An Open Letter to Andrew Lloyd Webber

 

Total: 100 Guests

Friday 08/29/2003 10:08:36pm
Name: Judith A Parry
E-Mail: juparry@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Salt Lake City, Utah
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: There is no one better for the Phantom, than Michael Crawford. How can it matter how old he is, hes wearing a mask. He has the most wonderful voice, I listen to his tapes, I have the orig broadway cast and others, please, please cast him in the movie, you are the best composer, writer we have now, tks, Judith Parry
Thursday 08/28/2003 5:56:11pm
Name: Vokar
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Dassel, MN
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: "Fondest greetings to you"
Why aren't you putting MC for the Phantom? Why? over 8000 people signed for him! But of course, "You don't have to! They can't make you!" It would have been such a wonderful choise! You would have made million more! Litterally! "It's your desision, but WHY not?" Are you "backing out"? Compared to MC the other singers are in did "insolent boy"s and "slave[s] of fasion" and "ignorant fool[s]" by way of music. Another thing is that I have heard a rumor that you are taking out music?! Are you? I can understand adding music (Here [you] bring the finished score!") I'm not so entirly sure about have Mr. Butler, but taking out your music!? Things brings to mind such things as "down you plunge""down that path into darkness (actually red numbers if you get my drift)""D*%nable!""How dare you!""[You] are ruined [Webber] ruined!!" Why this is so bad "It's just the sort of story" one would expect of disaster. The Phantom will not be so ghost like, the theaters will! The new "Phantom" "is nothing but a man! But while he [plays], the" theater will seem haughnted. Oh, well. "These things do happen."
Thursday 08/21/2003 11:51:15pm
Name: Marie Chappal
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: the bay area
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: I first heard the Phantom of the Opera as recordings of Michael Crawford's and Sarah Brightman's performances and I fell in love with the music. I am just fourteen and so I haven't had the chance to actually see them. When I heard about this movie me and my mom were overjoyed. But then I heard that Michael Crawford might not be in it, and was extremely disappointed. He is what makes up the Phantom! my mom has seen P/O 6 times and still totally loves the performance of Michael Crawford over all others. I will be VERY sad and dissappointed (as will MC fans everywhere) if u decide to cut out Michael Crawford.
Tuesday 08/19/2003 6:26:48pm
Name: what's it to u?
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: the middle of nowhere
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Mr. Webber, PLEASE put MC as the OG. I will be very angry if you do not. You do not want to be in the same state as me if I am angry, so here is a warning. MC is the BEST Phantom I have ever, or will ever, see or hear. Do NOT put some sappy actor who knows noting about the story instead of our orignal Opera Ghost. Remember what I said!
Tuesday 08/19/2003 6:22:19pm
Name: Erin
E-Mail: magicsgerl@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: what's it to u?
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: pu-lease put M.C. as the Phantom in the new movie! His voice is the best Phantom voice I have ever heard, all ghostly like and all. If you do not, I will be very angry. And one does not want an angry Barrel Racer!
PLEASE PUT MC AS PHANTOM!!!
Saturday 08/16/2003 3:03:31pm
Name: Jason
E-Mail: excelmanager@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: North Carolina
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Mr Webber, you have just signed the death warrant for Phantom of the Opera. I got taken in by it after listening to the CD's of Phantom. Many of my friends and family had done the same, then we saw the live broadway shows. Although Crawford wasn't there, we still enjoyed it a lot. Then there were my friends who did not hear the CD first and get sucked into the music of Crawford who say the live broadway. They were not very thrilled with it, and it was no big deal to them. Because Crawford is why we got into the Phantom, and now your casting somebody who just learned how to sing 1 month or so ago? Me and many fans are going to boycott the movie, I shall NOT see it, and I will rip off a FREE copy of it from Kazaa. You had better cease production of the movie and put Crawford in, or this will be a very large montetary mistake for you. If you have crawford, you'll have millions of fans on opening weekend, if you don't, you'll be hearing crickets in the theater on opening night.
Wednesday 07/30/2003 11:01:55am
Name: Amber Caul
E-Mail: broniadavis@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Uk
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Andrew, you are a total genius ... And a damn fool! How can you let some young sexy git of an actor steal the role that you and Michael created out of talent and friendship? Its obsurd to think that the likes of John Travolta are being asked to play the Opera Ghost, I mean can you seriously imagine, the Phantom bursting out a little song and dance of "night fever"? In his dungeon of black depair? I love your musical - it changed my life - and every moment I hear nothing but Michaels voice in my head. . . maybe its because that you've been hearing that voice for over a decade, but I'm only 13 and I swear to God if you do this ( as in NOT give MC the role of the Phantom) I will definatley f***ing kill myself, okay? Your obidient servant A.C.
Saturday 07/26/2003 3:55:01pm
Name: Emily
E-Mail: Empem8@pacbell.net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: California
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: I would like to say that since I heard of the possibility of making the Phantom of the Opera into a movie, I was really excited. But I think that it is a huge mistake not to use Michael Crawford. He is the man who made the Phantom. Even the Phantom who is touring right now, Brad Little, said that every Phantom has followed the mold created by Michael. Michael's voice is the purest, most beautiful voice...he has become the voice of the Phantom. To not allow him to play the role for which he has made famous,replacing him with a younger, sexier actor, is a huge mistake.
Sunday 07/20/2003 2:29:42pm
Name: Kathryn
E-Mail: LiserLS@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: CA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Andrew,
I went to a concert last night regarding the very best of your music. It featured one new song from the phantom movie, I must say it is so beautiful, it's called The Hardest Note To Write. I hope you will leave the score and add just a couple more songs that are critical to the story. I also hope you'll include Michael Crawford in at least directing something in the movie!! Thanks!
Wednesday 07/16/2003 12:22:03am
Name: I'll never te-ell
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Parts Unknown
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Not to be mean, but I'd really like to see your PHANTOM OF THE OPERA movie flop so you'll learn a lesson about casting and changing the script
Monday 06/30/2003 6:09:05pm
Name: Laura
E-Mail: PrettyGrl141@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir Lloyd Webber,
Even though you probably will not cast Michael Crawford and put Gerard Butler as th new, young, sexy phantom as you say he is, I will respect your decision for the casting and support the movie. We are not going against you, we would just rather see Michael Crawford than Gerard Butler. Gerard will be expected to be good because you chose him and you chose Michael Crawford all those years ago. So I hope you get the movie done soon, because I'm dying to see it. Thanks for making the Phantom an expierence from Heaven.
- Laura (a future Christine Daae)
Sunday 06/29/2003 11:09:45pm
Name: Michael
E-Mail: BeemanII@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: USA
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber...you CANT ADD NEW SONGS TO PHANTOM. The stage show is amazing the way it is and that is why it needs to be preserved. I will tell straight out that you will get some pretty unhappy fans if you CUT any shows from the musical. Adding a few songs is one thing but there is not ONE song in that musical that is not brilliant and can be cut. Phantom fans are hoping to see and adaption of the stage show NOT another Robert Englund or Claud Rains "VERSION" of Phantom... I mean really have you not LEARNED that Evita was a FLOP...stick to what you have...the stage musical is brilliant and should stay so
Thursday 06/26/2003 6:22:07am
Name: Pia Francesca
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Foggia /ITALY
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir,
Friday 06/20/2003 1:49:47pm
Name: Another Upset Fan
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Mr. Lloyd Webber, how could you do this to us?? How could you let us down by casting someone else and not Crawford as the Phantom?? I'm thoroughly disappointed in you.

We, the fans, counted on you to cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the POTO movie as you promised. We wanted so much to see Michael Crawford either once again or for the first time.

Mr. Lloyd Webber, I've been a fan of yours for quite some time, and all these years you have never let me down once. JOSEPH was amazing because you cast Donny Osmond in it. JCS was awesome because Glenn Carter was in it.

Now for the first tim you have let me down. Your Phantom movie would have been successful if Crawford had been the choice.

Well, this letter is long enough. I better let you go. Bye.
Friday 06/20/2003 1:33:25pm
Name: A Peeved Off Fan
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: None of your business
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Lord Webber, I would just like to say something briefly. Since you didn't cast Micheal Crawford in the Phantom Movie...YOUR PHANTOM FILM WILL NEVER BE SUCCESSFULL!!!
Sunday 06/15/2003 11:23:25pm
Name: Mary Weaver
E-Mail: Sweetums@sc.rr.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Sumter, SC
Referred By: Web Ring
Comments: I really wish that you would reconsider and use Michael Crawford for the Phantom of the Opera movie. I have seen the musical twice and, unfortunately, have not seen Michael Crawford in the role. I have the CD with his voice on it and have also seen him live in Las Vegas when he did EFX. He is absolutely terrific!! Please give everyone, who didn't get to see him in the Phantom of the Opera, a chance to see him in the role that he made famous!
Tuesday 06/10/2003 8:25:09pm
Name: Katie Zenk
E-Mail: starstruckdiva@charter.net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: USA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dearest Lord Lloyd Webber,
I want you to know how much I enjoy your musical "The Phantom of the Opera"! It is sheer genius! I was, however, dissappointed to learn that you will not be using Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman in the movie. It is rumored that Mr. Crawford will not be cast because of his age. I am well aware that he is older than the "desirable" age, but he doesn't look it. Besides, he would have the mask and a ton of make-up on. No one would ever know. More than that, it's not about looks, it's about the voice, the SOUL, he gives the Phantom. No one can play the Phantom like he can! My mother and I are both fanatics about the Phantom. We both feel that the movie, should be like "Cats" and "Joseph" video versions of the musical. At least that's what we,(and all the fans we know) want. It, of course, is your decision, but I sincerly hope that you would consider the wishes of your fans!
Sincerly Yours,
Katie Zenk
Sunday 06/08/2003 10:48:33pm
Name: maria roman
E-Mail: lucindastrinkets@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: mn in usa
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: you are looking a gift horse in the mouth. Who do yoou think madfe phantom. it's a crime to even think of anyone else
Sunday 06/08/2003 10:48:16pm
Name: maria roman
E-Mail: lucindastrinkets@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: mn in usa
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: you are looking a gift horse in the mouth. Who do yoou think madfe phantom. it's a crime to even think of anyone else
Wednesday 03/19/2003 2:43:59am
Name: Erika Nelsen
E-Mail: TheaterFan24601@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Plymouth, MN, USA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: DEAR LORD LLOYD WEBBER:

On behalf of all of the people at the MICHAEL CRAWFORD PHANTOM MOVIE CAMPAIGN website, I would just like to inform you that your fans, are VERY upset with you for refusing to cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the PHANTOM OF THE OPERA movie.

We do not want to see our favorite musical being ruined by Hollywood. Look a what happened to Evita. It bombed (meaning it was bad) because you got a Hollywood cast to do it. We don't want the same thing to happen to PHANTOM.

Michael Crawford is NOT too old to play the Phantom. He played Count Von Crolock in DANCE OF THE VAMPIRES, which I am sure is a demanding role. If he can do DANCE OF THE VAMPIRES, then he can do PHANTOM OF THE OPERA.

You're depriving your fans of the man who made it all happen, especially those who have not had the chance to see Michael Crawford as the Phantom.

You've heard our pleas and you've read our letters. We've asked you, now we're begging you to cast our beloved Michael Crawford to play the Phantom.

The fans and I will stand together and see that Michael Crawford plays the Phantom in the PHANTOM OF THE OPERA movie. We will not give up.

So do the right thing. Give Michael Crawford back the roll that made him famous. Cast him as the Phantom in the PHANTOM OF THE OPERA movie.

Sincerely,
Erika Nelsen, the people of the MICHAEL CRAWFORD MOVIE CAMPAIGN, and all the rest of your fans
Thursday 03/13/2003 2:48:16am
Name: Kevin Faulkner
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Norman, Ok
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Please, don't sell out to some Hollywood fool. Michael Crawford did an AMAZING job playing the Phantom, but so have numerous Phantoms in touring shows. Even if Michael Crawford turns down the role or is deemed inappropriate due to age or any other silly reason (or simply turns the role down), the part should go to someone who can play it with a degree of skill superior to, say, Antonio Banderas. You put so much work into this, and we have been loyal. You owe it to yourself, the fans, and every castmember or crewman to make the best possible artistic decision. The fans will buy art, but we'll be less apt to return four times to watch Antonio Banderas.
Tuesday 03/11/2003 7:44:38pm
Name: Tammy Sokol
E-Mail: tammy@thesokols.org
Homepage Title: The Sokols.org
Homepage URL: http://www.thesokols.org
Where are you from?: origoanlly, Texas, now living in Georgia
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber:

Years ago, I went to a theatre in San Antonio, Texas, and sat through one of the most wonderful amazing, spectacular things I have ever seen, "The Phantom of the Opera".

I am sure people have told you this over and over, and I wanted to add mine to the many accolades that you have received. Your work on "Phantom" is without equal. It is the best thing I have ever seen. Michael Crawford is perfect as the Phantom. You can't go wrong with him in the much hoped for an anticipated (especailly by me) movie. Again, thank you for the wonderful experience I had at "Phantom".

Tammy Sokol
Monday 03/10/2003 5:33:06am
Name: Scott Phelps
E-Mail: raven92080@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Parma ,Ohio
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Andrew Lloyd Webber,

I am writing to ask that you use Michael Crawford as "The Phantom" in your movie adaptation of "The Phantom of the Opera". He was the amazing actor that I saw the first time that I saw your amazing musical. He is a part of the reason that I still love "The Phantom of the Opera". I have heard other's try to pull off the same role, but none can compare to the way he pulls it off.
He symbolizes "The Phantom" for me in every way. From the the way he sings the role to the way he moves to the way he looks as "The Phantom".
PLEASE! PLEASE cast him for the role.
And thank you for your most valuable time.


Sincerly,
Scott Phelps
Sunday 03/09/2003 10:00:15pm
Name: Unknown
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Unknown
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: I can't BELIEVE that you would think Michael Crawford is too old to be the Phantom. I mean, COME ON. Would you vote for a president for his age and his looks?? Of course not.

You'd vote for a president for the good work that he does and a promising performance. If he was a good president you really wouldn't care about his age or his looks.

Well that's the same deal with the PHANTOM movie. You can't just cast someone based on their age or their looks. You have to cast them based on the quality of their voice and the hard work they do. Michael Crawford is just the man to do the role.

I mean, so what if he's too old? He's going to be in makeup so it won't really matter.

All I'm trying to say is that we (the fans) really don't care about how old Michael Crawford is. We just want the best and the best is Crawford.

So do us all a favor and vote "CRAWFORD FOR PHANTOM." It'll just save you a lot of trouble if you do. Trust me. You'll be glad you did.
Sunday 03/09/2003 3:22:28am
Name: Megana
E-Mail: megana_williams
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Wales
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Please, please choose the quality phantom actor that is Crawford.
Saturday 03/08/2003 10:19:54pm
Name: Charles T. Capone
E-Mail: wand@mahanoycity,net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: PA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Lord Webber,
After seeing Michael in DOTV several times, I think you should reconsider your thoughts. Michael Crawford created the character Erik and should be in the role in the movie. Michael's age should not be even a consideration. if you would have seen his performance in DOTV it was amazing and that voice!! Sorry, he is and always will be Phantom!! Please reconsider.
Wednesday 02/26/2003 9:37:58pm
Name: An Angry Fan
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir Lloyd Webber,

Mr. Lloyd Webber, I just want you to know that not casting Michael Crawford to play the Phantom in your PHANTOM OF THE OPERA movie is a slap in all of your fans' faces.

We spend countless amounts of money on tickets, CDs, posters, T-shirts, and other merchandise from PHANTOM OF THE OPERA. We, the fans are the ones making the money for you and giving you what you want. And now this is how you repay us?

You should give us what we want in return for giving you fame and fortune. We all want Michael Crawford as the Phantom in your movie, and we will NOT give up without a fight. We will NOT stay silent.

THE ROLL IS THE MAN! THE MAN IS CRAWFORD!!!
Monday 02/17/2003 6:44:05pm
Name: josh {JAZZ}
E-Mail: joshbird@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: aylesbury
Referred By: Web Ring
Comments: please put m.c in the movie i love ur shows n the film versions of ur shows he is great no matter what the age
Friday 02/14/2003 0:16:27am
Name: Sarah-Ann Lee
E-Mail: lee_meixia@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: planet earth
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Lord webber,

If you're reading this, I just want to tell you that I think you're making a gigantic mistake. I'm a new fan of crawford, a bit late really, since someone lent me the highlights of POTO i've been looking for the double disk but I just can't seem to find it in singapore...

If you are thinking that MIchael is too old to play the phantom, I can jolly well say that you are too old to be making musicals! and besides, you think Erick was only around 45 when he fell in love with christine? come on man! he would have been around 60 and even if he was a bit younger than that, Michael would be under all that makeup so no one would really care.

What we really care about is to hear Michaels voice sing the role he was destined for, that is all.

And if you thind AB can do it you are so wrong, the guy is too tall to act as a frenchman! he's spanish!
Friday 02/07/2003 7:16:49pm
Name: Melanie Dyer
E-Mail: terreis1@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Arkansas
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Mr. Webber,

When I was only twelve, I was taken to New York City with fourteen other girls my age. We were from a small town and, naturally, NYC was overwhelming for us. We were there for four days and saw fantastic things, but, on our first night there, we saw The Phantom of the Opera.
I'll never forget it. It was the first real play I'd ever seen and I immediately fell in love with it. I don't remember now who played the Phantom, because as soon as I got back home and bought the soundtrack, Michael Crawford's voice pierced my very soul. He IS the Phantom. No one else could ever be. Even now, thirteen years after I saw the play, all I have to do is hear Michael Crawford's voice and I'm transported back to that night.
Please don't rob those who haven't been able to see the play of the chance to see this man act in the part he was born for.
Sincerely,
Melanie Dyer
Saturday 02/01/2003 6:22:52pm
Name: Nancy Hoffman
E-Mail: otchmeg@aol.com
Homepage Title: Phantom
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Harrisburg, Pa. USA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: I had the priveledge of seeing Michael Crawford in Dance of the Vampires on Closing night. He is just as awesome and talented as he was 15 years ago in Phantom. In my humble opinion, HE is the Phantom and any movie made without him cast as such will be a hugh Farce!
Monday 01/27/2003 2:51:39pm
Name: Mrs Sandra McLeod
E-Mail: csmith@biocare.org
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Boston, Ma USA
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Sir,
We have heard that you believe that Michael Crawford is now too old to play the lead in the film. ACTUALLY, he is probably just the right age for perceptions of the phantom. He is also THE best. PLEASE reconsider. We are old fans (54 yrs old) of yours.
Thank You,
Tom & Sandy Mcleod
Monday 01/20/2003 2:24:11pm
Name: Phanari Rhun
E-Mail: phanari@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Phelan
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: ALW,
You really shouldn't worry so much about MC's age. He has a wonderful voice and he wrote the role of the Phantom not to mention the fact that he's still a lady killer (have you ever been to one of his concerts? You'll never seen so many women in one room in your life) and besides, he'll have a mask and tons of make-up on his face so you son't have to worry. Oh, and you must know that Erik (the real Phantom) was much older than 60 when he fell in love with Christine. It makes plenty of sense for the era. Come on, give MC a chance. We all want him and I'm sure you'll have the money and crowds you want in your movie.
~Phanari
Sunday 01/19/2003 4:01:37pm
Name:  
E-Mail: Phantomrose20
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber,

How can you possibly think of casting anyone else besides Michael Crawford as the Phantom?! I mean, are you crazy?

Back in high school is when my love for the Phantom began. I was the only student in the whole freaking school who was a fan of the Phantom and because of this I was severely teased and made fun of.
I would come home everyday after school crying from being made fun of just for liking the Phantom of the Opera.

And now this is how you repay me for suffering just to be a fan of your music? By not casting Michael Crawford in your Phantom Movie and making me suffer more?

Do me a favor and end my suffering. Please cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom.
Friday 01/17/2003 11:39:35pm
Name: Laura Schultz
E-Mail: PrettyGrl141@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: CA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber,
First, I want to thank you for all the work that you have done for the world over these many years. I wrote a letter to you saying how I love The Phantom and that I was going to sing a solo of the Music of the Night. I'm in 7th Grade- and well you see I'm not your average teen. I am a broadway freak and want to be singing the part of Christine Daae one day. When I sing my solo of the Music of the Night, the one person I want in my audience is... Michael Crawford. He has inspired me so much to be all that I want to be. It's true I've never met the talented man, and he doesn't know who I am but I know that he is with me somehow. When my older brother told me that there was a Phantom movie coming out I thought I would have a heart attack. Of course I thought it would be the original cast, but when I found out that it probably wouldn't, I was in deep despair. Michael made your dreams come true now its your turn to make one of his dreams to come true. I heard Antonio Banderas sing the Phantom part and he isn't half as good. If you put Michael as the Phantom youwould make me and everyone around the world extremely happy. Well please consider what I have said and thank you for taking your precious time of reading this letter.

Love always,
Laura S.- a future Christine Daae
Friday 01/17/2003 10:01:03pm
Name: Lauren K.
E-Mail: popcorn1289@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: California
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Mr. Lloyd Webber,

Recently I heard the news that the Phantom movie project is going ahead. I congratulate you on one of the smartest desicions you've ever made in your life. HOWEVER... I have also heard some rather unpleasant rumors about Antonio Banderas. :( . Why on earth would you cast HIM as the phantom???????? Please... your work is the best I've heard in a long time... don't ruin it. I can assure you, the main reason that you'll have an audience for this movie is if you have the only true phantom actor in the role: Michael Crawford. Please... do everyone a favor... don't ruin something so special. Michael Crawford IS the Phantom. Would you take him away from us?
Tuesday 01/14/2003 10:02:00pm
Name: Danise A. Hegerty
E-Mail: DofB5@prodigy.net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: January 14, 2003

Dear Sir Lloyd Webber,

I know that you must have read many letters in this
campaign to have Mr. Crawford star as the “Phantom of
the Opera”. It is my hope to possibly bring a
different perspective and to that end I only ask a
chance to plead not Mr. Crawford’s case but Erik’s.

I am a 44-year-old woman, not a child. I am not a
card-carrying member of Mr. Crawfords fan club. I do,
however, have a great respect for the man and his
work.

I first heard “Music Of The Night” on the “Premiere
Collection” CD which was given to me as a gift. It
caught my ear so I purchased the “Phantom” CD.

Eric’s voice moved me to tears. No thoughts of what
the actor looked like or his age entered my mind. The
music and the voice wrapped themselves around my heart
like silken thread and bound me to them.

When I finely was able to see “Phantom” at a road
show, I was very disappointed. My head knew it
wouldn’t be the same voice but the silken thread
around my heart tightened, refusing to allow me to
acknowledge the usurper. I walked out of the theater
feeling hollow and unfulfilled.

No matter how many times I have seen “Phantom” since
then I have never had the experience that matched the
voice on the CD. Many may try to replace him, but
that voice is the yardstick, by which all others must
be judged, weighed and ultimately found to be wanting.
Perhaps it was the truest “Phantom” of all, not
judged by appearances but by voice alone.

I believe that this is the sentiment the others of
this board are trying (perhaps a little over
enthusiastically) to convey to you.

I beg you to go some place quiet and to set aside all
images or thoughts of the appearance/age of the
actors. Please listen to their voices alone. Picture
Eric and I know in my heart that you will find there
is no reason to rethink your original choice.

The tears I’ll shed should you decide on someone other
than Mr. Crawford to portray Eric won’t be so much for
him as for Eric. You will have given him a body but
robbed him of his soul.

Thank you for your time, kind attention and any
consideration you may give my words.

I remain,

Respectfully yours,

Danise A. Hegerty
DofB5@prodigy.net
Tuesday 01/14/2003 3:54:54am
Name: Crystal Beck
E-Mail: sleuthgirl24@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Kentucky
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber,
I discovered today on TV Guide online that due to the success of "Chicago" you have finally decided to produce the film version of "Phantom". I am exhuberated at the idea. "Phantom" is my favorite musical and I have long wished to be able to watch it whenever my heart desires. But the article also metioned that Antonio Banderas has expressed an interest in the lead role. PISH POSH! He cannot sing the role of "phantom" and I would be disgusted til the end of time if he were to recieve this role. The obvious choice is Michael Crawford! He is what the fans want! You can use the other role to bring in the star power. Nicole Kidman as Christine. Ewan Mcgreggor as Raoul. But please, for the love of this musical and the fans who adore it so much, DO NOT CAST ANTONIO BANDERAS! I heard him sing "Music Of the Night" as few years ago at the tribute for you. He does not have the voice. If not Michael Crawford then please find someone who can pull off a falsetto note without making my blood curdle. "Erik" was not a stud! He was a pure soul, tortured and tormented his whole life for his appearance. Banderas would be an insult. I beg you, on bended knee. Do this film the justice is deserves. And please remove that, pardon my french, bull shit line of "don't forget the angel of hell" from the final act. It makes "Erik" seem cruel, stallerish, and sadistic. He was in actuality none of these things, but an animal who only attacked when he felt threatened. I thought I was going to scream when this was added during a performance I recently saw. "Erik" is a tragic character that has a beauty within him that is unable to live in the light because of the biases of the majority. His love for Christine is pure with no boundries, but years of physical, mental, and emotional abuse sends him into fits of madness. The actor who plays this role should have that kind of depth, and Banderas does not. The first actor I saw perform this live, Brad Little, was just what I had hoped for, minus not being Crawford. Crawford is not too old for the role since "Erik" is between 30 and 60. Keep the fans in mind when casting for this film. I beg you!

Your Obiedient Servant and Friend,

Ms. Crystal Beck
Sunday 01/12/2003 3:01:46am
Name: Tina
E-Mail: Jimmeebufet@cox.net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: USA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT !!! think of Antonio Banderas as the Phantom for the movie!!!! There is no one like Crawford with that voice that could make it work. I have seen the play about 7 times live and the only one that came close was a gentleman at the Wang Center in Boston about 6 years ago (I'm sorry, I forgot his name). I would absolutely LOVE to see Phantom on the big screen, but to be honest, if it was Banderas I don't think I would go. What a let down. Thanks for your time. And thanks for a great musical.....I've loved it for years and have known it word for word for quite a few of them :)
Saturday 01/11/2003 8:45:29pm
Name: Erica
E-Mail: angel_of_music89@yahoo.com
Homepage Title: The Angel's Labyrinth
Homepage URL: http://www.geocities.com/americanangel34429/theangelslabyrinth.html?1038275326660
Where are you from?: Florida
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber,
I LOVE your musical, the Phantom of the Opera. I first saw it on a field trip in 6th grade - I am now in 8th and I can still remember every little detail of that romantic, thrilling story... I can't remember who I saw as the Phantom, but after the show, I bought the CD with the original cast. When I read the cover, it said "Michael Crawford". "Hmm, I thought to myself, I wonder if he's any good!" I turn the CD on and I about faint. He was AMAZING! No words can describe how he sang. I now listen to that CD every single night, especially The Music of the Night because I love hearing Michael Crawford sing... When I heard that a movie of the Phantom of the Opera was going to be produced, I was thrilled. When I heard you were casting Michael Crawford, I was ecstatic. When I heard that you had been thinking about breaking your promise to Mr. Crawford and casting Antonio Bandares, my heart broke into a million pieces!! Yes, Antonio can sing. He has a good voice, but not a Phantom voice. It compares absolutely NOTHING to Michael Crawford's voice, which is sweet, soft, persuasive, and inticing. Mr. Crawford's voice is the PERFECT Phantom voice!!!! You, as well as anyone should know that. He was the ORIGINAL PHANTOM and the only true one... Mr. Webber, I may only be thirteen years old, but I know a talented, inticing voice when I hear one. And that voice belongs to Michael Crawford!
Wednesday 01/01/2003 8:48:29pm
Name: Richard K. Christovich
E-Mail: proteus333@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: New Orleans, LA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Lord Webber, Your Lordship created the Phantom, and Michael Crawford became the Phantom in every manner you could have envisioned. Please support his continuation of the role in the movie version. Thank you so much for all of the enjoyment you have brought to me and my family through your many works. Sincerely, R. K. Christovich
Monday 12/16/2002 6:58:22pm
Name: Wesley A. Kelly
E-Mail: -
Homepage Title: The man is the role, Crawford campain
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Portland Or
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: First of all I would like to give Andrew Lloyd Webber the recognition he is due for his work in the birth of the most beautiful and passionate piece of preformance art ever.Gaston Leroux would be pleased I am sure.Phantom of the opera has grown to become one of the most highly attended musicals ever. It has touched my life and once again I Thank you. However the overall balance of passion and power, seduction and grace, are largely owed to the foundation layed by the charismatic Micheal Crawford. I was horrified to hear that you,as one of the original master minds of this creation would consider having anyone other than Mr.Crawford portray our phantom on the silver screen.Broadway preformers can always change, this however is a perminent representation of the dream, the monster,the man, the phantom. You owe it to the fans who have also helped POTO become what is today, to do all in your power to keep the dream alive and preserved on film in all its glory. You know whats right. Dont let personal disires interfere with aesthetic judgement.
Saturday 12/14/2002 11:32:36pm
Name: Phantom lover
E-Mail: band_chick9@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Iowa
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Lord Llyod-Webber,
"Many have sent you letters of the most amiable nature, detailing how this musical should be cast. Our orders have not been obeyed, but we'll give you one last chance...
Michael Crawford is available to you, and we are anxious his career should progress...You shall therefore cast Banderas as Buquet. The part of the Phantom calls for a voice and appeal. The character Buquet dies quickly, which makes our casting, in a word, ideal! If these demands are not met, a box-office disaster beyond your imagination will occur.
I remain respectfully yours,
P.L."
Sunday 12/08/2002 10:47:34pm
Name:  
E-Mail: SweetPassion21@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Mr. Webber, you know right well that everyone wants Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the POTO movie and not Antonio Banderas or whoever the hell that guy is. So just give the fans what they want and cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom. He was the guy I fell in love with when I first heard the CD, not some spanish freak. Cast Antonio or any other person to be the Phantom, and you can kiss your fame and fortune goodbye.

P.S. I wasn't trying to be rude, but I was just telling you all of this for your own good.
Thursday 12/05/2002 2:50:41pm
Name: Maestro le Fantome
E-Mail: meastro_le_fantome@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Wilton IA
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Mr. Webber,
have you lost your senses, as a writer myself I know the feelings of wanting the best for your piece, however, Antonio is not the answer. You had him all along, Mr. Crawford.
He is the only one with the right to wear that mask.
My final note, you created a beautiful musical, and we thank you, but us fans are numerous and pissed off.
The artist can not exist without his fans,
Your obediant servent
Maestro le Fantome
Thursday 11/14/2002 1:37:01am
Name: Elena Hoexter
E-Mail: ehoexter@attbi.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Fremont ,California
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Phantom of the Opera IS the greatest musical I have ever seen. I found it interesting and questionable to why Antonio Bandaras would be cast beside Sarah. It just doesn't seem right. No one can take the place of Michael Crawford and it just seems so much more appropriate to keep Michael, the real Phantom, the one who has the experience and dedication and knowledge of the part. If Antonio Bandaras would be cast, it wouldn't have the same effect as Michael does on the Phantom fans. I am not saying that Antonio Bandaras doesn't sing well, it just isn't the same. People are so used to Michael that no one else would be exceptable. I mean, if Michael couldn't do, I think it would be wise to consider someone else who has had as much stage experience and experience with the part, such as Franc Di' Ambrosio. However, Michael is top choice. The Phantom phans(fans) and I ( I assume I speak for the other fans) don't think that casting Antonio would be appropriate.

THanks for the most wonderful music in the history of musicals.

A dedicated Phantom and Michael fan
Saturday 10/19/2002 7:56:20am
Name: jakub
E-Mail: chipmunkfisherman@most-wanted.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Australia
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: dear ALW
What do you think you are doing? Making your loyal fans suffer, look at all the sad and dissapointed faces around you. Why dont you listen to us? and keep YOUR fans happy, we are ones who have to go watch it to make you the money , so let Micheal Crawford play the role.
Jakub
Wednesday 10/16/2002 1:25:04am
Name: Sharon Payne
E-Mail: sharon_l_payne@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Australia
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr Lloyd-Webber,

I have been a fan of your brilliant creation Phantom of the Opera for a number of years now. At the tender age of 16 I was introduced to this visually stunning and beautifully written musical by a good friend for which I will be forever grateful. For my 17th birthday, I bought the album and listened to it continuously for three days and I am not ashamed to say that it was for one reason and one alone. The voice of Michael Crawford. While I hold attachment to a number of others who have played this role such as Rob Guest of Australia and Colm Wilkinson it is a role that truly belongs to Michael and none other. When I heard rumours of Antonio Banderas possibly playing the title role and heard a sample of his singing from your birthday special, I was most disturbed. Please Andrew, for the sake of the dignity of the character and for the well-being of your fans, allow Michael to continue and bring to life on the big screen, this character which has captured the hearts of many.

Sincerly and with much pleading,

Sharon
Wednesday 10/09/2002 10:16:15am
Name: Barbara stasak
E-Mail: crazygurl@netlimit.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: Australia
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Two days ago I brought the original cast recording of POTO after becaming intersted in Phantom thourgh reading the book.The first thing i listened to was the song POTO MC sounded nothing like I would have thought in fact I almost fell out of my chair , if there is a Angel of Music its Micheal Crawford and in my opionen you are mad not to cast him in the role and give people like me who are only 14 to see Micheal Crawford preform Phantom. I am yet to see Phantom but when I do I shall be imaging Micheal in the role the whole time.
Thankyou
 
Sunday 10/06/2002 10:11:24am
Name: Janne
E-Mail: operafantomet@hotmail.com
Homepage Title: Janes world
Homepage URL: http://www.geocities.com/pisslei/mas
Where are you from?: Norway
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Andrew, Andrew. Dearest Andrew. I could of course quote from Phantom (you were once my friend and father, then my world was shattered.... and so on), but that would be a too cheap point. I could hold against you what you have claimed in the past concerning the casting of this horrid movie. But I think you are aware of what you have said. I might mention that 92 % of the Phans worldwide claims that Michael Crawford is their first choice Phantom.
But no, the only thing I want to say to you is: SHAME ON YOU. Yes, "Phantom of the Opera" is your musical and your music. But the play will no longer be THE musical in the world if you don't pay attention to all of us - the Phans - which has supported and demanded more of Phantom for over 15 years. Why won't you pay attention to us? Why do you choose an amatheur singer as THE PHANTOM??? Even Harrison Ford would have been a better cast! I am so ashamed of and disappointed in you, although I don't know you and never will. I am honestly embarrased that you sell your masterpiece and integrity for the almighty money god. I had better thoughts of you. Had. No more.
"Angel of music, you denied us. Turning from true beauty."
Saturday 09/28/2002 11:23:18am
Name: ????
E-Mail: ????@cs.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: over there
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: ALW,
What are you thinking?? You made very many masterpieces but the Phantom is THE BEST!! CATS was a big hit and you didn't go Hollywood!! You have billions and billions of dollars, so how much more do you need?? I saw The Phantom of the Opera one year ago when I was 11!! Ive been obsessed with it and while kids in my class like Sugar Ray and stuff I am the only 6th grader who listens to The Phantom and ONLY The PHANTOM!! Please dont dissappoint your loyal phans by casting antonio banderas as The Phantom when Michael Crawford is THE Phantom!!!!!!!
Tuesday 09/24/2002 12:37:20am
Name: Le Fantome
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: L'Opera
Referred By: Web Ring
Comments: Is this how you amuse yourself?
You will cast Michael and no-one else!
Refuse us and you send your movie to its death!
THIS is the choice!
This is the point of no return!

I shall observe your every move until the casting of the Phantom movie is complete (and this takes a lot of stomach... The first time I saw what you looked like, I had to vomit- and that's coming from me!). Should the campaign's commands and mine be ignored, a disaster beyond your imagination will occur.

Your immortal creation- the only one!-,
Erik, the Phantom of the Opera
Sunday 09/22/2002 7:45:25pm
Name: Megan L.
E-Mail: PhntmGrl@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL:  
Where are you from?: California
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir-

This is it. I have decided to drop my "angry militant teenager" facade and give you the truth, pure and simple.

I loved Phantom the moment I heard your musical. It was actually one of the Harajuku remixes, but it did contain the essential, evocative "In sleep he sang to me...", even if it was sung by a Christine who sounded a bit like Nicole Kidman's character in "Moulin Rouge". I was still only nine years old.

A few weeks later, I was looking through a collection of tapes belonging to my grandmother. There it was: The Phantom of the Opera, The Original Cast Recording- Highlights from The Phantom of the Opera. And, for the first time, I was seduced by the extraordinary vocal talents of Michael Crawford.

To be frank, I was jealous of Christine. How many young women are lucky enough to be whisked through their mirrors by a charming, sensual, mysterious Angel of Music? I taught myself Christine's part. While my classmates were busying themselves with Britney Spears and her bubblegum clones, I waited for the school day to end so I could go home, start my stereo up, and listen to a song beginning with the words "Nighttime sharpens, heightens each sensation. Darkness stirs and wakes imagination."

A few years passed. My family tried to bombard me with your other musicals- which, by the way, are the worst sterotypes of musical theatre I'm aware of- but to no avail. I hope you understand that I am not an Andrew Lloyd Webber fan. I am a Phantom fan.

Before long, I had a beautiful collection of Phantom music boxes. At first, I thought, "There must be some mistake here! The Phantom looks terrible!" That was before I saw a picture of Michael as the Phantom- standing mysteriously in a wispy cloud of mist, his body wrapped in a swirling cloak, a wide-brimmed hat adorning his head. I saw a deep, intense longing in his eyes, and yet a trace of an amused smile around his mouth. What had seemed like a clumsy, confused expression in porcelain seemed sensitive, vulnerable, strong, and dark all at once on a real man. I had the privelige of seeing Brad Little perform the role of the Phantom in Sacramento on June 8, 2002, and while I was amazed by his stage presence, his voice was nothing to compare to Michael's. Just listening to Michael sing "Music of the Night" brings tears to my eyes.

But then, of course, came your little 'birthday party'. I suppose Michael had bored you by then? Was he even invited? And WHY did Antonio Banderas sing his part?

The awful truth leaked out:
Michael gave us our music.
Made your song take wing...
And now, how you've repaid him-
Denied him and betrayed him...

Please cast the movie right!
Wednesday 09/04/2002 12:28:36am
Name: Steph
E-Mail: Digital4001@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: wishing i lived by michael crawford
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Andrew,
If you don't cast Michael Crawford fo the lead role in the movie, a lot of people won't buy it. I think it is evil to cast a Hollywood star. You need to cast someone like Michael Crawford because they have expirience with Erik. I am a major phantom phan and my life is devoted to Erik. PLEASE cast Michael Crawford. A note back would be wonderful!! THANX
Tuesday 09/03/2002 6:17:49pm
Name: Megan
E-Mail: PhntmGrl@aol
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: California
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Lord Lloyd Webber:
I am 13 years old and have spent the last oh, I don't know, FIVE YEARS, listening to Phantom of the Opera obsessively!

Then I heard that you're planning to make a movie of it. My first thought was "Oh, good! I'll finally be able to see everyone on my CDs just like it was live, ESPECIALLY Michael Crawford!"
What a poor, misguided little thing I was. If only I had known you were planning to release the film with Antonio Banderas in the lead. That would have saved me a lot of pain and heartache, eh? No more afternoons creating makeshift Christine dresses, no more days full of acting out "Music of the Night" with an invisible Phantom.

But a wise person once said "Don't get mad, get even!" And that's exactly what I plan to do. I can't stand any of your other musicals in the first place! If the phans of the world have to try to get Michael Crawford ourselves and make our own movie, WE WILL. Because Phantom without Michael... isn't Phantom at all.

Neither obediant or friendly,
Megan
 
Friday 08/30/2002 8:03:24am
Name: George Smillie
E-Mail: george_smillie@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: London, UK
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: I have seen your musical, "the Phantom of the Opera" five times, and when I heard in 1991 about the movie, I was so excited, and yet here I am still waiting impatiently. Have you betrayed the millions of fans? Believe me Mr. Webber, as every day goes by, you lose another fan. I hate to say it, but I am disgusted by you and your shall we say "betrayal" of us? Micheal Crawford made your song take wing (pardon the phrase), and now how you repay him, you cast some guy from the Mask of Zorro?! What are you thinking? Your bending to all these Hollywood jerks! Keep Michael Crawford, and please try to keep Sarah Brightman...how can you keep the integrity of the original if you dont even have anyone from the original?! Keep your hands at the level of your eyes Mr. Webber. Remember all these people you are back-stabbing...

George Smillie
(A concerned and angry Phan)
Tuesday 08/27/2002 9:27:55am
Name: Mary
E-Mail: mdata9@msn.com
Homepage Title: Phantom Forever
Homepage URL: http://Michael is the only Phantom
Where are you from?: Philadelphia
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber:

It is with the deepest regards for your work that I implore you to only cast Michael Crawford as the Phantom in the Movie. Let this role be his just as Yul Brynner will always be the "King" from the King and I. When I first heard the CD of "Phantom". I was awe struck at the fantastic voice that the Phantom had. I could feel the emotions so strongly. I saw the performance in New York (regretfully) right after Michael left the role. I was very disapointed in the person who played the "Phantom". Because he did not make me feel the same way I felt when I listed to Michael sing on the CD. Please do not make the same mistake on the movie. Antonio, though very good in Evita was no Mandy either. Learn from your mistakes.

Sincerely Yours,
Friday 08/23/2002 2:56:30pm
Name: Shae Kangas
E-Mail: phantmsangel@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: US
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber,

Hello. My name is Shae and i am 13 years old. When i was a young child, my mothers CDs held a particular fascination for me. I used to listen to them for hours on end. One day I found a CD called "The Phantom of the Opera: Original Cast Recording" with Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman. I fell in love with the song "Phantom of the Opera" and cared nothing about the other songs on the CD. When i found this CD last year, i listened to it in its entirety and realized what a wonderful, enchanting, and beautiful story this was. Ive never seen Michael Crawford perform but i would LOVE to. PLEASE cast him in this movie. For the "Phans" (ick). For every little kid whos ever heard Michael and thought him the Angel of Music. And for me.

Please.

Your obedient friend and angel,

Shae

"Hide your face so the world will never find you.."
Thursday 08/22/2002 6:26:11pm
Name: Morella
E-Mail: pixiequeen426@cs.com
Homepage Title: Morella's Phantom Palace
Homepage URL: http://marblehalls.topcities.com/home.html
Where are you from?: Connecticut
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber, I have depended on you to provide wonderful entertainment all my life. Since I was a little girl at age seven, I have been captivated by your music. Particularly the Phantom of the Opera. Now, I am sixteen and your work still never fails to strech my imagination to the far ends of the world. I have suffered cruel comments and have been put down because of my devotion to the Phantom of the Opera. No matter how nasty people get, I know I can find comfort in your music. The Phantom of the Opera is something that is a very delicate story and it should be handled with care. Not many films have been able to show respect to the story in a way that could satisfy. But your play is the most strong interpritation of the classic love story. Must we get down on our knees and beg you? Is that what we must do? Because I don't think you'll find one phan too proud to do that. Pride is something we sacrifice when we devote our time to something that has no real value in anyone else's eyes. Please, if you are going to produce a film version of your play, then do not voluntarily destroy it. We want Michael Crawford!
Wednesday 08/21/2002 3:02:40am
Name: Linda C. Stebbins
E-Mail: pachebels_canon@yahoo,com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: USA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: How in the H__L do you think you can ever cast anyone in the role of the Phantom other than Michael Crawford????
I arrived in NYC too late to see him in that role.......but I've seen him since in other things.

You can't be serious in considering Antonio Banderas for the role of Phantom in the movie.....have you lost all sense of what needs to be?

Why does there need to be a famous Hollywood star in the title role? Don't think there needs to be. Anyone who is a Phantom fan will recognize the name of Michael Crawford!

Michael Crawford is all the name recognition that you need. There is no one who can do the role as well as he in the movie that is being planned.

And, anyone who truly loves "Phantom of the Opera" will see that Michael Crawford is the ONLY one who is truly right for the part.
 
Thursday 08/08/2002 4:27:56pm
Name: Shyra Enya Stevson
E-Mail: elemental_elf_13@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Cobh, Ireland
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Hiya, Mr. Webber.

My name is Shyra. I am a big fan of poto. In fact, i can play all the songs of poto on the piano. (and cats but that isnt wat this letter is about).

So. I would like to say. That i would please like u to make poto a movie. I mean and have michael crawford BE the Phantom. I have seen Michael Crawford on stage and i would like to see him on movie. I thank u.

Love, smiles, and support,
Shyra
Wednesday 08/07/2002 5:30:50pm
Name: Kimberly
E-Mail: tappin14@yahoo.com
Homepage Title: IT CAN ONLY BE THE TRUE PHANTOM
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: PA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Andrew Lloyod Webber,
I wanted to tell you that you have a gifted man as the phantom. I strongley feel that when this movie is to be made that NO ONE ELSE but MICHAEL CRAWFORD should play the phantom. Im 15 years old and I was just a baby when The Phantom of the Opera was first on broadway with its origional cast. Michael's voice is just amazing and it truly reaches out to me in ways that I can't explain. Its a shame that I talk to my friends about this play and about how wonderful Michael is and they tell me that they have not even heard of him!!!!! It's very hard to imagine some other actor playing the role of the Phantom. PLEASE let the one and only true phantom play his part. No one else is better than the master, MICHAEL CRAWFORD.Thank you for reading this and a response would be wonderful!
Saturday 08/03/2002 3:52:59pm
Name: Allie
E-Mail: cheleyatika_seilu
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Nowhereland
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir Andrew,
I am Allie from nowhereland, where nothing happens and nothing ever will, but that's not the point. I would like to begin by stating that I am an Erik devotee. I fell in love with your creation, your masterpiece, your genius. YOUR Angel of Music! By your marvelous composition, it's no secret that you put all of your soul into bringing him to life. He enchanted millions of people. YOU enchanted millions of people. Now, I ask, why would you risk letting your creation fall to pieces? All your devotees realise it. Why would you risk bringing down your masterpiece for the sake of a Hollywood name? Hollywood names fade away in time. Voices, such as Michael Crawford, Brad Little (U.S. tour Phantom, I saw him perform live. He would be an excellent choice if I do say so.), and Grant Norman do not die. When such talent goes to bring Erik to life, the voices will never die. He has become a muse of inspiration for so many artists as myself. If Erik is destroyed by someone who has never even portrayed him, such as John Travolta, he will never be the same. Phantom will close all over the world so nobody will ever see the real beauty of it again. PLEASE preserve the magic in you movie! He is YOUR Phantom! "Phans" (ugh! I hate that word, but it doesn't matter.) all over the globe are begging you to cast someone who you know will do him justice, will do YOUR MUSIC justice!

But who are we kidding!? We are just "Phans" (ugh.). We are only the people that make up your audience! We are only lowly devotees that don't matter (I mean, who can say you haven't just deleted this letter before reading it?). We have virtually no idea how much money you'll get either way, but we DO know that there is power in your phantom, and that your movie will more likely be a failure if you don't maintain that power.

Had enough of me yet? Good. I'm finished.

Your Obedient Friend,

Allie fom Nowhereland, Age 11
Friday 08/02/2002 7:34:06pm
Name: Janelle D.
E-Mail: act4_JD@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: West Coast
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: To the person it concerns most;
I would like to tell you a story; once opon a time there was a little girl who loved to dance and listen to her mothers CD player, now that was rather odd for a girl who was in second grade at the time. Well one day while she was looking for a CD to play she found a CD that said; 'The Phantom of the Opera'by andrew Lyold Webber, original cast recording starring Micheal Crawford, Sarah Brightman and Steve Barton...well her intrest was perked by the sound of it, so she put it on. At first the begining of the overtrue frightend her, but she enjoyed the 'Angel of Music' and 'The Mirror', to a little girls mind at the time those were the only songs that intrigued her, she learned the songs almost my heart and was enchanted by the mans voice who was called the Angel of Music...well as the story goes one day she looked for the CD but she could not find it and before she knew five years had elasped and she was moving and in jr.high. Sometimes she remembered the mans enchanting voice and would troop downstairs to find it but never did until her mother asked her to clean and pack up all her CD's, now at the time she was a few weeks from moving away from her school and friends to a place that she used to drive past on the way to her relatives, also she was busy concentrating on her own part in a play. So you can imagine her suprise when she found that Cd dust covered and all hiding in a corner, well she was surprised and pleased quickly finishing her work so she could listen to the words. Soon she came to learn that there was much more than just those songs and came to love the whole CD, still not even knowing what it was about, soon she began gathering what she could about the story and fell asleep listening to it every night. As a very hip young girl she went to every listed web site for 'Phantom' but quickly without looking further at it dismissed this site as a flop but learning more about what they were planning for the Phantom movie became so intrigued she spent hours looking at the site. When she found out who they were going to cast as Phantom she was outraged and spent hours fuming about it. That girl was me....and without even seeing the musical I have tried everything in my power to find stuff out about the phantom of the opera....please don't dissapoint me...seeing Micheal Crawford as phantom in the movie is the closest thing I'll ever come to in seeing him perform....a whole lot of other young ones like me who have fallen in love with phantom but haven be able to see it would love for the chance to see Micheal Crawford as phantom in the movie, not Antonio, gosh, we grew up watching him, and now our little siblings absoulutley cower to go watch him in Spy Kids...please give me a break. Phantoms face is disorted, so Mr. Banderas supposedly hearthrob would never appear...and plus Eric is french...not latino...so just forget the whole birthday gig, it was just a sweet thing that your ex and him put up to be sort of sentimental and funny, not a big duet worthy of praise, now if Micheal Crawford and Sarah B. had gotten together to do a famous duet that would of been something specail and memorable, but it didn't happen, instead all the phantom phans got a laugh instead of a great performance, thats what the movie would get if Antonio played the part of phantom, a whole bunch of laughs. I fully support the idea of not making the movie if Mr. Crawford doesn't get the part, and if you make the movie without him anyways i will boycott it, even if i would dearly love to go and watch it and laugh at whoever try's to play the part only one man has been ever able to convey it to his utmost ability and give a performance that only the real Eric who has long been dead could of protrayed if he ever existed. Do think about that...it would do your career good.
always a fan, janelle d.
Monday 07/22/2002 3:11:58pm
Name: Jessica Turner
E-Mail: random@flash.net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Hawaii
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Dear mr. webber,

I used to be one of those people who thought 'The Phantom Of The Opera' was just some stupid old play. But not anymore.My Friend Jen always use to play the songs on the computer.I used to getso annoyed with it I just shut it out. And judged it before I een took the time to actually listen to it.But when I heard 'The Angel Of Music" Michael Webber I liked 'The Phantom Of The Opera. Most of the fans fell in love with Michaels voice. Antonio's voice has to much of a Spanish accent to it.And I bet that if you sit down and listen to them both, I know that you cast Michael Crawford as 'Phantom'.

- Jessica

P.S

Antonio would do good as Piangi
Monday 07/22/2002 2:34:44pm
Name: Erica Darling&Shelby Hearthorn
E-Mail: EriksAngelofMusic_MegG@yahoo.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Texas
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: My name is Erica Darling. I do believe very strongly that if you use any one but Michael Crawford you will have very few people seeing your 'wonderful' movie. He is THE Phantom, I can and will not accept any one but him. I do beleive that this movie could be the best of all movies, BUT if you use some other than Micheal Carwford you will destroy the movie before it evens comes out. He has the most wonderful voice I have ever heard, not to say that he knows the part VERY well. I would also like to add that if you use any one other than him my passion for the Phantom of the Opera will be crushed for all time. I have read most the letters here and most beleive the same thing as me. I was shown this by my friend who is also going to say what see feels. One thing my friends have just come up with is (singing) Michael Crawford is the Phantoooom. Don't kill the Phantom of the Operaaaaa.(stop singing) I have stated my opinion.

one of Michael's many fans,
Erica Darling


(written in red ink)
Dear Lord Lloyed Webber,

My name's Shelby Hearthorn. And I wish to tell you what I KNOW.
Lord Lloyed Webber, I LOVE your musical. You picked the BEST casting for your origanal. Their still the best! So why choose anyone else? You made millions off of Mister Crawford! Don't you want more money? So kill two birds with one stone! Give the phans what they want, and you make your own money! I have read everything I can get my hands on of The Phantom of the Opera, including the origanal by Gaston, Le Fantom de l'Opera. I have not, however, seen your musical yet. I didn't have time to buy tickets, but I have been saving up for two years now, and been looking for the nearest location. Here is what I think when I put myself in Erik(the Phantoms) place and what he would think of this(pardon me for anything rude, like I said, I'm typing the words that I think Phantom would say):

"YOU want to put that FOP as ME?! HOW DARE YOU! He can't even speak correctly, with his strong spainish accent.what ARE you thinking?! I made Chrisitine think I was the ANGEL of Music, NOT the DEMON of Music! Did you choose him for his looks? HA! When was the last time you saw someone with their face made up to look like mine? You have no need to worry about looks! His fame, perhaps? Him trying to play as me will destory the poor man's career! Though he accpeting my part certainly makes him deserving of it! And most impotantly: HE CANNOT SING! He's too violent! I LOVED, and still LOVE her, I'm NOT supposed to be scaring the poor girl out of her wits! If you keep him, you poor fools! Keep your Mosueir Crawford as me! I've wrote this once to the Managers(poor fools), but I will say it to you, as well: 'Sould these demands be ignored, a disaster beyond your imagenation shall occur! NOW GET TO WORK ON IT IMMEDATELY!"

Uh- sorry about that. As I said before, I was saying things I thought he'd say. And when I put myself into the mindset of Erik, I most of the time have no CLUE what I'm saying.
Also remember- Erik hates people who don't keep loyal to their promises!
To me and my friends, Antonio cannot sing for Phantom. He's too violent. I don't even want to THINK about how he would sing The Music of the Night. ... And I don't think Erik would, ethier.
My Sap Story:
A while ago I kinda went insane. My family was having money problems, and...other things. I was slightly suicidal. I had been before.
I guess it was the pressure of too many things. Then I started listening to Phantom. That literally saved my life! But I just KNOW that without Michael Crawford it wouldn't have worked, and I would have killed myself.

Nice Sap Story, huh? Okay, so, where was I? OH, YES!

The Threat: IF YOU DON'T CAST MICAEL CRAWFORD, ME, MY FRIENDS, AND ALL THE OTHER FANS I'VE MET WILL BOYCOTT YOU!
"BOYCOTT, BOYCOTT, BOYCOTT! (Meachanical laughter) (chokeing sounds) Sorry."

Your Obedient Friend,

S.H
Thursday 07/18/2002 3:23:21pm
Name: Jenna Haywood.
E-Mail: fallchildren23@deadman.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Kansas
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: In regard to the upcoming Phantom movie, the slightest idea that Antonio Banderas would be playing the role of The Phantom is apalling and a horrific disgrace. Michael Crawford's voice is an exquisite and beautiful one. He and only he can do justice to the role of that sad and tormented composer and you have proved that to the world many times before. So please don't bring shame unto the equation. Michaels voice is the perfect one who can quite rightly depict despair, vengeance, contempt and unrequitted love in a single note. Please do the world a favor and do this film with the art of Michael Crawford.
Tuesday 07/16/2002 1:56:58pm
Name: Mildred
E-Mail: ClrGrdSpirit317@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: New Jersey
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber-

My name is Mildred and I'm 14 years old. Back in September/October/November, the marching band I'm part of performed songs from "The Phantom of the Opera" for our show. That was the first time I had heard the music, but my parents were already familiar with it. After the season ended, in February my parents decided to take me to see the show so that I can know where the music came from.

I think it was February 16th when I first saw it. I was kind of scepitcal, because I had never seen a play before. But then it started and I found myself soon lost in the play. I didn't care about anything, but the music.
When the play ended (and yes, I had to admit, I did cry at the end) I just sat there, stunned. I was unable to say anything. But when my mom asked me, "So, what did you think?" I had to reply, "That was the most smashing thing I had ever seen."

I love that play, and I still think it is the greatest. I bought the CD soon after I saw it and I haven't stopped listening since. Recently, for 8th grade graduation, I got my parents to take me again. It was still the greatest show I had ever seen and I love it. I hear Michael Crawford on my CD when I play it and he is the best. He sings so good and he plays the part with emotion and it makes me love it even more. So I hope that if you do make a movie that you use Michael Crawford, because he has the true spirit of the Phantom.

Sincerely,

Mildred
Monday 07/15/2002 9:12:44pm
Name: Bill Smith
E-Mail: adtech@ntr.net
Homepage Title: adtechproductions
Homepage URL: http://www.adtechproductions.com
Where are you from?: Louisville, KY
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber: I believe your work in "Phantom of the Opera" is absolutely brilliant. Unsurpassed in Musical/stage history. I emplore you to not let Warner Bros. cast anyone but Michael Crawford in the title role. This movie will be successful no matter who plays the role. But, if you want it to become a classic as your stage production has then please do what ever it takes to place Mr. Crawford in the lead.
Try to imagine "My fair Lady" without Rex Harrison, "Gone With the Wind" without Clark Gable?
In this day of High-tech film making, the only thing that will sustain a Classic is for the man who is Phantom to be the star. Michael Crawford has brought a dynamic to your wonderful production that has no equal.
Monday 07/15/2002 12:53:29am
Name: Kyle
E-Mail: KyleH2O@swbell.net
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Dallas TX
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Webber,

I am a great big fan of all your work! Where do you get those ideas? But could you tell me yes or no if you are making a movie of phantom. Email me the answer!
Thursday 07/11/2002 10:00:46am
Name: Chris
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Canada
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Dear Lord Lloyd-Webber,
I know that you must get hundreds f letters everyday, and that my letter may not mean that much, but it means so much to me, and I hope you have the time to read just another dedicated fans letter.

When I was 13, the Phantom ofthe Opera had just arrived in London, the original cast with Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford. At this time in my life I was well depressed and I was rather suicidal, now I know your going to say that I was rather young but at that age I knew alot... I was getting rather well close to commiting suicide so my mother tried to get me help, she looked to my frieds. One of my friends at school gave me the Phantom of the Opera CD. I listened to the entire CD, twice and memorized the lyrics. I listened to a song from that CD first thing every morning and the last thing before I go to sleep, and I still do. The Phantom of the Opera began and ended my day, and I was a crazed Phantom Phan but I had nothing still to hold onto in life. Until my mother took me to see the musical.

My mother had bought me tickets to see the musical and I was really excited, It was and still is the greatest musical I have ever seen, the story always touched me but on stage everything was so much more amazing. When Michael Crawford sang the Music of the Night, I cried like I cried, and I couldn't stop. And I watched Michael Crawford every move he made and every glide across the stage. And I thought he had the most incredible voice and body for the part... He was and still is THE phantom.

But the important thing is after seeing the Phantom, after seeing Raoul and Christine risks their lives for love, and the Phantom leave his life for Christine, I understood what there was left in my life. There was once again meaning to my life, and I am now a composer/singer, and I am trying to make "The music of the night."

But what is so important about that musical was that Michael Crawford touched my life, he gave me the real reson to move on in life to succeed and I thank the original cast as the performers and you as the composer, but Michael Crawford has to be in this movie. I believe that he can be, hundreds of others agree too, that man truly changed my life and it would be the most amazing thing if you cast him in that movie, no one else can do the job right. And i am no worse than anyother fan just trying to get my voice heard but I've been here fromthe start watched your career since I was old enough to read and without the Phantom of the Opera and michael Crawford I wouldn't be where I am today, He is the role.. He has to be.. even if it is only for the sake of the fans....
Wednesday 07/10/2002 8:27:40pm
Name: Thomas
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Canada
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Lord Lloyd-Webber,
I love the Phantom of the Opera, I know the lyrics, I know the actors, the characters, the sets, the music, I've read every book, seen 4 different productions and I for one believe that Michael Crawford must be the Phantom in that movie. The original cast was in my mind the greatest cast, Michael crawford was amazing and so was Sarah Brightman, and I think you need to re-assemble thiscast to truly make this movie a worth while success.
Wednesday 07/10/2002 8:22:14pm
Name: Alex
E-Mail: akreado@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Ontario, Canada
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Mr. webber,

I know that I can speak for many people when I say that The Phantom of the Opera is the greatest musical ever made, it has had absolutely huge grossings and dedicated fans around the world. All those people who watched that musical, who listened to that soundtrack who read the lyrics all trusted you to come through on making the movie. On casting Michael Crawford, the original and greatest Phantom in the title role.. Why do you need a big shot money making hollywood actor, to steal Michael's place.. You would be destroying the musical.. It would lose everything.. I'm only 14, yet for the last 8 years I have listened to your CD every single day and the phantom has become a part of my life, it inspired me. And now destroying all that with a movie would utterly change my life.. And the lives of many dedicated fans all over the world.
Wednesday 07/10/2002 1:26:41pm
Name: Christine (a singer)
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: From a Friend
Comments: Mr.Webber,
You should know that Michael is a great Phantom and to me the only who could ever play the part of the Phantom.As you can see I am a huge phan:) And don't know if I could see the film without Michael Crawford starring as the Phantom and that is the way a lot of phans feel.I seen the play once have the cd (w/ michael crawford as the voice of the phantom) and read the book as other phans have, somehow I feel like I know the Phantom and I feel that way because the voice of the Michael Crawford makes the fall in the with the Phantom.(I know Mr.Webber will never read so whats the use.)
Saturday 06/22/2002 12:09:31am
Name: Anna
E-Mail: phantomsangel@msn.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Colorado
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: To Lord Lloyd Webber;
Please please please do NOT cast ANYONE but Michael Crawford for the role of The Phantom if there will be a movie! Do you know how long us Phans have been waiting to see Mikey in a movie version of "Phantom"? And if you think that Antonio will bring in all the gold than you are mistaken! No one wants to hear him sing as the Phantom! He makes us want to vomit when we hear him TRY to sing as the Phantom! Please do not make us listen to that (and most of us, if not all of us, WON'T!)! Please dont be stupid and just cast Michael for goodness sake! We all know that you are a musical genius, so why not just use your brain on this one? Thank you!
-Anna :)
Friday 06/21/2002 7:10:40am
Name: Jennifer
E-Mail: AlwaysHyper55@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: New York
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: I am 13 and I rented the Phantom of The opera cd from my local library and instantly fell in love with it. I then got to see it 5 times since then. I have read the book by Gaston Leroux and Phantom by Susan Kay, and own The Complete Phantom Of The Opera by George Perry. I know everthing about the play- the special effects, all the lyrics and I need you to make a movie. If I had enough money I would go see if every performance- but thats impossible.
When you make the movie, I suggest you use Michael Crawford, or Howard McGillin, they have the best voice I have ever heard play the Phantom. Also, Sarah Brightman made an excellent Christine Daač as well. I hope you take this consent and use it wisely. Thank-you
Monday 06/17/2002 10:41:24pm
Name: Cassandra
E-Mail: utahraptorchick_03@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Cali baby!
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Lord Lloyd Webber,
There is no question in my mind who the Phantom is, however, you appear to have a rather.....odd (to put it nicely) idea. To put it bluntly, Antonio Banderas wouldn't know how to sing if instructions came and bit him on the...nose. There is ONE Phantom, and that's Michael Crawford. How you can contrive to even *THINK* of someone else playing the role is beyond me. While well aware of the "facial" draw factor to many movies, it is a ridiculus argument in this case. For almost the entire play(and most likely the movie as well), the face is covered, and then a deformity is shown. Don't let a Spanish Prima Donna ruin the movie!
Regards,
Cassandra
Monday 06/17/2002 8:15:16pm
Name: A Young Singer
E-Mail: .......
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Arizona
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: (This is if this goes to Andrew Lloyd Webber, and if not then ignore this)
Hello, Lord Webber. I have been a faithful Phantom fan for quite a long time, and nothing gives me shivers more than Michael Crawford's version of 'Phantom'. It is incredible how his voice and the character meld together perfectly, his superb way of using his talents to tell the tale of such a damaged man is sublime. You cannot find another person to fit the role so well. I admit, Banderas (excuse the spelling if it is incorrect) is a great actor and singer. But, truly, I hope you know who fits the 'Phantom' role best. If you are not a true Phantom fan, it is impossible for you to understand, but for those fanatics who are interested in seeing this story go to the homes and hearts of others _properly_ please take your promise and make it true. You made a promise in your own words, and Michael Crawford has been good to you by bringing such a magnificent portrayal of the Phantom to you and the crowds. You are most certainly a lover of the theatrical and musical arts, so please listen to yet another one like you. Never again shall another true Phantom come to the stage. He was the first, and in many hearts going to be the very last Phantom who tugs on everyone's heart strings. Please, take our pleas into consideration. If you want people to buy the movie, then use the correct Phantom. Give Banderas another role that is more deserving of him, and him more deserving of the role. The Phantom role goes to Michael Crawford completely just by his name being the first to be connected with the Phantom's character on stage, and then much more. Now, you tell me who will be the best sell...
Michael Crawford, the very first to bring Phantom to life, the incredible and unable to be compared singer...
or...
Banderas, the new, suave Phantom who is more sexy rather than theatrical?

Thank you for your time.

A Young Singer

P.S.
Begging and giving you words of wisdom completely from our right minds are the only things we can do to convince you, so please understand that your listening and trying to bring us what we want will finally bring us to repose.
  Thursday 06/13/2002 7:59:48pm
Name: Rai
E-Mail: HydePhan37@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Connecticut, USA
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Mr. Webber, when my parents saw Michael in the role of the Phantom of Broadway, they were amazed by his talent and became instant fans. I am likewise, and though I was too young to have seen him, I wouldn't pass up a chance to see the master in the role of the Phantom on the silver screen. While I concure that Banderas is a good singer, he doesn't know the character half as well as Michael does. It would be bad publicity, as well as a broken promise, to cast anyone else. If Banderas was casted as the Phantom, I will tell you now, every true Phan would not buy tickets. Cast Michael not only for the fans, but for the obvious financial benefits as well.
  Friday 05/31/2002 6:23:15am
Name: Tamika Albright
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Harleton, Texas
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber,

I became a big fan of yours in 1992, when I saw "The Phantom of the Opera" in Toronto, Canada. I loved the quality of Colm Wilkinson's voice, but nothing compared to the feeling I first felt when my grandmother sacrificed her only copy of the original London cast of "Phantom" to me. When I heard Michael Crawford's voice, I almost started crying. Since then, I have purchased many of M.C.'s albums, and many of yours, also. I would like to see a movie version of "Phantom" made with the legendary Michael. Antonio Banderas would make a mockery of the music you worked so hard and long for to make a success. Michael has the voice that makes men and women alike cry. Michael was your original choice for the stage Phantom, so why not the screen? Michael knows Phantom, unlike a lot of other performers, because he has played the role over 1300 TIMES!!! Antonio Banderas is not as intimate with Phantom as Michael is. In order to perform a role as it was written, you have to spend time with the character. Michael had spent countless hours with Phantom. He performed when he was sick. How many other actors can say that? Banderas would only be spending time with Phantom in increments of a few minutes, not near enough time to become best friends with the character. Michael is the ONLY logical choice for the role. He has the power to move a person's soul with his voice. He has the ability to transfer what he feels from his heart to ours. I know of no other actor who can do that. Michael can put so much emotion into a song, into a word, into a single note, that he can move a person to tears--literally wracking sobs into the theater. Who else can do these things? No one. Banderas would be a bad casting call. Think of what you would be doing to Michael, who loves Phantom so much, that he came back to perform the role repeated times, only to not be able to sing come his final performances. Andrew, you owe this to your fans, to cast Michael as the Phantom, and leave Banderas out of the picture. Please, we implore you. That's all we ask of you, to let us hear Michael's music of the night once more.

Thank you,

Tamika Albright
Michael Crawford Fan
  Wednesday 05/29/2002 6:47:15pm
Name: Kelley
E-Mail: glokelmar@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: New Jersey
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber,
I am a 15 year old fan of Michael Crawford. I am to young to have seen him in the Phantom of the Opera.
When I heard about the prospect of a Phantom Movie, I became very excited. I thought I would get the chance to see Mr. Crawford in his famous role. Then I found out that you were thinking of casting someone other then Mr. Crawford in the role of the Phantom.
Mr. Webber, I don't know if you realize it or not, but not casting Mr. Crawford would be a tragedy. Many people around my age, who are to young to have seen Mr. Crawford play the Phantom on stage, would be deprived of a fantastic expierence.
Mr. Webber, I ask, no I beg you to reconsider your decision about not casting Mr. Crawford as the Phantom. You would not only be hurting yourself, but you'd also be depriving generations to come of Mr. Crawford's magic.
  Sunday 05/12/2002 6:45:22pm
Name: Jenn
E-Mail:  
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: I have been a Phantom of the Opera fan since I can remember, I know almost every single word on the CD as well as some interesting past history of the Phantom (Gaston realted) before the plays, and every single time that I heard that the Phantom was playing, I had always tried to get tickets. But, when I heard that there was a movie planning to be made, I was, at first, happy. That is until I heard whom was planning to be casted. Truthfully, the ONLY person on this planet that can guarentee a prosperous movie would be if Michael Crawford was the Phantom. It is only logical, being that he was the original Phantom from the play in the first place and that there are so many fans that are determined to get Michael the leading role. I am hoping that Michael gets the role that he was promised to in the first place, and that the script will be just as rewarding as the play's.
  Tuesday 05/07/2002 11:09:52pm
Name: Kimberly Kendall
E-Mail: kimbo2375@msn.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Nashville, TN
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: I am twenty-six and unfortunately I became a Phantom fan to late to see Michael Crawford perform the lead role. I do however, own and love the CD. I since then have followed Michael's career and become a fan. I can't imagine anyone playing the role better than the man who made the show the hit it is.Please, do what you know is right.
  Monday 05/06/2002 9:08:15am
Name: Ben Stahl
E-Mail: lonestarslj@hotmail.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: Baltimore, MD
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Mr. Webber. I first saw "Phantom" while visiting New York City a month ago. I first want to congradulate you on making a truly amazing musical that will undoubtedly stand the test of time. I also want to wish you and Mr. Crawford luck on this movie idea. From what I have read about it, it sounds like it will do the original story some justice. Good luck again, and thank you for the music.
  Sunday 05/05/2002 9:16:02pm
Name: Diana Hsu
E-Mail: R_HSU@msn.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?: NJ
Referred By: Search Engine
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber,
Casting Antonio Banderas is a bad idea. The Phantom is French, and it is extremely obvious that A. Banderas is Spanish. He doesn't have a voice right for playing Erik. I simply don't understand why you won't cast Michael Crawford. You would make a huge profit from it.
  Friday 05/03/2002 9:08:05am
Name: Beth Liebner
E-Mail: bethliebner@aol.com
Homepage Title:  
Homepage URL: http://
Where are you from?:  
Referred By: Just Surfed On In
Comments: Dear Mr. Webber,
I am a fan of all your musicals,but my absolute favorite is Phantom of the Opera. When I heard that you were going to be doing a film adaptation of phantom I was so excited. Then I heard you were thinking of casting Antonio Banderas in the role. How can you?
I'm not saying that he has a bad voice but he can't possibly sing the role of the Phantom. The one and only actor who can possibly play the role is Michael Crawford. I didn't get a chance to see him in the show but I have the original cast recording which I listen to almost everyday. If you want the Phantom of the Opera movie to be as big a hit as the musical the only choice is Michael Crawford.
Sincerely,
Beth
liebner