Total: 1730 Guests
| Name: Ashley
Fisher Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Illinois Time: 1999-04-02 07:50:46 Comments: I totally agree that Michael Crawford should be the Phantom! I personally have never seen it, but I do have the CD, and the first time I listened to it, I cried three times. And Michael Crawford was singing everytime. And that was in 7th grade. Now I'm in 8th, but I am constently driving my friends nuts about how Michael Crawford should be the phantom. I think if Warner Bros. were smart, they'd cast Michael right off the bat. He'd draw such a large crowd with his name only. |
| Name: Gecko Website: Sunset Suite Referred by: From a Friend From: Jordan , Minnesota Time: 1999-04-02 07:32:20 Comments: It looks to me , without Michael Crawford . . . . This movie idea is headed straight for hell in a handbasket . |
| Name: Arlene Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-04-01 21:17:22 Comments: I never had the privilege of seeing Michael Crawford perform as the Phantom, but I do have the cd soundtrack to the play. I listen to it very often, and I am in awe every time I hear him sing. He evokes so much emotion into each note, and I can visualize the play being performed in my mind with such amazing brilliance. I have seen The Phantom of the Opera performed twice, and while I did enjoy the singing and the acting, to me it just was not as powerful as I envision Michael Crawford's performance to be. Also, as I stated, the singing was enjoyable, but it was also incomparable to the quality of Mr. Crawford's talent. I would DEFINITLY go to see a movie version of this phenomenal play - IF Michael Crawford was offered the role as "The Phantom"! WHO - ELSE - BUT - MICHAEL - CRAWFORD - COULD - PLAY - THIS - PART?!?! |
| Name: Eva
Kunesch Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Heilbronn, Germany Time: 1999-04-01 02:07:13 Comments: Back with another idea: What about casting Banderas as Raoul? He would be in, they would have their "big star", and everybody would be happy!!! He's in perfect age, he looks good, he gets the girl at the end... :-((( The longer I think about it, the better I like it! |
| Name: Eva
Kunesch Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Heilbronn, Germany Time: 1999-04-01 01:48:16 Comments: Also for me Michael Crawford is the one and only Actor I could imagine to play the role in a one-to-one on the screen. Banderas is a brillant actor, but he's much to young to do the phantom and I think would miss the deep emotions between heart and hate Crawford performed. By now I only heard the CD's bcose I never made it to London to see him live on stage and so my only hope to "get the feeling" was to see him in the movie! |
| Name: Josh
Israel Website: Referred by: SimpleNet From: Waltham, MA Time: 1999-03-31 23:49:29 Comments: Julie Andrews wasn't a big enough "star" for MY FAIR LADY... but who won the Oscar that year? Mary Poppins herself! |
| Name: Swati Desai Website: The World of Swati Referred by: NewsGroups From: Urbana, IL USA Time: 1999-03-31 21:59:27 Comments: Michael Crawford is a wonderful Phantom. Ever since I first heard his voice on the London recording of the show, I knew that he "was" the role. After that I have has the (dubious) pleasure of seeing Ian Jon Bourg as the Phantom and let me tell you, there is no way he can ever measure up to Michael Crawford. Now I hear they want to cast Antonio Banderas in the role of the Phantom. Why, at least Ian Jon Bourg could ACT! Banderas can't do even that! They went from a man who could both SING and ACT (Michael Crawford) to a man who could ACT (Ian Jon Bourg) to .... well, a NOTHING (Banderas)!!!! All I can say is: AHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!! |
| Name: NANCY
TAKATA Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Los Angeles, Ca Time: 1999-03-31 20:18:33 Comments: Michael Crawford is the only phantom worth filming. If the movie company wants the dough rolling in, Michael is the only choice. |
| Name: Loree
Lilygreen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: S.wales United kingdom Time: 1999-03-31 12:25:41 Comments: I just want to add my support in the campaign for Michael crawford for the phantom movie. I unfortunately missed Michael when he done the stage production, i became a fan after i heard the soundtrack of the stage show. I fell in love straight away with Michaels voice, and was so pleased when i heard that a movie was to be made. Now i feel really gutted, how could they even consider replacing Michael is beyond me. For me Michael is the Phantom and always will be, and like a lot of people i would never go and see it unless Michael is casted. |
| Name: Charisse Nikel Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Litchfield, Ohio Time: 1999-03-30 22:28:59 Comments: I agree that it is appalling that anyone other than Michael Crawford is being considered for this role. He is the soul of the Phantom and willing to play this role and it should be given to him before he loses interest. The less than mediocre performance by Antonio Banderas at ALW's 50th Birthday Party should wake anybody up to the fact that he cannot sing and cannot do justice to this role. Make this film a "classic" - not a comedy! |
| Name: Sitarra Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-30 22:10:23 Comments: As it has been said many times, many ways: Michael Crawford is the ONE, the ONLY, the ORIGINAL--"THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA"!!! He should be the one doing the movie. After all, he created and originated the role that many of his successors are doing! As one of them said along those lines, the other actors' are doing Michael Crawford's show. He went through the whole process first, he created it. Michael Crawford should be the one to do the movie! I share the opinion of many of those that if it is not Michael Crawford, I will not pay one red cent, dime, nickel, quarter, dollar to see the movie! Enough said. |
| Name: Bonnie Oram Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Vancouver, British Columbia Time: 1999-03-30 19:40:25 Comments: How can they replace Michael Crawford with Antonio Banderas or anyone else? Simple.......they can't. Michael is the POTO. Michael is the best!!! |
| Name: Jessica Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: NY Time: 1999-03-30 18:20:20 Comments: You should place an ad in Playbill to rile up the theater fans in support of your cause. Playbills reach lots of people. Jess |
| Name: Denise
Long Website: The Longs Referred by: Yahoo! From: Pennsylvania Time: 1999-03-30 16:19:01 Comments: When I heard that "they" were thinking of casting Mr "Zorro" Antonio Whatever, just for the box office draw, I thought it was such a shame. Doesn't years of a Broadway run, not to mention his incredible talent count for anything? I suppose he'll join the ranks of Julie Andrews, Patti LuPone, Carol Channing and so many others who were not "good enough" to do the movie of their stage production. Most likely, the movie will suck anyway...they always do! |
| Name: Ty Asper Website: Referred by: AOL From: Corona, CA Time: 1999-03-30 15:03:02 Comments: Who else other than Michael Crawford should play "Phantom!" |
| Name: Debbie
Crawford Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Cumberland, Maryland Time: 1999-03-30 09:38:48 Comments: This is to say that Michael Crawford has not only my support, but also the support of my mother who is probably the biggest MC fan I know. To us there is only one Phantom of the Opera and that is MC and no one else. To have someone else play the Phantom would be demeaning and would not be credible. Thank you. |
| Name: Carmen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-29 19:51:49 Comments: I also wish to convey my support of Michael Crawford to play the Phantom in the movie. It's a bit ridiculous and insulting to suggest that anyone else should do so. No one else can give the role the passion that Michael does. No one knows the role better than Michael. Why not go with the best? Do things right, Andrew, and you'll never regret it! With Michael, the Phantom film will go down in cinema history along side 2001 and Ben Hur. It will be of the same caliber of Casablanca. Casting anyone else will dilute the energy that your story has. Thank you for your time and attention. Carmen Jackson |
| Name: Dolly
Fischer Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Houston, Texas Time: 1999-03-29 12:36:29 Comments: Michael Crawfor is the ONLY one for this role. He IS the Phantom. |
| Name: jay
bilderback Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: florida,usa Time: 1999-03-29 11:23:23 Comments: I think it is rediculous that a master like Mr.Crawford would have Antonio Bandares playing his signature role. |
| Name: Roxanne
Curry-Gomez Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Quartz Hill, California Time: 1999-03-29 11:23:14 Comments: Good Luck! |
| Name: Belinda M. Paschal Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Palmdale, CA Time: 1999-03-29 11:13:44 Comments: Actually, I was led to this Web site by the woman who created it. I'm astounded by the overwhelming response to her campaign! I have never seen Crawford as the "Phantom," but I have heard the soundtrack, as well as the gushing praise of his performance in the role. Unfortunately, I DID see Senor Banderas in "Evita" -- that is, before the movie put me to sleep -- and from his performance, I would surmise that he does not possess the vocal range and fortitude for such a role as the Phantom. Based strictly on Mr. Crawford's track record and his history of playing the Phantom, I'd have to cast my vote in his favor. Besides...1,700-plus guestbook signing fans can't be wrong! |
| Name: Eva O'Grady Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Lynn, Massachusetts Time: 1999-03-29 04:40:34 Comments: Michael Crawford WILL be wonderful in the movie |
| Name: Ila Jones Website: Referred by: Signing another Guestbook From: Washington, USA Time: 1999-03-28 22:36:59 Comments: I think they should have a Dream Cast. |
| Name: Rachael
Cothran Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Canyon Lake, TX Time: 1999-03-28 19:25:10 Comments: I would personally much rather see Michael Crawford in "The Phantom." Ever since I first heard the soundtrack of "Phantom," I fell in love. Michael Crawford is the only one that I would pay over ten dollars to see. Mr. Crawford is such an inspiration to me that anyone else playing "Phantom" would just seem wrong. If I had to pick one idol in the music profession, it would be Mr. Crawford, hands down. As a seventeen year old female who seeks to one day have a musical career, I think that Michael Crawford as "The Phantom" would be a dream come true. I think that the world will indeed loose something if Michael Crawford was never cast as the Phantom. It is my sincere desire to see Michael Crawford play the Phantom. I only wish that I could have been in my future brother-in law's shoes when he was at Michael Crawford's last performance in LA. I hope to be able to witness for myself the power of Mr. Crawford as the notorious "Phantom of the Opera." I however do not wish any of this if this is not something that Mr. Crawford does not want to do. I think that if Mr. Crawford would rather see someone else play his role, than so be it. No matter how much I would like to see Mr. Crawford himself play the Phantom, I would rather have him do it because it is what he wants to do. I do hope to see Mr. Crawford perform as the Phantom. |
| Name: Jena Greene Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Phoenix, AZ Time: 1999-03-28 19:21:32 Comments: I agree. Michael created the role of The Phantom. It is his. Some of the rumors I have heard have had John Travolta and others in the role. Please! |
| Name: Lindsay Website: Siren Referred by: From a Friend From: Earth Time: 1999-03-28 14:45:24 Comments: I've signed this before, but signing again can't hurt. Michael Crawford is is synonymous with the Phantom character, and casting Banderas in his stead would be cheapening the whole story. Banderas was wonderful as Che, I'll admit; but he lacks the sensitivity and passion that Mr. Crawford epitomizes. Banderas seems to merely be being typecasted, which is wrong to begin with, much less if they're not suited for the role. If ever you read this, Lord Lloyd-Webber: The overwhelming response to this ought to tell you ^something^. And if ever Mr. Crawford reads this: In the hearts and minds of millions, you were, are, and always will be the one, ^true^ Phantom. |
| Name: Tom Zielinski Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Michigan Time: 1999-03-28 12:14:36 Comments: I agree that Michael Crawford should be the Phantom for the Movie and I'm rooting for him. He is the original. |
| Name: Sarah Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-28 09:47:32 Comments: There's no question about it -- the movie of _The Phantom of the Opera_ *has* to have Michael Crawford as the Phantom. Considering what he did with and for the role to make it all but legendary, how can anyone else be cast in that role? How Antonio Banderas ended up as Che in "Evita" I doubt I'll ever figure out, but even that's not as ludicrous as the idea of him as the Phantom. When will people realize that he's an actor, not a singer, and simply can't measure up to such multi-talented actor/singers as those in the original _Evita_ and _The Phantom of the Opera_? Even if the proposed Phantom *was* an excellent actor and singer, Michael Crawford would still be the best choice for the role. Yes, a flashy star would lure more crowds, but in the long run casting someone who is all but guaranteed to play the role wonderfully is better. |
| Name: Desiree Baird Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Ohio Time: 1999-03-27 22:24:03 Comments: No one could possibly do it better. |
| Name: Victor
Motta Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Brazil Time: 1999-03-27 18:33:10 Comments: I think that Michel Crowford its the phantom re-encarned... he is perfect for the paper, but the another concorents are Antonio Banderas or John Travolta and they are famous! So if a famous actor make the movie, it will be more suscesfull, because the people wants the famous guys!! But I think that the original phantom(Michel Crowford) will be grate making the movie... |
| Name: darrell
moore Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: toronto canada Time: 1999-03-27 16:03:01 Comments: Bravo!!!! Late February we emailed Really useful group, with our own views that michael crawford should be the only consideration for the role of Phantom in regards to the movie version of Phantom of the Opera, keep up the good work,hopefully Andrew Will Listen darrell moore toronto canada |
| Name: Carolyn
Ivanson Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: California Time: 1999-03-26 17:31:00 Comments: It would not be the "Phantom" without Michael Crawford! |
| Name: Carolyn
Ivanson Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: California Time: 1999-03-26 17:26:19 Comments: Phantom with out MC is a loser. |
| Name: Donald
Baier Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Indiana Time: 1999-03-26 13:27:03 Comments: I have seen the Phantom of the Opera seven times, but have not seen Michael Crawford in the role of the Phantom. This would possibly be my only opportunity to see him play the Phantom. I have enjoyed the recording of the Phantom many, many times. |
| Name: D.Wooton Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Los Angeles and Tucson Time: 1999-03-26 13:05:56 Comments: We had the honor and privilege of experiencing three outstanding performances of Michael Crawford in Phantom of the Opera in Los Angeles. We saw another performance as well, without Mr. Crawford. It was good but it wasn't the same. His voice, his emotion, his interpretation and characterization are superior. We have enjoyed his cd's and other live concerts. We are never disappointed. We were disappointed, however, when we watched Antonio Banderas recently on PBS; his singing and his performance of Music of the Night was uninspired and unconvincing. The film version of Phantom of the Opera will last forever in the motion picture archives. This film deserves the best, and the best is Michael Crawford. He own the role, he is the Phantom, and the world automatically recognizes Michael Crawford as the Phantom. Why settle for less? |
| Name: Margaret
Moran Website: Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button From: Lake Arrowhead, CA Time: 1999-03-26 09:06:35 Comments: Michael Crawford deserves and has the talent to star in the Phantom of the Opera. He is the Phantom of the Opera.! Do what I say, MOM. |
| Name: Teri
Blumenthal Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Los Angeles Time: 1999-03-26 08:58:42 Comments: I saw Michael Crawford at the Hollywood Bowl last summer. His voice and delivery are better than ever, and he moves as well as ever! He is the ultimate Phantom! No one else should be considered for the movie! |
| Name: Larry
Schlegel Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Los Angeles, CA Time: 1999-03-26 08:55:49 Comments: I have seen POTO 14 times. Many of those performances were with Michael Crawford. I have also seen Davis Gaines, Robert Guilliame (sp?), and Ron Barton (?). Quite simply, Michael Crawford is the Phantom. His performance must be preserved on film. It was special. I saw Antonio Banderas in Evita. His singing was OK for that limited situation. Many in the audience giggled from embarrassment because of his limited abilities. Plus anyone who saw the recent 50th birthday celebration for ALW cannot seriously consider him for the role. Likewise, POTO is along way from Grease. I haven't heard John Travolta sing lately. There is probably a reason for that. if he had been much of a singer, we probably would have heard him during his long period of acting inactivity. Unless Crawford's health precluded the possibility of his participation, this decision is a no-brainer. |
| Name: Judith Langer Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Chicago Time: 1999-03-25 21:31:25 Comments: PLEASE! When choosing the actor to play the Phantom, It must be Michael Crawford. I have seen the play twice. Cast Antonio Banderas and the depth of the part will be lost! Also, I WILL not pay to see it. Maintain the purity of the part. Please. J. Langer |
| Name: Pedro
Langre Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Mexico Time: 1999-03-25 20:43:16 Comments: There is no person who would be suitable for the Phantom role than M. Crawford. It is totally unfair to make the movie without him playing the Phantom. Many people I know, wouldn't even go to see the movie if M. Crawford doesn't get the role. How can ALW think Antonio Banderas would create the energy that Crawford can give the audience? That's more politics than art. |
| Name: Lou
Kravitz Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: San Francisco Time: 1999-03-25 19:46:22 Comments: Would greatly appreciate Michael Crawford in his special role as the Phantom in the movie. |
| Name: Lisa
S. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 1999-03-25 16:21:52 Comments: I can't imagine any other actor more suited to the Phantom movie than Michael Crawford. Good job guys, for getting your message around. |
| Name: Cynthia
Salmons Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Tampa Time: 1999-03-25 14:35:01 Comments: I saw Crawford perform the show in NYC. He is definately the only Phantom. It would be the same if Rex Harrison did not play Henry Higgins in My Fair Lady. |
| Name: Lynsey Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: Belfast, Northern Ireland Time: 1999-03-25 13:05:13 Comments: I can't imagine anyone else playing the phantom. Crawford was the original and best and no-one else could ever bring as much feeling to the role as he did. My dream is to see him perform it on stage, or in the movie. |
| Name: evie
stone Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: los angeles Time: 1999-03-25 10:42:35 Comments: I had the privilege of seeing "Phantom" with Michael Crawford in Los Angeles six times. THERE IS NO OTHER PHANTOM. I have also been to his concert(the first tour). Ever since I first read, some years ago, that A.L.Webber was considering(at that time)John Travolta, and now Antonio B. I was devastated. I hope this gets to someone who can understand the mistake that would be made by using anyone other than Michael C. to star in the movie. |
| Name: Ronda
England Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Jacksonville,Fl Time: 1999-03-25 06:41:50 Comments: I just saw Phantom of the Opera the Broadway production with Brad Little and although he does a wonderful job, I feel I've missed out by not seeing Michael Crawford performing the Phantom. I've listened to the Original London Cast Performance and it never ceases to move me to goosebumps. Michael Crawford's voice portrays an element of passion that takes the listener on a voyage of emotions. I would thouroughly enjoy seeing Mr. Crawford as the Phantom in a movie. I feel he is the only choice for the movie who can portray the Phantom in it's fullest potential. Please no Antonio!!!! If Mr. Crawford was in a movie production of the Phantom then fans like me who missed his original performance could enjoy the true original. |
| Name: jude & beth
powers & family Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: hemet, california Time: 1999-03-25 05:58:38 Comments: read about you in the riverside press and my wife said i had to contact you and vote for crawford. i have heard banderas sing on channel 6 the other night and he was good, but crawford has just the right quality in his voice for this role. the english phantom was terrible. my wife and family have seen the phantom in la twice and loved it jude powers |
| Name: Julie L Wood Website: Referred by: AOL From: Geneva, Fla Time: 1999-03-25 05:26:42 Comments: I have seen "The Phantom of the Opera" on Broadway, Her Majesty's Theatre, and Orlando. I can't express my love for the story. Then someone told me of Michael Crawford so I saw him in FX in Vegas and have since been his fan. YES, noone can do the Phantom justice but Michael Crawford. What a public shame if someone else is cast. |
| Name: Beth Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 1999-03-24 23:12:41 Comments: Michael Crawford is the TRUE Phantom. I refuse to accept any substitutions. I have seen him perform the role several times, and no other actor comes close to the emotional range and singing ability that he has. Don't destroy the movie musical...cast Michael Crawford. |
| Name: jon and letty
cisneros Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: LOS ANGELES, CALIF. Time: 1999-03-24 22:14:10 Comments: WHAT CAN I SAY , ONLY THAT MR.CRAWFORD IS MEANT FOR THE ROLE OF THE PHANTOM , AND ANYBODY ELSE CHOSEN FOR THIS PART WILL BE AN INSULT TO THE MILLIONS OF FANS WORLD WIDE . |
| Name: Mr. and Mrs.
Everett Gorman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-24 20:34:48 Comments: My husband and I definitely want to see Michael Crawford as the Phantom! |
| Name: Terry
Lynn Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-24 19:37:00 Comments: Dear Terry Semel I strongly urge Warner Bros. and Andrew LLoyd Weber to consider Michael Crawford as the only possible choice to play the Phantom. The mere idea of Antonio Banderas or any other actor playing the part is unthinkable. Michael Crawford is The Phantom of the Opera and Sarah Brightman is Christine. Please, please do not make a major mistake in casting this film. Thousands upon thousands of people will boycott this film. Sincerely, Terry Lynn |
| Name: Gisela
Schettini Website: Referred by: Net Search From: USA Time: 1999-03-24 18:06:43 Comments: I would love to see Mr. Crawford as the Phantom!!!!! Never in my life a singer has brought me to tears nor made feel the music the way he has in the past. Phantom of the Opera without Michael Crawford would not be Phantom at all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thanks to the people that had this great idea you have my total suport........ |
| Name: Scott Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Los Angeles, CA Time: 1999-03-24 17:45:52 Comments: This should be addressed to Warner Bros and Really Useful Productions................ After viewing and RE-viewing the PBS special for Andrew Lloyd Webber's birthday special (3/99), I am even more convinced that casting Antonio Banderas as the phantom would be a monumental mistake. I like Antonio Banderas but he is completely wrong for the role. His voice is VERY weak and not capable of handling the challenging role. He is also way too young to be considered a convincing character. Antonio's SPANISH accent is a MAJOR hindrance as well. It interfers with his singing and is not appropriate for a story that supposedly takes place in Italy. In my opinion, the movie should be done correctly or not done at all. That means casting Michael Crawford in the pivotal role. There were tens of thousands of people who saw Michael Crawford perform in Los Angeles, New York City and London, and many more that literally flew to those cities to see the musical. I WOULD NOT go see the film if less capable actors were cast in the movie. You people know deep down that there is no other choice. Forget about demographics and think about story for a second--though the target demographics who are knowledgeable about this musical would vote for Michael Crawford hands down--it is a poignent love story about a man haunted by his past as well as his love for Christine. There are multidimensional emotions that need to be conveyed while the story is playing out. Michael Crawford achieves them LIVE without the benefit of a camera crew. You are sitting 40 rows away from the stage and you see and feel the torment and confusion that he is going through. Can there be any doubt who should really be playing the phantom????? (Michael Crawford, in case you forgot!) |
| Name: beverly
mirsky Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: southern california Time: 1999-03-24 17:32:59 Comments: I think that Michael Crawford is great and should be given the part as the Phantom in the planned movie. Any thoughts of having Antonio Banderas as the phantom is ludicrous! |
| Name: Jessica Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Hawaii Time: 1999-03-24 16:33:21 Comments: ***You can obtain the addresses to write to by logging onto the campaign's main page: www.phantommovie.com Then press the "links to info." button and there will be a button called "addresses." They're all right there! Thank you for your support!--- *** Where is information on addresses for the "decision-makers"? And who are the people who will make the final decision? Continued good luck in your efforts. |
| Name: Chris
Stapleton Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Val Verde, Calif. USA Time: 1999-03-24 14:44:20 Comments: After watching Antonio on ALW 50th b-day show, he's ok but he's no PHANTOM!!!!!! |
| Name: Terry
Lynn Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Studio City CA Time: 1999-03-24 14:09:25 Comments: I am outraged that Warner Bros. and Andrew Lloyd Weber would even consider Antonio Banderas for the role in Phantom of the Opera. Michael Crawford is The Phantom and Sarah Brightman is Christine. Sincerely, Terry Lynn 4518 Ethel Avenue Studio City, CA 91604 (818) 501-6143 |
| Name: Cindy Marlowe Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Kentucky Time: 1999-03-24 13:48:16 Comments: I cannot imagine why Hollywood would ignore the obvious. We fans of the Phantom of the Opera have eagerly awaited a possible movie--so that those of us who missed seeing Michael Crawford on stage would get the chance to see his acclaimed performance immortalized on film. I certainly don't understand the possible casting of Antonio Banderas. If Hollywood is hoping to attract the 20 something demographic, they are making a major mistake--20-something fans of the "Phantom" are also fans of Michaels--The rest of us are tired of this excuse for poor casting and project development. Warner Brothers and Andrew Lloyd Webber risk undermining the existing fan base in an effort to attract an audience that is not known for consistency. Don't sacrifice the quality of a major work and take such a great risk. Michael is the best possible choice for the role. |
| Name: Linda L.
Swanholm Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Time: 1999-03-24 12:58:14 Comments: There is only one "Phantom" and that is Michael Crawford. |
| Name: JAN KENSON Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Placentia, CA Time: 1999-03-24 12:38:13 Comments: Antonio Banderas does not have the strength to sing this score!. |
| Name: Elisabeth
Johnsen Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Norway Time: 1999-03-24 11:15:06 Comments: Michael is the only true Phantom. Cast him! |
| Name: rodger
lefebvre Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: sioux city, iowa Time: 1999-03-24 10:15:09 Comments: I just want to say that what is going on here is very inspirational. For people to be as passionate about something like this is great. You have my full support and vote. There is only one Phantom, and that is Michael Crawford |
| Name: Geri A.
Mellgren-Kerwin Website: RealXPress Referred by: NewsGroups From: Minnesota originally, now Burbank, CA. Time: 1999-03-24 09:12:02 Comments: There is no better Phantom than Michael! Bandaras is not a musical star, just a pretty face, and that isn't required for this role. What is needed is an exciting voice and gobs of sex appeal, which is M.C. Let's have Sarah Brightman as Christine also. Do it right, Warner Bros. |
| Name: Norma W. Oester Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Redondo Beach, CA Time: 1999-03-24 08:09:09 Comments: There is only one Phantom of the Opera--MICHAEL CRAWFORD! |
| Name: Sherry Crowl Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: CA Time: 1999-03-24 00:29:43 Comments: Loved Michael the two times I saw him in the Phantom. Also have watched the pbs special with Michael several times. He is the only one who really puts the passion into it. I have been waiting and wondering about the movie ever since I heard that Andrew Lloyd Webber was considering making a movie. Keep up the good work. |
| Name: Steve
Telepman Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: San Juan Capistrano CA Time: 1999-03-23 23:14:41 Comments: Without M. Crawford this will be another bonfire of the vanities |
| Name: Yitung Kao Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Taiwan Time: 1999-03-23 22:03:10 Comments: I suppport Mr. Crawford in the role of the Phantom in the film version of the musical. |
| Name: Margaret
Moran Website: Referred by: Clicked on a 'Guestbooks by GuestWorld' Button From: Lake Arrowhead, CA Time: 1999-03-23 21:33:57 Comments: Michael Crawford deserves and has the talent to star in the Phantom of the Opera. He is the Phantom of the Opera.! Do what I say, MOM. |
| Name: betty beck Website: Referred by: AOL From: w.p.b.fl. Time: 1999-03-23 21:29:44 Comments: please i hope he gets to play the phantom because it just wouldn'y be the same without him thank you |
| Name: Harvey
Laderman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-23 21:29:25 Comments: Just want to add my voice to the many others who are supporting Michael Crawford in the lead role of the movie. Only Crawford captured the real essence of the role. Only Crawford would generate repeat attendance to see the movie. Only Crawford would cause me and many others to purchase the home video version of the movie after it is released. Harvey Laderman |
| Name: Arlene &
Lowell Johnson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Irvine, Calif. 92604 Time: 1999-03-23 21:11:08 Comments: Michael Crawford is the phantom and apparently Andrew Lloyd Webber thought so to or else he never would have casted him in the role. We thoroughly enjoy Antonio Banderas but not as the phantom. |
| Name: Daisy Thompson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 1999-03-23 19:50:11 Comments: I was looking forward to the movie version of the Phantom of the Opera with Michael Crawford as the "Phantom". I was very disappointed when I found out that ALW was casting Antonio Banderas. I saw the ALW 50th birthday celebration on KCET with Banderas singing the phantom song and he just does not have the powerful, mesmerizing voice that Michael Crawford projects. If ALW and Warner Bros. want a classic movie, they should cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom, and Sarah Brightman as Christine. The POTO is musical theatre; and musicals draw a certain group of audience. If Warner Bros. want an actor that can draw the other audiences then they can cast Banderas as Raoul. This way they will not disappoint the many many phantom fans who were looking forward to the movie version of the POTO with Michael Crawford as Erik. Michael Crawford is the "Phantom". |
| Name: a.m. cook Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: los angeles Time: 1999-03-23 18:49:46 Comments: In regards to the casting of Michael Crawford in the movie version of Phantom, I would like to say that I saw two performances of Phantom in Los Angeles. One starred Michael Crawford and one didn't (I can't remember the actor's name. That's how unremarkable he was.) The differences in the two actors' performances was so great that I decided I would never attend a performance of the Phantom that did not feature Mr. Crawford. I sincerely hope that Mr. Webber has the good sense to go with Mr. Crawford. He IS the Phantom! |
| Name: Mollie Mole' Website: Referred by: AOL From: California Time: 1999-03-23 18:48:12 Comments: Recently saw ALW's 50th birthday celebration on public TV. Antonio Banderas sang The Phantom of the Opera. I assume this is to introduce us to the new phantom. Mr. Banderas is a fine singer, but his voice can't be compared to Michael Crawford's. Crawford's voice is full. He sings with emotion--acting the part with his voice as well as his body language. Banderas is also too young, slight of build and intense without actually acting the part. Crawford moves the listener emotionally. I've seen four performances of the Phantom with four different phantom's. None have been able to create the emotional response required for the telling of this story. If Crawford doesn't get this part, it will be a sin. You can tell ALW so for me. Thank you. |
| Name: Cristin Website: Legacy Referred by: NewsGroups From: Vienna, VA Time: 1999-03-23 18:04:51 Comments: I love the Phantom of the Opera, not only the musical but also the man, as do many others. Please let us have an actor who can do justice to the man we love. Michael Crawford embodies Erik and is the one the phans love and trust with our most precious Phantom. |
| Name: Joan Thurbush Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Fontana, Ca. Time: 1999-03-23 17:30:31 Comments: I'm so glad I found this phantom web site, I am a phantom fan you can tell by my e-mail address. I have seen phantom 4 times and hope to see it again and again. thank you for this web site. |
| Name: Julie
Yamashita Website: Referred by: Yahoo! From: California Time: 1999-03-23 17:22:22 Comments: Please make sure that you count on my support for Michael! Cheers! |
| Name: Megan Website: Chicago the Musical Referred by: Signing another Guestbook From: Adelaide, Australia Time: 1999-03-23 17:18:02 Comments: I think that it is disgusting how Hollywood try to capitalise on the magic of theatre, and they always fail. The one thing that would ensure this does not happen to Phantom, is if they cast it correctly, which means using Michael Crawford. I hope that the morons in Hollywood realise this before they ruin yet another great piece of theatre. |
| Name: Sarah Gray Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Indian Wells, CA Time: 1999-03-23 17:09:29 Comments: Hi. My name is Sarah Gray. I have been a fan of "The Phantom of the Opera" since I was 3 years old. I am now 16 and this play has made a dramatic impact on my life. I have adored Michael Crawford and admired him for everytime that he steps up on that stage and gives the always ethereal and heart-stopping performances as the tormented and love-stricken Phantom. I think that it would be foolish to cast anyone else in this role. Michael Crawford may have done it a thousand times over, but he IS the Phantom. Yes, Antonio Banderas is very talented, but I think that he would be better suited as the young lover Raoul. Let Michael Crawford have the spotlight as the Phantom, he deserves it because he is without a doubt one of the most talented men to ever grace the stage. Sincerely, Sarah A. Gray |
| Name: Keith
Johnson Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Los Angeles Time: 1999-03-23 16:59:34 Comments: I have seen Phantom about 30 times, in New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Orlando. I have seen probably 10 different leads, and have always considered Michael Crawford the yardstick by which all others are measured. The role of the Phantom is pivotal to the success of the play (and I think the same will be true for the movie, though perhaps to a lesser extent, depending on how true to the play the movie is). Perhaps most people don't realize that, but I do, and I imagine anyone who has seen Michael and others as the Phantom would agree. I STRONGLY support your effort to promote Michael Crawford as the Phantom. The movie will only be made once, and it deserves the best Phantom. And Michael Crawford deserves to have his performance captured for posterity. |
| Name: Judy Tims Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: California Time: 1999-03-23 15:05:20 Comments: We also saw Michael Crawford in LA. What a thrill. He must be in the movie. Also saw ALW show and agree that Antonio can not sing the part. So glad to see that so many people care about this. |
| Name: Thomas Shea Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Redondo Beach, CA Time: 1999-03-23 12:56:24 Comments: I havn't had the pleasure of seeing Michael Crawford in the roll; I've seen Davis Gaines in L.A. twice, but from video I've seen and from the soundtracks featuring Crawford, there is clearly no other choice. I love Antonio Banderas, but this roll is beyond his ability... |
| Name: Rebecca
Wagner Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: California Time: 1999-03-23 12:45:15 Comments: Michael Crawford isn't just "a" Phantom; he's "the" Phantom!! |
| Name: Paul Gulino Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Los Angeles Time: 1999-03-23 11:59:14 Comments: My wife and I were able to see Michael Crawford twice while he was in the Los Angeles production of Phantom. We do not think there could be any other person to play the Phantom. Michael Crawford is the only choice. I hope Andrew Lloyd Weber and the powers that be at Warner Bros. realize who the correct actor/singer is. |
| Name: Robert
Stelmar Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Los Angeles Time: 1999-03-23 11:52:36 Comments: There is no one, and I mean no one, who should be the phantom other than Michael Crawford. I will not see the film if he is not the phantom. It is only right, and if Mr. Crawford is the phantom the movie will be a huge success. |
| Name: P. Connolly Website: IT MUST BE MICHAEL CRAWFORD Referred by: From a Friend From: Los Angeles, California Time: 1999-03-23 11:43:48 Comments: I learned of the "Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign" in the L.A. Times. We were fortunate enough to see Michael, THE PHANTOM, on opening night at the Ahmanson. Antonio Banderas is a real cutie, but his voice is TOO WEAK to carry the Phantom role, he just IS NOT a trained singer. Please don't BLOW your one chance to DO IT RIGHT. For the movie to SUCCEED, Michael Crawfor MUST play the PHANTOM. Please do not repeat your "EVITA" movie mistake. |
| Name: Johnny Butler Website: Referred by: AOL From: Tujunga, California Time: 1999-03-23 11:04:13 Comments: We were fortunate enough to see Michael Crawford perform at the Ahmanson. After observing Tony Banderas' feeble attempt at "Music of The Night" with Sarah Brightman for ALW's 50th anniversary on PBS, we are convinced that only Michael Crawford can play the role of the phantom. We were embarrased for Banderas. |
| Name: Marilyn
Keenan Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Time: 1999-03-23 10:37:12 Comments: Reading the L.A. Times this morning I was happy to see that someone was doing something about getting the original - Michael Crawford - to be in the Phantom movie. Good for you!!! |
| Name: Michele Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Michigan Time: 1999-03-23 09:47:04 Comments: I would love to see Phantom made into a musical for the screen. Since you can't force anyone (Micheal Crawford) into becoming the Phantom on screen, another suggestion I would have is Antonio B. It would be great to have Micheal, but if he wants to... thanks Michele |
| Name: Ann Marie
Gibbons Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Pennsylvania Time: 1999-03-23 06:49:31 Comments: I seen Phantom of the Opera in Canada and I Loved it. It is coming to Pittsburgh, PA in 1999 and I'm planning on taking my nine year old son to see it with me. I really think he will enjoy it. I wish it was on vidoe tape I would buy it I already hve the sound track. |
| Name: Brian
Belcher Website: My Pictures & Links Referred by: Clicked on our Banner Advertisement From: Toronto, Canada Time: 1999-03-22 23:56:38 Comments: Hi, I think That with no Doubt that The Only Performer To Play "The Phantom" in a Movie is Michael Crawford! He has The Prencence, The Voice, The Acting. I'm Sorry but I recently Saw The Concert For ALW's Birthday and Did not Believe that Antonio Banderas had The Voice or The Precence That MC has. I fully Support This Campain To Support Michael Crawford in Being Cast as "Phantom" in the film. Keep up The Great Work! thanks, Brian |
| Name: Linda Levitt Website: Referred by: AOL From: Bryn Mawr, PA Time: 1999-03-22 17:50:09 Comments: I am just so proud of all of you and so appreciative for all your hard work and efforts - I'm trying with donations but it is not the same - You are all the best - thank you so much for doing this for THE MAN - and I mean MICHAEL CRAWFORD - a most devoted fan - Linda Levitt |
| Name: Barbara J.
Roberts Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Fla Time: 1999-03-22 17:35:37 Comments: Have seen "Phantom of the Opera" 3 times. Twice with Grant Norman and once with Brad Little. Norman missed a note..( I should say THE note..."soar") in MOTN the first time I saw him. The next time he was better.. but still lacked...something. Brad Little? Please. He was pathetic and that is being kind. I had the immense pleasure last year of seeing Michael Crawford live during his tour. I also was even more immensely pleased to have front row and dead-center seats. A late bithday present. I was less than 10 feet from him..and I can only say that his voice is at least 5 times better live. I hadn't believed he could possibly sound any better, but? To hear him live? Puts the original cast recording of "Phantom" to shame! My mouth fell open and stayed there for most of the show in awe. Even my husband was impressed and went out the next morning and bought Michael's newest CD. To imagine him in that part, on film to have forever? Well, what more could any TRUE Phantom fan wish for? There is NO ONE else that should be cast in that part. I'd certainly go see the movie with Michael in it.. buy it and perhaps an extra for when I wore that tape out! If...and I do say if. If Lord Lloyd-Weber truly cares at all about what the people who made this musical so sucessful really want? He'll give it to us! And that means Michael Cawford in this role! Why make the film a poor shadow of what it could be? Why not give your best to create your best? Surely, that makes sense. I have all of Michael's albums.. I have the tape of his show. I have another tape of his and I also have the premier collection video with Michael doing "MOTN". I believe I have put my money where my mouth is. And if Michael tours this way again? I'll buy tickets in a moment! Well worth it! |
| Name: Fran Seaman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Niskayuna, new York Time: 1999-03-22 13:00:14 Comments: I can't imagine the thinking of anyone who would NOT cast Michael Crawford in the movie - HE IS THE PHANTOM!!!!!!!!!! My husband and I wouldn't even consider seeing the movie without Michael Crawford in the role of the Phantom!!! |
| Name: Sianna
Hoskins Website: Referred by: AOL From: Las Vegas, NV Time: 1999-03-22 10:31:32 Comments: I am outraged that Warner would presume to cast *anyone* in the title roles other than Michael or Sarah/Dale! Michael Crawford is the quintessential *Phantom*....Banderas hasn't the mystique for this character. I for one will boycott Warner Bros. and the Really Useful Group if any but Michael is cast in this role! |
| Name: lee
abrams Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Time: 1999-03-22 10:15:52 Comments: I support your efforts to make true movies, not those ruined by using "name" stars rather than the original cast. |
| Name: Lisa K.
Kuehl Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: Boone, Iowa USA Time: 1999-03-22 00:31:35 Comments: Saw "Phantom" on the London stage for the first time in 1993 and was moved to tears. Have since seen it seven more times throughout the U.S. I am also a dedicated Crawford/ Brightman fan and would pay my last dollar to see these two untouchable talents bring their original roles to the big screen. Who else is there, really?! By the way, I appreciate the work that the Cast Micheal groups are doing. You have my support and I hope our dreams can become a reality. I'd also enjoy hearing from some other "Phantom Fans," especially any mid-westerners out there. |
| Name: C. L. Moke Website: Referred by: From a Friend From: Akron, Ohio Time: 1999-03-22 00:28:44 Comments: michael forever, antonio never |
| Name: Adam Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In From: syracuse,NY Time: 1999-03-17 17:47:56 Comments: Mike is the best singer in the world. Nobody will beat his singing ability. There is no comparison. He is ultimately the one and only "angel of music". It's not worth voting for! Antonio is a joke!! LONG LIVE MAGIC, MIGHTY MKE. |