huffman Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Harrisburg PA Time: 1998-09-03 05:39:03 Comments: Michael Crawford...there is no other phantom! |
| Name: Kaori Heltman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Hawaii Time: 1998-09-03 00:30:00 Comments: The phantom must be Michael! |
| Name: Myron Shreves Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Lancaster CA Time: 1998-09-02 13:37:43 Comments: Let the "Master" do it....Michael Crawford |
| Name: Lynda Rocha Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: San Jose Time: 1998-09-02 12:43:23 Comments: Michael is the only choice. He embodies the passion of the Phantom...he is the Phantom. |