Total: 3800 Guests
The Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign Guestbook
| Name: Lucy Dickinson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Phoenix, Arizona Time: 2000-06-19 03:08:07 Comments: Its hard to believe there even has to be a campaign for this purpose. Michael Crawford and all of us (his fans) were promised this movie with Mr. Crawford 10 years ago. We have been waiting patiently for this to come about. I'm tired of waiting for people to decide what they want to do. It shouldn't take too many brains to figure out. On one hand you have the man that originated and perfected the role. On the other hand you have a man not at all noted for his singing and not even doing very well in his movies. Any 5year old could tell you the best choice. Please come to your senses Lord Lloyd Webber and Warner Bros. before its too late. |
| Name: Michael Orr Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: UK Time: 2000-06-19 02:17:27 Comments: I have seen Phantom Of The Opera five times, on both sides of the Atlantic and each time with a differnt actor in the role. The only one I would want to see again is Michael Crawford. The man was superb and that's putting it mildly! No one will ever improve Upon Crawford's performance and any actor would surely have nightmares just trying to equal such a performance! As for the idea of casting Antonio Banderas as the Phantom - the least said the better!! |
| Name: Catherine Orr Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: UK Time: 2000-06-19 02:06:10 Comments: If Michael Crawford had failed in the role of the Phantom, then it would be sensible to cast someone else, but Michael Crawford won every award on the planet for the role and whether Andrew Lloyd Webber likes it or not, his name is synonymous with the part. No one is going to get excited about Antonio Banderas as the Phantom - no one gets excited about Antonio in any role these days! His Spanish accent will make him sound like Carlotta and Piangi and his singing ability leaves a lot to be desired. If Michael Crawford is not given the role in the movie - a role he has earned and rightly deserves- then there is no doubt that this movie is destined for the dustbin!! |
| Name: Karen
Burrows Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Edmonton, Canada Time: 2000-06-17 21:21:08 Comments: I am fully in support of a Phantom movie with Crawford in the title role, especially with the news of possible casting that I have been hearing: I'm sorry, but Antonio Banderas simply cannot sing. I would love to see this movie done with as much of the original cast as possible; however, the Phantom is one of the two roles that simply *cannot* be filled as adequately with anyone but Crawford (the other role would be Christine, with Brightman's performance being completely memorable). Michael Crawford's performance as the Phantom is inimitable... no one else should even try. |
| Name: Mariem
Henaine Website: "Links to my various web pages" (including Michael´s Crawford´s COMPLETE discography) Referred by: From a Friend From: England Time: 2000-06-17 20:54:42 Comments: O.K., here´s the thing: you simply and absoluteley CANNOT REPLACE THE ORIGINAL PHANTOM!!! Michael Crawford is and will always be THE unique, exclusive and ONLY Phantom in this world, like it or not, so if ALW and the WB have a little bit of reason in their minds, they´ll do what´s right and NOT, BY ANY CHANCE put Antonio Banderas as the Phantom. |
| Name: Kate Brown Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Kentucky Time: 2000-06-17 14:59:36 Comments: While A.B. has a wonderful vocal talent, it can not match that of Michael Crawford. Michael Crawford IS the Phantom of the Opera, and that cannot be changed. It is his voice and his alone that creates the "music of the night." I'm sorry, A.B., but you are NOT suited for the role of the Phantom of the Opera, that role is for one man and one alone: Michael Crawford. |
| Name: JOYCE
Cebular Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Clearfield, PA. Time: 2000-06-17 00:07:29 Comments: TO W.B. EXECS. i and many thousands of people world wide are very anxious, to see this movie appear. But to that it must be done right with the right casting of characters, and the orginal music score intact. Let me ask you this, 1. how many times has Antonio Banderas played the role of the Phantom? ans. zero 2. How many times has he sung the difficult music that the Phantom requires? ans. zero. 3. Has Banderas had any operatic vocal training? ans. no. 4. how many times has Banderas had any major movie hits? none that i can think of. 5. does he ask for a huge salary? ans. yes. are you ready to hand out mega salary to someone who has a poor track record at the movies? i certainly hope not. Now let's take a look at Mr. Crawford, has he done the role of Phantom? ans. yes 1300 performances in London, N.Y. and the L.A. STAGES. 2. Has he had any operatic training/ ans. yes. 3. Is he capable of sing the difficult music? ans. yes. 4. He has wowed the audiences with his range, power, emotion, and tenderness of his music. 5. His age is just the right age of the Phantom, and he is physically fit to fly all over the stage. 6. Mr. Crawford is the only person who has put such high standard on the role that other phantoms have a hard time keeping. 7. and MR CRAWFORD will not demand a high mega salary from you to do the role he loves. And finally let's take a track record of Sir ANDREW Lloyd Webber. 1. the movies he did after his plays have failed miserably. 1. Evita. bad casting, because he wanted hollywood names that were big, Madonna, and Banderas, both bombed, not a box office draw, not even nominated for the emmy, JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR, failed miserably on broadway, critics panned it said it stunk, why because he had to rethink it, it did not even win the tony. this is what you want, from him on the phantom? i would think you want critic acclaim, as well as the audience acclaim for this classical masterpiece. So think it over Warner BROS. you are paying the bills. |
| Name: Serena Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 2000-06-17 14:31:54 Comments: If I had a choice to see Michael's Phantom for just one time and to never see the musical again I would,choose Michael's performance,because I've only seen the musical a few times but all the other actors I've seen just weren't Michael. They just didn't have the voice or the passion that Michael pours into the role. I would travel anywhere to see Michael Crawford the REAL Phantom of the Opera!! From a fan who was too young to see Michael in the role. |
| Name: Bethanie Rayburn Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Southern California Time: 2000-06-17 14:31:52 Comments: I feel for those of you who truly don't know what you are missing. To those of you who have never had the opportunity to see Michael Crawford perform in the stage production. Yes, I know that many, many of you are passionate fans of other actors who have followed in MC's footsteps (which is the nature of theater, time goes on, and other actors inherit the role). But for those of you who have not seen Mr. Crawford in this role, you simply don't have the experience and perspective that some of the lucky ones have. You simply don't understand the impact that seeing that performance had. I had read the reviews, I had seen the crowds outside the theater on the evening news, I heard people at work raving about this play from the hip teen grunts, to the top executives (my CEO and all his lieutenants along with their spouses were at the opening night). As the buzz grew I wondered what the big deal was...on February 26, 1991, I found out. Words on a page, words spoken to you cannot deliver the experience. You must have seen it for yourself to truly get it. I'm sorry to say so, but that's just the way it is. It is impossible to fully describe the depth of emotion that engulfed all my senses during the performances I witnessed with Mr. Crawford in the lead. This unassuming man (who you wouldn't look twice at if you saw him on the pavement) had 1800 people in the palm of his hand. He was larger than life; he somehow made everyone in that theater experience what the Phantom felt, he exposed the Phantom's very soul-not through a pretty face-but through his voice and physicality. I don't have the vocabulary to describe what it is I felt emotionally and physically during the evening. All I can say is that it was the first time in my life that I understood what a truly great actor does. His performance was spellbinding, heartbreaking and emotionally draining and he possessed me for those hours that he was on stage. Those words don't to justice to what was going on in me during the performance. Since MC went away, I've seen other actors perform in the role, but none delivered the emotional ring, the physical ring that those of us who have seen Mr. Crawford perform, felt. I've seen some legendary theatrical performers...Tony Roberts, Leland Palmer, Bernadette Peters, Patti LuPone, Mandy Patinkin, Robert Morse, George Hearn, Angela Landsbury. Yes they are all fabulous and wonderful, but none of them gave me the jolt that Michael Crawford did. I know that I can't make those of you who support others in this role understand if you haven't seen Mr. Crawford's performance. He is simply incomperable...it's like trying to compare a Rolls-Royce to an MG. That's why I so very badly want Mr. Crawford to play the role in this film, so that each and every one of you out there understand why he IS the Phantom, the same way that Rex Harrisson IS Henry Higgins, Yul Brynner IS the King. He is an Icon to the British public, the way Bob Hope is an Icon to Americans. He is the greatest living musical theater actor of his generation, and if we don't get this performance on film our culture will lose something very special. We don't want to be hanging our heads and saying why didn't the studios film him? I want my nieces and nephews, I want my own future children to understand and respect this great performer. I hope that someone close to Mr. Crawford sees this and tells him that he needs to get back on stage as the Phantom. He needs to return to New York, London, Los Angeles...then some. He needs to play the role in Sydney, Toronto, Chicago, Atlanta, Edinburgh. The ticket sales alone will go through the roof if he returns to the role. It will give people who didn't have the opportunity to see him before understand why he MUST play this role on film. And it will give the new executives at Warner Brothers a chance to see his power in action. Finally, it will allow Sir Andrew a chance to remember why he was so wise to offer Michael Crawford this role in the first place. To hear what developed from a vocal studio, through months of rehearsal and five years of eight-shows-a-week, into what is now. A true jewel that deserves the most precious of settings. Please Mr. Crawford, come back...and those of you who haven't seen him---run to the box office. Then everyone will get it and understand what all the fuss is about. |
| Name: Jenna
Daley Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Southern California Time: 2000-06-16 21:08:26 Comments: Hello! I am 15 years old, and I have been a Phantom of the Opera fan for the past 3 years. Although that isn't long compared to some other fans, I can say that those long time Phantom fans agree with me that no Phantom actors are nearly as good as the original: Michael Crawford. Although I commend Andrew Lloyd Webber for writing such intriguing melodies, I have to completely disagree on his current choice for the actor who is supposedly going to play the Phantom in the movie. Michael Crawford is indeed the best Phantom there was and ever will be, and no one will ever surpass the character he created or the number of people he touched when he performed as the Phantom. He has had much training in musical theatre and the Phantom role, and has performed many remarkable concert performances (I have seen him live three times, and all were incredibly amazing). Please, make the right choice and choose Michael Crawford for the Phantom! |
| Name: phantom_valjean Website: Referred by: Signing another Guestbook From: SW Washington Time: 2000-06-15 22:13:44 Comments: i can't believe WB would stupid enough to cast anyone else besides THE phantom (Micheal Crawford of course) as the phantom. I've seen Micheal in his concert movie and Antonio in the ALW birthday celebration and the comparision is almost funny. It's not that Antonio doesn't have a wonderful voice, he does, but it isn't a phantom voice. The ignorant fools and insulant boys! Phantom_Valjean |
| Name: melinda Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: USA Time: 2000-06-15 16:35:01 Comments: Please give us the real Phantom of the Opera first, then if Andrew Lloyd Webber wants to change things let him do it in a sequel. I finally watched part of the Webber birthday bash on PBS (fundraising time) - not the POTO segment which I've seen before (no comment)- but the Evita segment. I was never so surprised in my life. Since I never saw the movie, I always thought Antonio Banderas being Spanish would at least be able to put some hot blooded latin pizzaz into the role. Nothing but a gravely voice and a blank stare - where was the passion? What was he doing - a Robert Stack impression? He didn't even light up the stage. I actually watched the backup singers instead. When they surrounded him at the end of the song I couldn't even find him. He not only blended in with the crowd, he hadn't even bothered changing his blank expression. A blink of the eye now and then would have helped prove he was still alive. Yikes! There's always been no doubt in my mind about Banderas not playing the phantom. After finally seeing him on stage in the Evita segment, I don't even want him to play the role of Raoul. |
| Name: Sue Gleeson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Australia Time: 2000-06-15 10:52:18 Comments: Please, please, there is no one else who can play the PHANTOM, but Michael Crawford, I have seen him LIVE five times here in Australia. The first time was with the Andrew Lloyd Webber Show in 1992. What on earth is Lloyd Webber thinking of?? If Ben Elton is helping re-write the script then is it to be a comedy???? In that case it will be a comedy of errors, a real joke, with a comedy type script and NO Michael Crawford, who on earth would want to see it??? In anycase surely there is a video around which could be released as with "CATS" and "BARNHAM" I wouldn't have a doubt that a video could be released onto the World Market - The Original Phantom Of The Opera - London Production - surely that solves all the problems...Why bother to make a movie in the first place?????????? |
| Name: Lindsey Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Colorado Time: 2000-06-15 04:33:39 Comments: Michael Crawford MUST be cast as the Phantom in the movie version. He originated the role (and turned it into a star-making turn) and deserves to play the part in the film. There is no alternative. If a Hollywood "name" is cast instead, not only will the theatre community be outraged and boycott the film, it will tarnish the fantastic character which is the Phantom to those who have not seen the musical live. I personally believe it would be a tragedy and an extremely bad decision if Michael Crawford is not given the chance to play the character he is most identified with and share his amazing talent with the movie-going audience. |
| Name: Dave Lechtenberg Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Milw., WI Time: 2000-06-15 00:52:36 Comments: Warner Bros. would be a fool if Michael Crawford was not cast as the 'Phantom'! I have personally seen his performance, and to say anything short of AWESOME would be denying him due credit. |
| Name: Sakari Kaulaote Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Finland Time: 2000-06-14 12:22:18 Comments: This guy rocks, The Music Of The Night is brilliant. |
| Name: Rose Willow Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Knoxville, Tennessee Time: 2000-06-13 22:02:55 Comments: I am all for this campain. I wish you luck and hope it goes well. If a boycott is in order, then I will participate. |
| Name: Dave Bupp Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Tampa, Florida Time: 2000-06-13 14:04:08 Comments: I hope that Michael will get the part in the movie because he was the original Phantom and he made the Phantom who it is to this day. |
| Name: Julie Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Montana Time: 2000-06-13 04:19:29 Comments: I'm really glad that this page is dedicated to getting Michael Crawford into the role that only he could do justice too. I think that if they just absolutely couldn't get M. Crawford then they should atleast get someone who performs Phantom on Broadway, and not some hollywood star who wouldn't be able to really portray the agonizing story of Phantom of the Opera. I think it's really too bad they have to make changes to the play and write a script and make it into a movie like that. I think the way they recorded Cats is just marvelous, and if they could do something like that with Phantom (if Michael Crawford was playing Phantom it would be even better) then they could truely show audiences just how great the play is! I think it would be a much bigger success if they casted Michael Crawford as the Phantom, sure a big Hollywood name might bring more business in the first few weeks of the show, but if they had a Broadway Star like Michael Crawford, then Phantom fans all over the world (there are millions of people) would flock to the theatres over and over to watch this wonderful masterpiece! I'm sure people would see it more than once with Michael Crawford performing, and I certainly know that me, and several phantom friends of mine would buy it for sure when it came out on video. It is my opinion that Michael Crawford would lead the Phantom movie to the success that it is capable of, and I think that if they recorded it as they recorded Cats, the outcome would be even more sucessful. Either way, Michael Crawford or another Phantom veteren if he is not able to play it, should be casted as Phantom, because only the people who have actually lived the role on stage can do it justice, and show the world the agony of loving someone and never having that love requitted. Michael Crawford is the man! Sincerly, Julie Starr |
| Name: Snow
Baker Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 2000-06-12 22:50:43 Comments: Dear People, How can you mess with perfection! No one has the Class and Eloquence that this man possesses. For once let a movie studio cast a musical correctly and they might reap the rewards. Forget Big named studio actors cast for once on talent and class. Michael Crawford is a God given talent please let us flock to see him create the performance of a Lifetime...!!!!! |
| Name: daz Website: The Pantomime Goose Referred by: From a Friend From: Australia Time: 2000-06-12 22:12:57 Comments: My very good friend mailed me to let me know what is going on. I am more than happy to support this worthy campaign; I have seen Micheal in concert and his charm, grace, charisma, humour and VOICE (not to mention the fact that he IS the Phantom) make him the ideal, and only, choice. Movies are made for the people. So if we the people demand loudly enough, we shall be heard. Solidarity Brothers. And Sisters. :-) |
| Name: Deb Peterson Website: Referred by: AOL From: MN Time: 2000-06-12 20:54:14 Comments: In the POTO story what is it about the phantom that mesmerizes Christine in the first place?--his VOICE! What does Michael Crawford have that no one else can come close to?--his VOICE! Since the phantom's face is covered, what does this actor need in order to reach the audience?--his VOICE! Listen up ALW and WB, you must realize that it's the VOICE that will make or break this movie. Michael Crawford has THE VOICE!! He IS the phantom and no substitute for the real thing will be acceptable. |
| Name: Christine
Damerell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Nanuet, NY USA Time: 2000-06-12 17:39:29 Comments: I've logged in before, but I've had another thought since then. The Phantom is supposed to be a father figure to Christine, right? If Antonio plays the Phantom, what are they going to do, have Brittany Spears as Christine, and Ricky Martin as Raoul? Give me a break! Let Michael play the Phantom, let Antonio play Raoul, and it won't matter who plays Christine as long as "she has the voice." |
| Name: Leah
Evans Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: CO Time: 2000-06-12 04:07:45 Comments: No one could take Michales place. He is truly extodinary! |
| Name: Joanne Daley Website: Referred by: AOL From: Illinois Time: 2000-06-12 03:47:35 Comments: Phantom of the Opera is a great musical and can be preserved as a classic on film with Michael Crawford starring as the phantom. Antonio Banderas, a Hollywood name can fill the role of Raoul since he can sing as he did in Evita - not a very good voice but his looks will see him through. Why put Antonio in the phantom's hideous makeup and mask when he can't sing - we won't see his good looks but only hear his terrible voice. And if you dub in his voice, why bother to put him in the role??? Hollywood names don't always guarantee a blockbuster. People who didn't see the Phantom in the theatre will want to see it for the price of a movie ticket - don't disappoint them. |
| Name: David
Hill Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Boyds, MD Time: 2000-06-12 03:39:45 Comments: I can't believe you would consider casting anyone but Crawford in the lead role. |
| Name: Priscilla Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Texas Time: 2000-06-12 02:45:15 Comments: I find it very hard to believe that Andrew Lloyd Webber is in his right mind, if he plans for Antonio Banderas to try to wear Michael Crawford's shoes----and mask----as the phantom. Haven't the powers that be in the movie industry had enough experience with failure to recognize another one coming along? This is not your ordinary Hollywood project that can be done with ordinary Hollywood actors---only the original TALENT--the ORIGINATOR---will do! |
| Name: Samantha
Fletcher Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: lafayette, indina Time: 2000-06-12 02:29:24 Comments: I would just like to say that I am one of the biggest fans of The Phantom of the Opera, and when Andrew Lloyd Webber does the movie like he did for Cats and Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, I hope he has Michael Crawford play the part of Erik because let's face it people, HE IS THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA!!! And I also know that the music of the night will live on forever. |
| Name: Bonnie
J. Manley Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mantua, Ohio Time: 2000-06-11 19:37:48 Comments: Antonio has done some fine work, but this is not a role for him. There is only one person who can possibly do the role justice, Michael Crawford. Mr. Crawford would immortalize this movie for Warner Brothers. |
| Name: Mr.
Thomas Connor/jhcebular Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Fairless Hills, Pa. Time: 2000-06-11 18:44:57 Comments: Hi, I'm having my friend Joyce do this for me as I'm a guest in her home. I'm a big fan of Mr. Michael Crawfords Music. Joyce told me what was going on. I asked her to write to you my thoughts, Mr. Crawford's music has such range, power and emotions, there is no one better or finer to do the role of the phantom than Mr Crawford. It would be such an injustice to the role, the music, the performer, and the novelle. If Mr. Webber puts anyone other than Mr. Crawford in the role, Mr. Crawford has made the role exciting, emotional, not only with his body language on the stage, but also his range of musical prowress, is far superior to any other performer Mr. Webber chooses to do the role. If Mr. Webber want A.B., let him do the role of the viscount, and give Mr Crawford the role he deserves, and has done so eloquently on the London, Broadway, and LA. Stages to standing ovations, and still does with his concerts world wide. |
| Name: William
Beaudin Website: Referred by: Signing another Guestbook From: Montreal, Canada Time: 2000-06-10 11:41:17 Comments: Hi to all. I ve been 'enchanted" by the Phantom when I was 11.I think that you (WarnerBros.) should get both Michael Crawford AND Sarah Brightman together for this production. Why not put the big money issues on the side for once and come up with a masterpiece? TK William sonotech@colba.net |
| Name: Melissa
Bashardoust Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Los Angeles Time: 2000-06-10 01:09:53 Comments: To whom it may concern, songs are made of three elements: Music, lyrics, and voice. The Phantom of the Opera has the most beautiful music, lyrics, and story I have ever heard. The wonderful music and lyrics would be NOTHING without a wonderful voice to sing them. In my humble opinion, Warner Brothers and Andrew Lloyd Webber are going to DESTROY this beautiful piece of work by casting a Hollywood "pretty-boy." The only man who can really bring POTO to its full potential is MICHAEL CRAWFORD! Give him the role...please. His voice is too beautiful to put to waste. Let him relive the role of the Phantom. He really does deserve it. Pretty, pretty please? |
| Name: Libby
Edwards Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Nashville, NC Time: 2000-06-09 18:53:44 Comments: Please oh please oh please don't be stupid!!! It is obvious from "Evita" that Antonio banderas is totally wrong for the role of the Phantom! Only Michael Crawford can give the role to the public the way Gaston leroux intended! Would you have put anyone else but Barbra Streisand in the role of "Funny Girl"? Please don't make this huge mistake! |
| Name: Jackie
Attwood Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Encino, CA Time: 2000-06-09 18:12:07 Comments: Now wait a minute. Would someone please explain to me what has happened? I saw Michael Crawford in Los Angeles in 1990 and from what I understood he was going to film the movie. What did he do? I am very unhappy with this news. This is really a shame. I suppose I should say thank you to end this. I would have thought a movement like this would not have been necessary, it certainly looks as if you have done quite a large amount of work. Did anyone at Warner Brothers see the man in the play? If they had they certainly would not be propagating the use of John Travolta or Antonio Banderas for a minute. Jackie S. Attwood, Encino, California |
| Name: Christine Damerell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Nanuet, NY Time: 2000-06-09 00:04:43 Comments: I was given my name because my mother and both of my grandmothers loved the Lon Chaney movie. I never liked my name until the first time I heard Michael calling for his "Christine." Now I can't imagine being called anything else. Antonio Bandaras "doesn't have the voice" for the role of the Phantom! Michael is the only person capable of giving the Phantom his soul. If Michael won't be in it, I won't go see it. Let Antonio play Raul, if he wants to be in the movie so badly. I'd believe him as Raul, but not as the Phantom! |
| Name: Eva
Jeanette Iversen Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Norway Time: 2000-06-08 10:28:00 Comments: "The phantom will never die" |
| Name: lisa garwood Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: ohio Time: 2000-06-08 05:45:21 Comments: i wont watch the movie unless micheal is the phantom!!!! |
| Name: Seza Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Toronto Time: 2000-06-08 01:47:49 Comments: I never got the chance to see the actual play of the Phantom, but heard the CD and it is amazing. I really hope there will be a modern movie on it. |
| Name: joyce
cebular Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Clearfield,pa. Time: 2000-06-07 23:46:18 Comments: Hi gang, my family and my friends who enjoy quality Broadway shows, would also enjoy the same High quality, in our movies, and that also includes, Phantom of the OPERA MOVIE. IF they are going to do it, let's do it right from the start, no messing around, with miscasting, music, or scenery. the novelle, was and is a classic masterpiece, and should be treated as such, and not as a so so, movie. We all expect to be treated to the best, and highest quality, and artistic integrity, that both W.B. and ALW CAN GIVE. If ALW, really cares about what people think of him and the many high quality plays he has produced in the past, he needs to and think the same, about the movie, as well or he will be bottomed out and not be praised for his work, and what a blow to his ego. the Cebular, Beightol, and Dunkel Families. |
| Name: Marie Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: California Time: 2000-06-07 20:40:26 Comments: I've had some people both in cyber-space and the real world question my desire to see Mr. Crawford in a film version of POTO. Some question why I say I won't waste my money on the touring companies again, or on the current casts in the original theaters. Back in 1988, 89 when everyone was raving about the show, I couldn't understand why it was such a big deal. My cinema history class had featured the Lon Chaney version, and I couldn't concieve of how it could be made into a stage musical. Of course with Mr. Crawford in it, tickets were nearly impossible to get, unless one had a lot of income (scalper prices in the hundreds and thousands of dollars). My family wasn't able to secure tickets until after he left the show, and we saw the next leading actor, a gentleman who had performed in theater for years with a national reputation for his film and television work. Well, the show was lovely to see, effects were very interesting, but I still didn't understand why people were camping out all night to get tickets, and didn't comprehend the emotional whallop that some co-workers had described (they had been lucky enough to see Mr. Crawford). My viewing of POTO was been there, done that. All that changed about three months later. Rumors started circulating that Crawford the Great would be returning to the role. I immediately bought a pair of tickets for the time I guestimated he'd be back. Oh my gosh, I can't even begin to describe how thunderstruck I was at the difference between a good actor and a brilliant actor. He blew all my notions and misgivings out of the water. I have never before or since seen any performer take emotional choices and risks to the level that Mr. Crawford did. Even the amount of characterization that he put in his voice and movement was astounding. His enterance in the dressing room, where all you hear is his voice---the hair on my neck was standing on end and I had goosebumps ---oh my, I'd never had that reaction to any singer or actor before (not even my all time fave, Paul McCartney!). I was fortunate enough to see Mr. Crawford perform three times, and it seemed that when he was in the leading role, it raised the bar for the rest of the cast, and they all tried their hardest to match his level of talent; in a way the cast was like a beautiful velvet jewel box made to set off the ultimate diamond to perfection. So how does my point of view change, to never wanting to see the show again? I decided Phantom was my favorite musical ever, and after the original cast (with the exception of Mr. Crawford) went away after four years and moved north (with the original sets, costumes and supporting cast along with Mr. Crawford's replacement), I took a chance on the touring company that came back into our metropolitan area (population 13 million). My best friend went with me, and she had seen the show six times herself with the original production values. At the theater the road company reminded me of a CLO. Within the middle of the first act, I wanted my money back, it was the worst "Broadway level" theater I'd ever seen. To start with, the actor who "played" the Phantom came up with one of the poorest characterizations I'd ever seen...he did a pale imitation of Mr. Crawford when it suited him (mostly during MOTN), and in his remaining scenes, played the role as a combination Jack-in-the-Box/schitzoid-paranoid/ psychotic. There was none of the grace, none of the sensuality, none of the power that Mr. Crawford had brought to the role. In the denounment, which should have been heartbreaking, there was only the relief that the gosh-darn thing was finally over. During the interval, we were in the lobby as others were complaining to someone whom I assumed was with the theater and he responded to the complaint that "well *** *******'s portrayal is very different, but it's still a valid portrayal." Valid??? To me that calls up ideas of just barely passing snuff (all right, you've got a C-average, but we'll let you into the state university anyway, because we want your parent's money). The young lady who played Christine was beautiful of face, but that was all. Her timing was off, her dancing was not so graceful (she was wearing practice slippers instead of pointe shoes...if she can't fulfill the original requirements of the role, why is she onstage???), and worst of all, her singing was atrocious. (i.e. I have been in and out of the business since the '60s, with many years spent in singing |
| Name: Nicole Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: US Time: 2000-06-07 19:16:06 Comments: I would personally love a Phantom movie, but only keeping with the true essence of the play will do. In other words, we do not need a Hollywood star. Michael Crawford is the Phantom, no one else will do. |
| Name: Robert
Edmunds Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: South Wales, UK Time: 2000-06-07 13:29:57 Comments: I feel that, considering Michael Crawfords extensive experience in a wide range of musicals, Barnum, EFX, and most notably Phantom, he certainly has more experience than Antonio Banderas to play the Phantom in the movie, and he can speak English too. I definitely can't imagine Antonio Banderas singing Music of the Night with the same passion and emotion. Hope this helps. Good luck! ROBERT EDMUNDS |
| Name: Rosie Website: The Damian Wilson Official Homepage Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: The Netherlands Time: 2000-06-06 13:36:39 Comments: I don't object to Antonio's accent, I object to his acting ability. The part was promised to Michael and he should be the one who gets to play it. |
| Name: Milan
Vincent van Weelden Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: the Netherlands Time: 2000-06-06 12:42:23 Comments: I hope Michael Crawford is going to play the role of Phantom in the Andrew Lloyd Webber-movie. A Phantom who has a spanish accent isn't a Phantom, but a Don Juan with a mask on his face.... Michael Crawford forever!! |
| Name: Kate
Brown Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Kentucky Time: 2000-06-06 04:21:18 Comments: He has to be the Phantom, I mean, there is no choice in the matter. M.C. IS the Phantom. |
| Name: Barbara A
Merville Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Ellwood City, PA Time: 2000-06-05 03:18:59 Comments: I support all efforts to have "The Phantom" memorialized on film for us to enjoy over and over...but only with Michael Crawford!!!!! |
| Name: Susan Boerman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Massachusetts Time: 2000-06-05 02:52:42 Comments: The first time I saw "Phantom" was in 1994 and I loved it. Then I bought the original cast recording and discovered Michael Crawford. I am now a huge fan of his. The one thing I have regretted was not seeing him play the phantom on stage. When I heard that a movie was to be made, I was so excited that I would finally see Michael play the phantom. I was very disappointed to hear that Antonio Banderas(or anyone else for that matter) was in the running to play the phantom. No one but Michael can bring the range of emotion to that character. Michael Crawford IS the phantom and if he has any interest in playing in the movie, I think the studio should have him as their first(and perhaps only) choice. I hope the powers that be who read and hear our pleas for Michael take us all seriously and give the public what they want and that is MICHAEL! |
| Name: joyce
cebular Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: clearfield, pa. Time: 2000-06-04 21:31:12 Comments: I'VE signed this guestbook before, and i'll do so until the right thing is done. I applaud all of you with your valiant efforts. keep up the good work. i've also done letter writing campagin, sent mail to the really useful co. in u.k., also posted a message on sonicnet.com, and i'll send a message to the theatre critic at 2 phila.newspapers. GOD BLESS ALL OF YOU. |
| Name: Cassie Gornowicz Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Wisconsin Time: 2000-06-03 18:11:56 Comments: I think that if any other man was to play The Phantom it would ruin the whole movie. Michael Crawford makes The Phantom so real and life-like. He made the role of The Phantom famous. |
| Name: Laurie Weston Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: USA Time: 2000-06-03 05:55:12 Comments: How can anyone else possibly hope to be accepted as "THE PHANTOM?" There is no other voice in the entire world that is so MOVING and ANGELIC! It was Michael Crawford who infused the Phantom with a soul. He was the one to give the opera ghost the power to reach into our hearts. Anyone else would truly be a ghost, a mere shadow of Michael Crawford’s Phantom. What I say to the "power that be" is, be true to the fans. When in all the history of film has the public made petition about the making of a film? Doesn’t that speak to you? On this we care tremendously! Think of us! Make history by listening and acting in accord with what your public desires. We will repay your loyalty. |
| Name: Nils
Christian Biseth Pedersen Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Tønsberg, Norway Time: 2000-06-01 23:51:45 Comments: The Phantom of The Opera is one of the best musical ever!! |
| Name: Dominique
Rhoades Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Dunstable, Bedfordshire Time: 2000-06-01 22:20:22 Comments: I actually found out about this monstrosity from a leaflet I picked up when I recently saw Michael in concert (Brighton, 2000) where Michael was magnificent! I am I think, probably one of the youngest Michael Crawford fans at the age of 16, and as so I have never known anyone else to play Phantom. I was at the time too young to have had the pleasure of seeing one of the grestest performers of all time on stage in his finest performance and would dearly love to see him in the movie. Phantom was and is one of the greatest musicals to ever grace the stage and it would not have been the same without Michael! He successfully lead various different casts of Phantom all over the world for ten years and I think it absolutely appauling that anyone would even consider making the film without him! Clearly this is what all the fans want and believe me, no Hollywood hotshot young actor will ever do it justice! If the reason you want a Hollywood actor to play Phantom is to get someone "younger" or "better known" or even "sexier" - I dont know that might be why (stupidly and blindly) I hear rumours of Antonio Banderas! Then there is noone with more talen, more fan support or class, style, taste, brilliance and sheer downright godliness than he! Oh yeah and if you hadn't noticed that fact that the man is damn sexy and a living legend, the people everywhere want Michael, only a fool would put money into a film this great and then cast a no brain, no talent leading man! |
| Name: Garrett
Gilchrist Website: MEUHnet Referred by: From a Friend From: Monroe, CT/Carlsbad, CA Time: 2000-05-31 21:46:36 Comments: As a young screenwriter and director of several features on video, I follow what goes on in Hollywood very carefully. I have, like many movie watchers, been waiting for this film for a long time, and waiting for the great Michael Crawford. The movie musical is said to be dead, which is why movies like The Fantasticks gather dust on studio shelves rather than getting a proper release. Young filmmakers, however, know better, and break that rule year after year with great success. Frank Oz, Trey Parker, Brian De Palma and many others cemented their careers with musicals. "Phantom" with the original cast would be huge in every way that recast-with-stars efforts like "Evita" haven't been. Money in the bank, Warners. We're still waiting. |
| Name: Amanda L.
Lockwood Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 2000-05-31 21:29:43 Comments: I personally have never seen Michael Crawford play the Phantom, yet it is still one of my dreams. The Phantom was the first Broadway play I ever saw and is my favorite to this day. When news of the movie broke and mentioned that Antonio would possibly play the part my husband and I both said that it would not be much of a movie without Michael Crawford playing the part. Futhermore, I thought Andrew Lloyd Webber was not going to agree to the movie being made without Michael Crawford as the Phantom. I personally will not go see it without Michael Crawford as the Phantom and my opinion is shared with most of my close friends and relatives. Sincerely, Amanda L. Lockwood |
| Name: Dr. Jack C.
Scott Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Cresson Texas Time: 2000-05-31 20:18:45 Comments: Put Michael Crawford in the role, the only rational and practical path, he is the Phantom, the greatest musical I have seen. |
| Name: Barb
Rice Website: Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button From: Pennsylvania Time: 2000-05-31 14:52:20 Comments: I've signed this guestbook before, but I'll sign as many times as I can to see that Michael gets the movie role. He's the only one who can and should do this movie. |
| Name: Zhan Stoltz Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: South Africa Time: 2000-05-31 13:20:44 Comments: I believe it would be a very big impact if Michael Crawford is cast as the Phantom, as he made the character come alive and is a legend in his own stride. I have heard many versions of Phantom of the Opera performed by many, but Michael Crawford sings it the BEST. It would be a very hard act to follow. I lend you all by support for this cause! |
| Name: Bill Thon Website: Maximum Technology Solutions Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Granada Hills, CA Time: 2000-05-31 01:10:49 Comments: Please have Michael Crawford play the phantom. And I just went to England and saw Phantom there and the entire cast was fantastic. I really loved it and hope the cast stays english. Keep the movie filled with a cast of stage performers and leave all thebig movie stars OUT. In fact I heard a rumor that John Travolta would be in Phantom. If that happens I would not go to see it, and would never buy it when it comes out on DVD. If Michael Crawford or the present phantom playing in London is in the film - I will go and see it severeal times, buy the DVD when it comes out and Buy more DVD's as gifts. That is a promise. I love this Musical almost as much as Puccini. Best wishes, Bill Thon |
| Name: Paul Mitchell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: South Florida Time: 2000-05-29 14:09:07 Comments: Far too many times, in my opinion, have we, the theatre audience, had to endure film remakes of musicals that may include many of the original cast, but not the principles. While there may be a contract snag from time to time that prevents the performer who originated the role form reprising it on screen, unfortunately, it seems far too often the decision to cast someone other than the incumbent is made by a person who does not appreciate the importance to the live-theatre crowd of having the original performances preserved. Remember, there is always time to produce a remake later on, if it’s deemed necessary to do so. Hopefully, the producers will seize the moment and give us Mr. Crawford while the opportunity exists. |
| Name: Chele
Tourney Website: CheleMarie's Complete Waste of Time Referred by: Yahoo! From: Greencastle, PA USA Time: 2000-05-28 06:28:32 Comments: How can anyone in their right mind imagine the Phantom NOT being Michael Crawford??? I have seen the show on Broadway with a different actor, but I still much prefer my original London cast recording. I would go see a film version starring Michael about a dozen times and be the first person in line to buy it on video. Come on Warner Brothers, wake up! Do the right thing and hire the real Phantom, please! |
| Name: Rosemary
Baxter Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 2000-05-28 06:11:02 Comments: I sincerely hope you succeed with the campaign to have Michael Crawford portray the Phantom. Why Webber would even consider Banderas is beyond me. What a joke that would be. Keep up the good work. |
| Name: gary gersin Website: wheres dale kristien Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button From: mentor ohio Time: 2000-05-28 02:14:40 Comments: bring in dale kristien |
| Name: Claudia Wagner Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Munich, Germany Time: 2000-05-27 23:24:43 Comments: Here’s my vote for Michael Crawford starring as Phantom in the upcoming movie version of Phantom of the Opera. Ever since I’ve seen MC in the original West End production of POTO I’m a big fan of the man and the voice. Unfortunately you don’t see much of him here in Germany, but at least I’ve got the CDs and videotapes. It would be marvelous to see him do the Phantom again ( and again and again and ...) |
| Name: John Huston Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Atlanta Time: 2000-05-27 14:31:57 Comments: Please! Antonio Bandaras? Only M. Crawford can be the Phantom on film! |
| Name: Bonnie
Fredericy Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mantua, Ohio Time: 2000-05-27 04:40:03 Comments: I saw Phantom for the first time and I was mesmerized. I plan on seeing it as many times as possible before I die. I have never experienced anything so powerful and moving. I love Erik, I would take him just as he is, his internal being is dynamic. I want to find out as much as possible. I am a devoted fan, help me, guide me, show me the way. |
| Name: russell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: usa Time: 2000-05-26 16:12:06 Comments: Essentially, any actor playing the role of the "Phantom" after Crawford left, is actually playing the role of "Crawford playing the role of the Phantom". They are following his blueprint. That's why no actor, no matter how excellent their performance, who has played the role since Crawford, has been nominated for an Olivier, a Tony, etc. The only nomination they could win would have to be titled "Best Actor Imitating a Best Actor in a Musical is..." Antonio Banderas tried to sing ALW's music at ALW's Birthday bash. Whether you are trying to mimic Crawford or not, Webber's music is very difficult to sing. Banderas was not only unsuccessful, he wasn't even close. Obviously, he hasn't been taking any singing lessons since "Evita". Entertainment critics, not Phantom fans nor Crawford fans, have labeled Crawford as the only singer/actor who can consistently and successfully "muscle Webber's music to the ground". From all news accounts, Webber is rewriting the music of the Phantom and eliminating the signature song "Music of the Night"- for what reason we can only speculate. Webber didn't pick Crawford to play the phantom and then wrote the music to fit his abilities. He wrote the music and found the actor who had the ability to play to role. |
| Name: Bonnie
J. Manley Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mantua, Oh Time: 2000-05-26 13:45:46 Comments: My sister took me to see "Phantom" for my birthday, and it was the greatest gift I have ever received. No one, and I mean no one, could ever duplicate his power. |
| Name: Karen Healey Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Hartford CT Time: 2000-05-26 09:16:20 Comments: There is only one true Phantom...Michael Crawford!!! |
| Name: Andy
Harris Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Illinois Time: 2000-05-25 22:57:46 Comments: I have been a major fan of the Phantom since I was around the age of 5 or 6. I am now 23 and have a greater admiration for the Phantom. I have read the books by Gaston Lerous and Susan Kay. I have seen most of the movie versions. And if they wish to do a new one, I believe they should put the man who brought the character back to life in the title role. In my opinion he has done the best job in capturing the true character of the Phantom. Thank you. |
| Name: melinda Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: USA Time: 2000-05-25 19:38:04 Comments: Why reward WB, ALW, et al for bad behavior? They're not even casting someone who has played the role of the Phantom before. Would you pay the full price for a ticket to see a Lakers game if NBA MVP Shaq were available to play but not playing. Sure the other guys are talented enough and can play a decent game. But if you want to see a game that is worth more than the price of the ticket. A game you can share memories with others and say "remember that move Shaq put on so and so. It was unbelievable". Wouldn't you save your money to see Shaq and see why he's rated the MVP of the NBA? Wouldn't you save your money to see Crawford and see why he's so highly awarded for this perfomance? People were not waiting outside the theatre for hours to see Andrew Lloyd Webber. If Antonio Banderas had been the originator of the role and had entranced the audiences as Michael Crawford did, then this site would have been named The Antonio Banderas Phantom Movie Page and there would be no problems with the movie casting. Andrew Lloyd is making so many changes to the Phantom that fans won't be able to recognize their favorite musical. Everyone familiar with Crawford's work ethic and respect for his audience would see the injustice of it all. |
| Name: david hatch Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: va. beach, va. Time: 2000-05-25 06:27:26 Comments: i support your view that michael crawford is the only person who should play Phantom in the movie. to me he will always be the Phantom. |
| Name: Shelley Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 2000-05-25 04:11:18 Comments: I am all for Michael staring in "The Phantom". As far as I know, he created that role so he deserves the honor. Michael is an excellent singer and person. Love ya! |
| Name: Johnny Butler Website: Referred by: AOL From: Tujunga, California Time: 2000-05-24 23:13:35 Comments: We were fortunate enough to see Michael Crawford perform at the Ahmanson. After observing Tony Banderas' feeble attempt at "Music of The Night" with Sarah Brightman for ALW's 50th anniversary on PBS, we are convinced that only Michael Crawford can play the role of the phantom. We were embarrased for Banderas. |
| Name: Diane
Dombrowski Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Florida, United States Time: 2000-05-23 18:40:50 Comments: Why isn't there any taped performances of The Phantom starring Michael Crawford??? It is a timeless classic, as well as the ONLY actor to make the Phantom truly famous! |
| Name: Eva Kunesch Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Heilbronn, Germany Time: 2000-05-23 16:30:33 Comments: I'm surfin' in every few weeks and still am afraid that Banderas could be casted because his name is more popular to movie-freaks... Okay, Banderas was a very funny Zorro, but this movie was made to BE funny. Phantom never could be even it could have its moments, but the phantom's character is tragic! He should be played by an older man than Banderas is now just bcose of the wisdom of age, and if you have somebody who is willing to play the role on the silver screen after played ist hundreds of times on stage you would be a fool not to cast this man! Crawford is just perfect! He's the man that knows this character best of all, he's in the right age, his voice is magic and powerful and he plays THAT elegant...!!! So I'm still hoping to see the right man on the screen: Michael Crawford... Rgds, Eva |
| Name: Alison Fox Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Logan, Utah Time: 2000-05-23 05:00:24 Comments: I think Michael Crawford should definently play the phantom in the movie version. He is the original phantom and he did such a wonderful job that he deserves to be cast as the phantom in the movie. He is the only one to do the job! I also believe Sarah Brightman should be cast as Christine in the movie. |
| Name: Stephanie
Hoffman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 2000-05-22 22:54:11 Comments: This muscal has been my all time favorite.To hear Michael Crawford sing on the cd's is just extrodinary.It's so wrong to have Antonio Bandaras to be the phantom.I've always wanted to see Michael Crawford play the phantom.This would be my only chance through this movie. But I guess that won't happen as long as Warner Bros. keeps Bandaras.That's why it should be Crawford or no movie at all!!!!! |
| Name: Jamie Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: sc Time: 2000-05-22 04:58:01 Comments: The Phantom of the Opera never comes to my city and I can't travel to any to see it. And I agree that MC is the phantom and makes him great. I would love to see him do it, and if not then it just wouldn't be nearly the same to watch and i thank you for this page to such a wonderful cause. |
| Name: Nancy
Marotta Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Jersey City, New Jersey Time: 2000-05-21 20:28:54 Comments: I saw Michael Crawford in Phantom of the Opera in New York at the Majestic Theater and he was fabulous. The movie definately needs Michael Crawford, without him it wouldn't be much of a movie. |
| Name: Mike
Bindon Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Swindon, UK Time: 2000-05-21 17:32:12 Comments: Michael Crawford is the obvious choice for role of Phantom, and particularly more so than Banderas, who has already had the privilege to star in a Lloyd Webber film. I cannot see how any other actor could even begin to fill the shoes of Crawford. |
| Name: Carla Pollard Website: Referred by: Net Search From: California Time: 2000-05-21 17:21:39 Comments: There's only one Phantom and his name is Crawford. His name is definitely not Banderas. |
| Name: lucy badman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: weston-super-mare Time: 2000-05-21 15:46:38 Comments: I have been a great fan of michael crawford for over 10 years, and have met him in person. If it is only Warner Bros. preventing him from carrying out the role as the phantom, i will totally support your campaign to boycott their work. Without Michael, the phantom just simply does not exist. |
| Name: Gerry Website: gateway Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button From: New Jersey Time: 2000-05-20 21:09:21 Comments: I have not seen the play, but my daughter was taken for a birthday gift by her friend. She still talks about the wonderful presentation. A movie would be wonderful with the original lead. Gerry |
| Name: Heather
Michele Downing Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Murrieta, California Time: 2000-05-20 17:28:33 Comments: I firmly believe that Micheal Crawfoird should play the Phantom. After all, the part was written for him! Who better to play the older man who sings beautifully and lures Christine down to his lair? I hope Warner Brothers will see that the world wants Crawford in the title role! Just as Donny Osmond played Joseph in "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat" movie, and that was a PERFECT choice! Give the people what they want!!! |
| Name: Jacqui Hughes Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: New Zealand Time: 2000-05-20 16:12:24 Comments: A Phantom of the Opera musical movie without the original phantom? You must be joking. It would be like the King & I without Yul Bryner! Michael Crawford absolutely has the prestige required for the role. It would be an insult to movie veiwers & those who have supported the Really Useful group by seeing the live show or purchasing recordings to put some one else in the lead role.If Crawford is not cast I for one will be disapointed. Having Crawford immortilised on celluloid will give those of us who were not fortunate enough to ever see him in the role a once in a life time chance. I have seen the Phantom twice now.Once in Australia & once in New Zealand. Both productions were certainly admirable & the casts talented. Still I walked away from both saying " Wouldn't it have been great to see Michael Crawford, he's the Phantom personified". |
| Name: michael nelsen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: nyc Time: 2000-05-20 04:06:54 Comments: can not believe anyone would want their music sung by anyone but the BEST !! is the GREED FACTOR is strong that one has to settle for the mediocre ? given hollywood's history, i'm afraind we'll see another "mame", leaving us to think...."if only, if only" m.n. |
| Name: Maribel Arzola Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: New York City Time: 2000-05-19 23:20:13 Comments: I am signing the guestbook to support for getting Michael crawford to star in the phantom. |
| Name: Bobby Gonzalez Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Kingsville, Texas Time: 2000-05-19 18:12:59 Comments: I had always rested easy in the fact that no film studio would be stupid enough to cast anyone other than the original and only Phantom, Micheal Crawford as the lead in a full length feature film. However, when I heard rumors of Antonio Banderas starring in the film I became very worried. Don't be stupid Warner Bros., Cast Crawford and just his name alone on the bill will bring in people if that's what they are so worried about. If somehow they consider the integrity of the musical then cast the person with the best vocal ability for the role and whose voice is what has set the standard for the performance of the music. |
| Name: Stephanie
Prince Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Little Rock Air Force Base Time: 2000-05-19 07:00:29 Comments: I cannot even imagine anyone else playing the "Phantom" but Michael. He has made this character so memorable to many people who were lucky enough to see him in the role on Broadway, why not make the movie as memorable? My seven year old daughter loves the soundtrack from the show,and it is Michael whom she speaks of when telling anyone about the show!!!! Stephanie Prince |
| Name: Linda Hanlon Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Wall Township, New Jersey Time: 2000-05-19 02:27:11 Comments: Anyone who has any appreciation for Phantom knows that there is only one person who can play the role and do it justice. That's Michael Crawford. Michael IS the Phantom! To cast anyone else in that role would be a disservice to the play as well as the public. Those of us who were fortunate enough to see Michael in the play know the extent of his talent and how he, literally, turns himself into the character. Those unfortunate people who didn't see him should be given the opportunity to experience this amazing performance through the movie version. It is something they won't soon forget. I saw Michael in the play twice and have attended his concerts in New York and New Jersey. Each time he sings his songs from Phantom the audience just goes wild. There is only one Michael Crawford and only one person who can play the Phantom. They are one and the same! |
| Name: Edgar Contreras Website: Referred by: Clicked on our Banner Advertisement From: El Paso,tx Time: 2000-05-19 01:59:23 Comments: H aving no respect for Antonio Banderas I would never rush to the theater to see phantom of the opera If he were staring in it.I would truly like to see Micheal Crawford seeing that he is the original, and the fact that this would allow anyone who missed him on broadway to see him. I think that this would a much better casting choice, and think that anyone else would be a great mistake and the greatest mistake of all would be Antonio Banderas! |
| Name: John T. Ferraina Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Philadelphia PA Time: 2000-05-19 00:38:32 Comments: I have seen Phantom 3 times the first time with Michael Crawford, everytime after that It just wasn't the same. The show is great but he is the best. I heard about the movie, I can't see anyone but him. |
| Name: Rachel Garrison Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Pensacola, FL Time: 2000-05-18 17:28:35 Comments: This site is extremly informative. And as a true Phantom fan, I hope that everyone sees that Michael rightfully deserves the part that only he can portray. The silver screen and Broadway are alike in the aspect that they both need good actors to truely create the role. And only Michael can create Erik as he does. Hope to see you all at the opening of the movie as Michael as the lead. |
| Name: Linda Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Pittsburgh Time: 2000-05-18 01:20:47 Comments: How many times is Andrew Lloyd-Webber going to "re-write" the Phantom script before he realizes that he got it right the first time? He also "got" the Phantom right the first time, Michael Crawford, who won the Tony and every other award available for his performance |
| Name: Stefano
Rommel Website: Referred by: htmlGEAR From: Milan, Italy Time: 2000-05-17 16:52:47 Comments: It's impossible that the Phantom could be that bad actor Banderas!!! |
| Name: Sylvia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Hong Kong Time: 2000-05-17 08:24:33 Comments: You have me as your Hong Kong respresentative! :) |
| Name: Kai Hsieh Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Los Angeles Time: 2000-05-17 06:54:47 Comments: Michael Crawford is a great performer. If he is willing to play the role, and the fans want him to play the role, why would WB cast anyone else to play the role??! This is just nuts. I guess WB really wanna piss people off these days. |
| Name: Diane Nilsen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Rochester, New York Time: 2000-05-17 01:55:43 Comments: Michael Crawford is the Phantom. I had the pleasure of seeing him in New York. This show is not the same without him. He brings tears to my eyes everytime I listen to his music or watch a video of him singing the Phantom music. |
| Name: The Michael Crawford
Phantom Movie Campaign Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 2000-05-17 01:46:13 Comments: Welcome to Guestbook 38. We thank all who come here and sign in support for the original Tony Award-winning Phantom, Michael Crawford, to star in the film version of the stage play "The Phantom of the Opera." TMCPMC |