Total : 530 Guests
| Name: megan morgan Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Time: 1998-07-14 12:33:04 Comments: I would LOVE to see Michael Crawford perform the role of the Phantom!He is my FAVORITE actor and singer! I'm a BIG fan of his!Scince I won't get to see him perform the Phantom on stage I would at LEAST like to see him in the upcoming movie! |
| Name: Debbie Trow Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Central CA Time: 1998-07-14 11:30:06 Comments: I have loved POTO for years and was never fortunate enough to see Michael in the role. I do have the CD's of Michael's Phantom and listen to it all the time. I have waited for years to see him do the role on the big screen and was so distraught to find that he was not considered. The role belongs to him and him alone. I will go to see the movie only if Michael is Erik. ALW promised him the role years ago...what happened??? I hope our voices here are heard in Hollyweird...Forever a PhantomPhan... Debbie :) |
| Name: Dale
Crawford Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Dallas, Texas Time: 1998-07-14 10:47:22 Comments: Phantom of the Opera is already a tragedy -- don't make another one by casting Banderas! |
| Name: Kim Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: New York Time: 1998-07-14 09:48:20 Comments: Hello ! Ever since i first heard The Phantom of the Opera on tape, i became very interested in the person who played the phantom : michael crawford. i thought that he was very talented and had a splendid and beautiful voice. sometimes i wish that i could go back in time to the late '80s to see the show in new york city. when i heard that a phantom movie was in the works, i was very happy. i thought that crawford would be cast without a doubt since many people connect the phantom with him. i think it would be unfortunate if crawford didn't get the part of the phantom because he is not a widely - known film star. crawford is obviously talented enough and has had much experience in film, theater, radio and television. if crawford was cast for the part of the phantom i think the film would be a great success ! thanks for reading my lengthy letter ! |
| Name: Shelley
ILER Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Pueblo,Colorado Time: 1998-07-14 09:03:19 Comments: I arriven in London in 1987 and took a working/holiday. While working I would pass the Theater where Phantom played with the original Cast. Being from Canada, I have seen most of Michael Crawford's early comedy work. I loved him. After hearing all the rave reviews of the show, I wanted to go so badly. However, my father passed away, suddenly, and I returned to Canada, never seeing Michael as the Phantom. I wish I could turn back the clock. I listen to the soundtrack constantly!. I can't imagine any other man for the movie roll. Even though we can't turn back the clock, perhaps I can still have a chance to see him as the Phantom. Best of luck in this truly meaningful cause. |
| Name: Debbie
Crawford Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Cumberland, MD 21502 Time: 1998-07-14 08:47:49 Comments: To me there is only one Phantom and that is Michael Crawford. Someone else would be a poor example. If Michael is not in the movie, the movie would not be worth going to because whoever is the Phantom (if it is not MC), would be a fake one. L ike the song goes - ain't nothing like the real thing. And the real thing is MC. |
| Name: Lorraine Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: Atlanta Time: 1998-07-14 06:13:37 Comments: Yesterday Michael performed at Chastain Park here in Atlanta. The local paper, the ATlanta Jour nal/Constitution was entirely devoid of any advertising for this show. Guess what happened? People found out in spite of the newspaper and the outdoor theater was 90% full, only the seats in the very back were empty. I have NEVER been to a performance that had standing ovations in the middle of the concert!! ANd, guess which songs? Yes, those from Phantom. People love Michael as the Phantom because he IS The Phantom!! Warner BRothers, if you want a successful movie that will live forever cast Michael. I know the bottom line is money, money, money, but this is your way of making money AND pleasing the public. Hey "bosses" go to one of the concerts, see for yourself! |
| Name: Ina Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: TX Time: 1998-07-14 02:16:55 Comments: I think this movie would be a flop if it didn't have the Phantom in it.Who is the Phantom? Michael Crawford,of course! It would be wrong not to have Michael in the movie because he is the Phantom. He is the heart and soul as well as the voice of the tortured heartbroken Phantom. Michael's portrayl of the Phantom is simply breathtaking where I hardly know where the Phantom stops and Michael begins,since he puts so much of himself into the character of the Phantom. He has the ability to make us believe the Phantom is not a cold-blooded monster but a man just as human as the rest of us who only wanted to love and be loved in return.I implore you to please consider Michael Crawford for the movie role of the Phantom because he is the man behind the mask,the heart,the voice and the spirit of the Phantom. Ina |
| Name: Kim Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Fl. Time: 1998-07-13 21:24:13 Comments: I'm somewhat new to this so do bare with me... I love the plot and music of the Phantom of the Opera, I have also seen Michael Crawford in concert... or at least on tape :) By these I have come to believe that the role of the Phantom would be best played by Michael Crawford himself. I wish nothing but luck to those who are fighting for Michael and I do wish them a succesful mission! :) |
| Name: Kevin Schwab Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: New York City Time: 1998-07-13 21:21:56 Comments: I would very much like to see Michael Crawford perform the role of The Phantom in Andrew Lloyd Webber's blockbuster movie-musical... Crawford is the reason for the Tony awards that the show won in 1988 and he should be given the chance to act the part again on the silver screen.Joel Grey was not a famous film actor but his role in the movie of Cabaret gave him an Academy Award and the same challenge should be given to Mr.Crawford. he may not be a big selling star like the people that are up for the role but I would not want to see an untalented person take on my favorite Broadway role. If Banderas gets the part, he would be giving ALW a bad casting reputation. First off, Phantom is not spanish (not racist- its truth) and second, he was already in Evita- its time for Michael to come on back. GIve him a shot. Thank you. |
| Name: Sherry Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Kansas City, MO Time: 1998-07-13 21:07:25 Comments: Yes, I know already signed this guestbook once but I just had to add something after what I saw today. Did anyone else see the ridiculous performance by Antonio Banderas on The Rosie O'Donnell Show today? I have never wasted my time by seeing one of his movies so this was my first opportunity to observe him. I easily came to the conclusion that Banderas is a complete fool. Why does Warner Bros. think he is so great? Of course, ALW thinks Banderas is perfect; after all, Banderas has shamelessly buttered and lobbied ALW for the Phantom role. I had hoped to find something about Banderas that would redeem him for the Phantom. Unfortunately, I could only find him tacky and totally tasteless. What was with all those little head jerks he kept doing? Do we really need a Phantom that looks like he belongs in the barnyard pecking with the rest of the chickens? Michael Crawford wouldn't be caught dead making movements like that on camera, especially while discussing Phantom. I hope someone comes to their senses before it's too late. Banderas as the Phantom--what a joke! |
| Name: Jennifer Abila Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Mission Viejo, CA Time: 1998-07-13 19:32:52 Comments: I find it completely obsurd that they are considering anyone beside Michael Crawford to perform the role that he does so perfectly. Everyone who has ever seen him perform raves about how wonderful he is, and anyone who never got to see him in Phantom (me included) regrets missing one of the world's greatest performances. Crawford still sings as beautifully as he did 12 years ago (maybe even better) and seems interested in the project, so why even consider Antonio Banderas? They're trying to make the movie into a joke instead of an artistic masterpiece. I know many people who would be excited to see Crawford in the movie (and you know Phantom fans spend lots of money on merchandise as well as seeing the movie multiple times). I don't know anyone excited about Banderas, except maybe ALW. |
| Name: Sarah Jedrey Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: North Carolina Time: 1998-07-13 12:25:07 Comments: Thank God that there are other (sensible) people who share my views! Crawford is the ONLY Phantom worth considering for the part! Honestly, boys, get a little sense in your pinheads! |
| Name: Mary A
Armellino Website: Mary On the Move Referred by: From LinkExchange From: Barstow, Ca. Time: 1998-07-13 12:12:30 Comments: There is no other Phantom. Anyone else in the role would destroy this great musical drama. |
| Name: Mary Clark Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Clearwater, Florida Time: 1998-07-13 06:28:43 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the Phantom. Why on earth would they even consider anyone else? Antoniao Banderas is a fine actor. He is just not the Phantom. Michael Crawford is. It would be like making a movie of Roy Rogers in his prime and casting Clint Eastwood. It is wrong, wrong, wrong. Mary Clark |
| Name: Allison Website: Four Corners: Rambo's Mag7 Page Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Pennsylvania Time: 1998-07-13 04:23:48 Comments: I saw Phantom last year in Toronto because I was already obsessed with it after listening to the original cast recording. When I heard whoever was playing the phantom sing *Can't remembers his name right now!* I just laughed because he didn't sound good!! Michael Crawford was the original Phantom and should play him in the movie, not John or Antonio! |
| Name: Tara Barth Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Vermillion, SD Time: 1998-07-12 23:42:42 Comments: I saw Phantom of the Opera for the first time in March of '98. I must admit, I never really showed any interest in it at first, but after I saw the play on Broadway...I was in love. Even though the Phantom I saw wasn't Michael Crawford, I bought the soundtrack and have been listening to it ever since...until just recently my car got broken into and that CD happened to be one of many taken from me. So today I still sing that whole CD in my head everywhere I go, because Mr. Crawford has an exceptional voice, and the Phantom of the Opera is one musical that can never be topped!!! Long live the Phantom!!! Long live Michael Crawford!!! |
| Name: peggy othen Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: New York Time: 1998-07-12 19:33:48 Comments: Michael is he only person who can do justice to the role. Warner Bros will be making abig mistake by casting someone else. He has made the role his own. He owns it!!!!! |
| Name: April
Bostwick Website: shadowsong.com Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Michigan Time: 1998-07-12 19:32:34 Comments: The entry by this person is from a separate campaign and is in no way affiliated with The Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign or this web site. Every person has the right to their own opinion, however this campaign was started in support of Michael Crawford starring in the movie Phantom. This page is not her fault, we have no prior knowledge of this person, but is the fault of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Warner Bros. for backhanding Michael Crawford who was contracted and partly filmed this movie in 1991. We the members of the Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign feel Michael Crawford should star in this film version of the play to ensure that it lives on as a classic and a work of art for future generations. The Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign *********************************************************************************************** Please, I am begging you. I have been repauled by this movie since well over a year ago. I was extremly active in capain work and getting John Travolta out of the picture. I wrote to the Warner Studio itself several times pleading, and often, demanding that there be no movie made. It is simply terrifying at what has happened since I quit. You see, I became active in a lot of classes and such and didn't have much or any time to get on the net. Before I would visit sites everyday, encorage people by directly e-mailing those that had signed the campaign and signing several different pages and much much more. All in all a very tedious task, I can assure you, but I had the time then. This is the first time I have been on in months and I am horrified that anyone should be in this movie. I am even more frightened that this page is my fault. I was very active in the campaign and left my name only as "Christine Daae". Well, I didn't want Michael Crawford, John Trovolta or Antonio Bandaras in this movie. There should not be one at all! The Phantom is a classic. Screen is dead. There are no feelings as in theatre or literature. Just cheesy actors who slept with directors. If you care anything of Erik and you have the time, please, Erik, I and his true friends beg of you: Devote that free time into stopping the movei, not getting Michael Crawford or anyone else to star in it. No one can make it good on screen. Help save real theatre. As myself and fellow actors know, it is fading to comparison of the "silver screen". |
| Name: Lynn Wegrzynek Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Pittsburgh, PA Time: 1998-07-12 17:09:17 Comments: I wish that I could be there for the actual demonstration at Warner Brothers' Studio. I am planning to send a message of support. THERE IS ONLY ONE PHANTOM....MICHAEL CRAWFORD. What more do they need to hear? |
| Name: Dotty
Schwalb Website: Referred by: Net Search From: USA Time: 1998-07-12 16:10:41 Comments: Michael Crawford just IS the Phantom. He just IS! |
| Name: Jenny and Amy Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Idaho Time: 1998-07-12 15:23:58 Comments: HI! Michael Crawford is the only one to be the Phantom. His voice is so wonderful and his hand movements are amazing. I am only 11 years old and I love him. He is my Hero. And Andrew Lloyd Webber shouldn't be allowed to take away all our hopes and dreams just like that. Michael is our Phantom. He cares and well, he is just our man. You can't beat the best. Andrew said he was too old. Michael is only two of three years older than Andrew! Antonio is not right for this part. He is wonderful as Zoro, but not as the Phantom of the Paris Opera house! WHat is Andrew thinking. If this movie comes out with Bandaros in it, Antoinio will be known as the true Phantom and not the man who started it. If only Andrew would visit this awesome site he might listen to reason. If any of you people suporting Michael through this all the way have any idea of what a Idohan can do please feel free to e-mail me. Or if you just want to talk about Michael (the one true Phantom) TaTa |
| Name: Noel E. Bishop Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Grand Blanc, MI Time: 1998-07-12 13:58:40 Comments: Michael Crawford deserves the role of the Phantom because he is the original, it is in his blood, he gets into the character when he sings the songs, and he is a very good actor who takes his job seriously. Andrew Llyod Webber what's wrong with you? You should cast Michael Crawford in the role of the Phantom. I LOVE MICHAEL CRAWFORD! |
| Name: Mike Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Time: 1998-07-12 10:54:53 Comments: I must agree with number 72, Betty Fisher. |
| Name: Michael Smith Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Ft. Lauderdale, FL Time: 1998-07-12 10:05:14 Comments: Did they (whichever movie company) not learn anything from not casting Julie Andrews in My Fair Lady?!? I love Audry Hepburn as much as the next person, but she wasn't the original! I like John Travolta and Antonio Banderas, too...BUT! These are not the people who should play the Phantom!!! Michael Crawford was my insiration to follow my love for music, and now I sing with many musical organizations. Let him continue to be an inspiration to countless others by casting him in the movie version of Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera! |
| Name: David Levian Website: SickDawgs Philosophy & Poetry Page Referred by: Advertisment/Brochure From: Rockford, IL Time: 1998-07-12 06:47:13 Comments: I have discussed the thought of anyone but Michael Crawford playing The Phantom with 15 friends and we are in agreement that if anyone else is cast this is one movie that we will absolutly miss. I could not in my right mind watch anyone play this part when Michael Crawford is this part. |
| Name: Stacey
Schedler Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Coon Rapids,MN Time: 1998-07-11 21:02:42 Comments: I agree with what you guys are trying to do. He will be and always will be the best phantom. Michael Crawford is one of my favorite singers. I hope you suceed in what you are doing because I don't think I would like to see the movie if he is not in it. |
| Name: Tim Rauser Website: the lake on the fifth cellar Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Glen Burnie, MD Time: 1998-07-11 20:16:44 Comments: Diane, This is from TIm (the person who has his Read Death picture on your page). I am making a new Phantom page, and need some publicity. I was wondering if when it is finished you could add a link to it. I don't have it up and running just yet, but will soon. It does not compare to your page (made using hot-mail), but it's OK. I am going to add in some great artwork done by Paul Faris, that realys the Phantom theme (off of the original novel), but not based on hte ALW musical. Just e-mail me back even if you can't add a link. Thanks, Tim Rauser |
| Name: Betty Fisher Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Maryland Time: 1998-07-11 18:24:29 Comments: Recently saw Michael Crawford's concert on PBS--fantastic! I've seen the stage version of Phantom several times, but never was fortunate enough to see Michael Crawford in the role. However, in watching the concert on TV, when he sang "Phantom of the Opera" with Dale Kristien, it was amazing to see him become transformed---facial expression, body language, attitude, gestures---into the Phantom. No one else could do the role justice. I hope Warner Bros. wakes up to this simple truth in time to save the movie and their reputation. A mistake like this could cost them big time. None of us die-hard Phantom fans will pay to see a less-than-perfect Phantom, but all of us will pay---again and again---to see Michael Crawford in the role. |
| Name: Kim Oldziej Website: N/A Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Eastpointe,Mi Time: 1998-07-11 18:17:33 Comments: Michael Crawford is the most talented performer of our time!! |
| Name: Mike Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Missouri Time: 1998-07-11 17:25:28 Comments: Michael Crawford is God . . . the only Phantom |
| Name: Bill Walker Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Tampa, Florida Time: 1998-07-11 16:16:19 Comments: Seeing Michael Crawford at the ICE PALACE in Tampa was an extraordinary experience! To capture the essence of the Phantom in any other would be like taking a bite out of an apple expecting to taste carmel...it aint in there! Adios Banderos! |
| Name: s.m. mccrea Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: moon township[pittsburgh pa area Time: 1998-07-11 13:12:00 Comments: have been trying to get to see mr crawford on one of his tour to starlake ampitheatre but when announced on t.v. that he is to appear all tickets already spoken for would like to know in advance of t.v promo so i could finnally see him in person is this possible through this e-mail message?sg |
| Name: Yoli
Lawrence Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Perth Western Australia Time: 1998-07-11 00:43:47 Comments: Michael is one of the driving forces behind the resurrection of the musical today! He is known all over the world for the Phantom. You can talk to someone who has no idea who he is and just say "Oh he played the Phantom" and they instantly say - oh he is amzing. For all that I liked Antonio Bandaras in Evita (A role that he played to perfection) he is a little young for the tourtured genius of a man who has had to survive on his own wits. Madam Giry makes the comment that "Years ago a travelling show came to town" she was a young girl then - and he was a man - it follows then that he should be in his 40's-50's now. Please let our Phantom sing with the voice of a "Master Showman" |
| Name: Marilyn Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-10 21:37:07 Comments: Love the idea of a demonstration! Wish I lived closer so I could participate. Hope every possible media outlet is made aware so the coverage will be HUGE. It's about time this campaign got some national coverage. The timing is perfect to tie this in with Michael's concert at the Hollywood Bowl. Go, Go, GO!! Are you listening, Warner Bros. and Andrew Lloyd Webber?. That's the sound of Phantom's/Michael's fans jingling all the money you WON'T get at the box office if you cast anyone but Michael Crawford in your "Phantom" movie. We mean business and we intend to be heard --NOW-- before it's too late. |
| Name: Lauren
N. Baker Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Grass Valley Time: 1998-07-10 16:21:11 Comments: I am as much of an Andrew L.Webber fan as the next guy, but, common, Antonio B., THE PHANTOM?!?!? I don't think so!!!! Michael, we love you....you're the only Phantom for us. Heck, you could even be Raoul if ya like...we love ya just the same. If anyone wants to email me and complain...go for it. love you all and GOD BLESS!! Love, Lauren |
| Name: Thalia Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Dallas Time: 1998-07-10 16:13:31 Comments: Nothing against Banderas or any of the fine actors who have portrayed Erik the Phantom on stage, but Michael Crawford has gone further than anyone else to embody the Phantom's soul. He created the Phantom, he slowly and gently explored the Phantom, he worked to make sure that every atom of the Phantom's being was clear to audiences, and he's avoided seeing other Phantom actors so that his Phantom was purely Erik. I also believe that in LA, when he was announced for the film, he consciously worked at making the characterization 100 percent complete and very very subtle, which would be appropriate for the camera. You can't fool the camera, and Crawford has nothing to hide--his Phantom IS the Phantom; his voice IS the Phantom's voice, his accent IS the Phantom's accent. And his age IS the Phantom's age. He alone would give the film honesty, reality, theatricatlity, and soul. Please--someone, anyone in power--tell Andrew Lloyd Webber and Warner Brothers that if they want a film that resonates with audiences and critics, that the public will accept as authentic, it MUST star Michael Crawford. Thalia |
| Name: Tasha
Lea Whited Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Pensacola, Florida Time: 1998-07-10 14:15:19 Comments: As a devoted fan to the musical production, I refuse to see a Hollywood name take Mr.Crawford's role away from him! I have already passed out the addresses of The Really Useful Group as well as Warner Bros. to many of my peers in my high school. I am only seventeen years old, yet, as an aspiring, young actress, I am determined to make it to Broadway! However, if Hollywood gives away Mr. Crawford's role of the Phantom to some overpaid, undeserving actor, who knows what will become of the musical? My dream is to someday have the honor of playing the role of Christine Daae, and if the stage show dissolves because of Hollywood, I will have nothing else to dream of! Please, I beg of anyone reading this, PLEASE do not support a Hollywood celebrity! You know who the real Phantom wants to portray him, and I know for a fact that it is not Antonio Banderas or Mr. Saturday Night Fever!!! Listen to your hearts, listen to the Phantom's requests, and follow this campaign. Just remember this: "You will curse the day you did not do, all that the Phantom asked of you!!!" Thank you, and God bless Michael Crawford! |
| Name: Ali Paskun Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-10 13:15:44 Comments: Michael Crawford is the only actor/singer qualified to ' bring the Phantom to the screen. Casting anyone else is that role would be a disgrace. I have loved Lloyd Webber's musical version of this story for years,and have seen the stage show several times. However, I would NEVER consider supporting (with my time and money) a film version in which Crawford was not the Phantom. And I am not alone. I personally know many people who enjoyed "Phantom" because of Crawford's electrifying performance in the lead role. I know they would not be enticed to see a film version without Crawford. I think it would be in WB's best interest to reconsider this casting decision. |
| Name: Dee
Leidlein Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: New Philadelphia, OH - USA Time: 1998-07-10 12:30:11 Comments: I saw Michael Crawford in concert for the first time on June 27, 1998 in Columbus, Ohio. I have always been a fan of his, but I had no idea of the pure talent this man possesses. I have been buying every CD of his I can lay my hands on since then. I cannot seem to get enough. It truely would be an injustice to cast ANYONE else in the role that he created. Thank you. |
| Name: Sally Swindells Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: uk Time: 1998-07-10 12:20:49 Comments: Michael Crawford has long been acknowledged as the definitive Phantom - the definitive Phantom is so obviously the first choice for the film. So why go for anyone else - it is illogical. The other actors suggested for the part may have good voices - may be good actors, but they can never be the Phantom Michael Crawford has given us - the voice, the charisma and the depth of emotion. They will always be regarded as pale imitations. And why have an imitation when you can have the real thing? |
| Name: Mollie & Annie Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Tampa, Florida Time: 1998-07-10 07:35:39 Comments: We've seen Phantom several times, in different countries, with several other stars, but Michael Crawford IS the Phantom!! No-one else could ever capture the role as he does. He BECOMES the Phantom. We wouldn't even bother to see the movie unless he was the star. Good luck with your campaign. |
| Name: RON FORD Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: SPRINGFIELD Time: 1998-07-09 21:50:50 Comments: My guess is that the millions of PHANTOM fans worldwide will be the majority of ticket buyers for the movie. So the studio had better pull it's collective head from it's ass and bow to the will of the people. Madonna as EVITA?!! Remember? (she was actually pretty good,but just imagine what a real singer and actress could have done). |
| Name: Jennifer Kord Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Hyattsville, Maryland Time: 1998-07-09 19:36:29 Comments: Any rendition of "The Phantom of the Opera" lacking Michael Crawford is doomed to fail miserably, and will ultimately make a mockery out of what is a truly beautiful work of art. Shame on Warner Brothers for sacrificing true beauty for a superficial movie, starring an actor that cannot possibly grasp the depth of character that only Mr. Crawford is capable of bringing to life. |
| Name: Kari Casady Website: The Book Barn Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Missouri Time: 1998-07-09 17:46:04 Comments: I am truly disgusted that Warner Brothers would even CONSIDER anyone but Michael Crawford for the part of the phantom. And when I heard the name John Travolta mentioned as the lead I felt truly sick to my stomach. To have anyone but Michael portray the phantom would be an act of total disregard for true art and the love of true talent....JOHN TRAVOLTA...please GROW UP!!!!!!! |
| Name: Jennifer
Boht Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: Indiana Time: 1998-07-09 17:22:30 Comments: Michael Crawford is the only Phantom of the Opera. To have some big named actor play the role would ruin the story and the best musical of all time. |
| Name: Jennifer Website: Annie 20th Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Louisiana Time: 1998-07-09 12:20:20 Comments: Just wanted to sign in to show my support. |
| Name: Barb Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-09 10:19:37 Comments: I fell in love with the music of the Phantom of the Opera with Michael Crawford singing it. He was my first Phantom ... After a long awaited period of anticipation, I saw the stage show of the Phantom at the National Theatre in Washington, D.C. Michael Crawford had retired as Phantom, so I was not able to see him. I was terribly disappointed in the production. I can't imagine anyone other than Michael Crawford playing the Phantom in the movie. I was aware that the movie was even under "construction," far less that they are thinking of casting someone else. To the powers that be: Anyone other than Michael Crawford will be a disappointment. PLEASE don't even consider it! |
| Name: Sheri
DeBacker Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: NJ Time: 1998-07-09 08:12:40 Comments: I was appalled when my father told me that he heard the "choices" for the actor to play The Phantom in the movie... John Travolta, Nicholas Cage or Antonio Banderas???? What are they thinking? There is one and only one man who can truely be The Phantom and that is Michael Crawford! I am attending his concert in NJ on July 19 and my friend told me that I should see if I can meet him and tell him myself that I (and clearly many people) would be devastated were he not to star in the movie. Yours truely, Sheri |
| Name: Kelly Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-08 23:55:23 Comments: If Michael wouldn't want to play the Phantom, I think Thomas James O'Leary--the current Phantom on Broadway--should be asked to play the lead. I saw him recently and thought he was amazing!!! Just giving my suggestion. I love Phantom and a movie version would be wonderful. If I ever became a famous producer or director I wanted to create a movie version. A little late for that though. Have fun with the movie. Kelly |
| Name: NOEL
B. QUIAMBAO Website: NO HOMEPAGE YET Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: PHILIPPINES Time: 1998-07-08 23:24:14 Comments: July 9, 1998 Good day. My name is NOEL and I am from the Philippines. While surfing all the broadway plays, I chance upon this message regarding a request to Warner Brothers to star Michael in the lead role. That of the PHANTOM OF THE OPERA. I am an avid fan of Michael Crawford and his music. His voice is so exceptional and his portrayal of the role of the Phantom is superb. No, but no one can duplicate the performance of Michael. Imagine, combining acting and at the same time singing, only Michael can do it. I bought a lot of broadway tapes and CD's, all the musical plays with their original cast recordings. But do you know that I have completed almost the CD's and tapes of Michael? That is how I believe in his talent and skills. I was so happy when EVITA was made into a movie. But I was even more excited when the news of the PHANTOM play being made into a movie is on the planning stage. Honestlly, when the musical play "Phantom of the Opera" being made into a movie hit the pages of our newspapers , only one name came into my mind : It ought to be MICHAEL CRAWFORD. No one else. Now, I am begging, pleading, asking, requesting, praying and hoping that Warner Brothers GET and CAST MICHAEL CRAWFORD to be the Phantom of the Opera! Come on, begin the Music of the Night! Because if these demands are not met, the curse of the phantom might occur. HOPING THAT YOU CAST THE KING OF THE MUSIC OF THE NIGHT, Good Luck, God Bless, NOEL |
| Name: Kathy Fanlund Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Wisconsin, US Time: 1998-07-08 21:36:36 Comments: Love the page! Keep up great work! |
| Name: Ruey-Wen
Yuan Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Taiwan/ GA Time: 1998-07-08 21:02:10 Comments: Michael Crawford is only one phantom I like to see in new coming movie. Regarding the sensation of the voice ... who can be better phantom. |
| Name: Rosemary E.
Kord Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: MCKINNEY, TEXAS Time: 1998-07-08 20:20:37 Comments: Evidently, Warner Brothers, in their infinite concern of garnering huge box office revenues by casting a "Hollywood name", has decided to turn their back on the most magnificant love story of the century and the only ACTOR who MADE THE PART,MICHAEL CRAWFORD, his own signature piece. In so doing, they will suffer losses of great magnitude reflecting the absence of conscience in preserving the integrity of a movie that belongs to only one man. |
| Name: Ruth Ann West Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Holbrook, MA Time: 1998-07-08 19:14:56 Comments: I found this through Krista's Michael Crawford site. Michael Crawford is THE BEST choice for the movie. What he brought to the role on stage is what he would bring to the movie, not an actor playing a role but rather a spellbinding event that pulls you to that time and place, leaving you aching inside to see him again and again and again. And if it's the "bean-counters" making the decision, think about this, when Carol Channing was passed over for 'Hello Dolly' the audience made their displeasure known by not going to the film, making it a box-office failure inspite of a tremendously talented cast (I would dare say Barbara Streisand has more talent than either Antonio Banderas or John Travolta ever will even dream of having in the vocal department). It's your decision, but if you cast anyone other than Michael Crawford, I, for one, will never see it. However if you do the intelligent thing and cast him, I would see it time and time again. |
| Name: Cathy
Lantz Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Columbus, Ohio USA Time: 1998-07-08 14:14:21 Comments: After seeing Mr. Crawford in concert just about two weeks ago, it is unfathomable that he would not be chosen to be the film Phantom. He is a great talent, and no one else could recreate his feeling for the role. Thank you. |
| Name: Ken Garcia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Austin, Texas Time: 1998-07-08 09:46:52 Comments: I'm still hoping this is all just rumors. I just can't understand why ALW would do this; has he and Michael Crawford had some sort of falling out? I fell in love with POTO long before I ever actually saw it. Because of the cast recording, I could just picture it all in my head so clearly, and Michael's voice was just awesome. I've seen it several times since. Why would Webber want a star in the part (as if Michael wasn't one)? It's not as if Antonio's good looks will be on display under all the make-up, just his voice (yikes!). Why take the chance when you have such a sure thing in the palm of your hand? I hope all this effort is somehow going to the desk of Andrew Lloyd Webber. It's up to him to stand up for Michael and The Phantom. |
| Name: Dana
Cooper Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Minnesota Time: 1998-07-08 08:19:24 Comments: This is a wonderful website. Keep up the wonderful work. |
| Name: Ron &
Heidi Burns Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Texas Time: 1998-07-08 05:34:45 Comments: If they won't let Michael Crawford do POTO at Warners, than Please let them release the video they Must have of him doing it on stage !!! |
| Name: Emily C. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Detroit MI Time: 1998-07-07 21:43:20 Comments: Who's crack headed idea was it to put Pretty Boy in the role of the Phantom? He can't sing! He's too pretty! He needs to stick to disaster and latin films. Michael Crawford is the one true phantom. Everybody knows that! Antonio as the Phantom?! You can't understand a word the guy says! Why don't you just slap a phantom mask on the little Taco Bell dog and have him play the role! I say, "Yo Quiero Michael Crawford!" |
| Name: Jennifer L Jones Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Tullahoma TN Time: 1998-07-07 18:28:40 Comments: No one can out act, sing , or put emotion into Phantom as Michael Crawford Enough said!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Anna Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Redding, CA Time: 1998-07-07 17:36:57 Comments: The Phantom of the Opera was a wonderful show. Even though I am only 13, I know good music when I hear it, and when I went to go see the San Francisco performance of Phantom of the Opera I was breathtaken. The music is simply wonderful and even with my less than, well, good voice, it still sounds beautiful when I sing it. However, there is something about Michael Crawford that just exceeds perfection and brings the phantom to life. I own the cd of the original london cast recording of PTO and I listen to it daily, and hearing Crawford's voice just makes it all so real. Especially in the end song with Raoul and Christine where she has to make her choice. He gives such devotion to his character. The movie would be okay without him, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as good as it would with out him. That is his role, and no other up and coming actor with a pretty face would do it justice. I'm 13 and I'm saying this!!!!! Cute guys are all that are going through my mind right now, but I still don't care if the role was offered to Matt Damon!!!!! It belongs to Michael Crawford!!!! |
| Name: Call
me Christine... please. :) Website: Through the Portal... Tori, Bowie, Phantom Referred by: Net Search From: The bowels of the Paris Opera House Time: 1998-07-07 16:32:05 Comments: I think we should organize a revolt if the deity Michael Crawford is not cast. You know, like the Peasants' Revolt, except... well, different. No one can be as hypnotic, obsessive, yet darkly seductive as our dear Mr. Crawford.. ESPECIALLY not someone who, not too many years ago, disco'ed in a horrid leisure suit for a living.. Or someone about whom the only thing I like is pronouncing his name.,.. Say it with me: Ahn-toh-nee-o Bannn-derrrrr-ahs... POWER TO THE PEOPLE!!! |
| Name: Mary E. Zeiner Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: Rochester, NY Time: 1998-07-07 15:38:19 Comments: So, it doesn't matter who is behind the mask? Remember when they slighted Clayton Moore when remaking The Lone Ranger? Let's see, who starred in that flop, again? |
| Name: L.A. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Colorado Time: 1998-07-07 10:18:41 Comments: Michael Crawford should definetly be the Phantom in the movie! No one else could ever be as good as him (especially not Antonio Banderas!). And that's a fact! |
| Name: Jill Garcia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Auburn, CA Time: 1998-07-07 09:12:45 Comments: "Why, Andrew, why?" You had PERFECTION in the voice and acting of Michael Crawford. Michael says, "I'm available." This would seem to be a "no-brainer". Yet you seem determined to choose Anonio Banderas. Why must you disappoint us? Why must you fail us all? Why must you break our hearts knowing that we could have the REAL phantom in all his glory instead of an imitation??? RECONSIDER. WE WANT MICHAEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Amanda G. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Ohio Time: 1998-07-07 07:49:57 Comments: I think it is absolutely revolting that they would even concider casting anyone other than Michael Crawford! Cas Banderas as Raoul...his less than stellar voice can handle that. Besides, the actor playing the Phantom will be so grossly deformed that it shouldn't matter whose face is under the makeup anyway!!! Amanda |
| Name: Kara Campbell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: utah Time: 1998-07-07 07:46:42 Comments: Michael Crawford is Erik. When ever i read the books on phantoms or even think or hear of the POTO, I envision MC as Erik. There is no substitution. MC was possesed by Erik on the stage, and would do it once again in the movies. If there worried about his age...then make up would do wonders...after all, the phantoms face is usually well covered. And lets not forget...MC is a well peserved man for his age. If im 23...a 23 yearold who never would date a man over 32...and im attracted to michael...a lot of girls would be :) |
| Name: Kim Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Pennsylvania Time: 1998-07-07 07:13:37 Comments: Michael Crawford is the only one for the part of the Phantom in the movie. Although I was never fotunate enough to see him on Broadway, I fell in love with his voice from the moment I heard him on the soundtrack. I now have all of his albums and will be going to his concert on July 19. If Mr. Crwaford does not get this part, then the entire movie will be a waste of film! |
| Name: Tamara Marks Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Glenview, Illinois Time: 1998-07-07 05:48:58 Comments: Just hope you are successfull |
| Name: Coral
Meetens Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: United Kingdom Time: 1998-07-07 05:29:59 Comments: I agree with you absolutely. I wasn't fortunate enough to see Michael Crawford when he was in London, but I have the London Cast recording, and I think he's brilliant - the best there could ever be. Nobody else should play the Phantom in the movie. (P.S. You can try reaching me at: grahams@mistral.co.uk.) |
| Name: Christine Garcia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-06 23:27:18 Comments: Sorry ,forgot my address:Christie@foothill.net. Please E-mail. |
| Name: Hollie Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-06 16:35:44 Comments: In the Phantom's own words "Have you forgotten your angel"? |
| Name: Jen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: CT Time: 1998-07-06 16:02:40 Comments: I like the page and I agree with it completly..Mr.Crawford should be the Phantom no one else will ever be able to act out the part like he can.... |
| Name: Christine
Garcia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Auburn,CA Time: 1998-07-06 14:56:50 Comments: I'm only 15, but I'm on my way to being a devoted Michael fan. I've got most of his CDs (including the one with the unfortunate duet with Barbra Streisand on "Music of the Night"). I've also got front row tickets to his Aug. 4th concert. I think it is just plain wrong to cast Antonio as the phantom. You might as well change Erik's name to Bob and have him roam a 7-eleven. I hope Andrew has nightmares for this mistake. They just need to drop a chandelier on the whole Antonio idea. And I visited Antonio's Web site and they all agree it's wrong too. Michael is unquestionably the ONLY phantom! E-mail me if you want to discuss this urgent matter. I look forward to your response. Thanks. |
| Name: Robyn Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Idaho Time: 1998-07-06 14:38:59 Comments: I think it would be absolutely wonderful if Michael Crawford was cast as the Phantom, however, I do think it is necessary to keep all of this in proper perspective. If he is cast, that's great, there should be no need for demonstrations, etc. As I see it, if he is not cast, as long as the integrity of the story is protected, I would have no reason to boycott it. The story of the Phantom of the Opera is truly a beautiful work of art, and I see no reason why it should not be performed by anyone, as long as they really have a passion for it. |
| Name: Caitlin
C. W. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Michigan, USA Time: 1998-07-06 11:26:39 Comments: I love Mr. Crawford's voice! He does a magnificent job in the play, and I have the Phantom CDs. Without him, it wouldn't really be the Phantom of The Opera. I really feel sorry for the Phantom at the end of the play. He is just... There are no words. If he ever reads this: YOU ARE SO COOL! I LOVE YOU!!!!!! |
| Name: Bethany
Cap Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Time: 1998-07-05 20:06:48 Comments: I just wish they would cast anyone that has actually done the part in the role. The only reason they want Banderas is because of star pull. Don't they think that the name of the movie ALONE would bring in people? What has happened to the movie world where a movie has to have a big star in it or they think it won't sell? Or have the producers become so paranoid that they believe without an established *movie* star the movie will sink? What happened to giving new people a chance anyway? Michael has been in movies and on TV before. And it's not like his name isn't known. |
| Name: Rebekah Brown Website: N/A Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: New Zealand Time: 1998-07-05 18:03:23 Comments: Michael Crwaford would be the best Phantom for the Movie. He was the original and has so much passion for his music , and this comes out in his acting. He is the one and only choice for the Phantom. |
| Name: Virginia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Los Angeles Time: 1998-07-05 13:59:45 Comments: I am in no way for the movie being made at all, but if it must, then let the real Erik play the role. Peace, Love, and Micheal Crawford. :-) |
| Name: Lance and
Judy Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Newport, Oregon Time: 1998-07-05 13:04:03 Comments: Excellent,Cognitive,Informative Web Page......Well done! |
| Name: Susan A.
Patterson Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Spring,Texas Time: 1998-07-05 12:39:22 Comments: Michael is the ONLY PHANTOM and I won't go see the movie if he isn't in it!!!!I have been a fan of Michael's for many years going back to English movies(my mother loved English films!) and his voice is incredible and he's a wonderful actor.Others could do an average job,but Michael is the only one who could do an exceptional job!! |
| Name: c-girl Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: England Time: 1998-07-05 10:46:18 Comments: All I have to say is that at one point in my life i became so in tune to phantom that i lived for it. It's not healthy but i didn't care. All i had was phantom. I've seen phantom bought lots of cd's and tapes. Through all of them Crawford is the one and only person that can play phantom . It truly hurts that they don't want to let him be phantom. If Crawford is not Phantom I'm not going to see the movie. And there are alot of people who feel like just the same. They'll lose so much money by getting someone other than Crawford. |
| Name: Madaline
Bennett Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: North Carolina via Alabama via Illinois - Roll Tide Time: 1998-07-05 08:29:37 Comments: There can be only ONE person to play the movie version of The Phantom of the Opera and that is MICHAEL CRAWFORD!! I have seen the Phantom twice since September, first at the Kennedy Center in Washinton, DC and in Raleigh this past May. Although both men who protrayed the Phantom did an excellent job, they are NOT Michael Crawford. I have played the soundtrack so much that his is the voice I hear in my head no matter who plays in role. For those who say that he is too old or not well enough known in the movie industry to be in the movie version must not remember movies like "Hello, Dolly!" and other things that he has done. My husband and I are really looking forward to hearing him in concert May 15 at Hardee's Walnut Creek. We understand that the concert is a sellout. Looks to me as if a lot of us know of him. GO MICHAEL!!! |
| Name: Kate Website: Referred by: Net Search From: PA Time: 1998-07-05 08:16:36 Comments: MICHAEL CRAWFORD SHOULD PLAY THE PHANTOM ON THE BIG SCREEN OR WE SHALL BOYCOTT THE MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Jennifer Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-04 21:31:07 Comments: It would be a terrible mistake to even consider allowing anyone other than Michael Crawford to play the role of Erik in the new movie.He portrays the tragic charactor with more feeling and emotion than anyone else ever could.The Phantom of the Opera is Michael Crawford no questions asked.Don't ruin this beautiful musical the same way so many others have been. Let Michael play the role that he was born for and leave the Hollywood faces for Hollywood's movies. |
| Name: Kathryn Vermeer Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Time: 1998-07-04 20:57:05 Comments: I have been watching, and reading this board for a long time. I keep wondering, what more could I say to convince ALW and WB that Michael Crawford MUST be cast as Erik. All these eloqent, heart felt notes have said it all. I have talked to dozens, and dozens of friends, acquaintances, co-workers, and strangers. They all say the same thing. "You've got to be kidding. No-one but Michael Crawford should be the Phantom". The book, the past movies, not even the musical itself, would not have,could not have, touched me so deeply, and reached down to my very soul, like Michael Crawford's voice and portrayal of Phantom. Won't you PLEASE give the rest of the world the opportunity to see, hear, and know, the "real" Phantom? What a shameful fraud this movie will be without him. I won't be there to see you desecrate the most beautiful, musical story of our time. Nor will any other Phantom of the Opera follower. We will be attending a funeral.......Erik's funeral And may he NOT rest in peace, but come back to haunt all of you that had a part in his demise. |
| Name: jo ann robinson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: ny Time: 1998-07-04 18:17:15 Comments: i hope warner bros. will cast the only true phantom of the opera michael crawford. for no one can play the part as well as he can. |
| Name: lori robinson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: ny Time: 1998-07-04 18:12:40 Comments: i hope tha he will be playing the role of the phantom in the movie. |
| Name: Linda P. Website: Referred by: Advertisment/Brochure From: Mt. Laurel, NJ Time: 1998-07-04 14:31:05 Comments: I can't imagine anyone but Michael Crawford portraying the Phantom in a film version of POTO. I just saw him at Radio City Music Hall in NY and with his incredible voice and stage presence, this could be one of the great musicals. When he sang songs from Phantom, you could see him go right into the role, and he really was the Phantom as he sang. He created this role and it should be his to play in the film. Hollywood's desire to have a "name" or a "pretty face" is just to sell tickets, however, if anyone but Michael Crawford plays this role, it won't do this wonderful play justice. I would think there is a large audience (not just Michael Crawford fans) who wouldn't even bother to see the film without him - myself included. It's been a long time since a really great musical has been produced by Hollywood and now is their chance to show they can still make a great film. There is a whole generation of young adults and children who have never experienced the beauty and emotion of a truly great musical. "Grease" was fun, but not the caliber of what Phantom of the Opera could be. I implore ALW and Warner Brothers to consider ONLY Michael Crawford as PTOM. |
| Name: CINDY
THOMISEE Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: LITTLE ROCK ARKANSAS Time: 1998-07-04 13:02:39 Comments: I FEEL LIKE MICHAEL CRAWFORD IS THE ONLY TRUE PHANTOM.I HAVE BEEN FOLLOWING HIM FOR YEARS NOW. I JUST WENT TO HIS CONCERT IN ST. LOISE AND IT WAS WONDERFUL. I WILL BE VERY DISAPPOINTED IF HE DOESN'T GET THE ROLE. EVER SINCE I HEARD THEY WERE MAKING THE MOVIE I HAVE BEEN SO EXCITED BUT IF MICHAEL DOESN'T GET THE ROLE, IT JUST WON'T BE THE SAME! |
| Name: THE HARVEY'S Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: BEL AIR, MD. Time: 1998-07-04 12:25:37 Comments: Seen the show twice. Will not watch the movie if Michael is not the star!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Sheroiz
Hakimudin Website: - Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Malaysia Time: 1998-07-04 10:27:48 Comments: Let it be Michael Crawford, and Sarah Brightman too if possible. BTW, when is the movie due to be released? |
| Name: Peggy Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Evansville, IN Time: 1998-07-04 10:07:13 Comments: This is a no brainer! Michael Crawford was, is and ever shall be, THE Phantom of the Opera. Why is anyone else even being considered? Doesn't ALW understand that his show belongs to all of us because its message is universal? Who hasn't experienced ridicule in some degree...and don't we all fear rejection? That is the essential message of "Phantom" and explains why people have taken this show to their hearts. It may border on melodrama, but we all can relate to the Phantom's pain. ALW and Warner Bros., watch out! You're tampering with some deep-seated emotions and some strong pre-conceived ideas of what this movie should be. In the hearts of several million fans, Erik has only one voice--MICHAEL CRAWFORD'S. |
| Name: Krystal
Morton Website: Krystal's Home Page Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Raleigh, NC Time: 1998-07-04 10:01:31 Comments: First things first, Michael Crawford was the original phantom in london, new york, AND in los angeles. he started phantom and made it what it is. why not recreate this atmosphere for the movie? people are going to go see the movie whether there is a big name star or not...so why not make it good. secondly, the phantom of the opera was written by gaston leroux and takes place in paris. paris is in france. erik is french. antonio banderas is spanish. having studied french for the last 5 years, there is a big difference between the two accents and cultures. not even to mention the fact that antonio is not as good an actor as michael and he proved in Evita that he is not as good a singer either. I won't even go into John Travolta, Mr. Disco King/Danny Zuko That is my $.02 worth |
| Name: Joe
Martell Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Long Island, NY Time: 1998-07-03 21:10:23 Comments: I think this site is a terrific idea, NO ONE would do the part justice like Michael Crawford!!!! GOOD LUCK!!!!! |
| Name: Claudia
Hemsi Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Brazil Time: 1998-07-03 16:25:11 Comments: I'm a member of the Michael Crawford International Fan Association in Brazil and Michael's most fervorous admirers. Like you, I agree that he is the only one able to portray Erik with perfection. There are a lot of good actors out there (Antonio Banderas and John Travolta are not), but the original, the first, the one who gave birth to the character deserves this honor and IS the best. Michael is the best, no question about it. I hope the film makers realize it before it's to late to prevent an injustice being commited. So let's pray, wait and see. Thanks and bye-bye, Claudia Hemsi |
| Name: Jenny K. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-07-03 15:40:21 Comments: hey, I like the little Phantom quotes at the bottom of the screen!! I've heard some rumors (or maybe perhaps they are more than that) that John Travolta might be playing the phantom in the film version. I love John Travolta and all, but there is only one person who can be the phantom, if you were only to base that judgment on his voice alone! Of course this person is no other than Michael Crawford. |
| Name: Dori Bruns Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Fallbrook, CA Time: 1998-07-03 15:38:01 Comments: POTO is a musical play about OPERA. The actors playing Erik and Christine must have trained voices that the audience can associate with operatic singing. Erik has been Christine's teacher. She thinks of him as the "Angel Of Music". His voice hypnotises her, haunts her, and stays "inside her mind". This voice must be both powerful and seductive. It must have tremendous range and be capable of showing the Phantom's heart-wrenching dispair when Christine leaves him. The audience must feel his pain and longing. The part of Raoul does not require such range or quality. He just has to sound romantically appealing. This part, Antonio Banderas, with his Latin charm, could undoubtedly do. But for Erik, Banderas would be woefully inadequate and the film would suffer. Michael Crawford created the part and has thrilled audiences and critics in the UK and the US. His performance is the one we want to see in the film. No one else should even be considered. |
| Name: Mrs. Miniver Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: a place where people drive like theres no tomorrow Time: 1998-07-03 08:36:55 Comments: Age is not a factor in the role of the Phantom. Michael Crawford is the Phantom. Antonio Banderas is being used soley for his youth appeal. |