Total: 2530 Guests

 

Total: 100 guests
Name: Jane fairlee
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: PA
Time: 1999-08-29 14:30:03
Comments: I think Donny Osmond said what a lot of people think but don't have the guts to say, although you can bet when the movie comes out they'll have the knives sharpened. I've talked to a lot of people on this subject and the general reaction even from industry insiders is "You're right but it's Hollywood. What can you expect. They are aiming at a bunch of teenagers they think won't know or care that they are not seeing the best. Feed them hamburger, tell them it's filet mignon and they won't know the difference or care." First of all I think they underestimate their teen audience. Secondly, if that is who they are aiming at with this movie they ARE fools. The problem WB and ALW have that they don't seem to grasp is that millions of people have seen Phantom or have the original cast album. They have something to compare the movie to. That triples the risk factor although Hollywood doesn't seem to have figured that out yet. Maybe they should take a good look at the AVengers, which was a sophisticated TV show for adults who knew that movie was a bad rip-off and avoided it like the plague. Phantom, unlike Evita, has attained almost cult status with its fans who are going to be very, very vocal on this movie if it isn't as good or better than the show. If this movie is made with someone other than Michael Crawford, and it fails (for ANY reason) the casting WILL get the blame. I have never seen another show that was so dependent on an actor as that one. My reactions have ranged anywhere from having to be dragged from the theatre because I didn't want it to be over, to rooting for Raoul, to wanting to leave at intermission to go shopping. And those reactions were totally due to an actor who is on stage less than a fourth of the time. That's a scary burden to place on an actor. If this movie fails, nobody gets to walk away from it and shrug it off, Not Andrew Lloyd Webber who will be blamed for destroying his masterpiece, Not Warner Bros. who will be blamed for ignoring the fans and not the actor who plays the phantom. If this movie is less than it should be the fans will NEVER forgive or forget.
Name: Mimi Clavir
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Bethel Park, PA
Time: 1999-08-29 07:25:01
Comments: Actually saw your website mentioned in the newspaper (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette). I would never buy tickets to (or rent the video of) a Phantom movie without Michael Crawford in the title role!
Name: Brie
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Washington, D.C.
Time: 1999-08-28 20:56:45
Comments: I've enjoyed your website very much and understand that you are up against those big tough guys in Hollywood, and they'll probably win because money is thicker than their greedy souls. Please add me to the list to BOYCOTT any PHANTOM MOVIE made WITHOUT Mr. Crawford. In fact, I'm really hoping POTO will be coming out in video form instead, and of course starring Michael Crawford. Antonio Banderas would make a perfect Raoul :) He's not really a bad singer, but he's certainly NOT the Phantom. Also, I was really blown away by the video production of CATS, and look forward to the release of JOSEPH. Yeh, I'm a diehard ALW fan, and will still love him, even if lets his beloved Phantom get screwed up :)) For the love of God, Andrew....what are you thinking????? Brianna Luck
Name: Matthew Helm
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Eureka, California, USA
Time: 1999-08-28 20:37:03
Comments: Michael Crawford deserves the role! Cheers to him!
Name: Camille Zhang
Website:
Referred by: Net Search
From: Beijing China
Time: 1999-08-28 18:26:00
Comments: Hi, I had been looking for this album for almost 2 years in Beijing. In may this year, My boyfriend bound it in Japan.You can imagin how happy when I listend to it!I am attracted by the moving story and the sound of angel!!
Name: Judy K.
Website: none
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: K.C.MO
Time: 1999-08-28 11:31:17
Comments: Michael is the man!!! All others are second-choice.
Name: Genie
Website:
Referred by: Net Search
From: Denver
Time: 1999-08-28 09:24:28
Comments: I was searching the Internet for a copy of Phantom of the Opera. Being a new Michael Crawford fan, I didn't know if I could find him starring in the role of Phantom in a VHS movie version. I'm very disappointed there isn't. I would like to express my whole-hearted support of him being cast in a movie -- there could never be a better person! He has been my favorite in the role and I feel there can be no other!
Name: Sarah Croker
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From:
Time: 1999-08-27 22:32:42
Comments: It's never the same when you change the original character. Just like Craig Mclachlan just isn't going to be quite right as the fonz in the musical HAPPY DAYS.
Name: Marie A. Roberge
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Seattle, WA
Time: 1999-08-27 21:26:46
Comments: As someone in Michael's age group who missed the opportunity to see him perform his Phantom role on stage, I would die a happy woman if I were able to see him reprise his role in the movie verison. I know I am not alone in feeling this way. Thank you, powers that be, for making it possible for this role to be recorded for posterity, with the man who created the role that so many try to emulate. Marie Roberge Seattle, WA
Name: Rose McCaffery
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Phila., PA
Time: 1999-08-27 20:16:06
Comments: Attn: Warner Bros. Michael Crawford IS the man we are all expecting to play the part of Erik in the movie version Phantom of the Opera. Without Michael, why ever bother going to see it! Michael has proven to us over and over again that he is the best person for this part. Please make the right decision and give the public what it wants: Michael Crawford
Name: Maurice O. Gauvin, Jr.
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Taunton, Massachusetts
Time: 1999-08-27 20:14:04
Comments: Michael Crowford is the only actor who will be able to do justice to the role of the Phantom on the big screne. He brought the Phantom to life on the stage both in London and New York. Michael is the Phantom!
Name: Richard Barrom
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Memphis,Tn.
Time: 1999-08-27 19:51:22
Comments: I whole heartedly agree that Michael Crawford should be cast as the phantom if A Musical version is made. I have never had the pleasure of seeing him in the play; however, if his performance in the ALW premier collection video is any indication, he is the only logical choice. I am not interested in seeing Antonio Banderas as the Phantom. I hope that Hollywood listens to us. After all, It is the fans who have put them where they are!
Name: Marilynn
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Georgia
Time: 1999-08-27 15:46:22
Comments: Dear Sirs: The movie of Phantom of the Opera is a chance to put on the screen and immortalize the stage program that has become a part of the lives of theatre goers around the world. However, unless the original and best actors are used in the movie, the ones who created the role from within themselves, the movie should not be made as it would be a mockery of the genius of this production. Among the original actors was Michael Crawford as the Phantom who became Erik and gave Erik a heart and soul with whom the audience loved and identified. Michael Crawford possessed Erik in his own heart and soul and gave performances that captured the audience and left them spellbound by the end of the evening. Not only was Michael Crawford's acting superior, but his voice was perfect for the Phantom. It could be tender and it could be powerful but, at all times it reached out and spoke to each and every audience member. Even today, as Michael Crawford performs songs from POTO, he becomes the Phantom even without costumes or scenery and he sings the songs better today than ever before as they are part of him. Please, make a movie that will be a financial and artistic blockbuster by recreating the stage production with Michael Crawford as the Phantom of the Opera. Thank you!
Name: Linda Hagerty
Website: n/a
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Currently reside in Florida
Time: 1999-08-27 07:55:58
Comments: I've listed to the Phantom tape 1,000's of times, and the beauty and power of Brightman and Crawford is wonderful. The photos from the original cast are extraordinary too. I was not lucky enough to see the performance with the original cast, and it would be wonderful to see them reunited in the movie version.
Name: Pat Francis
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: virginia beach va
Time: 1999-08-27 04:02:15
Comments: Crawford is the Phantom.
Name: Jack Leff
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Time: 1999-08-26 17:38:24
Comments: Michael Crawford is the Phantom. Clayton Moore is the Lone Ranger. Antonio Banderas is Zorro. Pray tell how anyone could justify a Phantom with a Spanish or Latin accent in the Paris Opera House. I would prefer the Lone Ranger or Silver instead of Antonio Banderas, who, like the Lone Ranger or Silver, can't sing. The role warrants perfection and Michael Crawford is indeed perfection.
Name: Sandy Bergelson
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: New Jersey
Time: 1999-08-26 07:54:57
Comments: There is only one phantom.....and his name is Michael Crawford.
Name: Meszlényi Gyöngyi
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Hungary
Time: 1999-08-26 01:53:07
Comments: Dear Warner Bros! The Phantom movie can only be successful with Michael Crawford, whose name by now means 'The Phantom'. If You choose another actor You'll ruin the Phantom. I've been waiting to see the musical on TV for so long. Now it would be a great time for You to make this movie - but only with Michael. Best wishes Meszlényi Gyöngyi from Hungary
Name: Sue K
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Pennsylvania
Time: 1999-08-25 18:25:18
Comments: I just finished reading the movie script of what might have been and what I am hoping could still be. The only person who should play the phantom is Michael Crawford!! I never saw him as the phantom but was fortunate to see him in concert in Philadelphia and at Radio City Music Hall. I also saw EFX twice in Las Vegas while he was the star. I hope Warner Bros and Andrew Lloyd Webber come to their collective senses and cast Michael Crawford. I wish you all the best with your campaign and will be visiting this site often. If you stage any more rallys please contact me. I would love to help by showing up. I work for an airline and can travel to anywhere that rally might be held. Also if anyone knows where Michael Crawford is appearing in concert, I would love to see him perform again. Again, I wholeheartedly agree with your campaign!! Keep up the good work and the world will see a truly wonderful performance and movie!!
Name: David Carr
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Leeds U.K.
Time: 1999-08-25 15:12:14
Comments: I have seen Michael when he was Phantom alongside Sarah Brightman in London, and he is the best!!!!!
Name: M. O. Sun
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Indiana University@Bloomington
Time: 1999-08-25 09:11:39
Comments: My god, it would be a travesty were Michael Crawford NOT be cast in the role he created!
Name: Hazel Miller
Website:
Referred by: SimpleNet
From: California,USA
Time: 1999-08-25 00:52:58
Comments: Hello out there in Hollywood, After seeing Michael Crawford perform at cerritos I was Breathless after hearing his performance of Phantom mucic Everyone in the theatre was magically taken back a few years When Michael sang on stage then,if you can believe it he was even better than I had ever heard him before. You can take any actor to play the role but never anyone to sing like Michael it is his soul in that part. I love all of Andrew webber music and it should be on film. We all want to see his musicals over and over again!! Thank you so much, Hazel Miller
Name: Yi-Ching Ong
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From:
Time: 1999-08-24 21:22:03
Comments: The Phantom of the Opera is an exceptional musical, which will make an exceptional movie. However, much of the power, intensity, and beauty of the musical come from Michael Crawford, the original, and in my mind, the only Phantom. Casting Antonio Banderas as the Phantom is a grievous oversight on the part of Warner Brothers. People expect and demand to hear the voice of Michael Crawford as the Phantom. Yi-Ching
Name: Mary Kaminski
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Time: 1999-08-24 18:14:23
Comments: There is no other person who can fill these shoes of the Phantom. I do not want Antonio Banderas to play this part. I saw him on PBS for Andrew Lloyd Weber's 50th birthday, you could not understand a word he was saying. He does not fit the role. I beg that Michael Crawford is the Phantom...
Name: Shirley Kneff
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Veradale, Wa
Time: 1999-08-24 16:13:54
Comments: I understand you are making a movie of Phantom Of The Opera, and are considering starring someone other than Michael Crawford to play the phantom. I am writing to request you PLEASE star Michael Crawford as the Phantom. I would love to see this movie with MICHAEL CRAWFORD. if you do star someone else, I can assure you, you will lose a lot of patrons. My husband and I made a special trip to Las Vegas to see Michael starring in EFX at the MGM Grand a few years ago. If anyone else had been cast in the show we certainly would not have bothered. We love Michael Crawford. His voice is very special. Please cast him in the starring role.
Name: Jens Lemmermann
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Germany
Time: 1999-08-24 07:47:26
Comments: phantom of the opera ist the best musical by alw i´ve ever seen - the romantic, the dramatic. the scene i´d like most is "wishing you were somehow here again" - that melody run though my mind, when i stand at the open grave of my father. michael crawford ist the BEST phantom i´ve heard! he had to give the phantom in the movie! antonio banderas was a good che - but he is NO PHANTOM!
Name: Brianne Woosley
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Pa
Time: 1999-08-24 07:44:30
Comments: I would really like to see Michael play the role of The Phantom in the movie. He really cares about the role and believes in it and I believe him when he plays the Phantom and I will not watch it if Michael is not cast.
Name: A fan of MC continued!
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From:
Time: 1999-08-23 22:21:54
Comments: I thought of something to add- even if they do come to their senses and cast Michael Crawford as the phantom, what about Chritine? Raoul? And all the great supporting roles? I don't believe those parts should be given to non-professional singers either!!!! What about the director, and whether they add/take away/alter the music? It seems to me this film has a very small chance to be well-done, and stay true to the stage version. But Warner Brothers and Andrew sure aren't getting off to a good start, by giving the role that will make or break this film to someone like Banderas! Aghhh!
Name: a fan of MC
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: USA
Time: 1999-08-23 22:16:11
Comments: Even if Banderas does the film, it ends up being a good film, and makes hundreds of millions of dollars (by the way I really doubt this would happen!), I know I am doing the right thing by not going to see it. Because I know what it could have been, starting with the proper casting. Since WB and ALW are ignoring the fans who really love the story, the music, and the wonderfully talented actors who've been in the phantom musicals, I have no problem ignoring their movie. I hope that all of us don't give in, let's show them that true fans DO count!!!! Go Michael Crawford!
Name: JoAnna Sonnenburg
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From:
Time: 1999-08-23 20:54:23
Comments: I have been a loyal fan of Michaels since I first heard him in the Phantom 6 and half years and I personally feel it would ONLY be the Phantom of the Opera if Michael Crawford was in it, especially along with Sarah Brightman. Andrew needs to sit back and remember if it's about the money to remember how much Michael raked in. But if it's about the sheer talent Michael should again pop up in his head. It would be a great cotaastrophe if the movie was made without Micheal Crawford. Michael Crawford is "The Phantom of the Opera". Thank you for your time. JoAnna Sonnenburg Little_20@hotmail.com
Name: Elizabeth
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: USA!
Time: 1999-08-23 20:38:55
Comments: I won't see this movie if the role of Phantom is not given to a professional singer, who is capable of opera. What is the point? The entire story won't be at all believable. And since Michael Crawford was the original phantom, is by FAR the most famous and well-liked of all the phantoms of various shows, it just makes sense he should get the part. You don't need to have seen him in Phantom to know it- you just need to hear him on the Original Cast Recording. He is amazing, and I can't imagine hearing "The Music of the Night" sung by anyone else!!!!!!!!
Name: Mike Bowling
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From:
Time: 1999-08-23 18:56:02
Comments: W.B. -- Elmer Fudd before Antonio.
Name: Jack Leff
Website: N/A
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Time: 1999-08-23 15:33:00
Comments: I agree that Michael Crawford appropriately deserves to recreate his role in the movie as the Phantom because he is the single best entertainer in the world and he developed the role and on the other hand Antonio Banderas SUCKS! With all the discussion relating to the Phantom role, I have not yet read who are projected to play the parts of Christie and Raoul. Michael Crawford was awesome when I saw him in concert in Pittsburgh and I will be seeing Sarah Brightman next month in concert for the first time. I am very pleased with your efforts and looking forward to Michael Crawford as the Phantom.
Name: Donna Thoreson
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Climax, MN
Time: 1999-08-23 09:59:42
Comments: I just wanted to say there is no other Phantom than Michael, He IS the PHANTOM!! Go for it Michael. Your fan, Donna
Name: J.C.
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Time: 1999-08-23 09:29:06
Comments: I have had the opportunity to see "Phantom" in several cities including New York and L.A., and seeing Michael Crawford's performance in New York was the most incredible and memorable, by far...infact it was perfect. No other actors performance has come close. He IS the "Phantom".
Name: Lindsey Ward
Website:
Referred by: Net Search
From: texas
Time: 1999-08-23 08:16:46
Comments: I have heard rumers that Antonio Banderes is going to play the Phantom in the movie. Those in charge of the casting have to know that Antonio is not right for the part! Michael is the ONLY Phantom!
Name: Lynn Bowling
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Byram, MS
Time: 1999-08-23 08:03:09
Comments: I heard the website name on a local radio station that takes sattelite feed from somewhere - they play 1950's to present music, and occasionnally play Michael Crawford. After a song the DJ talked about the ALW birthday celebration and then gave this website address.
Name: Gai McGowan
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Virginia
Time: 1999-08-23 06:06:47
Comments: My mom and I did not see Evita because it was mis-cast. Many movies have been ruined simply because the wrong person was picked to star in it. Please give the role to Michael, it is his creation. I'm sure Anthony is a fine actor, but this simply is not his part.
Name: Jean Jenkins
Website:
Referred by: Net Search
From: San Diego
Time: 1999-08-22 20:53:54
Comments: Our KPBS TV station is airing pledge week specials. Last night I had the pleasure of watching a Michael Crawford special in which he performed selections from "Phantom." I was mesmerized by an exquisite performance. Tonight, the station is airing the special "Birthday Tribute To Andrew Lloyd Webber," in which Antonio Banderas sings with Sarah Brightman. The performance was so weak and laughable that I cannot imagine a producer in his or her right mind who would cast him in the role. He couldn't even sing the word 'phantom,' for pete's sake; it came out 'phamton.' Somehow Crawford MUST recreate the Phantom for the screen!
Name: Troy LaFleur
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Billings, Montana
Time: 1999-08-22 14:53:44
Comments: I have been a fan of the Musical and of the novel for several years. I have seen the musical twice and hope to see it again. I have been looking for a video version for quite some time since I have seen recorded versions of the musical with Crawford/Brightman on a cable channel dedicated to the performing arts. I never imagined a major motion picture but am thrilled by the idea. Especially a version starring Crawford. Now I can see how a movie studio would want to use a mainstream star; but that would be a mistake. Take as evidence Evita with it's Madonna/Banderas combo. The problem was that it didn't stike a cord with audiences. Mostly people went to see Madonna. A Phantom with your run of the mill Motion picture star -- who knows. A Phantom with Micheal Crawford would be something BIG. Big name stars get people into the theater when there is nothing else to drive them. However, occasional dark horses come and blow the typical Hollywood equation out of the water. Take for example the recent Blair Witch Project which should have been a sleeper but instead went on to be a hit It struck a cord and the intitial response motived others to go see it. I believe the same phenomena could occur with a decent making of a Phantom movie. The millions of Phantom fans will be the initial flashpoint. The initial furor will pique the curiosity of your typical filmgoer who is wanting to escape, be dazzled, be moved. Phantom has that capability and filmgoers will recognize this. Sincerely, Troy LaFleur
Name: Virginia Kryl
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: West View, Pa
Time: 1999-08-22 10:42:01
Comments: Any film that is made of Phantom will be a farce if Michael is not the Phantom. I have heard others sing this role and they all leave something to be desired. Michael has the most glorius voice, a voice that is God given. When I heard Antonio Banderas sing one of the Phantoms songs on PBS I nearly cried. It was so bad!! I like Banderas as an actor, but a singer of the caliber that is needed for the role as the phantom he is not. If Michael is not cast as the phantom, I will not see this movie! He is the sexiest and best singer in this role yet. I hope to join him and Rev Schueller in the Holy Land on Christmas Eve where he will sing Silent Night. This will be a real blessing.
Name: Lisa
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Florida
Time: 1999-08-22 09:08:30
Comments: When casting is done for a movie, no one knows for sure whether someone will do the role justice because (duh) the movie hasn't been made yet! Millions have seen Michael Crawford onstage as the phantom, and they should know better than anyone how deserving he is. Even those who have not seen him as phantom, but support him should be listened to. I have not seen crawford as the phantom when he was onstage, but I am positive he would be the best choice. Here is why- I have seen him live in concert, and he does have awesome stage presence, and literally transformed into the phantom when he sang the songs from the musical- with no makeup, costume, backdrops, etc. I have seen several phantoms onstage, and all were good, but none held a candle to Crawford in terms of singing, and emotional depth. I have the Phantom soundtrack so I can definitely attest to that! He has done several films before, so no one can argue his performance wouldn't transform well to film. He is the only reason to watch Hello Dolly!- he's hilarious! I saw a video of him singing Music of the Night with Sarah Brightman, in the EXACT context of the musical (staging, costumes, etc). He was amazing. Finally, he was the orignal, he created the role with no one else to "borrow" from, like subsequent phantoms onstage. I hope Andrew Lloyd Webber and Warner Bros. are taking all these messages from people into serious consideration, because it sounds like a lot of us aren't going to be seeing the movie otherwise!
Name: Richard L. Derringer
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Huntington, CT
Time: 1999-08-22 08:00:09
Comments: I have been waiting for this movie since its original Broadway run. There is no other choice for the role than Michael Crawford. Don't overthink this thing!
Name: Elaine England
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Overland Park, Kansas
Time: 1999-08-21 23:46:23
Comments: As far as I'm concerned, Michael Crawford should be the ONLY candidate for the role of "The Phantom"!! He made the role what it is today. I have seen him in concert twice and he is a marvelous talent.
Name: Chris
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From:
Time: 1999-08-21 14:31:53
Comments: If I said to people- The phantom of the opera is just that- an OPERATIC musical, so singing is of key importance. would you rather see the upcoming musical Phantom film with the original Phantom, a professional singer/actor who has been in films before, and for his portrayal of Phantom has won almost every award imaginable, or with a professional actor with a bigger name, but has never been in any production of phantom onstage, is too young for the role, has an accent that cannot be covered adequately and doesn't fit the role, and is not even a professional singer? Not only that, he is a BAD singer, and has never attempted to sing opera? And someone would pick the latter? Well, I guess those with that opinion deserve what they get. I, for one, won't subject myself to it.
Name: sick of Hollywood
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: USA
Time: 1999-08-21 14:15:56
Comments: Everyone knows that money is compromising quality in this issue of casting in the upcoming Phantom film. I am not accepting this anymore. I hate how so many idealize Hollywood, and simply go to movies because of the big names (often known for looks before talent). I can't understand how people would rather see this film with a "sexy", less qualified star, than see it with the most talented cast availiable. It's so sad, because this film could be such an amazing classic with the right people. The studios aren't concerned with putting out the best product availiable, and the much of the public isn't interested in seeing it.
Name: consider this
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: US
Time: 1999-08-21 11:40:55
Comments: If I hear more people say "Well, if Antonio takes some singing lessons, why not give him a chance", I will, well I don't know what I would do. Do you think a few months of lessons will prove someone capable of succesfully performing a huge scale operatic musical??????? People like Mr. Crawford have spent DECADES of hard work in pursuit of "perfecting" their voices. So to these people that made this comment, we could ALL take lessons and be successfully cutting CDS and performing on Broadway!!!! I could take decades of lessons, and I am sure that while I'd improve, I could never hold a candle to professional singers. Why? Something called RAW TALENT...........
Name: A Phantom Fan
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: MD
Time: 1999-08-21 11:08:40
Comments: While I don't think it is right to say that Crawford is the "only" phantom, I do think he should get the part. There are many phantoms performing onstage in the world- some are not so good, and some are wonderful. It is worth it to see Phantom onstage whether Crawford is there or not- the story, music, the experience overall is amazing. I agree though, that Crawford's interpretation of Phantom is singular and amazing. He is my favorite of all phantoms, and since this is going to be the only ALW version of "Phantom" onscreen, my vote is definitely for Michael!
Name: Karen Marlo
Website: Don't have one
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Stow, Ohio
Time: 1999-08-21 10:21:20
Comments: I finally saw Antonio Banderas's performance on a PBS repeat of ALW's birthday celebration, and there's just no way that he should do the POTO movie instead of Michael. Even if he were able to lose the Spanish (!) accent, he can't change the fact that he is just too young! The Phantom is supposed to be old enough to be Christine's father, so Michael would certainly be more believable in the role. Apart from that, after all the wonderful things I've read about Michael's stage performances of "Phantom," I can't understand why ALW himself would want to see anyone else in the role. Why do the "powers that be" want to mess with perfection? I will not go to the movie if anyone but Michael is the Phantom.
Name: Suzanne
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: USA
Time: 1999-08-21 09:17:49
Comments: The only people I think could support anyone but Michael Crawford (or another professional theatre singer) playing the Phantom in the upcoming movie, are those who are any and all of the following- they have never seen the musical onstage, they haven't read the original novel, they are not theatre fans in general, therefore they don't really care for or appreciate music and voice talents, and they have never HEARD Michael Crawford sing or act. That is the only way I can comprehend it. I don't believe ALW and WB should be catering this movie towards those who are mainly going to see the Phantom because a hollywood name is in it.
Name: Michelle Fredericksen
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Kennewick, WA
Time: 1999-08-21 08:38:25
Comments: No other Phantom except Michael Crawford! Please, do not disgrace the roll with a "Hollywood Hot Shot" whom doesn't have the voice capable of bringing the Phantom to life and cannot even speak the english language without a spanish accent! This is quite disturbing. This decision must be reconsidered. Myself and my family & friends will not spend the money to watch such a horrible representation of The Phantom of the Opera!! Please choose Michael Crawford.
Name: Claire Casey
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Louisiana
Time: 1999-08-21 06:41:50
Comments: I love the Phantom!
Name: Chris Rankin
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Austin, TX
Time: 1999-08-20 22:36:14
Comments: I never got to see Michael Crawford as the Phantom. A friend and I drove from Austin to Los Angeles to see him, but he was sick for the performance we attended. I did get to see Mr. Crawford in the Andrew Lloyd Weber in concert series, and wished I could have seen him in a full production of The Phantom of the Opera. Now, it seems that the only chance I might have of this is if the studio wises up and casts him in the movie.
Name: Katie Ryan
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Abilene,TX
Time: 1999-08-20 18:18:39
Comments: I have followed this campaign for quite sometime and voiced my opinion that Michael Crawford should play this role.I just read the Recent News section of this web site. There I read of Michael's magnanimous offer to dub his voice over that of whomever plays the role. He said that he would be happy just to do that if it were offered him. I must disagree. Yes it is the voice which makes "The Music of the Night" sing to all of our hearts. But it is Michael's creation of this persona that truly bring this character to to life. He gives him life and breath and makes us love, fear and pity him all at once. While having Michael's voice on the movie soundtrack would be wonderful, it isn't enough. Andrew Lloyd Webber and Charles Hart (the lyricist) were absolutely correct when they penned the words for Michael Crawford sing in one of last lines in the musical,"You alone can make my song take flight..." Truer words were never spoken.
Name: MJL
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Pittsburgh, PA
Time: 1999-08-20 15:22:46
Comments: The Phantom of the Opera can only be Michael Crawford. Regardless of his age, if he has a mask on, what difference does it make. The phantom has no age. Please don't make the mistake of not casting Michael Crawford in the role.
Name: Kate Rodgers
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Pittsburgh
Time: 1999-08-20 14:34:14
Comments: Antonio B may be a popular actor and be a good choice for some roles, but this is not one of them! AB has an accent even when he sings - anybody who watched the tribute to Andrew Lloyd Webber can tell you that! And since the Phantom took place in France, not Spain, he would be mis-matched. The best choice is obviously Michael Crawford. He has an incredible passion for this role and watching him really makes you feel like you're part of the performance. It would be incredibly hard to match his talent!
Name: a really upset fan
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Ohio
Time: 1999-08-20 12:20:14
Comments: There are many talented people portraying the Phantom onstage in theatres all over the world. Although it is pretty unanimous that Crawford will always be the most amazing phantom of past and present (and I totally agree!), there are many great singers playing the role now. And the musical itself is wonderful, the story is wonderful, etc. BUT! There will only be ONE screen version of Lloyd Webber's phantom. just one. That is why thousands of us fans are so upset, for those who don't understand. There are so many who have never had the honor of seeing Mr. Crawford perform phantom, and the fact that he is able, willing, and has been WAITING to do it makes this situation a travesty! The fact that the role is being given to someone who is not even a professional singer is, well, I can't find words. If the studio were to cast another musical star who has performed Phantom onstage I would not be so upset, but it is obvious they don't want to hire ANY previous or current phantom, otherwise they would have casted Crawford, hands down. Because he makes most box office sense, and is the most well-known of all Phantoms.
Name: Mary Ellen Connolly
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Pittsburgh
Time: 1999-08-20 10:11:13
Comments: Love to see him in the move. Never got to see him in the stage version, but have all his tapes and have heard him in concert. He would definitely be a theatre draw.
Name: Beth
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Pittsburgh,PA
Time: 1999-08-20 09:14:57
Comments: Nice page... keep up the good work!
Name: J.D. Mang
Website: na
Referred by: AOL
From: Pittsburgh, Pa.
Time: 1999-08-20 07:28:58
Comments: It is about time we see this wonderful story in a movie version. And who else but Michael could star? No one else..
Name: J.D. Mang
Website:
Referred by: AOL
From: Pittsburgh, Pa.
Time: 1999-08-20 07:26:19
Comments: There really isn't anyone else to star in this role. I have seen the Phantom three times now and I never tire of it. Time now to share this great story with everyone.
Name: Joseph A Saccoman
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Northern New Jersey
Time: 1999-08-20 04:21:43
Comments: I have seen Phantom 8 times and three times with Michael Crawford. His expressions and talented voice should be the voice used to portray the Phantom in the upcoming film.
Name: Sara
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Austin, TX
Time: 1999-08-20 00:50:09
Comments: I must agree with everyone else. Michael Crawford is the Phantom in too many hearts and minds to be put aside in the pursuit of greed. Please listen to this public outcry and make a movie worth remembering.
Name: Melyssa
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Portland, Oregon
Time: 1999-08-19 21:42:32
Comments: Michael IS the Phantom. No question about it. Certain actors are usually identified by one major roll in their career. In this case, Michael is most widely known for his portrayal of the Phantom. It wouild be a terrible shame if Michael didn't play the part. Antonio would only put the role of Phantom to shame. Anyone see "Evita"?
Name: Beth
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Maryland
Time: 1999-08-19 19:28:08
Comments: I thought that ALW was doing this project to be a screen version of his musical. OF HIS MUSICAL. And to me that means keeping it as close to the original as possible, in every sense. If this were just another movie based on phantom, then I would have no problem with Antonio or any other actor doing it (although I am sure it wouldn't be too great). But this is a one-time deal. People who go will think this is the definitive version of ALW's work, and his vision at its' best. Now, Michael Crawford is availiable, "would love to do it" (from his own lips)! What a fabulous opportunity for everyone who wanted, and still wants, to see that legendary performance! To see Phantom as close as we could get to seeing it on stage! How could it get any better? We would have the original's awesome performance preserved forever! And for ALW and Warner to give this great role to someone who isn't even a professional SINGER- it boggles the mind. I have known about this for weeks now, and I still can't get over the huge mistake being made. This movie/musical has the potential to be MASTERPIECE, if the top brass has their hearts and heads in the right place, and casts wisely! Michael Crawford would be phenomenal, everyone knows this!
Name: Kat
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Seattle
Time: 1999-08-19 15:13:55
Comments: I am a very active and concerned member in this campaign, in fact, I am active and concerned beyond healthy reason....BUT! I was just reading some of the recent news about the radio reports and such, and I'm so excited! I think there is hope! "There's a place for us...a time and place for us..." sorry, West Side Story....Michael sings it on his songs for stage and screen album....it just came to mind. Michael is the Phantom! You should all go to Michael Crawford online and read some phantom reviews from when our phine phantom phellow was still with the show! So should Mr. Lloyd Webber. People that hated the show loved Michael....the critics were very kind to him. I'm rambling on again, I tend to do that, it's just that I am very excited and I had to tell someone that cares. "God give me courage to show you....you are not alone!" Sorry, more lyrics...well then....Bye! Keep fighting, my friends! -KAT (I don't go away, do I?)
Name: Roy Anthony
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: California
Time: 1999-08-19 14:26:58
Comments: I think Antonio Banderas is a great actor/performer but I just can't see him as the Phantom. When I think of Michael Crawford, the first thought that comes to mind is the is The Phantom of the Opera. When I think Antonio Banderas I think of Zorro or Desperado. Please cast Crawford. You can cast Banderas as Raoul.
Name: J.C. Simpson
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Candler, NC
Time: 1999-08-19 13:25:46
Comments: I would recommend to anyone who did not have an opportunity to see Mr. Crawford in the original Phantom to get the video of his PBS special of last year. There is magic on the stage when or where ever he appears. to select anyone else to appear in the movie version would, in my opinion, doom it to obscurity. Remember My Fair Lady!!
Name: someone who is dumbfounded!
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: OH
Time: 1999-08-18 23:19:48
Comments: I cannot believe this is happening. How can ALW think that Antonio Banderas will make more money than Crawford? Even if he does think that, then why the heck is he agreeing to make this great musical into a movie?????? Antonio will draw many young female fans, I am sure. But will they come back for repeat performances? I doubt it. And I don't believe female fans who like "phantom" will really want to see him in the role! And think about it, the only guys who are going to come are phantom fans and musical buffs, meaning they will want quality. Meaning they will want CRAWFORD. Besides, making less money with a quality movie always looks better than a crappy movie that made a lot of money (like Godzilla). Besides, I am so certain that with Crawford in the role, it would be a HUGE success. My family and myself would be in line more than once, I promise you!
Name: Hal H.
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Ohio
Time: 1999-08-18 22:09:29
Comments: I can't believe that, besides Michael Crawford not being "famous enough", some think he is too old! What?????? Jeez, it doesn't matter if the guy is 80, as long as he can still sing! His face is going to be entirely covered in latex, and a mask! Come on, think of a better excuse than that! I would much rather hear a beautiful voice like Crawford's than some Hollywood pretty boy bumbling his way through the songs. This is the final straw for me with Hollywood- I am sick of execs making potentially good movies into horrible ones because they have to cater to movie-goers who want to see a stud, or star of the week. Even if the film, should they actually choose Michael after all, doesn't do as well as it would with Banderas (yeah, RIGHT), it will be far superior, and have a lasting impression as a great film for years to come.
Name: Donna Thoreson
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Climax, Minnesota
Time: 1999-08-18 22:02:22
Comments: I heard on the radio last week about the campaign to get Michael Crawford to do the Phantom in the Movie. I can't believe they would even CONSIDER anyone else doing the part. Michael IS the Phantom. thank you for the opportunity to make my wishes known. C'mon Michael, !!!!!
Name: Susan Keller
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From:
Time: 1999-08-18 20:05:34
Comments: I am here to tell you something, i believe that Michael Crawford is the phantom and the olny one, NOONE can take his place on stage or off. As you can see i like your website verymuch and i'll be right behind you and your feeling about Mr. Crawford getting the part .. I also read that article about Michael Crawford and about the moive fom usa weekly, I think, and that person is write, we the people are the ones who buys the tickets for any show. Susan Keller ;)
Name: Patricia and Roger Olson
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Los Angeles, CA 90049
Time: 1999-08-18 17:06:23
Comments: My husband and I are not "record-setters," but we saw "Phantom" 7 times, unfortunately only twice with Michael Crawford. As far as we are concerned MICHAEL CRAWFORD IS THE PHANTOM!!! His voice, his body language and characterization, his face and THOSE HANDS!!! IT WOULD BE A TRAVESTY TO CAST ANYONE BUT MICHAEL CRAWFORD IN THE ROLE OF THE PHANTOM!!!
Name: Jane Martins
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: New Haven Ct
Time: 1999-08-18 16:58:13
Comments: My vote --now and forever-- is for Michael Crawford in the role of the Phantom. michael Crawford IS the Phantom, and anyone who has heard the recording knows this.
Name: Kara Christie
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: Hamden, CT
Time: 1999-08-18 16:54:04
Comments: The role of the Phantom belongs to Michael Crawford, just as The King of Siam belonged to Brynner and Prof. Higgins to Harrison. When Crawford left the role on Broadway, fans camped out on the sidewalk to obtain tickets for his last performances. No one else has that haunting voice that is associated with the Phantom. I have had people who listened to the CDs over and over before actually seeing the musical tell me how disappointed they were in not seeing Crawford because "it just wasn't the same." This type of comment has been made by many, many people of vastly differing ages. Anyone who would consider casting another actor, however talented or "charismatic", in this role is underestimating tremendously the impact made by Michael Crawford.
Name: Andrea Cecily Vera
Website:
Referred by: Net Search
From: Largo, Florida, United States
Time: 1999-08-18 11:48:58
Comments: I'm 12. I will be 13 on October 31. I've never seen ANY phantom. I've never been to any Andrew Lloyd Webber production. I've never been able to. Yet I love the Phantom of the Opera. I first heard of it last sumer, my mom and I were driving to Ohio for a family reunion, and my mom popped in a Micheal Crawford tape. I was stunned by his voice instantly, even before any of the Phantom songs came up. Once they did, I was like "Mom! I have to get the Phantom of the Opera tape!!!" I did get it on my 12th birthday, as well a Sarah Brightman tape. My mom had said that it was Miz Brightman singing on the tape with Mr.Crawford. Once I heard the real Sarah Brightman sing, I realized that she was NOT on the MC tape. Since then, I have become a Sarah Brightman fan. I owe it to Micheal Crawford in an indirect way. I have recently gotten the original recording(soundtrack, the tape I had was only the highlights) of the Phantom of the Opera and i was stunned once again. I'm not saying that I stopped listening to MC as soon as I heard of SB, NO WAY!!! We had to drive down to Florida from Maryland. A 144 hour trip. I filled that time with Sarah Brightman of 1998 and 1986. and Micheal Crawford of 1986 and 1991. It was a fantastic trip because of the music and the phantom songs became firmly ingrained in my mind. I can still hear their voices, weaving and twisting around each other's voice(Sarah Brightman and Micheal Crawford), magnifing the beauty of the song and themselves. They were each one half of the whole show. Together(Sb and MC) they made the show real. When Sarah B left, it took away from the Phantom. I still refuse to hear anyone but Sarah Brightman as Cristine and Micheal Crawford as the Phantom.It would be a shame if the Phantom was captured forever on tape, with both halfs of the show missing. LET US SALVAGE WHAT WE CAN AND GIVE TO THOSE WHO WERE NEVER ABLE TO SEE THE PHANTOM WITH THE ORIGINAL CAST. PUT THE MAN WHO MADE UP HALF OF THE SHOW ON TAPE LET THE YOUNGER GENERATION SEE AT LEAST THE ORIGINAL ANGEL/PHANTOM/ERIK. I beg you. NOTE THAT I have never seen the POTO and yet I defend the Micheal Crawford and Sarah Brightman based on ONLY WHAT I HAVE HEARD!!!
Name: Linda Hanna
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From:
Time: 1999-08-18 09:47:23
Comments: I don't understand the logic Andrew Lloyd Webber and the execs at Warner Bros are supposedly acting on!!!!! Using a Hollywood "Star" to play Phantom will not increase profits. If people don't like musicals, they will not go and see this whether he, or John Travolta, or whoever they are thinking of is cast! Second, the people who WILL see the Phantom Movie are those who have been longtime fans of Phantom, the Webber production, and musical theatre in general. And it has been made obvious that most are not happy about trading true talent and quality (Michael Crawford) for a money ploy that will ultimately fail. I think it is insulting that Crawford, who was offered the role first, is now out of the running. And I admire his attitude and graciousness through this mess. He's too old some say? Ridiculous! I don't think there has been an actor so linked to a role for decades, and for good reason. He is an incredible singer and actor. I am not going to see this movie if he is not cast, and from what I have heard from my friends, neither will they.
Name: Hazel Miller
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: California
Time: 1999-08-18 02:07:46
Comments: I just came from Cerritos Performing Arts Center where Michael Performed The best concert I have ever heard in my life. I have been a fan for as long time and listen to the music quite often,I have never-ever heard MUSIC OF THE NIGHT sung better.I would like to see Sarah and Michael together again as there is no one esle for tyhese roles.They were cast perfectly the first time DO IT AGAIN ALWEBBER for all the world to see. Michaels voice just gets better and better who could catch him now?
Name: Jimmy Crespo
Website: Riff and Roll
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: California
Time: 1999-08-17 21:56:18
Comments: I am a musician, former guitarist/member of Aerosmith and most recently completed a two year tour with Rod Stewart. I am not only a fan of Mr. Crawford, and like everyone else clearly believe he is the only one to play the Phantom in a feature film but am also a fan of Mr. Webber. I believe Mr. Webber has the soul and vision to cast Mr.Crawford. I have no doubts.
Name: Joy Wills
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Sanford, NC
Time: 1999-08-17 15:45:22
Comments: To have anyone else play the phantom except Michael Crawford is just plain foolish. He did such a wonderful job so why fix something that isn't broken. He is a little older but when you play the phantom you wear the mask anyway and his voice is just as great now as it was when he played on Broadway and in London. No one can replace him.
Name: Sondra Thiederman
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: San Diego
Time: 1999-08-17 15:47:50
Comments: I have seen several men portray the Phantom and, talented as they were, it is absurd to think that they could or should be in the movie. No one has the charisma, not even Banderes, to pull it off. I feel so strongly about this that, quite frankly, I probably would not go to the movie unless Michael Crawford is in it. That is saying a lot as I am a big movie goer.
Name: Karen Marlo
Website: Don't have one
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Stow, Ohio, USA
Time: 1999-08-17 15:41:01
Comments: I finally saw Antonio Banderas's performance on a PBS repeat of ALW's birthday celebration, and there's simply no way that he should do the POTO movie instead of Michael. Even if he were able to lose the Spanish accent, he can't change the fact that he's just too young! The Phantom is supposed to be old enough to be Christin's father, and Michael would certainly be more believable in the role. Apart from that, after all of the wonderful things I've read about MC's Broadway performance, I wouldn't even _want_ to see the movie if he wasn't the Phantom! Why do the "powers that be" have to mess with perfection??
Name: Steven
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: St. Louis, Mo.
Time: 1999-08-17 12:04:08
Comments: Michael Crawford is the only reasonable choice to play the Phantom! Antonio Banderas' accent and voice would just not fit into a story that takes place in one of the classiest theatres in Paris. His performance on Andrew Lloyd Webber's birthday special was not very inspiring and I was surprised when Michael Crawford was not the one picked to portray the part that he made. And I also think that Lloyd Webber should also consider casting Sarah Brightman as Christine, as she still has a miraculous voice that moves people to tears and thunderous applause! After all these two extremely talented individuals made the Phantom of the Opera all that it is and I am convinced that it would not be as popular as it is without these two wonderfully exciting people. Steven
Name: Paula J. Carmer
Website: Paula's Home Page (Still under construction)
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Holland, MI
Time: 1999-08-17 11:46:30
Comments: When I first started taking voice lessons, the first musical my voice teacher introduced me to was Phantom of the Opera. I bought the two CD set of "Phantom" from a nearby music store and since then have been thoroughly enthralled by Michael Crawford's voice. Soon I had the priviledge of seeing the actual stage performance at the Pantages theatre in Toronto, Canada. Although I was not disappointed, the actor singing the part of the phantom didn't even come close to Michael Crawford. I've seen it on stage four times now and have heard different recordings of the musical. None of the phantoms could come close to that CD set of the original London recording. Since then, I've longed to see Mr. Crawford perform as the phantom. If this wonderful musical is going to become a movie, I really can't see anyone else playing the part of the phantom except for Michael Crawford.
Name: aubrey salvino
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: kent, ohio
Time: 1999-08-16 22:43:34
Comments: when i heard that michel was maybe going to play the part i cryied. i never got to see him perform the phantom and there is only one phantom and a thousand imatators. how could you give the part to antonio he is che not the PHANTOM.
Name: Steven
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: St. Louis, Mo.
Time: 1999-08-16 21:07:34
Comments: I agree with everyone else in this guestbook! Michael Crawford is the only possible choice for the movie of the Phantom of the Opera. Banderas was good in Evita because his accent fits in a story that takes place in Argentina, South America. But the Phantom takes place in Paris and therefore Banderas' voice would just ruin the mood of the movie and story. And also, I think Lloyd Webber is crazy for not offering the role of Christine to Sarah Brightman. She is still a beautiful singer who would be the best choice for the role. Just as Crawford created the role of the Phantom, Sarah created the role of Christine!
Name: Steven Baker
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: St. Louis, Mo.
Time: 1999-08-16 20:50:22
Comments: If you have seen the Hey! Mr. Producer! video you will know that Banderas is not the best choice to play the phantom. The Phantom of the Opera was not set in an opera house in South America! Banderas' accent does not fit in well at all! The reason he was so popular in Evita is because Evita takes place in Argentina, a country where his accent is appropriate. And what about Sarah Brightman! I am confident that she could easily handle the role of Christine even now. Catherin-Zeta Jones once again does not fit the part because of her ethnic origin. Give the parts to the best talent!
Name: Amy T. Ogilvie
Website:
Referred by: Yahoo!
From: Logan, Utah
Time: 1999-08-16 19:51:29
Comments: In 1990, I was 13 and heard "Phantom of the Opera," for the first time. It was the most incredible music I ever heard. I went home and begged my mother to give me the money to buy the album. My passionate plea finally made her give in and we bought the album that day. "The Phantom of the Opera," covered my walls and the music floated through our home daily. Michael Crawford IS the Phantom!!! HIS voice is the power behind the music, the tragic humanity of the story and the phenominon behind "The Phantom of the Opera." Please do not make the mistake of passing on this incredable talent. Thank you, Amy Ogilvie
Name: Sally, Caity, Bitsy, Allyson and Kathryn.
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Tennessee
Time: 1999-08-16 19:05:52
Comments: Sally votes for : Michael, Caity votes for: Michael, Bitsy votes for : Michael and Allyson votes for (hmm guess!) MICHAEL>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WE ALL DOOOOOOOOOOOOOO GET THAT THROUGH YOUR HEAD WARNER BROTHERS please thank you for your time and clean underwear (I can't spell underware) If you don't choose Michael box 5 won't be the only seat empty!!!!!!
Name: JESSICA BODTKE
Website:
Referred by: NewsGroups
From: Michigan
Time: 1999-08-16 16:41:14
Comments: When I read the article about you group in USATODAY I was thrilled!!! I have never had the chance to see Michael Crawford in POTO or anything else but after hearing him on the origial cast recording I knew that he would always be the only Phantom for me. I think Antonio Banderas was wonderful in Evita but the only Phantom I can picture is Michael Crawford. Maybe Antonio Banderas could play Raoul. That could work. But what could not work is anyone but Michael Crawford as the Phantom and if Andrew Lloyd Webber and the people at Warner Bros. think differently then there is nothing in my heart twards them but pity. Pity because they cannot see what is right in front of them, pity because of what the Phantom of the Opera will be without Michael Crawford, and pity for the millions of people who will go to see the movie and come out of the theater without ever hearing that haunting, ethereal vioce sing "Music of the Night" or seeing the only true Phantom in all his glory, majesty, and power.
Name: Robert / Virginia Kelley
Website:
Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button
From: California
Time: 1999-08-16 01:21:30
Comments: Michael Crawford is a must to do the MOVIE. He made the play. The movie will not be successful with out him in the Phantom part.
Name: Kelley
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Nashville, TN
Time: 1999-08-15 22:35:25
Comments: Hi, I'm 13 and would like to tell you how much i love Michael's voice, i have never seen him preform but just listing to the Phantom of the opera cd with him in it brings tears to my eyes. He has the best voice, PLEASE reconsider before you let a really talented singer, Micheal Crawford loose HIS role as the Phantom wich is his, and always will be his no matter what.!
Name: elinor and chris weber
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From:
Time: 1999-08-15 22:20:52
Comments: two votes for michael crawford!!!!!!!!! elinor and chris weber
Name: Millie Smith
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From:
Time: 1999-08-15 22:22:32
Comments: I think it would be a shame if Michael Crawford was not chosen for the role he created. winning a Tony for his performance. Hollywood, shame on you for even thinking of anyone else to play the role. Michael is the Phantom. Millie Smith
Name: Michael & Pamela Henry
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Shawnee, Oklahoma
Time: 1999-08-15 22:20:08
Comments: We saw Michael play the Phantom twice during its run in Los Angeles. There are certain roles that come around that were meant for that special star: Yul Brenner as the King; George C.Scott as Patton; Gable and Leigh as Rhett and Scarlet. The Phantom is a role that should be played on screen by the man who made it a legend on the stage - Mr.Crawford. Our friends agree that none of us will probably see the movie with another actor in the role. Cordially, Michael & Pamela Henry Shawnee, Oklahoma
Name: Kathy
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Time: 1999-08-15 21:49:12
Comments: I can't believe that ANYONE would be so foolish as to even THINK about filming "Phantom of the Opera" WITHOUT Michael Crawford -- He IS the Phantom. I will honestly say that anyone else in the role would cause me to not only boycott this film, but any other that Warner Bros. would produce in the future. How can you trust the judgement of those who don't even know when they are handed the ideal leads -- Michael Crawford as Eric and Sarah Brightman as Christine. Who else could handle these roles as well as the two performers they were created for?
Name: Tammy Costello
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Michigan
Time: 1999-08-15 20:58:23
Comments: I would love to see any Phantom movie with Andrew Lloyd Webber music. I saw the Phantom 2 xs is Toronto and 2 xs in Detroit. I love Crawford and Brightman the best for the roles. They have the best voices.
Name: Hazel Miller
Website:
Referred by: From a Friend
From: California
Time: 1999-08-15 20:35:55
Comments: HI After last weekend at cerritos Performing arts Center Is there still a question of who should be Phantom?
Name: Darlene
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Nashville
Time: 1999-08-15 20:08:48
Comments: It would be a travisty to even entertain the idea of anyone playing the lead in Phantom of the Opera except for Michael Crawford. There will never be any other Phantom in the minds of millions!!!!!
Name: Michael & Pamela Henry
Website:
Referred by: Just Surfed On In
From: Oklahoma
Time: 1999-08-15 19:42:17
Comments: We saw Michael in Phantom twice during the Los Angeles run. How about putting someone else in these roles: Replace Yul Brenner in the King and I ? Replace George C.Scott as Patton ? Replace Clark Gable and Vivian Leigh as Rhett & Scarlet ? The point is simple. There are some roles that should be played by certain people and this is a role that should be played by Michael Crawford. The chances are better than not that we and our friends probably won't see the movie with another performer in that role.
Total: 100 guests