Total: 2230 Guests
| Name: Amalia Ferris Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: POB 1255, Frazier Park, CA 93225 Time: 1999-07-18 16:15:24 Comments: It is to be noted by all concerned that the 'Phantom' libretto is being played out in Lord Webby's real life. Notice as you go through the libretto how Phantom is betrayed after being the one who should be recognised. Compare how Raoul is his rival to that of Michael Crawford's rival, Antonio Banderas. Has Lord Webber forgotten -- all that the phantom asks??? |
| Name: Katy Cutter Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-18 13:05:21 Comments: Hi, My name is Katy Cutter. I agree with you and loved your article in the LA Times. I Think Michael Crawford should be the Phanatom in the Movie. I also hope he gives the lead to Sarah Brightman. Antonio is too young of a kid for this role...hadn't the Phanatom haunted the theater for years???KT |
| Name: Walter J.
Zemrock Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Framingham, MA Time: 1999-07-18 13:04:53 Comments: Mr. Crawford was exceptional in the role of the Phantom, and I can not imagine any other actor playing this role in a film version of this classic, expecially Antonio Banderas. I believe that Mr. Crawford could bring a bigger draw to the box office as the star of this movie: many people who did not have the chance, or who could not afford the price of a broadway show, could now experience the music of the night. It would be a huge mistake in my opinion to have Banderas in this role - he took away from my enjoyment of the film version of Evita. Please let Mr. Crawford take on this role - a role that he has made such an enjoyable performance for millions around the world! |
| Name: Kat Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-17 20:57:25 Comments: Andrew Lloyd Webber....has he gone mad? Michael Crawford is a genius. It has been said several times that the only one that would make the role of the Phantom work was indeed Michael Crawford. His voice is the only I know of that is so hypnotic to portray realistically the emotion-the flesh and blood Erik, that any one but Mr. Crawford would callously butcher without mercy-I just don't believe that any one would want to cast aside this incredibly gifted man from the role he was so obviously born to play (well, that and Frank Spencer). I fear that this movie will do very poorly if it has not the original cast. The phans are despairing! Andrew Lloyd Webber has the power of casting, and he neglects to consider the ones that will really make this film count. We, the phans, will be the ones that will bring triumph to this film. Look what we did for the musical in it's theatrical form! Andrew, "I advise you to comply, my intstructions should be clear; remember there are worse things than a shattered chandelier!" That is all for now, though I have much to say. Much, which I can hopefully voice in a more aesthetically pleasing way than violence toward certain asinine people in charge of important choices. A book or movie perhaps...."Phor the Phans"... -Kat |
| Name: Cassandra Website: Ellara Referred by: Yahoo! From: Alderaan, arguably Time: 1999-07-17 20:33:53 Comments: All I can say on this matter is that if they did not cast Michael Crawford as Erik, they would be ruining the musical. He is the *only* one who could possibly play the role with such fervor and passion as displayed in the original London version of the musical. He *is* the true Phantom, and no one shall convince me otherwise. |
| Name: Than Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Jamestown, NY Time: 1999-07-17 17:53:35 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the Phantom! How could anyone consider using someone else. |
| Name: Susan Riordan Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Maryland Time: 1999-07-17 16:45:03 Comments: I am a Michael Crawford fan who would very much like to see him star in the movie role of the Phantom of the Opera. |
| Name: Bud and
Marge Stafford Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Hackensack, NJ Time: 1999-07-17 14:57:36 Comments: We read our Bergen Record newspaper yesterday and learned about the phantom movie website. Thank you one and all for having this website. We want to vote for having Michael Crawford be the Phantom (the only real Phantom!!) in the movie. His interpretation of this role is beyond what any other person can imagine. He created the mystique about the Phantom. The sold-out theatres around the world definitely prove that he must be the movie Phantom. Please include our 2 votes and prayers that A.L.W. will reconsider. Surely anyone can close his/her eyes and hear the difference of Michael Crawford's voice and Antonio Banderas' voice. Antonio is a fantastic actor - The Mask of Zorro surely was one of his many successes. But the world heard him sing a song from the Phantom at A.L.W.'s birthday salute, and clearly, Antonio Banderas is NOT the Phantom. Thank you for this website and this mission! Bud and Marge Stafford, Hackensack, NJ |
| Name: Ilene Miles Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: plano, texas Time: 1999-07-17 10:31:37 Comments: my favorite client kelly crawford told me to sign this so here i am...I hope what ever you are doing...works..michael crawford should be the only phantom... |
| Name: Rebecca Meyer Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mulberry Florida Time: 1999-07-17 09:42:09 Comments: I first met the Phantom when I was 13. It wasn't Micael Crawford, but Brad Little. Afterwards me and my phantom obsessed handbell group couldn't stop singing. Later I bought the Origional London Cast Recording w/ MC and SB. From that day to now there has not been one day when I haven't listened to it. Michael is one of the greatest, no, the greatest Phantom that has ever sung. When I first heard about a Phantom movie, I thought, "not a bad Idea. I would really like to see Crawford in this role." Then I read about Antiono or Travolta in the role. I mean I have nothing against Antiono or John, but come on! No one but Michael can bring that phantomness to the Phantom. NO ONE! Of anyone person in the world Michael is the only logical choice. If movie makers cast anyone besides Michael, it will be their darkest hour. |
| Name: Lauren Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: New Jersey, USA Time: 1999-07-17 07:26:30 Comments: "Who was that shape in the shadows? Whose is the face in the mask?" Christine, let's hope it's Crawford!!! Angel of Music, guide, and guardian, please be Michael Crawford! I am only 14, and have seen Phantom only once, three days ago. I saw it with the very handsome, talented, and expressive Hugh Panaro. But everyone who is a fan (myself included) has the Original Cast Recording (OCR) and Crawford lights up the house with his voice! The OCR is what we fans want to hear when we go to the theater. And you can only get that quality with Crawford! Antonio Banderas?! That is actually a SCARY thought! I AM the movie generation. My friends and I go out and see movies all the time. Doesn't WB want us to see Phantom? I do believe they want profits. But, without Crawford, I won't be recommending. Even if a current Phantom actor is put on the screen, it won't be the same. If you keep the story (which you MUST!) then you have to keep the legend. Crawford is the legend. Age doesn't matter. If it does, good-bye to Tom Hanks, my personal favorite movie actor. Good bye Jack Nicholson, good-bye Hollywood! So if age is your arguement, than all is lost for the movie world. I swear none of my friends will see it. Nor will my best friend in another town, being in love with the play, and Crawford. If it isn't Crawford, it isn't Phantom. Broadway, LA, and all the other big theaters, will laugh in your face as people flock to the play to see REAL, quality actors imitating Crawford's fabulous acting. No Crawford? No problem. But don't expect to see anyone in the theaters. So please. Think before you act. Or the only thing you will hear outside your WB offices is the famous line of the Phantom, sung by Phantom himself. The sweet music will be over. There will be no fans. And so, be prepared to hear: "It's over now, the music of the night." ~Lauren~ |
| Name: Ron Kollar Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Time: 1999-07-16 19:06:51 Comments: Regarding a recent article in the Calendar Section of the Los Angeles Sunday Times entitled "They Want Their Phantom," my family and I are casting our vote for Michael Crawford for the leading role in the Phantom of The Opera movie. Thanking you for your consideration in this matter. |
| Name: R. John &
Hetty J. Muller Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-16 19:03:50 Comments: Include us in the expanding group that would prefer Michael Crawford as the Phantom in any movie of Phantom of the Opera. He is the original--he IS the Phantom! R. John & Hetty J. Muller--RJMHJM |
| Name: Christine
(no, really!) Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Nevada Time: 1999-07-16 18:49:16 Comments: I have had the pleasure of seeing "Phantom of the Opera" twice in my life (so far!). Once in London and once in San Francisco. Unfortunately, I never had the opportunity to see Michael Crawford as the Phantom. However, I did catch him on PBS's "An evening with Michael Crawford". I must say, even without the costumes and sets, just the passion he put forth when he performed Phantom songs sent chills all over my body. I was truly stunned. His voice, his passion in the role, as well as the number of performances in which he's honed it to perfection, make him the ONLY one truly qualified to convey this characters poor tortured soul. Phantom IS Michael Crawford. Michael Crawford IS Phantom. Anyone else in that role would be a joke as well as a waste of celluloid. And I almost fell out of my chair when I heard that Antonio Banderas is being considered for the role. One question: Are you insane?? Michael Crawfords performance will go down in HISTORY. He will ALWAYS be remembered. You mention Antonio Whats-his-name 10 years from now and everyone will say, "Who?" Look at how many people have visited this web site. That's a portion of how many people are NOT going to attend the movie if Michael's not in it. Your setting yourselves up for a colossal bomb. The people who would go to see Phantom on the big screen are the same people who have seen it in the theatre. We know who Mr. Crawford is. You can't feed us tofu and tell us it's chocolate. Don't make this mistake. There is only one Phantom. Michael Crawford. |
| Name: Bernie
Cottone Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Lakeland, Florida Time: 1999-07-16 17:39:03 Comments: I have seen the Phantom on stage twice, unfortunately not with Michael, but have listened to him over and over on the sound track CD, and when it wears out I will purchase another. I have seen Michael perform and captivate the audience on stage in Tampa. He was made for the part of the Phantom, just as Clayton Moore was for the Lone Ranger, whom the world also loved. Michael made the Phantom a success on stage for ALW and would do nothing less for the Movie. Antonio is no Phantom nor will he ever be. |
| Name: HAZEL HEINBUCH Website: Referred by: AOL From: BALTIMORE MARYLAND Time: 1999-07-16 17:05:53 Comments: NO MICHAEL...NO MOVIE... |
| Name: Jennifer
Anthony Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: NJ Time: 1999-07-16 06:37:20 Comments: ILove Phantom of the Opera & have seen it 3 times on Broadway. Unfortunately never with Michael Crawford, but I adore him & he is the only TRUE phantom in my eyes. It would be an artistic sin if they do not cast him in the role as the Phantom. As for Antonio Bandaras playing the lead, that would be the ultimate sin & a flop, did you hear him in Evita, I had to turn off the CD. I hope our influence as "the audience" has some persuasion over Hollywood in casting him. After all, we pay their salaries by viewing the movies, don't we? Without us the show mustn't go on. |
| Name: Mary Sleker Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-16 05:34:52 Comments: Michael Crawford gets my vote for Phatom in the movie. Please do all you can towards that goal. Thank you. |
| Name: Susan Fleck Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Manotick, Ontario, Canada Time: 1999-07-15 20:19:07 Comments: Can't believe they would consider anyone else for the role. Good luck in your efforts! |
| Name: Barb Lehnen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-15 18:18:14 Comments: Although never having seen Michael Crawford in the Phantom, I did have the thrill of seeing him live in concert several years ago and wholeheartedly agree that he should be cast in the starring movie role of the Phantom. Banderas had Evita, let Crawford have the Phantom. And wouldn't it be great if the original Christine, Sarah, could also be cast!! |
| Name: Bill Haner Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Time: 1999-07-15 18:19:33 Comments: I to am a Phantom nut, seeing it 8 times, 7 with Crawford. I was lucky to be at his 1000th show in LA. Needless to say it is by far the best show I have ever seen ( with Michael ). I read your article in the Times and I could not agree with you more. Without Michael it will not be the same nor will I see it. I hope your efforts will help spur Warner Bros. to make the right decision and get Crawford. Good Luck, Bill Haner |
| Name: Ted
Mueller Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Time: 1999-07-15 18:04:34 Comments: Please make the right choice of Micheal Crawford |
| Name: Debbie
Caracciolo-Smith Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Campbell, California. 95008 Time: 1999-07-15 17:24:30 Comments: Read an article in the San Jose Mercury News dated July 11, 1999. Using Diane Flogerzis Web site we would like to voice our opinion too. We have seen Phantom in London, L.A. and San Francisco. We've seen Robert Gullioume, Davis Gaines, Michael D'Ambrosio,forgive if the spelling is not correct. Back in 1990, we heard that Michael Crawford was to perform a few short months at The Ahmanson in Los Angeles. We'll we rushed to get the first available tickets for a wednesday evening performance. Fantastic seats!!!! Anyway, hopped on a plane after work in San Fransico about 6:00-6:30. Arrived in LAX 7:35, rented a car, drove to the Ahmanson, had dinner saw the most incredible performance in our lives. We were so moved by the sensual and flawless performance we can't even imagine anyone else in the role. We just hope that all of the people involved in eventully making the Phantom think about all the other re-makes or theater to screen and some of the worst casting ever. The Avengers, terrible casting, what were they thinking? The Wild, Wild West, please, there are some things you just should not touch. The World has waited to see this on the big screen and the poor people who didn't have the opportunity to see him perform will get to in the movie. Do the right thing, cast Banderas in another role, I'm sure he wouldn't be dissappointed. |
| Name: B.A.Wright Website: Referred by: AOL From: Lakeland FL Time: 1999-07-15 09:49:06 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the Phantom. |
| Name: Jean Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Lansing, Michigan Time: 1999-07-15 06:41:34 Comments: I just read the article in the Lansing State Journal. Which is located in Lansing, Michigan. Need to get this information out. I was appalled when I read that they were considering using someone other than Michael Crawford, he owns the role.What can they be thinking? |
| Name: John Lang Website: ---------------------------------------------------- Referred by: AOL From: Yakima, Washington Time: 1999-07-14 23:43:59 Comments: One of my favorite musicals |
| Name: Sue Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-14 21:56:41 Comments: We are all for Michael Crawford appearing in the Phantom of the Opera movie. It seems that anyone who appreciates the music would know that he is the obvious choice. I would think Andrew Lloyd Weber would feel the same. Instead we are getting a pretty face instead of a talented actor and accomplished singer. My family and I have seen the play ten times in Toronto with another wonderful singer named Colm Wilkinson. I can't imagine anyone but Michael or Colm singing in the movie. I am a Phantomholic and the music has invaded my soul. Sue |
| Name: Barbara Harris Website: Referred by: AOL From: Florida Time: 1999-07-14 21:41:08 Comments: I was upset when Audrey Hepburn played in My Fair Lady, and when Richard Harris starred in Camelot. I will be very, very unhappy if Antonio Banderas is cast in "Phantom" instead of the only person who can do it right! There is only ONE Phantom: Michael Crawfod. And one Christine: Sarah Brightman. What are the chances both will star? Ha! |
| Name: Kay
Erickson Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Campbell, CA Time: 1999-07-14 21:28:07 Comments: I think the idea of Michael Crawford extending his talent into a movie would be delightful. I have never enjoyed any performance more than the one he did in Phantom and would love to once again experience his thrilling performance. |
| Name: Lori Sears Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Maryland Time: 1999-07-14 17:35:46 Comments: In 1992, I saw "The Phantom of the Opera" performed at the Ahmanson Theater in California. It was fabulous, and the music was amazing. My only regret was that Michael Crawford was no longer in the starring role. After becoming infatuated with the show, I discovered Michael. I saw what I was missing. I saw him on talk shows, bought his CDs and discovered what a treasure he is. I saw him perform "The Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber" in Baltimore soon thereafter, and fell in love with him. He was witty, funny, intelligent and brilliant. His voice is magnificent, his presence overpowering. He is the greatest. Antonio is a fine man, but the "Phantom" role is one for Michael. Thank you. |
| Name: Ruth Brown Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Maryland Time: 1999-07-14 16:27:39 Comments: I would like Michael Crawford to be the phantom in the upcoming movie. He is the only phantom. |
| Name: Karen H. Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Western New York Time: 1999-07-14 16:10:23 Comments: I saw Michael in the Phantom in Toronto two times. He is ausome. He is the only one to play in the movie version. He is wonderful !! I would only buy the movie if he starred in it. Love to Michael !! |
| Name: Jenny
Ann Chin Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: London,England Time: 1999-07-14 14:46:38 Comments: Michael Crawford has the most unique voice I have ever heard in my whole entire life. I think Michael should get the part in the Phantom movie. Man! He played the Phantom on stage 3,200 times and knows the Phantom's part by heart. Michael is my singing idol, it would be nice to have a movie played by him that I can keep for a momento. |
| Name: elizabeth Website: Teacher's Toy Box Referred by: Yahoo! From: St. Louis, Missouri Time: 1999-07-14 10:27:00 Comments: I have been long awaiting the production of the Phantom movie. I have been in love with the Phantom of the Opera since it was released, and one of my fondest memories was when my parents flew me to LA to see it--with Michael Crawford and Steve Barton (he was a stand-in!) in it. I've been appalled at the men considered for the part, however. I mean, have we forgotten that this is a MUSICAL? I am, of course, partial to Michael Crawford. He definitely has a voice and has added something to the play that I have not seen in any of the other phantoms the 4 other times I've seen the play. He also has much experience with the big screen and is still capable of playing the role. I thought Antonio Banderas did well in Evita, and I enjoy seeing him in action movies. However, I am appalled that he is being considered for Phantom. I don't think his breathy, half-talking the songs can be pulled off in that show. Not to mention his singing on the ALW Birthday Celebration made me feel sick! Please don't take such a powerful musical with potential to revive musicals on the big screen and turn it into a disaster. Cast Michael Crawford. |
| Name: Jayne
Ross Website: Referred by: Signing another Guestbook From: Ireland Time: 1999-07-14 05:41:31 Comments: *****************Dear Jayne, Antonio hasn't been cast yet, but with all the publicity he's been receiving for openly "going" for the role, one would sure think he has. According to WB however, no one has been actually "signed" as of yet. Thank you for your wonderful entry to the guest book. It is so apparent that the role IS the man, and the man IS Michael Crawford!************** I was appauled to hear that Antonio Bandaras has been cast as the Phantom. Whilst I believe this was done due to his huge box office lure after Zorro and also his brillant portrayal of Armand in Interview with a Vampire, does ALW and the bean counters in Warner Bros not realise that this part is not for him. I first saw POTO in November last year in N.Y and was blown away. Immediately I bought the original cast recording and have been totally mesmerized by Michael Crawfords' voice ever since. I don't think a day has gone by when I have not listened to it. The love I now have for POTO has led me to see it a further 6 times and I have surfed into countless sites on the Net trying to gleam further information. Perhaps ALW and Warner are under the mistaken impression that due to the delays in production Michael Crawford is now too old for the film audiences they hope to appeal to? If that is the case I would like to point out that I am only 25 and I'm sure like most female fans find him very attractive. Perhaps they think he would not be enough of a pull at the box office? If that is the case perhaps they should be reminded that when you think of POTO automatically you think of Michael. I would give anything, go anywhere for that matter, to see him play this role again on stage, to see him weave the magic. Somehow I doubt that I will be going to the cinema 7 times to see this sham of a movie. Warner Bros and the Really Useful Company would do well to remember who their audience is. This is not a Kevin Williamson script, does not need to be directed by the likes of Joel Shumacher in a Batman genre. This is a love story which I believe Cameron Mackintosh described once as "Hyper Romantic". Whilst I understand that the overall aim of both W.B and the RUG company is to make money, surely they realise that to do that is to give audiences what they want. After this long wait for the movie, could they not reward the loyal fans who have returned countless times to see that stage version. It would lead to the film being an even greater success, a classic. Yours, J.B.Ross |
| Name: JAIME
CRAWFORD Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-14 02:03:36 Comments: Hi, Just a small comment:- I have a few versions of POTO on video-tape, BUT,--to have THE VERSION on video, with THE ONE & ONLY TRUE "PHANTOM" would really be a Godsend. Of the few versions I have, I do enjoy them, but the one I would watch THE MOST would DEFINITELY be the ALW one. Thanks, Jaime. |
| Name: kerin-leigh
puccia Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: ogdensburg, ny Time: 1999-07-13 18:50:12 Comments: i cannot concieve of anyone other than michael crawford and sarah brightman starring in this movie. i am from a small community in upstate new york and did not have access to any performances of the play when these two were in it and have dreamed of being able to view their performances when i first heard of the movie. i am so disappointed that now i may never have the chance to realize that dream. i saw an interview with alw when he stated that the first time he heard mr. crawford singing, he said to a companion, "i have found my phantom." has he forgotten his first impression, which is the shared impression of fans of this musical the world over. the movie of hello, dolly lacked in my opinion by not affording people the chance to see carol channing reprise her starring role which would have probably given the movie a greater audience. i notice that alw brought back original cast members from cats for the film version. i must admit that i enjoyed antonio banderas' performance in evita, but i do not believe that he can bring as much to the phantom role as could m. crawford. as far as bringing in a hollywood name, do not feel this is neccessary-people who love the phantom will go to see THE PHANTOM, which is m.crawford. the play itself will draw fans, but ifeel only by having its original star present, and most fans will probably avoid the movie with anyone else in the lead role, choosing to sty home and play there cd's and imagine the movie that might have been. i hope that acion can be taken to ensure a movie that mrwebber and the fans alike can be proud of.!! |
| Name: Joan Website: Referred by: Signing another Guestbook From: Huntsville, Ala. Time: 1999-07-13 18:37:25 Comments: I'm so glad I was lead to your website and this wonderful campaign to bring Michael Crawford to the big screen. My family and I have seen Phantom several times in both London and New York and it is our favorite A.L. Webber production. To think of putting any other person in the movie role of this movie would be insane. To even consider A. Bandaras in the role is impossible. It makes you wonder if any of the movie people have even seen or HEARD Michael sing??? Obviously not! Michael IS "the Phantom" and it is because of his singing and original performance that this show was made a hit and brought so many people back again and again to see this wonderful production. I am really sorry that Andrew Lloyd Webber would even consider anyone else playing this part. Perhaps Mr. Webber needs to sit quietly by himself and listen to his music and words coming from his own heart - the voice he will hear will be Michaels! I don't think I would even consider going to any movie that showcases some hollywood star in the role. Several years ago this same thing happened to Ann Rice when Hollywood got ahold of her popular Vampire book and Tom Cruise was put in the main role. Tom Cruise was the complete opposite of the main character and many of the devoted fans of this movie revolted - it was a poor choice by producers to think that they could stick some Hollywood leading man into a part that was not suited for him, only to try and make money off it. Now the same is being considered for "Phantom". Mr. Webber needs to stick to his art and not sell his soul for the glitz and glitter of Hollywood! My vote is for Michael Crawford anytime - he IS and always will be "The Phantom". |
| Name: Charles D. Esposito Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Buffalo, NY Time: 1999-07-13 16:16:58 Comments: Michael Crawford would be the only choice to play the Phantom. How could ALW even think of using Antonio in such a crucial role. It would lose the excellence of the part as played by Michael Crawford. KEEP UP THE CAMPAIGN !!! |
| Name: Jo Colby Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Holt,Michigan Time: 1999-07-13 14:06:19 Comments: Would love to see Michael Crawford in the movie version of the Phantom. |
| Name: Ilene K.
Zona Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Michigan City, Indiana USA Time: 1999-07-13 13:34:37 Comments: Michael Crawford is fantastic and I think he should be in the Phantom of the Opera movie. His singing of the music from Phantom of the Opera takes my breath away. |
| Name: Eric Adams Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Somerset, KY Time: 1999-07-13 04:39:36 Comments: Dear TMCPMC, I totally agree with you all, and I think this is a wonderful thing you are doing. I never got to see "Phantom of the Opera" with Michael Crawford playing the role of the Phantom. But I fell in love with "POTO" listening to Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman when I was only 13 years old. I am now 19 and "POTO" is still my all time favorite musical. Michael is the essence of the Phantom. No one can portray Andrew Lloyd Webber's work and imagination of the character of the Phatom the way Michael can. I watch a video called "Hey Mr. Producer! The World Of Cameron Mackintosh", which ALW was a part of himself. It had three performances from "POTO". "The Phantom of the Opera", "Music of the Night", and "All I ask of You". The Phantom was played by Colm Wilkinson, and Christine was played by Lisa Vroman. It's not that Mr. Wilkinson wasn't talented; it's just that he wasn't the Phantom. And his portrayal just wasn't enough for me. I wanted to hear Michael Crawfords captivating voice coming out from under that mask. I also feel the same way about Christine Daae and Sarah Brightman. Sarah IS Christine. Her angelic voice, her timid yet strong manner, and even right down to her big, beautiful, doe-like eyes. She is the spirit of Christine. To have two actors other than Michael and Sarah portray the Phantom and Christine become immortalized in something that rightfully belongs to them is unimaginable. I hope that this campaign is successful, and things turn out the way they were meant to be. I will do whatever I can to help you. Let me know how I can be of service to you. With best regards, Eric Adams |
| Name: Abby
Salceda Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Hemet, Ca Time: 1999-07-12 22:41:20 Comments: I have seen both Michael and A/B perform, now I am sorry but Antonio is out of his league. Michael has a hypnotic voice, a voice like no other. I am sure that if anyone other than Michael was cast in the movie I don't believe that I would go see it. There is one and only one Phantom, and that is Michael Crawford. Abby Salceda, Hemet, California |
| Name: Deborah Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-12 22:38:23 Comments: Can't imagine another Phantom than Michael. |
| Name: Chris
Kotowski Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Lancaster, NY Time: 1999-07-12 21:29:20 Comments: Michael Crawford is to the Phantom what Colm Wilkinson is to Jean Valjean in Les Mis. Having worn out the soundtrack of Phantom with Crawford, when I saw Wilkinson as the Phantom in Toronto, I was somewhat disappointed. Not to say Wilkinson wasn't good, but he just wasn't the Phantom. Likewise, Banderas may be able to sing the part, but he just isn't the Phantom. I don't believe age has anything to do with the performance or appeal of Crawford. Having recently seen Wilkinson recreate Valjean in Toronto, his age certainly did not compromise his performance to packed houses. I think it would be a grave mistake and an injustice to cast anyone other than Michael Crawford in the movie version of Phantom. |
| Name: Joanne Daley Website: Referred by: AngelFire From: Illinois Time: 1999-07-12 21:18:52 Comments: Michael Crawford is the original and best choice to play the phantom giving an academy award winning performance. If they want "bankable" stars, let them fill the roles of Raoul, Christine and the managers; however, I feel Michael alone will make the movie a huge financial success. If they want a movie star like Antonio Banderas who cannot sing, why not instead choose Ricky Martin to play Raoul -- at least he can sing, act and has a worldwide young female following who would see this movie multiple times. |
| Name: Avery Anne
Jones Website: Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button From: Westfield, NY Time: 1999-07-12 18:40:30 Comments: PLEASE WARNER BROTHERS have Michael Crawford play the Phantom in the movie. I have seen the production in Toronto and New York City neither of which Michael Crawford was in. I also have the tape and can tell you its his voice we should hear in the movie. Thanks. Avery Anne Jones |
| Name: SAUNDRA
FITZELL Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-12 18:39:36 Comments: I learned about your web site in the Sunday edition of the Baltimore Sun Newspaper published July 11, 1999. I was so pleased to read the article, and only hope that your efforts are fruitful. Michael Crawford is indeed The Phantom just as Yul Bryner was The King in The King and I. An article in Parade Magazine published about a year ago indicated that the reason Michael would not be chosen was his age. That's nonsense. I did see the PBS special which included Antonio Banderas singing with Sarah Brightman. I was sickened when I heard him. Michael not only has the voice for the part, but the sense of the character that no one else can duplicate. I attended an ALW concert that featured Michael Crawford. I sat in the front row. Even in a tuxedo when he sang the songs from Phantom, you were mesmerized. My husband and I saw Phantom of the Opera twice in London, but never with Michael Crawford. After seeing him in concert, my husband said that if Michael Crawford ever performs the role again, he would travel anywhere to see him! That is really saying something! Good luck with your efforts! I hope that those involved with the casting are listening to the theatre going public, and not just those looking for a "new name". Michael Crawford would be the draw for the film. Without him, I would not watch the movie. |
| Name: Duane Marski Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Chicago Time: 1999-07-12 15:56:25 Comments: Crawford defined the role --- could anyone be better suited to perpetuating Webber's brilliance? |
| Name: Kristin Triantafillou Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Buffalo, NY Time: 1999-07-12 14:24:49 Comments: I learned of your efforts from the local news paper, The Buffalo News. I can't even imagine what the movie would be like if WB chosed Antonio over Michael Crawford! I mean Antonio was excellent in Evita, but Phantom is a totally different story, and they better not mess up the movie by giving the part of Phantom to him. Michael Crawford on the other hand, is definitely the man to choose! Come on, its HIS PART!!!! He created and gave life to Andrew Lloyd Webber's character. If you don't meet our demands for casting Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the movie, like others have said "Box 5 won't be the only seat empty during the show" SO BEWARE!!! and chose wisely...the better man, MICHAEL CRAWFORD!!!!!!! |
| Name: BEA Engler Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Amherst, New York Time: 1999-07-12 14:06:48 Comments: I have visited the Pantages Theatre in Toronto three times so far to enjoy Phantom and have tickets to go once more in August before the show leaves Toronto after this long run. I cannot say how much I love the production each time, but - the original cast album always supplies my vision of the real "Man in the Mask". Michael Crawfore IS the Phantom . Please , please see that he lives forever in that role. |
| Name: Ivette
Cecilia Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Miami, Florida Time: 1999-07-12 12:04:01 Comments: I recently read an article in the Miami Herald about this and to my amazement, I guess I'm not the only Phantom fanatic out there. I've never had the pleasure and the honor of experiencing Michael Crawford as the Phantom, but my first introduction to the Phantom was through the Musical's cd; which are the original recordings of Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman. I know after seeing the Phantom many times, that what Mr. Crawford brings to this Music is not only his expertise as an actor, but this magnificent feeling that envelopes you with this true interpretation and understanding what love, pain, fear and devotion the phantom felt for Christine and the Music he so strongly believed in. Yesterday, I had the pleasure and honor of seeing Sarah Brightman in concert at the Jackie Gleason Theater in Miami. She was spectacular and of course she sang The Music of the Night among many other of my favorites. It reminded me of the musical and how much I have missed seeing it again. Sir Andrew Lloyd Weber might not have known it when he created this musical that he was going to create a legacy and what better way of passing this on to generations to come, but to create a spectacular piece of film that would provide us all with the magical feeling he has managed to intill in all the eternal fans. Antonio Banderas is a good actor. But no one can replace Michael Crawford. I saw Antonio Banderas recently in the Andrew Lloyd Weber's 50th Birthday Celebration and I am one to tell you immediately there is no comparison what so ever. If he were to cast Banderas as the Phantom he would probably loose all the originality and feeling we all hunger for and receive when Crawford portrays the phantom. Basically what it all boils down to is that Mr. Michael Crawford is the Man! |
| Name: Daniel H.
Tudor Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Huntsville, AL Time: 1999-07-12 11:43:14 Comments: It was the dream of my daughter to see Michael Crawford as the Phantom on Broadway. She was fortunate that we were able to afford the price of a ticket for her from a scalper ten years ago.. There are so many young children that want to be involved in theater, dance or another form of the arts that will never get the extroardinary experience of seeing the real Phantom, Michael Crawford, unless he is cast in the movie. Please help fulfill the dreams of many other children. Thank you. |
| Name: Ed & Pat
Reimer Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Webberville,Mi 48892 Time: 1999-07-12 11:34:52 Comments: There is only one PHANTOM that is Michael Crawford. We saw the show at the Wharton Center at Michigan State University. The road crew did an excellent job, but their is only one person who can play this part in the movie. I hope this campaign is successful and we can all enjoy this great performer on the screen as well as the stage. |
| Name: Michelle Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Maryland Time: 1999-07-12 11:24:24 Comments: I LOVE YOU |
| Name: Stefanie
Freckelton Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Illinois Time: 1999-07-12 11:00:49 Comments: I think Michael Crawford is the BEST Pantom ever. No one can ever surpass the emotion and talent he has, especially not Antonio Banderas. I love Andrew Lloyd Weber and consider him a genius but casting Antonio Banders as the Phantom is, forgive me, complete stupidity. Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman are an unsurpassable pair and I cannot see her at her full potential with A.B. He was wonderul in Evita, but as the Phantom! I wouldn't even see the movie. If A.L.W. really wants A.B. in his movie he should have Madonna play Christine because they would do much better than Sarah and A.B. I'm glad there are other people who were as upset as I am about this. |
| Name: Carolyn
Jamison Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Buffalo, NY Time: 1999-07-12 10:56:47 Comments: I received this Web site from the Buffalo News. Please cast Michael Crawford in the Phantom. I've seen the play six times; 5 times in Toronto and once in Buffalo. I have the original cast tape with Michael and I think he should do the movie. |
| Name: Suzie Burman Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Caldwell, Id Time: 1999-07-12 10:02:46 Comments: I saw a production of the Phantom about 8 yrs ago and was moved by it. It did not have Micheal Crawford and it did not have my fav Phantom song "Music of the night". But i was still moved to tears I love the play. I have seen bits and pieces of Micheal performing on different shows. He is thwe best for the part of the Phantom and that voice Oh my God how spectacular. Please let all little kids enjoy the man who made the part so wonderful. I live so far from any big places who have big Braodway productions and would love my son to experience Micheal Crawford as the Phantom. Very Very Very big fan from Idaho. |
| Name: Marianne
Noreau Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Norfolk, NY Time: 1999-07-12 09:41:39 Comments: I would dearly love to see Michael Crawford star in the movie production of "Phantom". Movie technology could enhance any feature that Michael may be concerned about at a young age of 57. If he truly chooses not to star, then any of the actors from the Toronto production would be more appropriate than Mr. Banderas. He is a fine latino actor. But Phantom is located in Pais, France! I have heard him perform with Sarah Brightman and to hear him say "zee phantom of zee opera" sends cold chills down my spine and I shudder in disbelief. Please consider casting Mr. Crawford as Phantom(Eric). The original is always the best!! |
| Name: Mark S.
Bialek Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Baltimore Time: 1999-07-12 09:08:14 Comments: I just wanted to let you know that the Michael Crawford article appeared in the Baltimore Sun: Sunday, July 11 on page 10 of the Arts & Society section. It seems that you have now reached Baltimore. You are doing a great job and I send all my hopes. I too would love to see Michael Crawford star in the film. Sincerely, Mark S. Bialek Baltimore City Resident and Michael Crawford fan |
| Name: Brian & Lynn Manville Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Leesburg, VA Time: 1999-07-12 08:12:24 Comments: We saw The Phantom while on our honeymoon in Toronto in September 1995. While I doubt that Mr. Crawford was doing the role then, we have heard him sing, and are convinced that Mr. Crawford is "The Phantom". Anything else would be second best. If one of the most popular musicals of recent memory is to be filmed for posterity, doesn't it make sense to cast the man who everybody associates with the role? Count us in as supporters of Mr. Crawford for the Phantom!!! |
| Name: Gloria
Salceda Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Hemet, Ca Time: 1999-07-12 08:01:54 Comments: It is obvious to me that Michael Crawford Is the one and only choice for the movie.. He is an outstanding and Brilliant performer. |
| Name: Tonna Lee Tudor Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Huntsville, Alabama Time: 1999-07-12 07:49:20 Comments: It seems to me that Michael Crawford and "Phantom of the Opera" are one in the same. There is no other option when it comes to the overwhelming portrayal Crawford has given to the character of the phantom. Even people who do not frequent the theater know that Michael Crawford and Phantom are two words spoken as one. I hope the studio realizes its unfortunate blunder. Assuming anyone other than the charasmatic Michael Crawford could fill such a role will cost them money at the box office. MICHAEL IS THE ONE AND ONLY CHOICE. Thank you for listening. |
| Name: Deborah
Bartholomew Website: Referred by: From a Web Ring From: Gouverneur, NY Time: 1999-07-12 05:44:22 Comments: I love the Phantom Of The Opera, I have seen it 3 times already and plan on seeing it again, in Toronto before it closing down. I would really love to see this version put into a movie. I wished I could play the role of Christine..... |
| Name: Jean Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Time: 1999-07-12 05:26:02 Comments: It would be awful if Michael wasn't the Phantom. Do you e-mail compaign going to the studio to let them know how many of us there are out here?***************** Hi Jean! We do indeed let Warner Bros. Studio and The Really Useful Group know how many of us there are. We download these guestbooks after every 100 entries and snail mail them to both companies. Thank you so much for visiting and signing your support! Best wishes. TMCPMC |
| Name: Joan
Seagal Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-12 04:41:02 Comments: I WANT MICHAEL! I WANT MICHAEL! If anyone is right for the role of the Phantom in a movie production, it is Michael Crawford. Please listen to our pleas. We love him and only him for that part. Thank you. -- J. Seagal |
| Name: Ruth Anderson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mt. View, CA Time: 1999-07-12 00:10:19 Comments: I read an article in my local newspaper (The Mercury News) about your wonderful cause. I FULLY SUPPORT your efforts to convince ALW to star MICHAEL CRAWFORD in any PHANTOM film to be made. I have seen PHANTOM 5 times (none with Michael unfortunately), and I have seen Michael in concert twice and in FX in Las Vegas. He is simply the GREATEST. I understand that Sir Andrew didn't want Madonna for EVITA at first, but she was so right for that film role, and Michael is SO right for this role, and he is the ONE AND ONLY PHANTOM. Good luck in your efforts to make the Music of the Night........sorry Antonio...LOVED you in EVITA though. |
| Name: Jean Beitz Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: buffalo, ny Time: 1999-07-11 22:32:07 Comments: Remember Barbra Streisand in Hello Dolly and Lucille Ball in Mame. Cast changes rarely result in a better movie. Use of the original cast would be preferred by most of the movie going public. Middle America isn't as insulated as it is assumed by Hollywood. We want the original Broadway stars, not imitations. |
| Name: Jeni Estacio Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Santa Clara, CA Time: 1999-07-11 19:35:16 Comments: I read your article in the San Jose Mercury News and was immediately intrigued. The first time I saw "Phantom" was 1996 in San Franisco and I went back 6 more times, much to the dismay of my husband. The actor that played the Phantom was very, very good, however it wasn't until I purchased the soundtrack that I realized that I hadn't even heard the magic yet. I saw "Evita" and was pleasantly surprised with the performance of Antonio Banderas, but there is in no way, shape, or form, any comparison between him and Michael Crawford. Crawford's voice is hypnotic and sensual. Casting anybody else in the role of the Phantom is sheer blasphemy. The movie would forever immortalize "Phantom" and it's just not right to do so without using the man who MADE the Phantom. Think about it, Bela Lugosi=Dracula, Boris Karloff=Frankenstein, Michael Crawford=The Phantom of the Opera. Anything less, would be an injustice to this beautiful, romantic, haunting love story. |
| Name: S. L. Ross Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Foster City, California Time: 1999-07-11 19:34:55 Comments: How can I express the disappointment my friends, family and I felt when we heard the announcement of the casting of the Phantom. Many of us have seen the Phantom more than once starring Michael Crawford, often times having to travel hundreds of miles to do so. We are not fanatics, harboring school girl crushes on the man, but genuine fans of great entertainment, and we know perfection when we see it. Those who have followed Crawford in the role have either failed miserably at trying to make the role "their own" or have proved to be nothing but a cheap substitute of the real thing. The Phantom of the Opera starring Crawford is the only Phantom we care to see. If your intent is to make a quick buck off a mediocre movie, Phantom is destined to a short lived and disappointing box office, followed by being just one of the hundreds of films sitting in the bargain bin at the video store. However, the right choice on your part, in choosing Crawford as the Phantom, could make this a classic memorable movie, duplicating and exceeding the success Crawford created in the theater, pleasing not only the many fans who know the potential of this great work, but the hundreds of thousands that were unable to witness the performance in the theater, who deserve to see everything the Phantom of the Opera is meant to be. |
| Name: Robert H>
Austin Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Watertown,New York Time: 1999-07-11 18:30:01 Comments: Our local newspaper ran an article from the Los Angles Times about Diane Flogerzi efforts to have Michael Crawford re enact his stage role, in any movie that would be made of Phantom of the Opera. I applaud her efforts and to have anyone else to play the part, would doom the success of the movie. |
| Name: Billy Nobel Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Toronto Time: 1999-07-11 18:00:05 Comments: The instant popularity of "The Phantom of the Opera" was due to the beautiful music of Andrew Lloyd Webber, and those original cast members that sang the music. Crawford's voice struck me as being so unique and extremely fitting for the role, and there can be no other person that is more appropriate for the role of the Phantom than he. To have a Hollywood movie star play the role in a film version simply for a box-office draw is ludicrous and highly outrageous. Michael Crawford is the voice we want to hear, for he helped bring the show a large portion of it's fame. |
| Name: Mrs. Joann
Russell Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Tahoe City, California Time: 1999-07-11 18:00:08 Comments: Banderas? NO!!! Let someone do the Phantom who can SING!! And Michael Crawford CAN SING!!!! He IS the Phantom to all the fans of the "Opera". Will I go see the movie with anyone else singing the lead role? NO!! The Phantom is not a sex symbol. He is a character who needs something more than a "pretty face" (though Michael's face ain't bad). The character needs a VOICE!! Michael's voice. For once, PLEASE let Hollywood do what is right - give us Michael Crawford as the Phantom. He IS the Phantom. Joann Russell Tahoe City, CA. |
| Name: Kelly
Sheridan Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Baltimore, Maryland Time: 1999-07-11 15:59:46 Comments: Any Phantom movie that does not have Michael Crawford in it is doomed to fail! That is not a prediction, that is a fact! Kelly Sheridan |
| Name: P. D. Waring Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: San Jose, CA Time: 1999-07-11 15:50:14 Comments: I read the 7/11/99 article published in the San Jose Mercury news. I believe anything less than Micheal Crawford acting and singing in the part of the Phantom is border line mediocrity at best. Thanks for giving me a forum to express my 2 cents. P D Waring |
| Name: Diane Hammond Website: Referred by: AOL From: San Jose, California Time: 1999-07-11 15:18:30 Comments: I read an article about your site in the Sunday (July 11) San Jose Mercury News. I agree that Michael Crawford should be the ONLY person to portray the Phantom in the movie! He is The Phantom!!! |
| Name: Donna Toney Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: San Jose, California Time: 1999-07-11 14:07:33 Comments: I love Antonio Banderas but there's only one Phantom & that's Michael Crawford! |
| Name: Dr.
Marian M. Gray Website: The personal start page of Marian Gray Referred by: NewsGroups From: Buffalo, New York Time: 1999-07-11 12:53:00 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the Phantom. Anyone else is second best or imitation. |
| Name: THELMA
ANDERSON Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: MISSISSAUGA (TORONTO) CANADA Time: 1999-07-11 11:48:25 Comments: Just read about casting Banderas as Phantom - how could they even think of anyone but Michael - HE IS "THE PHANTOM" - THE VOICE THE MOVES - THAT'S IT. Whether he is 57 doesn't make a difference he still is a very sexy, sensuous man & having seen him perform in Toronto & sing that special song from the opera it's very sexy & SENSUOUS - WOW!! For his legion of fans from across the world who have been unable to see him on stage it is only fitting they should be given that treat in the movie. I know I would NEVER go to see the Phantom of the Opera movie if he's not in it & I'm just one of thousands of his fans who I'm sure feel the same way. THELMA ANDERSON MISSISSAUGA (TORONTO) CANADA |
| Name: PETER NOBEL Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: BALTIMORE/TORONTO/BUDAPEST Time: 1999-07-11 11:17:36 Comments: Crawford all the way!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Diane Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Saratoga, California Time: 1999-07-11 10:46:52 Comments: I have seen Phantom in Los Angeles and San Francisco, missed Michael Crawford in LA by a month and have always regretted it. Neither performance thrilled me as much as listening to the original cast recording. Please put him in the movie...he IS the Phantom of the Opera! |
| Name: Felizitas
Devine Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Baltimore, Maryland Time: 1999-07-11 10:28:12 Comments: I read of this issue this morning in the Baltimore Sun. I am appalled that so many people are forced to commit time to show support for this issue. WHO SHOULD HAVE THE ROLE OF PHANTOM OF THE OPERA indeed!!!... Does anyone have to stop and think "Who is the King in The King and I?" No, of course it is Yul Brynner. "Who is Peter Pan?" Julie Andrews, but of course. Who is the Phantom in Phantom of the Opera? MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD MICHAEL CRAWFORD Please select who should be your obvious choice. |
| Name: Renee
Christian Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-11 09:42:14 Comments: I fully support all efforts to have Michael Crawford play the lead in the movie. Only he can do the roll justice. Sincerely, Renee Christian |
| Name: Dawn
Callahan Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: N Tonawanda, NY Time: 1999-07-11 09:40:18 Comments: I read your article in The Buffalo News this morning and was very impressed. Since I originally saw Phantom in Toronto in 1990 I have been in love with it. Even though Colm Wilkenson was the first I saw play Phantom, Michael Crawford has always been the Phantom to me. I was lucky enough to see him in The Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber when it came to Buffalo in 1992 and it was such an incredible experience. I believe that the only way the movie will have true success is if Michael is in the starring role. That is the only way it will become a classic. I know I would be standing in line to buy tickets!! If W.B. did choose Antonio Banderas it would be just another movie (kind of like Evita was just another movie!). Not everyone was fortunate enough to actually see Michael play the Phantom on stage. I have been waiting for this movie for a very long time, with the hope that I would finally see Michael Crawford as the Phantom. I can't imagine it any other way! |
| Name: Virginia R Website: Referred by: Clicked on our Banner Advertisement From: Baltimore, MD Time: 1999-07-11 08:51:46 Comments: The Baltimore Sun wrote a wonderful article about this web page. I hope others read it this morning too. It reminded me of "My Fair Lady". Though Audrey Heburn did a fine performance, I still believe the movie role should have gone to Julie Andrews. Let's stop giving roles to people based on boxoffice appeal and give the people who have "made" the role on the stage the right to make the movie too. I loved "Phantom of the Opera" and have always dreamed of hearing Michael Crawford play the Phantom. The movie version is the only way I'll realize that dream. |
| Name: Kathie Nicolet Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Chicago Time: 1999-07-11 08:37:44 Comments: I am a full time Chicagoland entertainer since 1983... One of the MOST requested scores/selections I get is "Anything From Phantom Of the Opera"!! Invariably, the conversation steers back to Michael Crawford. There are few electrifying moments in Broadway Musical Theatre that leave you hypnotized and totally glued to a performer as I was with Michael Crawford as the Phantom... Antonio Banderas???? PLEEEZZZZEEEE. Michael Crawford IS the Phantom!!! (If Banderas comes out as Lead in this movie, you can rest assured I won't be seeing it. Now, if Michael Crawford is selected, I will be looking for a front row seat opening night!!") I am shocked there's even a discussion about this~!~ Wake UP Andrew Lloyd Webber!! For Heaven's sake.. what are YOU thinking??? Listen to the fans!!!!! The Customer is ALWAYS RIGHT!! Kathie Nicolet-Solo Pianist Chicago (Performer for 16 yrs./Broadway Musical Theatre Afficianado) Reply |
| Name: Marianne
Goldberg Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Baltimore, Md. Time: 1999-07-11 08:36:18 Comments: I can't imagine anyone being the "Phantom" except Michael Crawford. HE IS THE PHANTOM!!!! I have seen Phantom several times but no one thrilled me as much as Mr. Crawford's voice and his acting ability. Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman are the only choices for the movie version. I do hope that Hollywood doesn't botch this up! Good luck with the campaign |
| Name: Virginia L.
Deardorff Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Baltimore, MD Time: 1999-07-11 08:32:14 Comments: I believe that using another actor to portray the Phantom will result in many fans NOT viewing the film. Also, and most importantly, what a shame to deprive all those who have never experienced Michael's incredible portrayal - probably the best theatre ever. |
| Name: Anne
Croteau Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Canada Time: 1999-07-11 06:19:48 Comments: I didn't have the chance to see Michael Crawford perform phantom. But I got the soundtrack where he sings! There is only one thing to do: cast him as the phantom in the movie or it will be a total ruin!!! |
| Name: erin
noreau Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Norwood NY Time: 1999-07-11 06:19:01 Comments: I do believe that Michael Crawford, is the only man that should play Phantom, but if he should decline from it, then phantom fans should not be insulted by having a Spanish/Latino playing the part of Frenchman. The Orignal text, in which Webber took the play from was written by Gaston Leroux, in France. The story takes place in the Paris Opera House. I have nothing aginst Banderas, he has done great things for other movies but after seeing him sing "Phantom" with Brightman on a PBS special. I knew it was not right for him to play the part. ( THE Phantom of THE Opera) Why won't Warner Bros. look at some of the wonderful understudies of Crawford or allow Crawford to help select the right person. A good movie does not nessceraily come about because of well- known actors or actress. |
| Name: Evelyn Lauer Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Ransomville, New York Time: 1999-07-11 05:48:09 Comments: Many years ago I saw Phantom of the Opera in Toronto. At that time I heard that Michael Crawford was going to play the Phantom in a movie version and I was elated. How else could someone like myself, who was not able to see Michael Crawford on stage, get to see the original Phantom in the role he created, if not in a film version. To Mr. Lloyd Webber: Remember how many people paid to see Titanic over and over again at the theaters, and how many purchased the video. With Michael Crawford as the Phantom you have those same possibilities. Don't let The Phantom of the Opera become a joke with another actor. |
| Name: Ted Leicher Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Cupertino, California Time: 1999-07-10 20:24:46 Comments: Crawford is the 'only phantom'. I saw him in concert not long ago and he was great!! |
| Name: Susanna Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-10 18:10:43 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the Phantom, and the ONLY choice for the movie version! |
| Name: Debbie Weber Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Metairie, Louisiana Time: 1999-07-10 17:00:45 Comments: I have not seen Michael's performance in Phantom. I did see the touring company and it was wonderful. I wish I could have seen it starring Michael. I am also a big fan of all the Lloyd Webber musicals. Michael Crawford should star in the movie. I can't imagine it without him. |
| Name: Kent Ong Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: La Crescenta Time: 1999-07-10 13:48:58 Comments: Found this web site through the article in the LA Times. My note is that having seen the Phantom once with Davis Gaines, once with someone else, and once with Michael Crawford (all in L.A by the way), Michael Crawford clearly defines himself as the Phantom. The movement of his hands and his passion for the character of the Phantom will never be defined by anyone else. Others may be good but none will ever clearly define themselves as the Phantom as Michael Crawford has. |
| Name: Beth Branning Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Baltimore, MD Time: 1999-07-10 13:23:17 Comments: I think your slogan says it all: The role IS the man. No one but Michael Crawford can play this part. Period. |
| Name: Mariah
Holloway Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Gunter, Texas Time: 1999-07-10 12:12:06 Comments: I love the Phantom of the Opera music. I love Micheal Crawford singing it. If anyone elses sings the songs it just dosent sound right. If I had a choice of who the Phantom should be it would be Micheal Crawford! No one else. |
| Name: Al
Kingston Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Burlington, Ontario, CANADA Time: 1999-07-10 11:29:34 Comments: Quite a few years ago another stage success "The Petrified Forest" was being transformed into a film version. The studio wanted a big name for one of the key roles. But there was tremendous pressure put on the studio from many sources to cast a relative unknown in the role. This actor was getting great reviews but the studio had never heard of him..... wanted to go with an established screen star. In the end, the studio bowed to the public pressure and cast the New York rising star. The character of Duke Mantee became one of the legendary great characters of the cinema and Humphrey Bogart was on his way!!! Think this lesson might be lost on ALW or WB???? |
| Name: Billie Website: Alt.Gossip.Celebrities Referred by: From a Friend From: Ohio Time: 1999-07-10 08:03:07 Comments: I saw Michael Crawford on Broadway in The Phantom (and gladly paid a scalper $150 for the tickets), and can't imagine anyone else playing this role...at least not anyone else I'd pay to go a movie theater to see. ALW should maintain the integrity of this play and it's players by casting the true "Phantom"...Michael Crawford in the movie. |
| Name: TMCPMC Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-07-10 05:53:08 Comments: Welcome to the 22nd Guestbook here at the Campaign. We thank all who come here and sign their support for Michael Crawford to star in the motion picture, "The Phantom of the Opera." The Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign |