| Name: Sue Jeffery Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Roy, Utah Time: 1998-05-31 21:34:01 Comments: It is beyond me why there is such a controversy over who should play the Phantom in the film version. There is only one answer...Michael Crawford!! He may not have the box office draw that the other actors that have been suggested have, but I think they should just realize Michael is the most logical person for the role and give it to him. If they are concerned about his age, that's what make-up and stunt doubles are for. If the studios can convincingly recreate the most famous shipwreck in the world, make us believe that New York City is being blown up by aliens, or being stepped on by a huge fictional lizard, certainly they can take a 56 year old man and make him look 30-ish. It would be a huge mistake if they cast any other person in this role. It is HIS signature role!! |
| Name: Regina
McCullough Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Las Vegas Time: 1998-05-31 18:56:19 Comments: I am most passionate about the casting of Michael Crawford as Eric in the proposed Movie of Phantom. I believe Michael knows that man as well as he knows Michael Crawford. It would be a great disservice to posterity if this portrayal is not immortalized on film!! |
| Name: Colleen Miller Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: CA Time: 1998-05-31 16:52:39 Comments: Cast Michael Crawford in the role of the Phantom on the film version, and you will have a classic that will live forever! |
| Name: Sara Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: North Carolina Time: 1998-05-31 05:32:17 Comments: I would love to see a film version of this wonderful masterpiece but only if Michael Crawford could star. It would be ruined if anyone else even tried to fill his shoes as the Phantom. I totally support your campaign to stop the production of this movie if it is not to star Michael Crawford. |
| Name: Roberta
Jackson Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Merrill, Wisconsin Time: 1998-05-30 23:26:43 Comments: If Andrew Lloyd Webber chooses anyone other than Michael Crawford for the role of the Phantom in the new Phantom of the Opera movie, it would be the same as someone handing him a huge, flawless diamond and him saying, "No, thank you, I'll just take a chintzy chunk of cheap glass instead." I would like to encourage Mr. Lloyd Webber to take the beautiful, flawless diamond that he's being handed and run with it! Choosing anyone other than Michael for the role of the Phantom would guarantee that this new movie would be nothing more than a shallow, hyped-up, second-rate horror film and would bomb big-time at the box office. |
| Name: Diana
L.Marshall Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Roswell, New Mexico Time: 1998-05-30 21:12:08 Comments: I have sent letters by mail and FAX, so far, to Warner Brothers and Really Useful Group, I will keep on sending until our voices are heard AND HEEDED. #1, Michael Çrawford is NOT too old for the movie role. He is more youthful looking and acting than Antonio Banderas. #2, just how young does Warner's and RUG think the Phantom character is? He is certainly middle-aged; also the character is completely disquised by his disfigurement, so the whole performance hinges on how the actor sings and acts. Millions of people worldwide(and I'm not exagerating) know that Michael Crawford is the ONLY Phantom. Warner Bros' bottom line WILL suffer if they do not cast the right Phantom! |
| Name: Christian Kelly Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Tucson,Az. Time: 1998-05-30 06:13:42 Comments: I just saw Michael Crawford in concert at Las Vegas for the first time. Unfortunately, I never saw him in phantom, but "WOW" what a singer and actor. In the concert, without a mask,makeup, or costume, he became the phantom right before our eyes. It would be the Hollywood blunder of the century to cast anyone other than Michael Crawford as Phantom. |
| Name: Magdalena
Johansson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Sweden Time: 1998-05-29 18:13:38 Comments: Michael Crawford is the only person that could play the Phantom!!!!!!! |
| Name: Emily Kooiker Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: White Cloud, Michigan Time: 1998-05-29 14:33:29 Comments: I agree that there should only be a movie if Michael Crawford plays the part of the Phantom. |
| Name: JUdy Plass Website: yahoo Referred by: Net Search From: Queensland Australia Time: 1998-05-29 12:47:14 Comments: Send Michael to Brisbane Australia. Keep up the good work put Michael in the film. thanks Judy. |
| Name: Nani Santos Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Philippines Time: 1998-05-29 09:46:13 Comments: I have been a fan of Micahel Crawford from the time he appeared as the Phantom. I've purchased all his CD's and some VHS videos. Planned my trip to the US and Las Vegas in October 1996 to watch his show. But sadly, he had a hip surgery at the time and some other performer replaced him. For me it was Michael Crawford or bust. Luckily, my reservation tickets were refunded. However, I still went to MGM Grand if only to buy the CD. Is there any word about his health? If Hollywood replaces him as the Phantom, I believe it will be a great disappointment to Michael's fans and a bigger disaster at the box office. Andrew Lloyd Webber should know how it is to lose money on a million dollar production. I hope whoever holds the key to the Phantom production will be enlightened and have a change of heart. One die-hard Michael Crawford fan. |
| Name: Linda
Hoekstra Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Holland Time: 1998-05-28 14:34:27 Comments: If it is a commercial necessaty to turn Phantom into a movie, please at least stick to the original and simply the best cast!!! |
| Name: robert
d'amico Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: boston, massachusetts Time: 1998-05-28 14:09:20 Comments: Any Phantom movie without Michael in the title roll will be a failure at the box office. People are not stupid and this move has many of them very upset. I intend to write to both Warner and ALW to try and have them re-think their casting policy. I for one would never attend a Phantom movie if Michael Crawford is not ion the tile roll. |
| Name: Nancy
Piscitello Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Hartsdale, New York Time: 1998-05-28 13:52:03 Comments: Diane, I just wanted to say how glad I was to meet you in Las Vegas this past week-end (wasn't Michael wonderful). I was shocked to hear about Lloyd Webber's comments. Considering he wanted Michael to star in the stage version, and to now have such a complete turnaround is really disappointing. If they really want Antonio Banderas in the film then cast him as Raoul (that part would fit him very well). If Andrew and Warners really want "star" names, then surround Michael with these "names", but the part of the Phantom should only be portrayed by the creator of the part, Michael Crawford. Diane, thank you for giving us an outlet to express our feelings, and best of luck to you. |
| Name: B. Pasterniak Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Jonesboro, AR Time: 1998-05-28 03:56:02 Comments: Diane, You have a fabulous web site and I truly applaud your heartfelt efforts to have Michael Crawford cast as the Phantom in the POTO movie. (If there ever is one.) I haven't seen him perform, but I do think he has the voice that no other person could come close to. I fell in love with POTO when I saw it in San Francisco. From all that I have read and heard it sounds like MC is the best choice for the part. I listen to his CD all the time. It sends chills down my whole body. I think it would be too overwhelming to actually see him act and sing at the same time. I WANT THAT CHANCE! Diane, keep up the good work. I believe in you! IMY |
| Name: Colleen Miller Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: CA Time: 1998-05-28 03:49:56 Comments: Michael Crawford and the Phantom are one - no one could portray Eric like Michael. Shame on Andrew Lloyd Webber for his comments regarding Michael being too old. Cast Michael and they will have a hit movie that will become a classic! A great web page! I will write to all the addresses! |
| Name: Christine Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Oregon Time: 1998-05-27 22:29:15 Comments: I agree completely with you, Diane. I would not go see a movie of POTO unless the star was Michael Crawford, whose genius is indescribable. Christine |
| Name: anonmyous Website: none currently Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Singapore Time: 1998-05-26 17:15:52 Comments: Michael Crawford is the one and only person deserving to be the Phantom!!! |
| Name: Sam Rader Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: London Ont. Time: 1998-05-26 16:47:48 Comments: The phantom was good. |
| Name: Terry D.
Tidwell Website: Referred by: Net Search From: San Luis Obispo, CA / Bakersfield, CA Time: 1998-05-26 15:51:23 Comments: I, like Dianne, cannot for the life of me believe that Andrew Weber, who has proven himself to be a musical visionary to this point, would even consider Antonio Banderas for the role that was brought to life by Michael Crawford. I read in the PARADE Magazine that Weber felt Michael was "too old" and not enought of a big star to carry off the role??? That is ridiculous!! Michael is the reason so many fans returned to the theater to watch this play, over and over!!!! Antonio is no where near sensitive or powerful enough to carry this role and I and many others, I'm sure will feel the same way. I, and my family will fervently boycott any production of this movie that does not star Michael Crawford. We also intend to pass by word of mouth, and the internet our intentions and to ask all our friends and everyone we meet to join us in this boycott effort. Thanks.....Terry 8-{) |
| Name: NARRELLE Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: PERTH WEST. AUSTRALIA Time: 1998-05-26 05:59:40 Comments: I THINK MICHAEL CRAWFORD SHOULD REPRISE HIS ROLE OF THE PHANTOM IN THE MOVIE. ALSO SARAH BIGHTMAN SHOULD PLAY THE ROLE OF CHRISTINE |
| Name: Amy Greenberg Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Ambler, PA Time: 1998-05-26 00:09:47 Comments: I feel that you have a very strong-worded website here, and if more phans were to write like this, then I would have no doubt in my mind that Warner Studios would start to listen to you. Thank you very much for informing me and many other phans out there about our struggle to keep the phantom alive in our hearts, and not through some idle, popular teen magazine. Congradulations on recruiting another phan in the fight to save Erik from Hollywood. |
| Name: Teresa
Dunkin Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Wheeling, West Virginia, USA Time: 1998-05-25 21:48:45 Comments: Count me in as one more who would love a chance to see Michael Crawford's Phantom. I've seen 8 different Phantom actors & have my favorites, but I would still love to see the man who originated the role & it looks like film will be the only opportunity. As for Michael's ability, maybe we should fly ALW in to the US to see him on his tour, about which I have heard nothing but raves, or send him a copy of the PBS tape wherein he does magnificent justice to the songs from Phantom. As for Michael not being a big enough film star - that is a load of . . . . . He is not only an actor who has film experience (Hello Dolly) but he has also made his mark as a stage star, Las Vegas star and television star. He should play the Phantom. . .he's earned it. . . Phantom fans want to see it. . .and in the end, he is the actor who will do the best job in portraying the ALW Phantom on Screen! |
| Name: Raymond Hefele Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Florida Time: 1998-05-25 18:13:28 Comments: Have seen the Broadway play and am very much in love withit the same as you. I hope all your hard work will showsome rewards. I will do my part and write a letter.Sincerely,Raymond |
| Name: Randy
Reeves Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Arkansas Time: 1998-05-25 16:59:36 Comments: Travolta as the Phantom? That's not even a funny Joke! |
| Name: Kathy
Goodwin Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Bath, Maine Time: 1998-05-25 03:04:22 Comments: After reading the article in PARADE today, I became more angry than ever at ALW and Warner Brothers. They must be out of their money-grubbing minds. I have seen the Phantom 6 times, but never with Michael. I have consoled myself that his unequaled performance would be preserved forever on film. As someone who is one year older than Michael, I was incensed that he is considered too old. At 56 he's younger than most people in their 30's. Even if he looked his age, his face is never seen. Those of us who have been following his career for the past few years know that his mesmerizing voice is more polished and powerful than ever. He would be an incredible movie Phantom. I traveled from Maine to Las Vegas to see him in EFX; I would go to the ends of the earth to see him in POTO. Keep up the good work, Diane. There are thousands of kindred spirits out here. |
| Name: Michelle Megan Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Metamora Time: 1998-05-24 20:14:02 Comments: I am a devout POTO fan. To even think of having Travolta or Banderas is a sin. Only a person with a GOOD voice and experience playing the part should even be considered for the part and I am outraged at the thought of anyone but a true Phantom playing Phantom. Long live Michal Crawford!!!! |
| Name: Christine
A. Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: upstate New York Time: 1998-05-24 16:42:16 Comments: Diane, I applaude your efforts and all the people who have joined your cause. Just today in Personality Parade, it was stated "Michael Crawford, who originated the masked role, is considered too old at 56 and not a big enough star." I, for one, found this highly offensive. Age only means experience, especially for a man who has performed the role in London, New York, and Los Angeles. He has continuously striven to improve his performance. In my opinion, he is better now than ever. I would like to hear their definition of big star, as well. For anyone versed in Phantom, the name Michael is synonymous. If Michael is not an option, at least someone who has dedicated himself to the role time and time again on stage should be chosen. I don't dislike Antonio Banderas but I honestly believe he is not the one for the emotional/physical/vocal range of the Phantom. If he must be cast, he should be Raoul. There have been Spanish flavored versions of that character and he is a major lead as well. If that must be, I don't see a problem. However, I'm not sure if it should be on the big screen at all. The stage version will surely lose money -- cheaper at the movies. Also, Evita lacked the fire the stage version had. They need people from the theater. I believe it would be a better idea if Webber followed suit with the Anniversary version of Les Miserables. The original lead appeared as well as a cast from the past productions. Only the best and brightest. It was a great seller in the stores and the play was promoted. It was true to the theater. I highly recommend it. Good luck to you, Diane, and to all of your supporters. |
| Name: Robert Violeri Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: New York Time: 1998-05-23 16:58:00 Comments: are Warner Brothers out of their gourd? Movie's are littered with rotten musicals, most of which failed BECAUSE they cast a popular but incapable film star in the male role. Look at Hello Dolly or Paint Your Wagon or Man of La Mancha.The Impossible Dream was impossible. But when Hollywood played smart--using right but relatively unknown folks, well, Rex Harrison and My Fair Lady won Oscars, Yul Brynner won an Oscar, Barbra Streisand won an Oscar for Funny Girl. They can sell POTO to theatre owners, financial backers, audiences based on the name alone and some good advertising. And it's not as though Crawford is entirely unknown. All the ads have to say is "...starring the original, definitive and Tony-winning star, Michael Crawford"--they'll know they're getting the REAL THING. And tell Warner Bros that I've seen almost every Phantom in the book--Michael Crawford IS the real thing. The camera will love him. Violeri |
| Name: Mellisa D.Davis Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Willow Creek Ca. Time: 1998-05-22 23:15:09 Comments: I saw the Phantom and I think that it was one of the best Opras that I've ever seen. |
| Name: JC Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Toronto, Canada Time: 1998-05-22 05:41:18 Comments: Michael Crawford IS the Phantom. I think it's rediculous to even think of casting anyone but. Travolta and Banderas will draw in a few extra hormone driven kidlets, but those few extra dollars will greatly decrease the value of the film and how it will be remembered years from now. "Hey, Honey, what do you want to rent tonight...Ernest goes to Jail or The Phantom? They're the only movies Blockbuster has in." The Travolta/Banderas are good actors and generally more widely known than Mike, but in my eyes they just don't fit the part. After seeing Crawford play the Phantom, it's inconceivable to think anyone else could pull it off. The guy made me cry, for goshsakes:) If the filmmakers were shooting for an Academy Award and not moolah, they'd be insane not to go for Crawford. |
| Name: O.G. Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-05-21 20:15:56 Comments: Diane, I am in agreement that the role of the Phantom should be offered to Michale first, and then perhaps to another of the actors who may be currently portraying the role elsewhere on stage. I have great many more ideas to discuss, but wish not to take up space, and bore you, or your guests with my dribble. However, as a theater major and a Phantom Phanatic you can count me in on your crusade to keep Phantom pure from the likes of a punk "greaser", and a Spaniard that can sing about as well as Madame Carlotta. I remain: |
| Name: Mark de
Vries Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: The netherlands Time: 1998-05-21 14:55:07 Comments: You can put a mask on someones face and he looks like The Phantom but you cannot put a mask on someones voice. For me there is only one true Phantom and that is Michael Crawford. The man is a genius. Mark |
| Name: Jennifer Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: California Time: 1998-05-21 01:09:10 Comments: I think that Michael Crawford should play Erik. Michael plays a really handsome Phantom and he has the best voice for him too. John Travolta should NOT play the Phantom. Although Antonio Banderas is good looking and he can kinda sing, I don't think he should play the Phantom. But either way, I will watch it because I love The Phantom of the Opera. I LOVE Erik!! |
| Name: Todd Website: Now the Place You have All been Waiting for: Todd's Homepage Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: TX Time: 1998-05-20 16:35:48 Comments: It makes me sad knowing they might cast Antonio Banderas, John Travolta or anyone else besides Micheal Crawford as the Phantom. First of all Antonio Banderas should not play the Phantom because he is Spanish and thne Phantom isn't! Also Antonio proved he couldn't sing in Evita. John Travolta is more of well.... a person who sing 50s through 80s songs...not really show tunes. Sarah Brightham is amazing without her or Micheal Crawford the show will be abominable (spelling) |
| Name: Steven
Sorensen Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Los Angeles Time: 1998-05-20 00:38:13 Comments: I agree 110% that ONLY Micheal Crawford should play the role of the Phantom in the musical movie version! If someone else like Antonio were to play the Phantom I would much rather see the movie NOT get made! I know a number of people who also feel the same way I do. PLEASE cast Micheal Crawford and Sarah Brightman in the two main lead ! ! ! Thank You! |
| Name: Mimi
Keller Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: Zeeland, Michigan Time: 1998-05-20 00:10:38 Comments: Michael Crawford should play the part of the Phantom in the film, Phantom of the Opera |
| Name: Deb Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: MN Time: 1998-05-19 23:09:22 Comments: I just want my voice to be heard. If Michael Crawford isn't cast as the phantom in the Phantom of the Opera movie then I have NO interest in seeing it. Michael is the phantom. |
| Name: Fiona
Pannell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Australia/Netherlands Time: 1998-05-19 20:03:12 Comments: No one could have been more suited to the role of Erik the Phantom - and Michael Crawford was made for the part and no one could ever replace him in part. Particularly someone like J. Travolta or Antonio Banderas. Sorry!! But I have loved Michael's work since seeing him in Phantom and before i cried for the Erik so many times when he did, becuase of Michael special brand of magic he put into the Part. Michael is and always will be Erik! |
| Name: Margaret
Hutchison Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Pennsylvania, USA Time: 1998-05-19 15:46:59 Comments: There can be no other Phantom than Michael Crawford! |
| Name: Heather
Jones Website: WHITEROSE71 Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: arizona U.S Time: 1998-05-19 08:16:39 Comments: I haven't seen Phantom of the opera on bordway yet. I neaver seen it at all and I seen in moives that don't do like the bordway they sould do that why all the song that on it and same way. But my sister seen on bordway and she said it great to see it. And I am going to. But I hop when I do see it I hope Michael Crawford is the Phantom. If he not I still see it. But not going to be just good. But I hope in the moive they making they put Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the moive. And just same thing I see it but I don't think going to be just good if have michael on it. Put my name down I am aguest the other actors doing this moive but I only want him to bee in. I hope the moive well come out soon. Bye for now. Heather |
| Name: Rosemarie
Strong Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Long Branch, NJ Time: 1998-05-17 22:06:48 Comments: I support your efforts fully. It is inconceivable to me that anyone but MICHAEL CRAWFORD would be considered for the role of the Phantom in the movie version. Count me as one who will boycott Warners and RUG if this comes about. Let me know if there is anything else I can do to assist you in this project - it goes without saying that my letters will be in the mail to Warners and RUG as soon as possible! |
| Name: Sarah
Risner Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Oklahoma Time: 1998-05-17 14:57:28 Comments: You are right. |
| Name: Norma
Fountain Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Salem, Oregon Time: 1998-05-17 00:39:45 Comments: Michael Crawford is not only the most highly qualified person to play the movie role as the Phantom, but his dedication to his craft should be rewarded in kind. Very few performers work as diligently as Michael does to provide his audience with the finest performance possible. He is a true artist in every sense of the word. |
| Name: Susan DuBois Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Orange County, CA Time: 1998-05-17 00:25:19 Comments: I Just want to give my whole-hearted support to your efforts to make Michael the one and only movie "Phantom". Keep up the good work!! |
| Name: Broadway Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: WA Time: 1998-05-16 01:39:29 Comments: I don't think that the roll at all belongs to John Travolta. Michael Crawford will forever and always be the Phantom and I am sorry to see that the title role is going to someone who obviously doesn't deserve it!!!! |
| Name: Shelia Ann
Adam Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-05-15 04:01:05 Comments: Please add my name to the list of the others who will boycott not only ALL Warner Brothers products and productions but that of RUG as well if the movie version of Phantom of the Opera goes into production without Michael Crawford as the Phantom. |
| Name: Diana
L.Marshall Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Roswell, New Mexico Time: 1998-05-15 03:16:18 Comments: What,then, was the significance of Michael singing at Terry Semel's wedding anniversary party? Wouldn't that have convinced Mr. Semel who should play the Phantom? |
| Name: Marti Osborne Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Orlando, FL Time: 1998-05-15 02:25:19 Comments: No other actor should play the Phantom except Michael - he is the Phantom! I will not see the movie if he is not in it. I think there are enough supporters worldwide to boycott the movie if he does not star and I will be one of them. Give us Michael!!! |
| Name: Christine
Berry Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Fresno,CA Time: 1998-05-15 02:02:36 Comments: I just can't believe that RUG and Warner Brothers could think of putting anybody else but Michael Crawford in the role of Phantom of the Opera. He is the only one who is qualified to be the Phantom. Anyone who would like to talk about it. E-mail me at nberry1@ix.netcom.com. Christine |
| Name: Jean
Hofve Website: Spirit Essence Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Denver, CO Time: 1998-05-14 22:58:40 Comments: I couldn't agree more that if Michael Crawford is not the Phantom, then there shouldn't be a movie. There isn't another soul on the planet who could do justice to the role. ALW apparently doesn't know a good thing when he sees one. |
| Name: Claudia
Albert Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Garden Grove, CA Time: 1998-05-14 18:32:41 Comments: I, too, will not see Phantom if Michael Crawford does not star! |
| Name: Matt
Sponsler Website: Beyond the Lake - The Phantom of the Opera Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Huntsville, AL Time: 1998-05-14 06:31:11 Comments: Well, there's not really anything new to say on this. Phantom is a powerful, beautiful musical. This fact alone means that it will be impossible to cater to the general movie going public. That only leaves us "Phans". And if we can support 4 or 5 house shows along with the various National Tours, then I think its well within our power to make the Phantom movie a hit. But that's just it. It rests solely on the likes of the Phans. And we want Michael Crawford. So if Warner Bros., ALW, and Co., are really not stupid and are simply motivated by money, it seems to me that a Spanish speaking Phantom simply won't get it done with the movie's target audience. So, in conclusion (it's pretty simple really) unless you want a flop on your hands (which I don't think ALW or Warner can sustain right now), give your fans what we've been screaming for - The ORIGINAL Libretto with the ORIGINAL Phantom. |
| Name: Crista
Orefice Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: New Jersey Time: 1998-05-13 17:54:34 Comments: What is happening in Hollywood? All these people care about is $$$$$$$.....What ever happened to art and to honor? All I know is that one unparalled, amazing, incomparable, and extremely talented actor was dishonored here. How DARE they even think of casting anyone else as the Phantom?!!! EVERYBODY who knows what the "Phantom" is all about must agree that only one man can do this mystical and moving story of love and music any justice. Who do you think that might be? MICHAEL CRAWFORD Mr. Lloyd Webber! Remember the one you hand-picked originally for the part? Why now after soooo many years of building up that man's hopes, as he sat with undying patience, must you totally dissolve your word and your promise? I admit I am an enormous ALW fan! But I am not of fan of this ludicrous idea of Antonio Banderas a Erik. It is unimaginable. I agree with everyone else's new idea-cast him as Raoul-I can see that. But PLEASE don't let another man beside Michael breathe life once again into the role that made him an international star! He has the passion, the sensuality, and above all the VOI CE! HE is the Phantom, there is no way around it. I support everything he does. Only he deserves to be forever immortalized in the film. I promise it will become a classic. Could you imagine anyone other than Judy Garland as Dorothy or Rex Harrison as Prof. Higgins? He played it on stage too, and it worked beautifully in the movie. Imagine the magic that Michael would bring to the sreen! Let's keep up with the continual support-Michael needs us! thank you Diane for this excellent and loyal idea for us to stand behind the TRUE PHANTOM! |
| Name: Brion Rector Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Louisville, Kentucky Time: 1998-05-13 15:59:30 Comments: I am really glad there is a web sight out there that I can goto to find out about one of the greatest things to ever hit Broadway. I agree M.C. should play the role of Phantom no one else could do it. If it was Antonio I would want to say "oh what a circus oh what a show" (Evita). I always wandered if they would do a Phantom movie after I saw Evita. It must be M.C. it just has to be. Plus the idea of a sequal is crazy I would go see it just to see it but it ruins the fact that you have to use you imagination. I would also like to find out if Phantom will be returning to my area. I don't have a computer I am using the one at school I would really like a response. My address is 322 Stonemill Dr Louisville, Ky 40222-6787 |
| Name: Berrett
Maynard Website: Michael Crawford Mailing LIst Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Salt Lake City, Utah Time: 1998-05-13 05:41:51 Comments: ALW is a Looney Toon, thats why the movie's being made by Warner Brothers, and the Warners sister DOT!!!! |
| Name: Janette
Cataldo Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: M.C.I.F.A. Time: 1998-05-13 00:10:02 Comments: I think what you are doing is great!! Keep up the good work and let me know if I can help. Janette P.S. Michael is the TRUE PANTOM |
| Name: Janet
Emanuelson Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Santa Cruz, California Time: 1998-05-12 21:46:11 Comments: I agree with all you say and I will follow through. Janet |
| Name: Maria Lew-Ong Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: San Francisco, CA Time: 1998-05-12 20:55:34 Comments: Dear Diane, Thank you for working on this campaign!! For over a year, I've been a fan of Phantom of the Opera. I borrowed the cd from a friend. When I heard the first overture, I was completely hooked. The next day, I returned the cd to my friend and purchased one myself. I listened to it at least 3 times a day. I'm a full-time mother, and I had time to just leave it on the player. My children also, grew to love the music. But what I loved about the cd, was Michael Crawford's lovely voice. His voice really showed the pain and anguish of the Phantom . I cried after the second act was over!! I didn't even see the stage show, and yet Michael's voice made me cry in the end. I was so torn over Michael's portrayal, and it only came through by his voice. Later, on I was connected to the internet, and discovered more about Phantom of the Opera and Mr. Michael Crawford. After reading everything I could possibly fine about POTO, I grew very upset with myself, that I was unable to see Michael perform the role of the phantom. He won awards for this portrayal and I heard that many of the shows he performed in were sold out. I truly regretted that I didn't discovered POTO earlier. I also read that Michael was promised the movie role of POTO. I was so happy to hear that, since I never saw him perform live. However, my premature elation was crush. Someone else was considered the role, John Travolta. I was totally shock, and couldn't imagine him as the Phantom. He is one of my favorite actors, but not as the Phantom. As of this year, I later heard that Antonio Bandares, was to portray the Phantom. I was very disappointed . I just could not see the Phantom having a spanish accent. Also, I feel he is too young for the role. He's a great actor, and I have seen him in many roles, but please, I don't want him as the Phantom. I know that movie producers are looking for a big star to do the role for Phantom. However, I feel that if Michael Crawford, was in the movie role, just as many people, will see the movie. The ones who are phanatics, the many people who saw Michael live on stage, and the many, many people who didn't see him perform on stage, like me. The only video I have of Michael as the Phantom is" Andrew Lloyd Webber's Premiere Encore Video" . It's the one where, Michael is singing "Music of the Night". I must have played it 1000 times. Plus, my daughters, always like me to rewind it back, to see Michael over and over. The tapes got so worned that I had to buy another video. I did finally see the stage production of POTO in San Francisco with my daughters. It was fine, but I compared it to the cd with Michael Crawford. It just didn't live up to my expectations. My daughters, asked me if it was Michael performing. I said no, since he doesn't perform it anymore. They were very disappointed. They are only 4 and 7. They keep on asking me for a video of Michael performing the whole show of POTO. I told them it does not exist. Since discovering Michael Crawford in POTO. I have purchased all of his cds and most of the movies he's been in. I feel Michael will be absolutely fabulous, if he did the movie role. The Phantom is the role he created, and I truly feel he cannot do anything wrong with the movie version. Also, I feel that if his movie came out on video, it will be one of the bestsellers. To this day, I still look for anything that has Michael Crawford in the Phantom of the Opera. It could be a poster, an old article, magazine, shirts, etc. Name it I want it. I will be attending his concert in Concord, CA. I promised myself that I had to go,, because I wanted to finally see the "Phantom" live on stage. I know it's not the stage performance. But to hear him sing "Phantom of the Opera" and "Music of the Night", that is all I wish for. I just could not miss this chance of seeing Michael perform. My husband, who is not a fan of the Phantom of the Opera, has told me so often that if Michael Crawford was to play the movie version. He would love to see it, however, he feels anyone else, will not do justice to the role. All I can say, is that if Michael Crawford doesn't do the movie version, I will not be spending my money to see the movie. I'll just save my money, to purchase Michael Crawford cds, and anything related to him. Thanking for taking the time to read this!! Sincerely, Maria Lew-Ong |
| Name: Ceeeceee Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-05-12 17:26:18 Comments: A recent article in the Washington, D.C. Cable Guide said of Michael Crawford, "He seemed to be able to take the heart of his audience and tuck it into his songs." He summed up the magic of Michael Crawford and his ability to reach out and make an audience FEEL what he sings. As an avid lover of Phantom of the Opera, I want very much to see and hear Michael Crawford make the movie the success it should be. With Michael, our beloved Phantom will be a classic movie. Ceeeceee |
| Name: Dee Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Time: 1998-05-10 19:25:46 Comments: Once again, ALW has done a 360 on all of us. For the past 8 years, all we've been hearing is that Michael Crawford was going to do the Phantom movie. Michael has the dubious distiction of joining both Faye Dunaway and Patti Lupone on ALW's reject list!! Last Feb, Antonio Banderas was a guest on Rosie O'Donnell's show, and he said he was very nervous about singing at ALW's birthday bash. He said "I don't sing very well, or speak English very well!!" Rosie had a very surprised look on her face, when he said he was singing the Phantom part. ALW never listens to what his audiences want, and takes them for granted. I don't think this protest will do any good, as he will do what he wants to do. The 90's have been a wasted decade for ALW, as I believe that when he divorced Sarah Brightman, he lost all his inspiration for composing the great music he created in the 1980's. A Disgusted Phantom Phan |
| Name: Mary McCuin Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Connecticut Time: 1998-05-10 17:18:04 Comments: Hi Diane: I agree 100%. Will join the boycott. Have already written to RUG and Warner. They obviously do not realize how much of a draw Michael was to the play. |
| Name: Sarah Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Wisconsin Time: 1998-05-10 16:56:31 Comments: I was very pleased to see an entire site dedicated to saving Erik. Although I am only 13 and have seen POTO only once, I am a HUGE phan. I was devastaded upon hearing the news that John Travolta was playing the Phantom. I cried when I heard that Antonio Banndares (sorry if I spelt that wrong.) was now signed on as Erik. Now, it is not only Erik who needs protection, but also Christine. they are saying that Kate Winslet is playing her. She can't even act, much less sing. I have encouraged all my friends to join the save Erik campaign and I have convinced around a hundred people in my hometown (now I have to work on the other 5,000) to boycott any Phantom movie, Warner Bros. movie, or RUG production if MC or an equilly talented actor (if there are any) does not placy the Erik. Let's hope we can save him! |
| Name: Diana Dailey Website: Youthtime Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Georgia Time: 1998-05-10 15:13:40 Comments: I love phantom of the Opera soooo much this is a nice web page :> |
| Name: Loretta Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Vermont Time: 1998-05-08 18:58:41 Comments: To see so many avid fans in one place is a sheer delight. I understand the need to express opinions regarding the POTO movie issue, but I can't help feeling that the "Powers That Be" will be as unfeeling about OUR interests as they are being of Michael's. It must be quite an insult to him having the executives look past him as a potential choice for the lead role. I also feel that we, as a group of his admirers, should stand behind Michael in whichever capacity he requires us to. And, this means if he asks that we are respectful of the choice made by the movie execs, then we should endeavor to do this; no matter how hard it may be for us. And, as anyone who knows Michael, even a little, knows just how gracious and kind he is. He will most likely elicit an appeal to his fans to support, or at least not verbally abuse the studio's choice. I would imagine the last thing he needs is to lose both the role, AND our support. At a time like that when we know what his wishes are, shouldn't we then follow those wishes? Afterall, aren't we doing all of this for him? And, who knows, the movie studios may wake up yet! We can hope anyway. Thank you for listening to my feelings on this matter. no request. |
| Name: Margaret
Canatella Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: New Mexico Time: 1998-05-07 06:29:21 Comments: I have become a Michael Crawford fan rather late. I saw POTO almost 3 yrs ago in Dallas, Tx. I came away a bit disappointed, certainly the Phantom I saw did nothing for me. And it's not as tho I'm not a musical lover; have been for over 45 years. Then I saw Michael's concert on PBS and was swept away! It's been years since I've seen and Actor/Singer that swept me away. By the time he had sung 3 numbers from Phantom I was in tears! How I wish I could have seen HIM do Phantom. Anyway, at this point I have the concert taped until I can buy the video..am trying to get other video of his other concert some years ago...have 4 of his albums and have tickets to see him in Las Vegas on May 23rd. I do hope Warner Bros. is paying attention to all the e-mail, etc. that is being seen on internet, etc. I just can't imagine that they could let anyone else do the roll. As some have said...not letting Yul do KING, Harrison MY FAIR LADY, etc. They've ruined so many wonderful movie musicals starring actors who hav |
| Name: Carol Nagie Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Northern California Time: 1998-05-05 22:58:26 Comments: I can't believe they aren't considering michael Crawford...ANtonio??? he sucked in EVITA!!!!!! Why do they NEVER cast the original??? The next best one would be Franc D'Amrosio...who is the Phantom In SF..and was Michael's son in the Godfather III. |
| Name: Wendi Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Alabama (by way of NY) Time: 1998-05-03 07:49:35 Comments: Dear Michael Fans: Great page. Thanks for keeping us up to date on the quest. It simply amazes me that people who are in charge of such large amount so of money and powerful material can be so blind. Did they tell Yul Brenner, oh we think we are going to go with Robert Goulet (in bringing The King and I to the screen from the boards??) NO!!! Now, they did replace Julie Andrews with Audrey Hepburn in My Fair Lady (personally, I would have stayed with Julie as her range is better, her voice quality is better and her accent was truer). Did they learn nothing from Evita?? Lets think a minute what the movie could have been had Patti Lupone and Mandy Patimkin been cast!!! Thanks for a place to speak my peace. Keep up the great work and FIGHT THE GOOD FIGHT. Wendi (FH35@aol.com) |
| Name: Honschu Website: Referred by: Net Search From: South Africa Time: 1998-05-03 07:05:43 Comments: Bravo to you! If they want to film the Phantom they should use a true Phantom and not just any Hollywood actor! MC should be the one and only choice! |
| Name: Claudia Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Colorado Time: 1998-05-03 03:57:11 Comments: Diane, thank you for your commitment. I'll add some support to your cause. Michael Crawford earned the right to do the movie with his award winning performances in London, New York, and L.A., and in the process made "The Phantom of the Opera" even more successful than it probably would have been had he not blessed the production with his amazing talents as an actor and singer thereby allowing the audience to witness a performance of a lifetime in a role he was destined to play. While I've enjoyed John Travolta in his movies (including "Grease"), and was very pleasantly surprised by Antonio Banderas in "Evita"...[this guy did not just suddenly take up singing lessons for the role of Che], I am not picturing either of them, or anyone else in the role of the Phantom except Michael Crawford who literally became the Phantom in every performance he gave, and in the minds of every audience that was FORTUNATE enough to have seen him in the role. Michael Crawford is the only Phantom I'LL ever need, and quite frankly, if "THE MICHAEL" ain't in the movie, then "I" ain't in the movie theatre.....nor will I be buying the CD or the video. GOT IT????? ALW, RUG, WB, FBI, CIA????? |
| Name: C Gatward Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Western Australia Time: 1998-05-02 04:03:00 Comments: MR MICHAEL CRAWFORD IS THE PHANTOM AND NO MOVIE SHOULD EVER BE MADE THAT HAS ANY OTHER PERSON PLAYING THAT ROLE. |
| Name: Denise Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Alvin, TX Time: 1998-05-02 00:09:36 Comments: I was browsing a book store the other day, and I picked up a book about the top ten in several different categories. In the musical section, it talked about the Phantom of the Opera being one of the best musicals, but it also said even though the music was wonderful, Michael Crawford's portrayal of the Phantom was undoubtably one of the reasons that the musical is as popular as it is now. There is no denying it...the man has talent! He has created a character that has one the hearts of many, many women and even men all over the world. I have seen several other performers portray the Phantom on stage, some were good, and some were not so good, but I did not think that any were as convincing as Crawford. I would love for this character to be immortalized on film by the man who created him. I do not think that the movie could be successful any other way. Crawford, I think, is really the only person who can pull off both the singing and the acting. If you want a dashing young hero, like Antonio Banderas, cast him as Raoul, the young, dashing love interest, but not as the Phantom. The Phantom can only be played by one person, the actor who created him. |
| Name: Ann Fama Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Conway, AR/TX/Australia Time: 1998-05-01 00:44:21 Comments: Want to see his comedy series brought to PBS in the U.S. They were made when he was very young and skinny. They are the best comedy of all time. They are shown often in Australia. I also love his musical talents. |
| Name: Marcus Vinícius Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Brazil Time: 1998-04-30 23:27:35 Comments: Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford are the only singers/actor who can make the film "the Phantom of The Opera" be a great success. If they're not in the cast, the wonderfull music Lloyd whote will be throed in the dump !!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Brendan
O'Connell Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: NSW, Australia Time: 1998-04-30 09:28:08 Comments: I for one would have to agree -- no Michael Crawford, no ticket bought by me.I have vowed not to see any filmed version of ALW's brilliant "The Phantom of The Opera" unless Michael Crawford is up there on the silver screen. |
| Name: Tara L . Evans Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Hitchcock, TX Time: 1998-04-29 19:55:40 Comments: I have mixed emotions about sequels. I am a big "Gone With The Wind" fan, and was very much against a sequel, but after seeing it I couldn't have been more wrong. It was closure to the original. I also didn't believe that anyone could compare to Vivian Leigh as Scarlett O'hara and Clark Gable as Rhett Butler, but what else to do, they are no longer with us. I know that this is no comparison to POTO, but if they will give the part to MC, why not do it? If they do not give it to him, than I agree, no sequel. But, there are so many people in the world that do not know about MC. He is absolutely mesmerizing, and this may be the only way to give him more exposure to the public. My husband and I cannot remember how we became fans, but do know that from the beginning we were hooked, and we have hooked many other people. Though, there are still many unknowing. I plan on raising my 4 year old son and the next child that we have on MC. We played POTO and MC, the entire time I was pregnant, and had my now 20 year old sister, singing the POTO when she was in Junior High. Let's try to give it a chance, but only if they give it to the appropriate actor. Wouldn't it be great to see MC receiving all the awards that are due him. I have several CDs that have other Phantoms, and they are a disgrace to ALW's musicals. I know that this will probably make some people unhappy, but I think MC deserves his day on the big screen. Thank you for your time. |
| Name: Gerry Gorman Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Dublin, Ireland Time: 1998-04-29 17:34:02 Comments: There is only one Phantom. MC. |
| Name: Dawn Swann Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Tacoma, WA Time: 1998-04-29 07:22:18 Comments: Dear Diane, Thank you for taking the time to put this page together. Many of us have great ideas and even greater intentions, but lack the discipline to put them into action. I am honored to be a part of the Michael Crawford International Fan Association. I saw him live in EFX in Las Vegas and saw the PBS taping of his live concert in Cerritos, CA, this past February. I will have the privilege of seeing him live in concert at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas on Memorial weekend. These trips all cost money and time, but to have the opportunity to see such a talented, caring man is, indeed, a privilege, and well worth the expense. Mr. Crawford has brought an elegance to his craft. He has given of himself to his audiences for many years, accepting nothing less than perfection from himself. I feel he has earned the right to portray Erik, aka Phantom, in the movie version/sequel. To have this 'plum' ripped out of his hands by a man he had trusted, and to see it offered to other performers, albeit talented in their own rights, is an afront of major proportions. I cannot think of any other performer who has consistently reached to the core of his/her being to bring life and depth to a character day after day, or who has gone to great lengths to prepare for a role (i.e., circus school for Barnum) as has Mr. Crawford. He is a role model for other performers, and an inspiration to all. Thank you for the opportunity to share my feelings on this subject. Sincerely, Dawn Swann |
| Name: Angie Coots Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Johnson County, KS Time: 1998-04-29 06:22:06 Comments: Diane, I am in total agreement with you. The article written by Dana Parsons was posted on both the POTO mailing list and the Michael Crawford mailing list and hopefully generated many responses. I feel RUG and WB are missing out on the advertising opportunity of a lifetime. With all of the fabulous print reviews from the finicky theater critics, WB could be advertising something like: "Come and see the man who had all the critics raving. See the perfomance that seduced and entranced women on two continents. Come and hear the voice that has haunted the legions that have heard it. Come and experience--Michael Crawford as: The Phantom of the Opera." But no, WB seems to thing that Banderas's name and face will bring in the right demographic. (Although, I'm not sure of the logic of this thinking, considering the man will be behind a ton of latex AND a mask. Oh well, I guess ours is not to reason why.) Keep your chin up, and remember, no matter what happens, at least you did everything you could to prevent this travesty from happening. MC fan for life Angie C. |
| Name: Joanne Daley Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Flossmoor IL Time: 1998-04-29 05:13:42 Comments: Michael Crawford would make the Phantom movie a classic to be enjoyed by all in addition to future generations. All other theatre phantoms followed Michael Crawford's lead and tried to duplicate his perfect interpretation of the phantom. No one on earth can do a better job. Michael's quality work would win new fans who would want to see more of Andrew Lloyd Webber's works. Michael is the one who would make it profitable for the producers at the theaters and on video. If Michael were cast as the Phantom, I know I would see it numerous times and definitely buy the video. If Michael Crawford does not star in this movie, it will just be another phantom movie of little consequence. Please don't pass up a great talent for a Hollywood cutie who's face will be hidden behind a hideous face and mask and will have only his acting ability to demonstrate the feelings of the phantom. Choose your Hollywood money-in-the-bank stars to portray Christine and Raoul, the other two leading roles. Please don't pass up |
| Name: Linda Frey Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Pittsburgh, PA Time: 1998-04-28 16:51:52 Comments: I don't want to see Antonio Banderas as the Phantom anymore than I wanted to see John Travolta. Michael Crawford is the only Phantom for me! I think Warner Bros. and ALW are playing April Fool's Day jokes on us! Deep down they have to know there is only one Phantom and his name is Michael Crawford -- the man who created the role and won a TONY award for his efforts!!!!! |
| Name: Diane
Jackson Schnoor Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Crozet, VA Time: 1998-04-28 14:15:03 Comments: Add me to the list of people who want Michael in the lead role. Otherwise, I too will refuse to see the movie. John Travolta or Antonia Banderas???? Bah! What are they thinking?!!?!!!? |
| Name: Alice Website: Alice's Page Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Australia Time: 1998-04-28 11:18:17 Comments: nice page! Michael is just amazing! |
| Name: Kelly Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Southern California Time: 1998-04-28 04:58:16 Comments: Hi, I just saw Phantom 2 months ago in San Francisco. Lets just say I've been obsessed with it ever since!! Ever since then, I've been tracking the progress of the movie and relayed info to my friends who like Phantom and to movie pages. I am very angry that Michael Crawford is not getting the role, if he was, I'd be very happy. Anyway, thank you for having this page. I am happy there are people who want to stop this. Keep up the great work! |
| Name: Sally Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Illinois Time: 1998-04-28 02:37:43 Comments: I've seen five Phantoms on stage and enjoyed four of them, but for the film, I'm just not interested unless Michael Crawford plays the role. For some reason, I don't find Banderas as offensive as Travolta as a potential Erik, but it doesn't really matter. I won't spend any of my money to see any of the "Box Office Names" that have been rumored or might be rumored. Michael or no one. |
| Name: Jane
Roxbury Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Arlington, VA Time: 1998-04-27 18:00:30 Comments: It is my understanding that Andrew Lloyd Webber gave in to the studio's wish that a bigger 'box office draw' be cast as the Phantom in the movie. How unfortunate that the world is being deprived of seeing the man who gave the Phantom his spirit immortalized in this role. It saddens me to think that ALW is willing to sacrifice his creation artistically because of a few studio bags of hot air. What a wimp! Maybe the Really Useful Group should make itself useful and fund the production costs itself. |
| Name: Carey Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: NJ Time: 1998-04-26 23:31:24 Comments: As everyone I think there is only one Phantom and that is of course MICHAEL!!!!!He is the person who made Phantom and I think he is the only one who will bring in viewers. I think Michael has so much talent and he knows the Phantom.Michael lives his part when he is in a role and that is what makes it so wonderful. Diane thank you for this chance to speak out. You are doing a great job. I plan on writing more letters with the addresses I found on the internet.And!!!I think Michael is very handsome!He not only is handsome but he is beautiful on the inside. Carey |
| Name: Cherisse Website: StarMyst Gra-Fx Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Florida Time: 1998-04-26 15:13:01 Comments: There is only ONE Phantom of the Opera. MICHAEL CRAWFORD! Wake up Hollywood! I've seen the play with some actor who's name I cannot recall. It was ok... but I rather listen to my CD of Michael Crawford. I saw Michael perform in Las Vegas in EFX. I was in awe of his talent and his electrifying performance. Listen to the people Hollywood and you will surely have a hit. Don't listen... and be assured of a flop. Cherisse\StarMyst |
| Name: Becki Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Ca Time: 1998-04-25 23:00:12 Comments: I just want you to know that I totally agree with you! If Michael is not going to be the Phantom no one shoud! He is what makes that play so popular. Granted, the music and script are good without him, but with him it is EXCELLENT!! If it wasn't for MC I would not be hooked on POTO. I want to know if there is something the rest of us Michael Phans can do to prevent this tragedy from taking place? Hollywood is already messed up enough as it is. This would just make it 1,000x's worse! Anyway that's what I think. The Michael Phan, Becki |
| Name: Lynnda Weschke Website: Sharif's Sundown Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Crescent City, CA Time: 1998-04-25 04:17:19 Comments: Even though I live in the boonies now, I was living in Los Angeles and saw Michael play the Phantom 6 times! I saw his special recently on PBS and Nobody but Nobody should play in the movie but Michael. It would be a sin and I certainly would boycot the movie. John Travolta, Antonio Banderas...Give me a break! Lynnda |
| Name: Deborah Hertel Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Palmdale, CA Time: 1998-04-23 14:45:52 Comments: I just wonder if Warner Brothers Studios knows what it is about to do to the career of Antonio Banderas. This is not going to set well with fans of Phantom of the Opera. He will be compared to the performance of Michael Crawford as the Phantom, unfavorably. |
| Name: Robert
Walling Website: Referred by: Net Search From: Tucson Time: 1998-04-22 07:13:07 Comments: I am a Junior in College who was introduced to the Phantom at an early age. Michael Crawford is the phantom that I grew up with and the only one that I listen to. Every production of the theater that I attend, no matter how awsome it is, is nothing compared to Crawford. I find the casting of Bandaras to be entirely STUPID!!!!!!!!!!! I can guarentee that it will bomb, if he performs. WB needs to hear the cries of the people paying to see this movie, and invite Crawford to reprise his role. |
| Name: Leatha A.
Betts Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Utah Time: 1998-04-22 00:44:32 Comments: You have a gorgeous web page with just the right Phantom....no question about it....Michael Crawford is the only one who can perform Eric/Erik properly. Warners can do their worst, the movie will bomb, like Chorus Line did, because they will not use the correct performance. Who could match the talent....who could love the character and give him such grace, poise, restraint, adoration, and pathos, that Michael Crawford can. He has more talent in his little finger (the right one with the ring) than Bandaras could hope to have in his entire lifetime of performances. Just because one is the flavor-of-the-month, that doesn't mean that they have talent....long after the movie is gathering mold on a shelf, the memory of Michael Crawford's stage work will still live on in people's hearts. |
| Name: The Man
Behind the Mask Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Wausau, Wisconsin Time: 1998-04-21 17:30:17 Comments: So they want someone of star quality to play the Phantom in the movie? How about someone who has taken a song from PTO high on the Billboard charts, attracted sold out crowds to see him Phantom (among other plays), has his latest album on the Billboard 200 ever since it came out, had amazing success with his latest PBS promotional concert (his concert was the most profitable in Wisconsin Public Television Pledge Drive history), has received countless awards and recognitions, and is adored the world over? Of course, I'm speaking of Michael Crawford. If Andrew Lloyd Webber doesn't think Michael Crawford will draw in audiences to the movie, then he obviously must be brainwashed by the likes of big business. M.B.M. |
| Name: Suzanne
Froman Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Burke, VA Time: 1998-04-20 22:36:55 Comments: It's simple Warner Brothers and ALW - Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the movie or NO ONE! Thanks for having this page! I surfed on in from the link at Krista's site - just FYI. |
| Name: Christine Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Medford, Oregon Time: 1998-04-20 20:43:48 Comments: What is wrong with Hollywood? A Phantom sequal and Banderas as Erik? As a loyal Michael Crawford fan, I would not watch it with anyone else as Erik. To do so would be heresy!! |
| Name: Wendy Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: CA Time: 1998-04-19 14:55:41 Comments: I also cannot belive they will cast a Phantom movie with any one besides Michael Crawford as the lead. I will not see a Phantom movie unless he is in it. thanks for the information. Nice site. |
| Name: Judy Watkins Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Menasha, WI Time: 1998-04-18 16:04:50 Comments: Hi Diane, I too, would like to see Michael do the movie, but if Antonio or someone else does it, I will just boycot the movie and I hope every MC fan and POTO fan out there does the same thing. As fans of Michael, what we need to do is to support him and see him in concert this summer, (I have my tickets), and let him know that we love him and that he and only he will be our Phantom. Things happen for a reason, and I have to believe that God has something special planned for him in his future. |
| Name: Berrett
Maynard Website: Berrett's home at Xmission Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Salt Lake City, Utah Time: 1998-04-18 03:42:30 Comments: Join the Michael Crawford Mailing List by sending a message to Majordomo@xmission.com with the words subscribe mcrawford |
| Name: Dori Bruns Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Fallbrook CA Time: 1998-04-18 03:17:34 Comments: Saw your light and just thought I'd drop by. I love Michael Crawford and want to see him make the film of "Phantom Of The Opera" or no one. Casting John Travolta or Antonio Banderas or any other mediocre talent is crazy. Why have someone who can't sing when Crawford is the ideal, Tony-award winning Phantom. Let one of the Hollywood boys play Raoul, if necessary, but only Crawford has the charisma and the voice to mesmerize the audience, as the role requires. |
| Name: Kelly
Ferrell Website: Referred by: Advertisment/Brochure From: Plano, TX Time: 1998-04-17 23:28:02 Comments: Diane, Great page! I am also a huge MC fan who is devistated that he won't be in the movie. I love the story itself and read everything I can get my hands on. No one but Michael could ever truly play this role. I read something that had been posted on the MC mailing list that I believe was from someone in the media that you had talked to, a Dana Person (?). Anyway, I emailed him with my feelings as did my fiance and I know many others. Maybe we can get this horror stopped before it happens! |
| Name: Audrey
Aucott Website: Referred by: From LinkExchange From: NJ,CA,&TX Time: 1998-04-17 15:16:15 Comments: Absolutely, only Michael Crawford can truely make Eric live and breathe. He is the greatest performer of this century! I guess it's time to write again!---- Terry Semel- c/o Warner Brothers - 4000 Warner Brothers- Building #2- Burbank, Ca - 91523 ------and-----Really Useful Company- 22 Tower Street-London WC2 H9SN-England--- Best Wishes, Audrey Aucott |
| Name: Mary Ann Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: New Jersey Time: 1998-04-17 05:13:18 Comments: Great page Diane. I am in complete agreement with you. I've seen Michael do Phantom and no one is more qualified to star in this movie than the man who originated the character in London, New York, and Los Angeles; who won every major theatrical award for his performance; and whose voice is on the cast album that has become one of the best-selling cast albums of all times. In the minds of people all over the English-speaking world, Michael Crawford is the actor/singer most associated with this show and this character. Andrew Lloyd Webber and Warner Brothers should have the courage of their original conviction when they cast Michael in the movie in 1990 and ran ads for that movie in the Hollywood trade papers. I've waited as long as you have for it to become a reality and, without Michael in it, I will not support it and I will discourage as many people as I can from supporting it. |
| Name: Debra Ball Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Royal Oak, Michigan Time: 1998-04-17 04:42:22 Comments: Hi Diane. Great site! I, too, check Krista's site almost daily. Wow, am I ever dismayed about the recent Phantom movie news. Its seems as if Hollywood never learns from its past mistakes. Am I crazy, or wasn't it Warner Brothers that decided not to cast Julie Andrews as Eliza Doolittle because she wasn't well known enough....and then she appeared in both Mary Poppins and Sound of Music almost immediately thereafter??? You think they would have learned!! (Although I am a huge fan of Audrey Hepburn, I really think that actors in musicals should be doing their own singing). I digress. Anyway, keep us all posted as to what we can do in protest. P.S. I consider myself a very lucky woman, because last month, as part of the pledge drive on my local PBS station (Channel 56, WTVS, in Detroit), I actually got to meet Michael Crawford and have my picture taken with him. I just got my pictures in the mail today, as a matter of fact. HE of course, looked great! And what fun it was to watch him do the pledge drive here!! A fellow fan, Debra Ball |
| Name: Stef Website: Stef's Musicals Page Referred by: Word of Mouth From: PA, USA Time: 1998-04-17 01:29:07 Comments: Thanks, again, Diane, for letting me use the No Antonio pic on my site! I totally agree that Banderas should not be the Phantom and MC or any other stage Phantom should get the part. Stef |
| Name: Michelle
(aka Little Lotte) =-) Website: Erik's Page- Cafe Lotte Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Michigan Time: 1998-04-16 17:38:06 Comments: Great site, Diane! I love the pic. Lets all hope that the role of our beloved Erik goes to the man who rightfully deserves it; the man who created the role and was promised it before anyone. I am, of course, talking of the imcomparable Michael Crawford. He may be older and not as well-known as Antonio, but he would make the movie phenominal, and people would see it again and again rather than just once. If they have to do a movie, I just hope they do it right; and the right thing to do would be to cast MC. -Erik's Bride |
| Name: Amy Carroll Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Gadsden, Alabama Time: 1998-04-16 16:48:46 Comments: Diane, Hi! I got your e-mail and thought I would visit your page. I am in total support of you. I agree that ALW and WB are not listening to the fans. I don't think that MC is necessarily the only one that could do the part, but I KNOW that Antonio Banderas is one who could not. I would however love to see MC take the part. He is such a fantastic actor and I know he would not disappoint. Well, that is my view about that. Amy Carroll |
| Name: Sharon Boles (Sheri) Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Albertville, AL Time: 1998-04-16 16:40:48 Comments: Dear Diane, I am a Michael fan myself and am utterly appalled that Antonio is even considered for the part. Michael Crawford is the original and only phantom. All of the others are "Copycats". I intend to write ALW and tell him my views. Like you, this fan can stay silent no longer. Let's hope we can make a difference. Sheri Boles |
| Name: Roger
Dickson Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Clarksville, TN USA Time: 1998-04-16 04:07:36 Comments: Not using Michael Crawford would be an insult to the fans of Phantom. Many would not go see the movie...I am sure. |
| Name: Matt Crigler Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Fort Lauderdale Time: 1998-04-16 02:56:04 Comments: When Gaston Leroux's Phantom died, he was reincarnated as Michael Crawford. He must play him. There is no other!!!! "The Opera Ghost really existed. He was not, as was long believed..." gaston leroux |
| Name: Dawn Swann Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Tacoma, WA Time: 1998-04-15 07:33:35 Comments: You've got the start of a really good site. Keep up the good work! Thanks for supporting Michael...he is so very special and precious to all of us at the Michael Crawford Mailing List. |
| Name: Nancy Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: SC Time: 1998-04-15 02:58:11 Comments: All I have to say is GO MICHAEL CRAWFORD!!!!! I have never gotten to see him live, but I was really hoping to see him in the role he was born to play--Erik. but NO, WB and ALW had to destroy my dream. I say no movie at alll!!!! Except with MC .....and I have to admit I would take some one with stage experience, but I WANT MC!!!!! I LOVE YOU MICHAEL, YOU'RE THE ANGEL OF MUSIC!!!! |
| Name: Darren W.
Freetage Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Akron, Ohio Time: 1998-04-14 19:13:38 Comments: Michael Crawford or anyone else who has played the role on stage should be the lead in the movie. This film does not need a movie star to sell it. The music sells itself. Hollywood should learn that. Yes Evita needed a star to sell it with Madonna, but everyone knows of the Phantom of the Opera with it's theatre marketing and wide word of mouth it has received touring and playing in many countries around the world. |
| Name: Viv Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Perth Australia Time: 1998-04-14 03:47:05 Comments: I cant believe that any studio would be silly enough to sign Banderas for the role of Phantom of the OPera. Michael Crawford is the quintessential Phantom,having won a Tony for his stage work in POTO. If the show goes ahead with Banderas it is obvious money only is the vision of the studio's,not making a classic film which would be around for years to come. Look what little impact Evita had.Is this what they want for Phantom. I think ALW should look at the thousands of fans who will not see the movies without Michael Crawford in the starring role. |
| Name: Aileen Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Lake Jackson, TX Time: 1998-04-13 23:44:26 Comments: Congratulations on your page, Diane. I support your stand on the Phantom film totally! I, too, would welcome the movie only if Michael Crawford is cast as Erik. I pray that this may come about and that the film is kept true to the original stage production. Michael Crawford is the one true Phantom! -- Aileen |
| Name: june laange Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: California Time: 1998-04-13 19:24:49 Comments: Found your message on the MC Berrett Maynard e-mails. Your's another slant, good show!!! |
| Name: Bonita Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Victoria, Austalia Time: 1998-04-13 12:42:10 Comments: Michael Crawford for the "Phantom" movie please, and only MC. I was fortunate enough to see MC in concert in Australia five years ago in "The Music of Andew Lloyd Webber"and without the aid of makeup, costumes, scenery, staging or that mask MC was able to convince me he was the Phantom. I've never heard anyone else portray the emotion and feeling he does in his singing of the Phantom music, he doesn't just sing the music like an "angel of music" but portrays Erik emotions in all facets of his character. I can't see how any Hollywood actor will be able to sing and portray the emotional needs of this role equal to MC and leave the audience convinced that Erik is deserving of sympathy at the end of the movie. MC for the Phantom movie and only MC. |
| Name: Maureen K. Troth Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: playbill article Time: 1998-04-12 15:16:23 Comments: Thank you Diane for what you are doing. I wish you every success. Hollywood has forgotten that some of us moviegoers still expect quality performances. No actor should be chosen for a part on name alone. Keep up the good work! |
| Name: Maureen K. Troth Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: playbill article Time: 1998-04-12 15:16:03 Comments: Thank you Diane for what you are doing. I wish you every success. Hollywood has forgotten that some of us moviegoers still expect quality performances. No actor should be chosen for a part on name alone. Keep up the good work! |
| Name: Louise Markowski Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Lancaster, CA Time: 1998-04-12 00:35:44 Comments: Commercialism and greed at its ugliest. Some people would sell their soul for wealth. Looks like Webber has sold out his play and his fans. I saw Michael Crawford sing in Cerritos. I just can't imagine Antonio Banderas replacing him in the movie. |
| Name: Allie Website: Oddeyes's Home Page Referred by: Word of Mouth From: TX Time: 1998-04-11 17:59:28 Comments: Phantom of the Opera is not ALW's personal creation-- the musical was based on the book by Gaston Leroux. The mere idea of ALW toying with the story more than he has (the musical left out a lot, but is still very well done) is disgusting. Erik was not handsome, so I don't understand why they're trying to cast these "handsome" guys... except to suck idiots into the theater who know nothing about Phantom. |
| Name: Janet
Emanuelson Website: Referred by: NewsGroups From: Santa Cruz, California, USA Time: 1998-04-11 06:14:36 Comments: I don't understand their reasoning either. Michael would bring in their almighty buck and yet be true to the story. |
| Name: Christine Website: Save Phantom From Hollywood Referred by: Word of Mouth From: UK Time: 1998-04-11 03:06:44 Comments: Hi... Well, you already know that I am completely against the movie and think the casting of Banderas is insane, and that the sequel is perhaps an even worse idea, so I don't really need to say it again! |
| Name: Yeo J Kim Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: LA Time: 1998-04-11 02:37:04 Comments: I am glad that I could meet a person who has same opinion as I have. I definately agree with you and would like to support your activety if possible. I think that's why I broke my silence and started talking to you. By writing to you I'd like to let you know that there are many fans who want to see MC on the screen as a phantom (because they lost their chance to see him on the stage.)but the fact that they don't have internet access make them off from joining your activity. So be encouraged and have a strong voice, there are fans backing you up |
| Name: Willaim Paul
McGinity Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Pittsburgh, PA Time: 1998-04-10 22:06:37 Comments: I totally support a movie being made about Phantom of the Opera as long as Michael Crawford is the title role. Long live PHANTOM! |
| Name: Laura Geyser Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: San Diego, CA Time: 1998-04-09 20:24:23 Comments: I find it hard to understand. Are they really going to use Antonio Banderas? I saw him in Evita. Can he sing opera? I saw Michael Crawford on stage. I don't think I will see this movie. I prefer my memories. How sad for Michael Crawford. How sad for all of us. |
| Name: Connie Kidwell Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Heath, Ohio Time: 1998-04-09 20:16:14 Comments: This is the best support I've seen for a "Classic Phantom" purist! There is only one Phamton, Michael Crawford!!!!!! I could never pay good money to see any other Phantom!!! The "Warner People" need to realize that it makes it's money one ticket at a time, and there are many of us who will refuse to pay for an inferior performance!!!! Please, please give us what we are more than willing (many, many times) to pay for, Michael Crawford!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| Name: Louise Burd
Flogerzi Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Palmdale, Ca. 93550 Time: 1998-04-09 17:32:25 Comments: We want Michael Crawford and Dale Kristan in the movie version of Phantom of the Opera !!!!!!! |
| Name: Suzy Flogerzi Inglett Website: Referred by: Word of Mouth From: Time: 1998-04-05 20:13:35 Comments: Keep up the good work, from a new fan, Suzy |
| Name: Diane Website: Referred by: Just Surfed On In! From: Time: 1998-04-05 02:37:40 Comments: Welcome to the Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Guestbook. I thought I would be the first to sign in support of Michael Crawford in the movie Phantom of the Opera! |